Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

There Exist Povm Measurements that Contradict the Quantum Measurement Postulate for Discrete, Degenerate Systems

Raymond W. Jensen

Published Jul 1, 2011• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

A 1986 experiment involving a two-particle entangled system is analyzed, and it is shown that: (1) the measurement results of that experiment are in contradiction to the discrete degenerate form of the quantum measurement postulate (DDQMP) and (2) the measurements done in the experiment are of the positive operator valued measure (POVM) type. Thus there exist POVM measurements which contradict the DDQMP. A modification to the DDQMP is provided which agrees with the experimental results. The modified DDQMP is then applied to a proposed experiment involving a three-particle Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state.

Related papers

Experimental Evidence for a non-Globally Trace-Preserving POVM

Raymond W. Jensen

Abstract. A well-known experiment from 1986 involving entangled pairs is examined. The data, which until now have not been modeled quantitatively, is shown not to be in agreement with the quantum measurement postulate using von Neumann projectors. On the other hand, the data agree with the postulate using a more general positive operator valued measure (POVM). The peculiarity of the POVM proposed here is that it is only conditionally a POVM; i.e. it is not complete (trace-preserving) on the entire Hilbert space but only on a subset, although the POVM elements are positive semidefinite observables on the entire space. The state vector of the aforementioned experiment is in the subset where completeness holds. An extension of the conditional POVM is then applied to a proposed experiment involving threeparticle Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) entangled states. As with the Aspect experiment, completeness holds for the conditional POVM upon application to the GHZ state. Violation of the Bell inequality in the GHZ experiment does not occur upon application of von-Neumann projectors; however the conditional POVM allows for Bell inequality violation. PACS numbers: 03.65.Ta,03.65.UdExperimental evidence for a non-globally trace-preserving POVM 2 1. Review of the experiment The experimental evidence examined here is from Aspect, Grangier and Roger [1], hereafter referred to as the Aspect experiment. In the experiment, systems of correlated photon pairs were produced from a single source. The photons, being correlated, are represented by a system of the following form:

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Quantum filtering using POVM measurements

Ram Somaraju, Alain Sarlette, Hugo Thienpont A

The objective of this work is to develop a recursive, discrete time quantum filtering equation for a system that interacts with a probe, on which measurements are performed according to the Positive Operator Valued Measures (POVMs) framework. POVMs are the most general measurements one can make on a quantum system and although in principle they can be reformulated as projective measurements on larger spaces, for which filtering results exist, a direct treatment of POVMs is more natural and can simplify the filter computations for some applications. Hence we formalize the notion of strongly commuting (Davies) instruments which allows one to develop joint measurement statistics for POVM type measurements. This allows us to prove the existence of conditional POVMs, which is essential for the development of a filtering equation. We demonstrate that under generally satisfied assumptions, knowing the observed probe POVM operator is sufficient to uniquely specify the quantum filtering evolution for the system.

IEEE Conference on Decision and Control (CDC)•Dec 1, 2013•5 citations

Quantum filtering using POVM measurements

Ram Somaraju, Alain Sarlette, Hugo Thienpont A

The objective of this work is to develop a recursive, discrete time quantum filtering equation for a system that interacts with a probe, on which measurements are performed according to the Positive Operator Valued Measures (POVMs) framework. POVMs are the most general measurements one can make on a quantum system and although in principle they can be reformulated as projective measurements on larger spaces, for which filtering results exist, a direct treatment of POVMs is more natural and can simplify the filter computations for some applications. Hence we formalize the notion of strongly commuting (Davies) instruments which allows one to develop joint measurement statistics for POVM type measurements. This allows us to prove the existence of conditional POVMs, which is essential for the development of a filtering equation. We demonstrate that under generally satisfied assumptions, knowing the observed probe POVM operator is sufficient to uniquely specify the quantum filtering evolution for the system.

