Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

Identical particles

Published Oct 13, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this chapter we develop some basic concepts associated with identical particles. Section 1.1 presents simple estimates that help to identify under what conditions quantum phenomena associated with identical particles occur. Sec. 1.2 discusses the theoretical and experimental background which suggest that only certain many-particle states are realized in nature. We briefly review the notation pertaining to one-particle quantum mechanics and continue with the case of two identical particles in Sec. 1.3. In Sec. 1.4 some illustrative examples are presented that clarify some experimental consequences related to identical particles. Finally, in Sec. 1.5 we construct states with N identical fermions or bosons and discuss their properties.

DOI
10.1142/9789819808052_0001

Related papers

Composite Systems

Tilak Sinha

In this final chapter we discuss composite systems in Quantum Mechanics. First, we lay out the necessary conditions that the state space of a composite system must satisfy by considering the trivial case of two juxtaposed systems. Then we point out the features that the interesting case of a composite system, whose parts interact with each other, must have. We then move to demonstrate how such a system can be naturally described (quantized) by employing tensor product spaces. The definition and the most relevant properties of tensor product spaces are introduced. Then the meaning of “interactions” in quantum mechanics is explored and the most nontrivial aspects of correlation and entanglement are discussed. Finally, in the last section, we introduce systems of identical particles. We describe how to represent the state space of such systems in terms of one-particle states, number operators and occupation number representations. Classification of identical particles into Bosons and Fermions is explained. Finally, introducing symmetric and antisymmetric states, the traditional quantization scheme using the symmetrization postulate is described. The permutation operator is introduced which is the main tool for dealing with identical particle systems in this language. We wind up by indicating how exchange degeneracy is removed which embodies the signature of indistinguishability.

Chapman & Hall/CRC eBooks•Jun 18, 2021•0 citations

Systems of identical particles

Donald D. Fitts

The postulates 1 to 6 of quantum mechanics as stated in Sections 3.7 and 7.2 apply to multi-particle systems provided that each of the particles is distinguishable from the others. For example, the nucleus and the electron in a hydrogen-like atom are readily distinguishable by their differing masses and charges. When a system contains two or more identical particles, however, postulates 1 to 6 are not sufficient to predict the properties of the system. These postulates must be augmented by an additional postulate. This chapter introduces this new postulate and discusses its consequences. Permutations of identical particles Particles are identical if they cannot be distinguished one from another by any intrinsic property, such as mass, charge, or spin. There does not exist, in fact and in principle, any experimental procedure which can identify any one of the particles. In classical mechanics, even though all particles in the system may have the same intrinsic properties, each may be identified, at least in principle, by its precise trajectory as governed by Newton's laws of motion. This identification is not possible in quantum theory because each particle does not possess a trajectory; instead, the wave function gives the probability density for finding the particle at each point in space. When a particle is found to be in some small region, there is no way of determining either theoretically or experimentally which particle it is.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 26, 1999•0 citations

Identical particles

Efstratios Manousakis

Abstract This chapter discusses the case of a many-body system of identical particles. It considers the consequencies of the symmetry of the Hamiltonian under particle permutations in this case. It discusses how to build many-body Boson and Fermion states. It then introduces the formalism of so-called second quantization, which is usefu, in the case of identical particles. It also expresses the many-body Hamiltonian in terms of creation and annihilation operators.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Nov 1, 2015•0 citations

Identical Particles

Jonathan Allday, Simon Hands

In quantum theory, and especially quantum field theory, the nature of quantum states is transformed if the particles are identical. In fact, the impact of particles (or better quanta) being identical is more profound in quantum theory than in classical mechanics. Their identity has direct experimental consequences over and above those related to the occupation of states. Over the next couple of chapters, we will explore the quantum theory of identical particles to draw out the impact on the entropy of a collection of such particles .

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 3, 2024•0 citations

- Many-particle Systems

Alastair I. M. Rae, Jim Napolitano

Although many of the principles of quantum mechanics can be adequately illustrated by considering systems that consist of only one particle subject to external forces, there are a number of important phenomena that are manifest only in systems containing two or more particles, and these will be the subject of the present chapter. We shall begin with some general statements and go on to consider the case of two interacting particles subject to no external forces, when we shall find that, in this case, the problem can be separated into one describing the behaviour of the centre of mass of the system and another describing the relative motion. We shall then consider the case of two noninteracting particles and show that these can often be treated independently as would be expected. In the case of indistinguishable particles, however, we shall find that a symmetry is imposed on the wave function that ensures that the behaviour of such particles is coupled even when they do not interact. We shall introduce the problem of interacting systems containing more than two identical particles, explaining what is meant by “fermions” and “bosons” and how their properties compare. These results will be illustrated by discussing the energy levels and optical spectra of the helium atom, starting with the approximation that the two electrons do not interact and extending the discussion to the realistic case using perturbation theory. The chapter closes with a consideration of the effects of particle indistinguishability on scattering theory.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 16, 2015•0 citations

