Abstract This paper addresses the critical challenge of modelling inductive couplings in superconductor integrated circuits by introducing a novel method for identifying dominant magnetic couplings in large, complex circuits. The technique first identifies all potential magnetic couplings and then uses admittance parameters from a multi-port network to extract the dominant couplings. This approach significantly streamlines the previously intricate and imprecise manual process of determining these couplings, thereby enhancing design and optimisation of superconductor integrated circuits. We validate our method with a detailed case study of an AC-biased rapid single flux quantum shift register, illustrating each step from circuit-to-graph conversion to inductance extraction from the physical layout. Additionally, we apply the method to an adiabatic quantum-flux-parametron buffer cell to demonstrate its efficacy in circuits with strong inductive coupling. Our findings show that the approach efficiently reduces complexity while maintaining high modelling accuracy, thus improving the design of superconductor circuits. The method presented in this paper is equally applicable to non-superconductor circuits.
Abstract This paper addresses the critical challenge of modelling inductive couplings in superconductor integrated circuits by introducing a novel method for identifying dominant magnetic couplings in large, complex circuits. The technique first identifies all potential magnetic couplings and then uses admittance parameters from a multi-port network to extract the dominant couplings. This approach significantly streamlines the previously intricate and imprecise manual process of determining these couplings, thereby enhancing design and optimisation of superconductor integrated circuits. We validate our method with a detailed case study of an AC-biased rapid single flux quantum shift register, illustrating each step from circuit-to-graph conversion to inductance extraction from the physical layout. Additionally, we apply the method to an adiabatic quantum-flux-parametron buffer cell to demonstrate its efficacy in circuits with strong inductive coupling. Our findings show that the approach efficiently reduces complexity while maintaining high modelling accuracy, thus improving the design of superconductor circuits. The method presented in this paper is equally applicable to non-superconductor circuits.
In the design of superconducting quantum chips, the control and readout of the quantum bit (qubit) are realized through interactions with other components in the circuit, such as drive lines, flux lines and readout resonator. Depending on the design, these interactions employ either an inductive or capacitive coupling scheme. Note that every interaction governs critical performance metrics for the chip, including gate fidelity, readout speed, and coherence times, a more effective and precise approach to extract the strength of the coupling is necessary. For most qubit designs, the structure of the qubit typically remains in the electrically small regime. Therefore, simulation software based on static fields and the Method of Moments (MoM), such as Q3D, is still applicable in most instances. However, as the number of qubits on a chip increases, Q3D faces challenges in effectively addressing the complex coupling and crosstalk issues present on the chip. In this work, we extend the lumped-element-based qubit model by using microwave network parameters and thus enable the simulation of the qubit for the Finite Element Method (FEM)-based 3D electromagnetic simulation software, such as HFSS. This approach is suitable for the determination of the capacitive coupling strength between the qubit and the drive line, as well as readout circuits. Furthermore, to address the inductive coupling between the qubit and the flux line, we propose a method in this work that directly computes the mutual inductance, which is implemented by determining the magnetic flux through the DC SQUID area, generated by the current port excitation in HFSS. The proposed methodologies not only effectively extracts the key qubit design parameters, but also offer broader applicability for analysing complex crosstalk in multi-qubit chip designs.
At present, superconducting integrated circuit layouts are verified through a variety of techniques. A layout-versus-schematic method implemented in Cadence allows extraction of circuit schematics with certain geometry-dependent parameters. Lmeter calculates inductance in a layout network and, with proper setup, may also calculate resistance separately. Recently, InductEx was introduced to calculate multiterminal network inductance in a superconductor structure with support for more complicated 3-D geometries. Here, we present an improvement to InductEx that allows resistance, inductance, and Josephson junction critical current extraction of a full superconducting digital logic gate or cell in a single execution, as well as in reasonable time. We show how InductEx was designed to operate on tape-out ready layouts and, through example, how it is used for full-gate layout verification of contemporary logic cells.
The design of single flux-quantum (SFQ) circuits requires well-defined inductances. In many cases these are created by irregular geometries and a computer-aided design tool is necessary for inductance calculations. This becomes a challenging task in cases where no ground plane is used and thus three-dimensional calculations are required. For this purpose, InductEx was developed and verified successfully for simple structures. In this work we take the next step and demonstrate the applicability of InductEx to the design of rapid single flux-quantum (RSFQ) cells. We use InductEx for inductance modeling as an integral part of the design cycle for an RSFQ cell with flux quantum transfer via mutual inductance and for a DC-reprogrammable logic circuit with similar inductive coupling. The relation between coupling factor and self-inductance is optimized in the circuit layout. All coupling structures are duplicated in SQUID modulation test circuits to measure and verify calculation accuracy. We find excellent agreement between the calculated and measured inductance values. Furthermore, the operational area of the basic cell is determined and compared with similar investigations reported earlier. Based on this comparison we conclude that InductEx is a valuable inductance design tool, and that mutual coupling in structures using ground plane holes and RSFQ-compatible self-inductances can be modeled and designed reliably.