arXiv:1303.2631•Mar 11, 2013•1 citation

Robust certification of non-projective measurements: theory and experiment

Raphael Brinster, Peter Tirler, Shishir Khandelwal +7 more

Determining the conditions under which positive operator-valued measures (POVMs), the most general class of quantum measurements, outperform projective measurements remains a challenging and largely unresolved problem. Of particular interest are projectively simulable POVMs, which can be realized through probabilistic mixtures of projective measurements, and therefore offer no advantage over projective schemes. Characterizing the boundary between simulable and non-simulable POVMs is, however, a difficult task, and existing tools either fail to scale efficiently, provide limited experimental feasibility or work only for specific POVMs. Here, we introduce and demonstrate a general method to certify non-simulability of a POVM by introducing a complete hierarchy of semidefinite programs. It provides upper bounds on the non-simulability measure of critical visibility of arbitrary POVMs which are tight in many cases and outperform previously known criteria. We experimentally certify the non-simulability of two- and three-dimensional POVMs using a trapped-ion qudit quantum processor by constructing non-simulability witnesses and introduce a modification of our framework that makes them robust against state preparation errors. Finally, we extend our results to the setting where an additional ancilla system is available.

quant-pharXiv:2511.04446•PRX Quantum•Nov 7, 2025•4 citations

Quantum phase for a system with an arbitrary discrete energy spectrum

D. Arsenović, Nikola Burić, Dragomir M Davidović +1 more

Positive operator valued measures representing phase observables for systems with arbitrary discrete, possibly degenerate, spectra are constructed. The general construction is presented and discussed using illustrative examples. The phase POVM shows intricate discontinuous dependence on the eigenfrequencies. Special discussion is devoted to the systems with degenerate energy spectrum, in which case the phase observable is nonunique. We present arguments that can be used to reduces this nonuniqueness.

Physical Review A•Aug 19, 2013•2 citations

Quantum filtering using POVM measurements: Conditional Expectation

Ram Somaraju, Alain Sarlette, Hugo Thienpont A

The objective of this work is to develop a recursive, discrete time quantum filtering equation for a system that interacts with a probe, on which measurements are performed according to the Positive Operator Valued Measures (POVMs) framework. POVMs are the most general measurements one can make on a quantum system and although in principle they can be reformulated as projective measurements on larger spaces, for which filtering results exist, a direct treatment of POVMs can be more natural and simplify the filter computations for some applications. Hence we formalize the notion of commuting (Davies) instruments which allows one to develop joint measurement statistics of two POVM type measurements as explicit functions of the POVMs. This allows us to prove the existence of a notion of conditional expectation POVM, which is essential for the development of a filtering equation. We demonstrate that under generally satisfied assumptions, the reduced model given by POVM elements is sufficient for the purpose of our quantum filtering task.

