Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Bulletin of the American Physical Society

Experimental Evidence for a non-Globally Trace-Preserving POVM

Raymond W. Jensen

Published Jan 1, 2013• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract. A well-known experiment from 1986 involving entangled pairs is examined. The data, which until now have not been modeled quantitatively, is shown not to be in agreement with the quantum measurement postulate using von Neumann projectors. On the other hand, the data agree with the postulate using a more general positive operator valued measure (POVM). The peculiarity of the POVM proposed here is that it is only conditionally a POVM; i.e. it is not complete (trace-preserving) on the entire Hilbert space but only on a subset, although the POVM elements are positive semidefinite observables on the entire space. The state vector of the aforementioned experiment is in the subset where completeness holds. An extension of the conditional POVM is then applied to a proposed experiment involving threeparticle Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) entangled states. As with the Aspect experiment, completeness holds for the conditional POVM upon application to the GHZ state. Violation of the Bell inequality in the GHZ experiment does not occur upon application of von-Neumann projectors; however the conditional POVM allows for Bell inequality violation. PACS numbers: 03.65.Ta,03.65.UdExperimental evidence for a non-globally trace-preserving POVM 2 1. Review of the experiment The experimental evidence examined here is from Aspect, Grangier and Roger [1], hereafter referred to as the Aspect experiment. In the experiment, systems of correlated photon pairs were produced from a single source. The photons, being correlated, are represented by a system of the following form:

DOI
10.13140/2.1.1710.5922

Related papers

There Exist Povm Measurements that Contradict the Quantum Measurement Postulate for Discrete, Degenerate Systems

Raymond W. Jensen

A 1986 experiment involving a two-particle entangled system is analyzed, and it is shown that: (1) the measurement results of that experiment are in contradiction to the discrete degenerate form of the quantum measurement postulate (DDQMP) and (2) the measurements done in the experiment are of the positive operator valued measure (POVM) type. Thus there exist POVM measurements which contradict the DDQMP. A modification to the DDQMP is provided which agrees with the experimental results. The modified DDQMP is then applied to a proposed experiment involving a three-particle Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state.

•Jul 1, 2011•0 citations

Quantum measurement beyond projection: POVMs, instruments, dilation theorems, ancilla-assisted partial measurement, and operational trade-offs

Sachin .

The projection postulate and spectral representation of observables remain central in quantum theory but describe only an idealized measurement limit. Realistic measurements may be inefficient, unsharp, weak, indirect, adaptive, destructive, or informationally incomplete. Positive-operator-valued measures (POVMs) provide the probability rule for processes, whereas quantum instruments specify state transformation. This review traces the hierarchy from von Neumann projective measurement to generalized measurement, emphasizing distinctions among effects, instruments, channels, and implementations. Naimark dilation realizes arbitrary POVMs through unitary coupling to an ancillary meter and projective readout. Stinespring dilation represents completely positive trace-preserving dynamics by unitary evolution on an enlarged system followed by partial trace. A qubit–ancilla interaction yields a partial-measurement instrument, its POVM effects, and its information–disturbance trade-off. It compares projective, generalized, and ancilla-mediated schemes; examines compatibility, instrument incompatibility, and disturbance; and surveys applications to state discrimination, tomography, control, and error correction. Recent developments in dynamic-circuit measurements and noisy-POVM compatibility are integrated with questions concerning measurement back-action and outcome definiteness. The review stresses that a POVM does not uniquely determine state update, dilation theorems establish realizability rather than unique mechanisms, and operational measurement theory does not settle definite outcomes, arguing quantum instruments provide a complete description of measurement.

International Journal of Physics and Applications•Jul 1, 2025•0 citations

Entanglement Assisted Quantum Communication Schemes

Z. Kurucz

Positive operator valued measurements (POVMs) are the most general measurements that can be performed on quantum systems.A POVM is described by set of positive operators instead of orthogonal projections, and it can always be traced back to joint von Neumann measurements on the system and on an ancilla attached to it (Busch et. al, 1991;Peres, 1993).* Note on nomenclature: subscript letters denote the appropriate state spaces for vectors and density operators throughout the document.The same symbol with different subscripts intends to mean that the same quantum information is represented on different systems.