IDENTICAL PARTICLES ARE INHERENTLY INDISTINGUISHABLE

The preceding development has been specifically restricted to systems of identical indistinguishable particles, but no further conditions were imposed on the particles or their microstates. The relations derived in Chapter 8 are therefore equally applicable to systems of identical particles in both classical and quantum mechanics, provided the particles are regarded as indistinguishable . As discussed in the Preface and Introduction, it is our firm conviction that identical particles, by their very nature, are indeed inherently and unconditionally indistinguishable. If that proposition is accepted, the relations of Chapter 8 combine with the results of previous chapters to provide a unified general statistical formalism which applies to both classical and quantum particles. However, the appealing simplicity of this picture is undermined by the widespread misconception that identical classical particles are distinguishable, at least in principle, and must be treated as such. In this section we discuss the apparent origins and rationale for this unfortunate misconception in an attempt to reconstruct and rectify the fallacious notions on which it is based.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 22, 2017•0 citations
In this chapter we develop some basic concepts associated with identical particles. Section 1.1 presents simple estimates that help to identify under what conditions quantum phenomena associated with identical particles occur. Sec. 1.2 discusses the theoretical and experimental background which suggest that only certain many-particle states are realized in nature. We briefly review the notation pertaining to one-particle quantum mechanics and continue with the case of two identical particles in Sec. 1.3. In Sec. 1.4 some illustrative examples are presented that clarify some experimental consequences related to identical particles. Finally, in Sec. 1.5 we construct states with N identical fermions or bosons and discuss their properties.
In this final chapter we discuss composite systems in Quantum Mechanics. First, we lay out the necessary conditions that the state space of a composite system must satisfy by considering the trivial case of two juxtaposed systems. Then we point out the features that the interesting case of a composite system, whose parts interact with each other, must have. We then move to demonstrate how such a system can be naturally described (quantized) by employing tensor product spaces. The definition and the most relevant properties of tensor product spaces are introduced. Then the meaning of “interactions” in quantum mechanics is explored and the most nontrivial aspects of correlation and entanglement are discussed. Finally, in the last section, we introduce systems of identical particles. We describe how to represent the state space of such systems in terms of one-particle states, number operators and occupation number representations. Classification of identical particles into Bosons and Fermions is explained. Finally, introducing symmetric and antisymmetric states, the traditional quantization scheme using the symmetrization postulate is described. The permutation operator is introduced which is the main tool for dealing with identical particle systems in this language. We wind up by indicating how exchange degeneracy is removed which embodies the signature of indistinguishability.
The postulates 1 to 6 of quantum mechanics as stated in Sections 3.7 and 7.2 apply to multi-particle systems provided that each of the particles is distinguishable from the others. For example, the nucleus and the electron in a hydrogen-like atom are readily distinguishable by their differing masses and charges. When a system contains two or more identical particles, however, postulates 1 to 6 are not sufficient to predict the properties of the system. These postulates must be augmented by an additional postulate. This chapter introduces this new postulate and discusses its consequences. Permutations of identical particles Particles are identical if they cannot be distinguished one from another by any intrinsic property, such as mass, charge, or spin. There does not exist, in fact and in principle, any experimental procedure which can identify any one of the particles. In classical mechanics, even though all particles in the system may have the same intrinsic properties, each may be identified, at least in principle, by its precise trajectory as governed by Newton's laws of motion. This identification is not possible in quantum theory because each particle does not possess a trajectory; instead, the wave function gives the probability density for finding the particle at each point in space. When a particle is found to be in some small region, there is no way of determining either theoretically or experimentally which particle it is.
In quantum theory, and especially quantum field theory, the nature of quantum states is transformed if the particles are identical. In fact, the impact of particles (or better quanta) being identical is more profound in quantum theory than in classical mechanics. Their identity has direct experimental consequences over and above those related to the occupation of states. Over the next couple of chapters, we will explore the quantum theory of identical particles to draw out the impact on the entropy of a collection of such particles .
Although many of the principles of quantum mechanics can be adequately illustrated by considering systems that consist of only one particle subject to external forces, there are a number of important phenomena that are manifest only in systems containing two or more particles, and these will be the subject of the present chapter. We shall begin with some general statements and go on to consider the case of two interacting particles subject to no external forces, when we shall find that, in this case, the problem can be separated into one describing the behaviour of the centre of mass of the system and another describing the relative motion. We shall then consider the case of two noninteracting particles and show that these can often be treated independently as would be expected. In the case of indistinguishable particles, however, we shall find that a symmetry is imposed on the wave function that ensures that the behaviour of such particles is coupled even when they do not interact. We shall introduce the problem of interacting systems containing more than two identical particles, explaining what is meant by “fermions” and “bosons” and how their properties compare. These results will be illustrated by discussing the energy levels and optical spectra of the helium atom, starting with the approximation that the two electrons do not interact and extending the discussion to the realistic case using perturbation theory. The chapter closes with a consideration of the effects of particle indistinguishability on scattering theory.
The preceding development has been specifically restricted to systems of identical indistinguishable particles, but no further conditions were imposed on the particles or their microstates. The relations derived in Chapter 8 are therefore equally applicable to systems of identical particles in both classical and quantum mechanics, provided the particles are regarded as indistinguishable . As discussed in the Preface and Introduction, it is our firm conviction that identical particles, by their very nature, are indeed inherently and unconditionally indistinguishable. If that proposition is accepted, the relations of Chapter 8 combine with the results of previous chapters to provide a unified general statistical formalism which applies to both classical and quantum particles. However, the appealing simplicity of this picture is undermined by the widespread misconception that identical classical particles are distinguishable, at least in principle, and must be treated as such. In this section we discuss the apparent origins and rationale for this unfortunate misconception in an attempt to reconstruct and rectify the fallacious notions on which it is based.