•Mar 11, 2013•0 citations
A 1986 experiment involving a two-particle entangled system is analyzed, and it is shown that: (1) the measurement results of that experiment are in contradiction to the discrete degenerate form of the quantum measurement postulate (DDQMP) and (2) the measurements done in the experiment are of the positive operator valued measure (POVM) type. Thus there exist POVM measurements which contradict the DDQMP. A modification to the DDQMP is provided which agrees with the experimental results. The modified DDQMP is then applied to a proposed experiment involving a three-particle Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state.
Abstract. A well-known experiment from 1986 involving entangled pairs is examined. The data, which until now have not been modeled quantitatively, is shown not to be in agreement with the quantum measurement postulate using von Neumann projectors. On the other hand, the data agree with the postulate using a more general positive operator valued measure (POVM). The peculiarity of the POVM proposed here is that it is only conditionally a POVM; i.e. it is not complete (trace-preserving) on the entire Hilbert space but only on a subset, although the POVM elements are positive semidefinite observables on the entire space. The state vector of the aforementioned experiment is in the subset where completeness holds. An extension of the conditional POVM is then applied to a proposed experiment involving threeparticle Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) entangled states. As with the Aspect experiment, completeness holds for the conditional POVM upon application to the GHZ state. Violation of the Bell inequality in the GHZ experiment does not occur upon application of von-Neumann projectors; however the conditional POVM allows for Bell inequality violation. PACS numbers: 03.65.Ta,03.65.UdExperimental evidence for a non-globally trace-preserving POVM 2 1. Review of the experiment The experimental evidence examined here is from Aspect, Grangier and Roger [1], hereafter referred to as the Aspect experiment. In the experiment, systems of correlated photon pairs were produced from a single source. The photons, being correlated, are represented by a system of the following form:
The objective of this work is to develop a recursive, discrete time quantum filtering equation for a system that interacts with a probe, on which measurements are performed according to the Positive Operator Valued Measures (POVMs) framework. POVMs are the most general measurements one can make on a quantum system and although in principle they can be reformulated as projective measurements on larger spaces, for which filtering results exist, a direct treatment of POVMs is more natural and can simplify the filter computations for some applications. Hence we formalize the notion of strongly commuting (Davies) instruments which allows one to develop joint measurement statistics for POVM type measurements. This allows us to prove the existence of conditional POVMs, which is essential for the development of a filtering equation. We demonstrate that under generally satisfied assumptions, knowing the observed probe POVM operator is sufficient to uniquely specify the quantum filtering evolution for the system.
The objective of this work is to develop a recursive, discrete time quantum filtering equation for a system that interacts with a probe, on which measurements are performed according to the Positive Operator Valued Measures (POVMs) framework. POVMs are the most general measurements one can make on a quantum system and although in principle they can be reformulated as projective measurements on larger spaces, for which filtering results exist, a direct treatment of POVMs is more natural and can simplify the filter computations for some applications. Hence we formalize the notion of strongly commuting (Davies) instruments which allows one to develop joint measurement statistics for POVM type measurements. This allows us to prove the existence of conditional POVMs, which is essential for the development of a filtering equation. We demonstrate that under generally satisfied assumptions, knowing the observed probe POVM operator is sufficient to uniquely specify the quantum filtering evolution for the system.
Determining the conditions under which positive operator-valued measures (POVMs), the most general class of quantum measurements, outperform projective measurements remains a challenging and largely unresolved problem. Of particular interest are projectively simulable POVMs, which can be realized through probabilistic mixtures of projective measurements, and therefore offer no advantage over projective schemes. Characterizing the boundary between simulable and non-simulable POVMs is, however, a difficult task, and existing tools either fail to scale efficiently, provide limited experimental feasibility or work only for specific POVMs. Here, we introduce and demonstrate a general method to certify non-simulability of a POVM by introducing a complete hierarchy of semidefinite programs. It provides upper bounds on the non-simulability measure of critical visibility of arbitrary POVMs which are tight in many cases and outperform previously known criteria. We experimentally certify the non-simulability of two- and three-dimensional POVMs using a trapped-ion qudit quantum processor by constructing non-simulability witnesses and introduce a modification of our framework that makes them robust against state preparation errors. Finally, we extend our results to the setting where an additional ancilla system is available.
Positive operator valued measures representing phase observables for systems with arbitrary discrete, possibly degenerate, spectra are constructed. The general construction is presented and discussed using illustrative examples. The phase POVM shows intricate discontinuous dependence on the eigenfrequencies. Special discussion is devoted to the systems with degenerate energy spectrum, in which case the phase observable is nonunique. We present arguments that can be used to reduces this nonuniqueness.
The objective of this work is to develop a recursive, discrete time quantum filtering equation for a system that interacts with a probe, on which measurements are performed according to the Positive Operator Valued Measures (POVMs) framework. POVMs are the most general measurements one can make on a quantum system and although in principle they can be reformulated as projective measurements on larger spaces, for which filtering results exist, a direct treatment of POVMs can be more natural and simplify the filter computations for some applications. Hence we formalize the notion of commuting (Davies) instruments which allows one to develop joint measurement statistics of two POVM type measurements as explicit functions of the POVMs. This allows us to prove the existence of a notion of conditional expectation POVM, which is essential for the development of a filtering equation. We demonstrate that under generally satisfied assumptions, the reduced model given by POVM elements is sufficient for the purpose of our quantum filtering task.