Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1907.09241 · Entropy

Entropy Production in Quantum is Different

Mohammad H. Ansari, Alwin van Steensel, Yuli V. Nazarov

Published Aug 31, 2019• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Currently, ‘time’ does not play any essential role in quantum information theory. In this sense, quantum information theory is underdeveloped similarly to how quantum physics was underdeveloped before Erwin Schrödinger introduced his famous equation for the evolution of a quantum wave function. In this review article, we cope with the problem of time for one of the central quantities in quantum information theory: entropy. Recently, a replica trick formalism, the so-called ‘multiple parallel world’ formalism, has been proposed that revolutionizes entropy evaluation for quantum systems. This formalism is one of the first attempts to introduce ‘time’ in quantum information theory. With the total entropy being conserved in a closed system, entropy can flow internally between subsystems; however, we show that this flow is not limited only to physical correlations as the literature suggest. The nonlinear dependence of entropy on the density matrix introduces new types of correlations with no analogue in physical quantities. Evolving a number of replicas simultaneously makes it possible for them to exchange particles between different replicas. We will summarize some of the recent news about entropy in some example quantum devices. Moreover, we take a quick look at a new correspondence that was recently proposed that provides an interesting link between quantum information theory and quantum physics. The mere existence of such a correspondence allows for exploring new physical phenomena as the result of controlling entanglement in a quantum device.

DOI
10.3390/e21090854

Related papers

Information Transport in Classical-Quantum Hybrid System

Julian Rapp, Radhika H. Joshi, Alwin van Steensel +2 more

Abstract Many of the quantities that matter in quantum technology, e.g. entropy, entanglement, etc., cannot be associated with operator observables, because they depend non-linearly on the quantum state’s density matrix. The non-linearity provokes another bigger issue: Standard open-system equations evolve just one copy of that matrix, so we cannot track how such elusive quantities change. A recent formalism by Ansari and Nazarov sidestepped this by evolving multiple virtual replicas at once, but only in the weak-coupling regime. Here, we remove that limitation. Our generalized, multi-replicative master equation follows entropy flow and other vital metrics even when a quantum device interacts strongly with a classical environment. We show quantum coherence and hybridization jointly act to inhibit the net transfer of entropy, effectively introducing a “bottleneck” in the thermodynamic process. This sharper view of quantum–classical hybridization points the way toward more robust, resource-aware quantum hardware.

•Oct 13, 2025•0 citations

Information Entropy as a Physical Quantity Measurement and Quantum State Correlation

Jincheng Zhang

This paper explores the potential of utilizing measurements of information entropy-related physical quantities as a novel approach to predict and control quantum state correlations. The central argument posits that precise determination of entropy-related parameters within a system can directly influence the associated quantum entanglement and correlations. We propose a new measurement device designed to simultaneously quantify entropy, energy, and other relevant physical attributes. This device, when coupled with a theoretical framework, offers a mechanism for manipulating quantum correlations by modulating these measured quantities. The research introduces a fundamentally new perspective on quantum control, shifting the focus from traditional methods to a measurement-based approach leveraging the intrinsic information content of a quantum system. The paper details the theoretical underpinnings, outlines the design considerations for the measurement device, and discusses the potential implications for advancements in quantum computing and communication.

•Sep 6, 2026•0 citations

Aspects of entropy in classical and in quantum physics

Stefan Heusler, Wolfgang Dür, Malte S. Ubben +1 more

Abstract Entropy has played an essential role in the history of physics. Its mathematical definition and applications have changed over time till today. In this paper, we first review the historical evolution of these various points of view, from the thermodynamic definition to information entropy from Shannon in classical physics, up to the modern concept of Neumann’s quantum entropy. As a specific example, we consider entanglement entropy and compare the phase space approach in classical physics to the Hilbert space approach in quantum physics in simple model systems. We derive a general expression for the entanglement entropy of fermions and bosons in arbitrary partitions of Hilbert space, valid beyond the thermodynamic limit. Next, we compare thermodynamic heat engines with quantum heat engines. Finally, we proceed to the more general concept of quantum (computational) complexity and argue, using the concept of entanglement entropy, that the Heisenberg time in classically chaotic systems coincides with the time when maximal complexity is reached in the quantum case for systems with all–all interactions.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Sep 5, 2022•10 citations