•Nov 23, 2007•0 citations

Quantum Measurements

Reinhold A. Bertlmann, Nicolai Friis

Abstract In this chapter we first review projective or von Neumann measurements from the point of view of the projection postulate and the Lüders rule, before turning to more general measurements modelled using positive operator-valued measures (POVMs). After examining their mathematical description, we discuss symmetric informationally complete (SIC) POVMs and Zauner’s conjecture, as well as the representation of POVMs as projective measurements on a larger Hilbert space, a result called Naimark dilation. We then a model for non-ideal projective measurements and analyse the properties of such measurements in relation to the properties unbiasedness, faithfulness, and non-invasiveness of ideal projective measurements. Finally, we consider the problem of distinguishing non-orthogonal quantum states and examine how the use of POVMs can be beneficial for this task.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 7, 2023•0 citations

On Quantum Entanglement and Nonlocality

Uddin, Mafiz

EPR showed that two particles emitted from a source can be entangled by a shared wavefunction where two non-commuting observables (position, momentum) can be simultaneously real, leading to a contradiction with quantum mechanics (two non-commuting variables can not be simultaneously real). John Bell derived an inequality where any local hidden variables prediction is bounded and quantum mechanics can violate the inequality. Bell tests on correlated photon pairs showed a clear violation of the Bell inequality and agreement with quantum mechanics. This study revealed that the Bell inequality holds at any individual instances in a given system but it does not hold over the entire population. The Bell inequality is not an incompatibility criterion for local hidden variables vs quantum mechanics rather it is a criterion for an individual nature vs population dynamics. The nonlocality prediction given by wavefunction is a system approximation and local causality (photon polarization) provides a complete description of the Bell tests. The paper concludes with great satisfaction that the measurement of two correlated photons at a distance was a local cause (photon-filter interaction did not violate the special theory of relativity).

arXiv:2506.00366•May 31, 2025•0 citations

Quantum measurement with a positive operator-valued measure

Howard E. Brandt

In the quantum theory of measurement, the positive operator-valued measure (POVM) is an important concept, and its implementation can be useful. A POVM consists of a set of non-negative quantum-mechanical Hermitian operators that add up to the identity. The probability that a quantum system is in a particular state is given by the expectation value of the POVM operator corresponding to that state. Following a brief review of the mathematics and mention of the history of POVMs in quantum theory, a particular implementation of a POVM for use in the measurement of nonorthogonal photon polarization states is reviewed. The implementation consists simply of a Wollaston prism, a mirror, two beam splitters, a polarization rotator and three phototubes arranged in an interferometric configuration, and it is shown analytically that the device faithfully represents the POVM. Based on Neumark's extension theorem, the two-dimensional Hilbert space of the POVM implementation can be embedded in the three-dimensional Hilbert space of an ordinary projective-valued measure. Also, analytical expressions are given for the maximum Renyi information loss from the device to a disturbing probe, and for the error and inconclusive rates induced by the probe. Various aspects of the problem of probe optimization are elaborated.

Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Jun 1, 2003•19 citations
Abstract. A well-known experiment from 1986 involving entangled pairs is examined. The data, which until now have not been modeled quantitatively, is shown not to be in agreement with the quantum measurement postulate using von Neumann projectors. On the other hand, the data agree with the postulate using a more general positive operator valued measure (POVM). The peculiarity of the POVM proposed here is that it is only conditionally a POVM; i.e. it is not complete (trace-preserving) on the entire Hilbert space but only on a subset, although the POVM elements are positive semidefinite observables on the entire space. The state vector of the aforementioned experiment is in the subset where completeness holds. An extension of the conditional POVM is then applied to a proposed experiment involving threeparticle Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) entangled states. As with the Aspect experiment, completeness holds for the conditional POVM upon application to the GHZ state. Violation of the Bell inequality in the GHZ experiment does not occur upon application of von-Neumann projectors; however the conditional POVM allows for Bell inequality violation. PACS numbers: 03.65.Ta,03.65.UdExperimental evidence for a non-globally trace-preserving POVM 2 1. Review of the experiment The experimental evidence examined here is from Aspect, Grangier and Roger [1], hereafter referred to as the Aspect experiment. In the experiment, systems of correlated photon pairs were produced from a single source. The photons, being correlated, are represented by a system of the following form:
A 1986 experiment involving a two-particle entangled system is analyzed, and it is shown that: (1) the measurement results of that experiment are in contradiction to the discrete degenerate form of the quantum measurement postulate (DDQMP) and (2) the measurements done in the experiment are of the positive operator valued measure (POVM) type. Thus there exist POVM measurements which contradict the DDQMP. A modification to the DDQMP is provided which agrees with the experimental results. The modified DDQMP is then applied to a proposed experiment involving a three-particle Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state.
The projection postulate and spectral representation of observables remain central in quantum theory but describe only an idealized measurement limit. Realistic measurements may be inefficient, unsharp, weak, indirect, adaptive, destructive, or informationally incomplete. Positive-operator-valued measures (POVMs) provide the probability rule for processes, whereas quantum instruments specify state transformation. This review traces the hierarchy from von Neumann projective measurement to generalized measurement, emphasizing distinctions among effects, instruments, channels, and implementations. Naimark dilation realizes arbitrary POVMs through unitary coupling to an ancillary meter and projective readout. Stinespring dilation represents completely positive trace-preserving dynamics by unitary evolution on an enlarged system followed by partial trace. A qubit–ancilla interaction yields a partial-measurement instrument, its POVM effects, and its information–disturbance trade-off. It compares projective, generalized, and ancilla-mediated schemes; examines compatibility, instrument incompatibility, and disturbance; and surveys applications to state discrimination, tomography, control, and error correction. Recent developments in dynamic-circuit measurements and noisy-POVM compatibility are integrated with questions concerning measurement back-action and outcome definiteness. The review stresses that a POVM does not uniquely determine state update, dilation theorems establish realizability rather than unique mechanisms, and operational measurement theory does not settle definite outcomes, arguing quantum instruments provide a complete description of measurement.
Positive operator valued measurements (POVMs) are the most general measurements that can be performed on quantum systems.A POVM is described by set of positive operators instead of orthogonal projections, and it can always be traced back to joint von Neumann measurements on the system and on an ancilla attached to it (Busch et. al, 1991;Peres, 1993).* Note on nomenclature: subscript letters denote the appropriate state spaces for vectors and density operators throughout the document.The same symbol with different subscripts intends to mean that the same quantum information is represented on different systems.
Abstract In this chapter we first review projective or von Neumann measurements from the point of view of the projection postulate and the Lüders rule, before turning to more general measurements modelled using positive operator-valued measures (POVMs). After examining their mathematical description, we discuss symmetric informationally complete (SIC) POVMs and Zauner’s conjecture, as well as the representation of POVMs as projective measurements on a larger Hilbert space, a result called Naimark dilation. We then a model for non-ideal projective measurements and analyse the properties of such measurements in relation to the properties unbiasedness, faithfulness, and non-invasiveness of ideal projective measurements. Finally, we consider the problem of distinguishing non-orthogonal quantum states and examine how the use of POVMs can be beneficial for this task.
EPR showed that two particles emitted from a source can be entangled by a shared wavefunction where two non-commuting observables (position, momentum) can be simultaneously real, leading to a contradiction with quantum mechanics (two non-commuting variables can not be simultaneously real). John Bell derived an inequality where any local hidden variables prediction is bounded and quantum mechanics can violate the inequality. Bell tests on correlated photon pairs showed a clear violation of the Bell inequality and agreement with quantum mechanics. This study revealed that the Bell inequality holds at any individual instances in a given system but it does not hold over the entire population. The Bell inequality is not an incompatibility criterion for local hidden variables vs quantum mechanics rather it is a criterion for an individual nature vs population dynamics. The nonlocality prediction given by wavefunction is a system approximation and local causality (photon polarization) provides a complete description of the Bell tests. The paper concludes with great satisfaction that the measurement of two correlated photons at a distance was a local cause (photon-filter interaction did not violate the special theory of relativity).
In the quantum theory of measurement, the positive operator-valued measure (POVM) is an important concept, and its implementation can be useful. A POVM consists of a set of non-negative quantum-mechanical Hermitian operators that add up to the identity. The probability that a quantum system is in a particular state is given by the expectation value of the POVM operator corresponding to that state. Following a brief review of the mathematics and mention of the history of POVMs in quantum theory, a particular implementation of a POVM for use in the measurement of nonorthogonal photon polarization states is reviewed. The implementation consists simply of a Wollaston prism, a mirror, two beam splitters, a polarization rotator and three phototubes arranged in an interferometric configuration, and it is shown analytically that the device faithfully represents the POVM. Based on Neumark's extension theorem, the two-dimensional Hilbert space of the POVM implementation can be embedded in the three-dimensional Hilbert space of an ordinary projective-valued measure. Also, analytical expressions are given for the maximum Renyi information loss from the device to a disturbing probe, and for the error and inconclusive rates induced by the probe. Various aspects of the problem of probe optimization are elaborated.