Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Information Transport in Classical-Quantum Hybrid System

Julian Rapp, Radhika H. Joshi, Alwin van Steensel, Yuli V. Nazarov, Mohammad H. Ansari

Published Oct 13, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Many of the quantities that matter in quantum technology, e.g. entropy, entanglement, etc., cannot be associated with operator observables, because they depend non-linearly on the quantum state’s density matrix. The non-linearity provokes another bigger issue: Standard open-system equations evolve just one copy of that matrix, so we cannot track how such elusive quantities change. A recent formalism by Ansari and Nazarov sidestepped this by evolving multiple virtual replicas at once, but only in the weak-coupling regime. Here, we remove that limitation. Our generalized, multi-replicative master equation follows entropy flow and other vital metrics even when a quantum device interacts strongly with a classical environment. We show quantum coherence and hybridization jointly act to inhibit the net transfer of entropy, effectively introducing a “bottleneck” in the thermodynamic process. This sharper view of quantum–classical hybridization points the way toward more robust, resource-aware quantum hardware.

DOI
10.21203/rs.3.rs-7652984/v1

Related papers

Information Transport in Classic-Quantum Hybrid System

Julian Rapp, Joshi, Radhika H., Alwin van Steensel +2 more

Many important quantities in quantum information science, such as entropy and entanglement, are non-linear functions of the density matrix and cannot be expressed as operator observables. Standard open-system approaches evolve only a single copy of the density matrix, making it impossible to track the dynamics of such quantities. A formalism proposed by some of the present authors addressed this challenge by evolving multiple virtual replicas, but was limited to the weak-coupling regime. Here, we extend this approach to strong coupling between a quantum system and classical environments. The resulting multi-replica master equation enables direct evaluation of entropy flow and related metrics in strongly hybridized quantum-classical systems. Our results show that quantum coherence and hybridization jointly suppress net entropy transfer, creating a thermodynamic bottleneck. This framework provides a general tool for studying entropy dynamics and guiding the design of more robust, resource-efficient quantum hardware.

arXiv:2508.07870•Aug 11, 2025•1 citation

Entropy Production in Quantum is Different

Mohammad H. Ansari, Alwin van Steensel, Yuli V. Nazarov

Currently, ‘time’ does not play any essential role in quantum information theory. In this sense, quantum information theory is underdeveloped similarly to how quantum physics was underdeveloped before Erwin Schrödinger introduced his famous equation for the evolution of a quantum wave function. In this review article, we cope with the problem of time for one of the central quantities in quantum information theory: entropy. Recently, a replica trick formalism, the so-called ‘multiple parallel world’ formalism, has been proposed that revolutionizes entropy evaluation for quantum systems. This formalism is one of the first attempts to introduce ‘time’ in quantum information theory. With the total entropy being conserved in a closed system, entropy can flow internally between subsystems; however, we show that this flow is not limited only to physical correlations as the literature suggest. The nonlinear dependence of entropy on the density matrix introduces new types of correlations with no analogue in physical quantities. Evolving a number of replicas simultaneously makes it possible for them to exchange particles between different replicas. We will summarize some of the recent news about entropy in some example quantum devices. Moreover, we take a quick look at a new correspondence that was recently proposed that provides an interesting link between quantum information theory and quantum physics. The mere existence of such a correspondence allows for exploring new physical phenomena as the result of controlling entanglement in a quantum device.