Abstract Currently, fabrication processes for superconductive integrated circuits are moving to multiple wiring and shielding layers, some of which are placed below the main ground plane (GP) and device layers. The Advanced Industrial Science and Technology advanced process (ADP2) was the first such multi-layer Nb process with planarized passive transmission line and GP layers below the junction layer, and is at the time of writing still the most developed. This process allows complex circuit designs, and accurate inductance extraction helps to push the boundaries of the layouts possible. We show that the position of ground connections between ground layers influences the inductance of structures for which these GPs act as return path, and that this needs to be accounted for in modelling. However, due to the number of wiring layers and GPs, full layout modelling of large cells causes long calculation times. In this paper we discuss methods with which to reduce model size, and calibrate InductEx calculations using these methods against measured results. We show that model reduction followed by calibration results in fast calculation times while good accuracy is maintained. We also show that InductEx correctly handles coupling between conductors in a multi-layer layout, and how to model layouts to gauge unwanted coupling between power lines and single flux quantum electronics.
With operating frequencies reaching hundreds of gigahertz and switching energies in the attojoule range, superconducting electronics has become one of the leading candidates among beyond CMOS technologies. The practical implementation of large scale superconducting digital systems is constrained by multiple challenges, including limited power delivery efficiency, restricted scalability and integration density, and the absence of mature electronic design automation tools for large scale circuit design. In this dissertation, modeling, analysis, and design methodologies are presented that address the scalability and integration density challenges of superconducting digital technologies. A methodology for thermal analysis is introduced to describe heat generation and propagation in rapid single flux quantum (RSFQ) circuits. The modeling approach provides temperature estimates that agree with numerical simulations while maintaining low computational cost, enabling temperature-aware design of RSFQ circuit structures and large scale layouts. By quantifying thermal effects on chip, this method supports reliable operation of digital circuits and guides the scaling of integration density in superconducting systems. To further improve scalability of superconducting digital circuits, the use of Josephson junctions with ferromagnetic barriers is investigated. Replacing the insulating barrier with a ferromagnetic layer modifies the current–phase relationship, enabling π-, 2ϕ-, and ϕ-junction operation. These junctions allow inductorless flux quantum storage, intrinsic bias, and phase logic, offering new approaches for area efficient and energy efficient computing with superconducting devices. An inductorless dynamic logic family based on bistable 2ϕ-junctions is proposed, exhibiting improved scalability compared with conventional RSFQ circuits. To enable accurate circuit analysis, a compact Verilog-A model of 2ϕ-junctions is developed. The model reproduces experimentally observed behavior of junctions with weak ferromagnetic and ferromagnetic insulator barriers, and simulations reveal the influence of harmonic components on switching dynamics, margins, and circuit robustness. A variation-aware design methodology is introduced for circuits employing superconductor-erromagnet-superconductor π-junctions. Sensitivities of the critical current density to process and temperature variations are quantified and margins are established for reliable circuit operation. It is shown that magnetic scattering, in particular spin-flip scattering, is the dominant source of parameter sensitivity in junctions with weak ferromagnetic barriers. Material and fabrication choices that enable better control of this parameter are therefore critical for improving reproducibility and reliable device performance. Together, the modeling and design methodologies developed in this dissertation contribute to improving the scalability and reliability of superconducting digital systems, supporting the advancement of high speed, energy efficient computing technologies.
The increasing complexity of modern superconductive circuits, and single flux quantum (SFQ) circuits in particular, has made the issue of coupling noise of growing importance. Limited metal resources within superconductive circuits have exacerbated this issue. In this article, the different sources of coupling noise within SFQ circuits are described. Coupling noise among inductors, routing striplines, and bias microstriplines within SFQ circuits degrade performance while decreasing margins. In this article, inductive and capacitive coupling between the different layers are characterized. Inductive coupling models between different layers in the MIT LL SFQ5ee process match experimental data within 3%. The dependence of inductive coupling on the thickness of the oxide and metal layer is also discussed. An understanding of inductive and capacitive coupling can determine the minimum physical distance between lines. In addition, tradeoffs exist among inductive coupling, capacitive coupling, layout complexity, and the vias between ground layers. The different coupling sources are characterized, and guidelines are provided to enhance the automated routing process.