arXiv:1907.09241•Entropy•Aug 31, 2019•12 citations

Open-system dynamics of entanglement:a key issues review

Leandro Aolita, Fernando de Melo, L. Davidovich

One of the greatest challenges in the fields of quantum information processing and quantum technologies is the detailed coherent control over each and every constituent of quantum systems with an ever increasing number of particles. Within this endeavor, harnessing of many-body entanglement against the detrimental effects of the environment is a major pressing issue. Besides being an important concept from a fundamental standpoint, entanglement has been recognized as a crucial resource for quantum speed-ups or performance enhancements over classical methods. Understanding and controlling many-body entanglement in open systems may have strong implications in quantum computing, quantum simulations of many-body systems, secure quantum communication or cryptography, quantum metrology, our understanding of the quantum-to-classical transition, and other important questions of quantum foundations.In this paper we present an overview of recent theoretical and experimental efforts to underpin the dynamics of entanglement under the influence of noise. Entanglement is thus taken as a dynamic quantity on its own, and we survey how it evolves due to the unavoidable interaction of the entangled system with its surroundings. We analyze several scenarios, corresponding to different families of states and environments, which render a very rich diversity of dynamical behaviors.In contrast to single-particle quantities, like populations and coherences, which typically vanish only asymptotically in time, entanglement may disappear at a finite time. In addition, important classes of entanglement display an exponential decay with the number of particles when subject to local noise, which poses yet another threat to the already-challenging scaling of quantum technologies. Other classes, however, turn out to be extremely robust against local noise. Theoretical results and recent experiments regarding the difference between local and global decoherence are summarized. Control and robustness-enhancement techniques, scaling laws, statistical and geometrical aspects of multipartite-entanglement decay are also reviewed; all in order to give a broad picture of entanglement dynamics in open quantum systems addressed to both theorists and experimentalists inside and outside the field of quantum information.

arXiv:1402.3713•Reports on Progress in Physics•Mar 26, 2015•328 citations

Entropy and energy in quantum networks

David K. Moser

Quantum channels are functions that map density matrices to density matrices. They can be used to describe a vast array of system environment interactions for quantum mechanical systems. The focus in quantum information theory lies on the study of the information content -- the quantum entropy -- of input and output system. The property of how much information a channel can convey is called capacity. When two quantum channels are combined they act on a bigger, possibly entangled state in parallel. The effects of entanglement on the capacity of a pair of channels have been widely studied. Still, recent work showed unexpected behavior. Hastings found that the capacities of two channels to transmit classical information does not simply add, but can exceed the sum of the individual quantum capacities, a property called superadditivity. We study Hastings' work and find estimates for how large the dimensions of such channels would have to be. The question of capacity relates to the behavior of quantum channels in extremal cases, when the output entropy is minimized. It is natural to wonder about the "standard" behavior of quantum channels and consider their average output entropy. We have studied this behavior in particular in cases where many relatively simple quantum channels act in parallel. When combining quantum channels in parallel, the parts of the system evolve independently of each other -- up to entanglement -- and only interact with the environment. Expanding on this idea one can think of a system where the parts not only interact with the environment but also directly with each other, a quantum channel network. Interesting cases of such systems arise naturally in the study of large biological molecules. In this case, information is often transmitted via energy pulses. Thus, the study of entropy and the study of energy overlap. Of particular interest to us are antennas in photo-active systems, they absorb light energy and transports it to a chemical reaction site. Recently, it has been discovered in the FMO molecule that this process evolves coherently, i.e. shows quantum oscillatory behavior. We study such quantum channel networks and how they can be approximated by kinetic networks. When considering the transport efficiency, this helps separating possible coherent effects from incoherent hopping.

•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Dynamical and thermodynamical approaches to open quantum systems

Vitalii Semin, Francesco Petruccione

The non-Markovian dynamics of open quantum systems is studied from two different points of view. The first one coincides with the traditional tracing out of the environmental degrees of freedom, presented in classical textbooks on open quantum systems. The second one is an approximation of the exact density operator with the knowledge of only several dynamical variables in the spirit of non-equilibrium thermodynamics. The approximation is based on the principle of maximal entropy. We discuss the information and the Renyi entropies, which lead to different approximations. The time-convolutionless master equation governs the dynamics of both traditional and approximated reduced density operator with a particular projection operator. Considering the example of two interacting qubits in a thermal environment, we compare the traditional and thermodynamical approaches.

Scientific Reports•Feb 13, 2020•12 citations

Quantum thermodynamics in the strong coupling regime

Newman, David

Quantum thermodynamics seeks to address the emergence of thermodynamic laws, which govern how energy is exchanged between physical systems, from a quantum mechanical description of light and matter. As such, the workhorse model for an underlying description of such energy exchange processes is the open quantum system: a quantum system which may interact with an external environment. Open quantum systems are well-understood in regimes where the interaction between the system and the environment is weak enough that perturbative methods may be employed to arrive at dynamical equations of motion for the evolution of the system. How to tackle the strong coupling regime is an open question and much research is still being devoted in this area. In this project we employ a technique developed for studying an open quantum system in regimes of strong reservoir coupling in problems in thermodynamics which have so far been restricted to the weak coupling regime. We spend some time developing our strong coupling framework and then use it to analyse a quantum heat engine to find that strong coupling leads to a particular set of operational costs which are not present in more well-understood weak coupling versions. We also identify effects purely quantum in nature, present in the engine cycle only at strong coupling, which lead to a degradation in the engine's performance. Finally we address the issue of quantum coherence more generally in archetypal open quantum system models beyond weak coupling, and identify a thermodynamic cost to its erasure.

•Oct 1, 2018•0 citations
Abstract Many of the quantities that matter in quantum technology, e.g. entropy, entanglement, etc., cannot be associated with operator observables, because they depend non-linearly on the quantum state’s density matrix. The non-linearity provokes another bigger issue: Standard open-system equations evolve just one copy of that matrix, so we cannot track how such elusive quantities change. A recent formalism by Ansari and Nazarov sidestepped this by evolving multiple virtual replicas at once, but only in the weak-coupling regime. Here, we remove that limitation. Our generalized, multi-replicative master equation follows entropy flow and other vital metrics even when a quantum device interacts strongly with a classical environment. We show quantum coherence and hybridization jointly act to inhibit the net transfer of entropy, effectively introducing a “bottleneck” in the thermodynamic process. This sharper view of quantum–classical hybridization points the way toward more robust, resource-aware quantum hardware.
Many important quantities in quantum information science, such as entropy and entanglement, are non-linear functions of the density matrix and cannot be expressed as operator observables. Standard open-system approaches evolve only a single copy of the density matrix, making it impossible to track the dynamics of such quantities. A formalism proposed by some of the present authors addressed this challenge by evolving multiple virtual replicas, but was limited to the weak-coupling regime. Here, we extend this approach to strong coupling between a quantum system and classical environments. The resulting multi-replica master equation enables direct evaluation of entropy flow and related metrics in strongly hybridized quantum-classical systems. Our results show that quantum coherence and hybridization jointly suppress net entropy transfer, creating a thermodynamic bottleneck. This framework provides a general tool for studying entropy dynamics and guiding the design of more robust, resource-efficient quantum hardware.
Currently, ‘time’ does not play any essential role in quantum information theory. In this sense, quantum information theory is underdeveloped similarly to how quantum physics was underdeveloped before Erwin Schrödinger introduced his famous equation for the evolution of a quantum wave function. In this review article, we cope with the problem of time for one of the central quantities in quantum information theory: entropy. Recently, a replica trick formalism, the so-called ‘multiple parallel world’ formalism, has been proposed that revolutionizes entropy evaluation for quantum systems. This formalism is one of the first attempts to introduce ‘time’ in quantum information theory. With the total entropy being conserved in a closed system, entropy can flow internally between subsystems; however, we show that this flow is not limited only to physical correlations as the literature suggest. The nonlinear dependence of entropy on the density matrix introduces new types of correlations with no analogue in physical quantities. Evolving a number of replicas simultaneously makes it possible for them to exchange particles between different replicas. We will summarize some of the recent news about entropy in some example quantum devices. Moreover, we take a quick look at a new correspondence that was recently proposed that provides an interesting link between quantum information theory and quantum physics. The mere existence of such a correspondence allows for exploring new physical phenomena as the result of controlling entanglement in a quantum device.
One of the greatest challenges in the fields of quantum information processing and quantum technologies is the detailed coherent control over each and every constituent of quantum systems with an ever increasing number of particles. Within this endeavor, harnessing of many-body entanglement against the detrimental effects of the environment is a major pressing issue. Besides being an important concept from a fundamental standpoint, entanglement has been recognized as a crucial resource for quantum speed-ups or performance enhancements over classical methods. Understanding and controlling many-body entanglement in open systems may have strong implications in quantum computing, quantum simulations of many-body systems, secure quantum communication or cryptography, quantum metrology, our understanding of the quantum-to-classical transition, and other important questions of quantum foundations.In this paper we present an overview of recent theoretical and experimental efforts to underpin the dynamics of entanglement under the influence of noise. Entanglement is thus taken as a dynamic quantity on its own, and we survey how it evolves due to the unavoidable interaction of the entangled system with its surroundings. We analyze several scenarios, corresponding to different families of states and environments, which render a very rich diversity of dynamical behaviors.In contrast to single-particle quantities, like populations and coherences, which typically vanish only asymptotically in time, entanglement may disappear at a finite time. In addition, important classes of entanglement display an exponential decay with the number of particles when subject to local noise, which poses yet another threat to the already-challenging scaling of quantum technologies. Other classes, however, turn out to be extremely robust against local noise. Theoretical results and recent experiments regarding the difference between local and global decoherence are summarized. Control and robustness-enhancement techniques, scaling laws, statistical and geometrical aspects of multipartite-entanglement decay are also reviewed; all in order to give a broad picture of entanglement dynamics in open quantum systems addressed to both theorists and experimentalists inside and outside the field of quantum information.
Quantum channels are functions that map density matrices to density matrices. They can be used to describe a vast array of system environment interactions for quantum mechanical systems. The focus in quantum information theory lies on the study of the information content -- the quantum entropy -- of input and output system. The property of how much information a channel can convey is called capacity. When two quantum channels are combined they act on a bigger, possibly entangled state in parallel. The effects of entanglement on the capacity of a pair of channels have been widely studied. Still, recent work showed unexpected behavior. Hastings found that the capacities of two channels to transmit classical information does not simply add, but can exceed the sum of the individual quantum capacities, a property called superadditivity. We study Hastings' work and find estimates for how large the dimensions of such channels would have to be. The question of capacity relates to the behavior of quantum channels in extremal cases, when the output entropy is minimized. It is natural to wonder about the "standard" behavior of quantum channels and consider their average output entropy. We have studied this behavior in particular in cases where many relatively simple quantum channels act in parallel. When combining quantum channels in parallel, the parts of the system evolve independently of each other -- up to entanglement -- and only interact with the environment. Expanding on this idea one can think of a system where the parts not only interact with the environment but also directly with each other, a quantum channel network. Interesting cases of such systems arise naturally in the study of large biological molecules. In this case, information is often transmitted via energy pulses. Thus, the study of entropy and the study of energy overlap. Of particular interest to us are antennas in photo-active systems, they absorb light energy and transports it to a chemical reaction site. Recently, it has been discovered in the FMO molecule that this process evolves coherently, i.e. shows quantum oscillatory behavior. We study such quantum channel networks and how they can be approximated by kinetic networks. When considering the transport efficiency, this helps separating possible coherent effects from incoherent hopping.
The non-Markovian dynamics of open quantum systems is studied from two different points of view. The first one coincides with the traditional tracing out of the environmental degrees of freedom, presented in classical textbooks on open quantum systems. The second one is an approximation of the exact density operator with the knowledge of only several dynamical variables in the spirit of non-equilibrium thermodynamics. The approximation is based on the principle of maximal entropy. We discuss the information and the Renyi entropies, which lead to different approximations. The time-convolutionless master equation governs the dynamics of both traditional and approximated reduced density operator with a particular projection operator. Considering the example of two interacting qubits in a thermal environment, we compare the traditional and thermodynamical approaches.
Quantum thermodynamics seeks to address the emergence of thermodynamic laws, which govern how energy is exchanged between physical systems, from a quantum mechanical description of light and matter. As such, the workhorse model for an underlying description of such energy exchange processes is the open quantum system: a quantum system which may interact with an external environment. Open quantum systems are well-understood in regimes where the interaction between the system and the environment is weak enough that perturbative methods may be employed to arrive at dynamical equations of motion for the evolution of the system. How to tackle the strong coupling regime is an open question and much research is still being devoted in this area. In this project we employ a technique developed for studying an open quantum system in regimes of strong reservoir coupling in problems in thermodynamics which have so far been restricted to the weak coupling regime. We spend some time developing our strong coupling framework and then use it to analyse a quantum heat engine to find that strong coupling leads to a particular set of operational costs which are not present in more well-understood weak coupling versions. We also identify effects purely quantum in nature, present in the engine cycle only at strong coupling, which lead to a degradation in the engine's performance. Finally we address the issue of quantum coherence more generally in archetypal open quantum system models beyond weak coupling, and identify a thermodynamic cost to its erasure.