Entropy production in a photovoltaic cell

Mohammad H. Ansari

We evaluate entropy production in a photovoltaic cell that is modeled by four electronic levels resonantly coupled to thermally populated field modes at different temperatures. We use a formalism recently proposed, the so-called multiple parallel worlds, to consistently address the nonlinearity of entropy in terms of density matrix. Our result shows that entropy production is the difference between two flows: a semiclassical flow that linearly depends on occupational probabilities, and another flow that depends nonlinearly on quantum coherence and has no semiclassical analog. We show that entropy production in the cells depends on environmentally induced decoherence time and energy detuning. We characterize regimes where reversal flow of information takes place from a cold to hot bath. Interestingly, we identify a lower bound on entropy production, which sets limitations on the statistics of dissipated heat in the cells.

arXiv:1704.05527•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 18, 2017•8 citations

Shannon entropy of the measurement record at measurement-dominated criticality and RG flow: A c-theorem for effective central charge and a g-theorem for effective boundary entropy

Rushikesh A. Patil, Andreas W. W. Ludwig

We present two theorems demonstrating non-perturbatively the decrease under relevant renormalization group (RG) flow of two quantities, $c_{\text{eff}}$ and $g_{\text{eff}}$ characterizing, respectively, the universal information content of the Shannon entropy of the measurement record for two different types of measurement-dominated criticality. First, we demonstrate the decrease of the "effective central charge" $c_{\text{eff}}$ of $2D$ replica field theories in the $R\rightarrow1$ replica limit that govern the long-distance physics of weakly monitored $2D$ classical critical systems (Baysian inference problems) studied recently in the literature [arXiv:2504.01264; arXiv:2504.12385; arXiv:2504.08888]. In particular, we show that $c_{\text{eff}}$ is $\textit{less}$ than the central charge $c$ of the unmeasured critical system. We refer to this result as the "$c$-effective theorem''. In addition, we present an analogous "$g$-effective theorem" demonstrating the decrease under RG flow of the effective "Affleck-Ludwig'' boundary entropy $\ln g_\text{eff}$, quantifying a corresponding contribution to the Shannon entropy for analogous $2D$ $\textit{defect}$ replica field theories in the $R\rightarrow1$ replica limit, which govern the long-distance physics in the problem of performing weak $\textit{quantum}$ measurements on one-dimensional quantum critical ground states. Lastly, we discuss a possible consequence of our theorems for classical systems with generic uncorrelated impurity-type quenched disorder, according to which, under a certain assumption, and as opposed to problems with measurement-induced randomness, the corresponding universal quantities $c_{\text{eff}}^{(R\rightarrow0)}$ and $g_{\text{eff}}^{(R\rightarrow0)}$ in the $R\rightarrow0$ replica limit would $\textit{increase}$ under RG flow.

arXiv:2507.07959•Jul 10, 2025•15 citations

Quantum Chaos and Quantum Information: Interactions and Implications

Arul Lakshminarayan, Karol Życzkowski

The notion of Shannon entropy is crucial for the theory of classical information. In quantum information theory, an analogous key role is played by the von Neumann entropy: quantum information processing is closely related to entropy dynamics. This reveals a direct link with the theory of quantum chaotic systems, which can be characterized by a positive entropy production. Furthermore, noise, which inevitably affects any quantum system, can be modeled by a random quantum operation or by coupling to an environment in a generic chaotic state. In this contribution, we emphasize the universality of quantum chaotic dynamics and discuss its implications for quantum information processing.

quant-pharXiv:2604.12267•Apr 15, 2026•2 citations
Currently, ‘time’ does not play any essential role in quantum information theory. In this sense, quantum information theory is underdeveloped similarly to how quantum physics was underdeveloped before Erwin Schrödinger introduced his famous equation for the evolution of a quantum wave function. In this review article, we cope with the problem of time for one of the central quantities in quantum information theory: entropy. Recently, a replica trick formalism, the so-called ‘multiple parallel world’ formalism, has been proposed that revolutionizes entropy evaluation for quantum systems. This formalism is one of the first attempts to introduce ‘time’ in quantum information theory. With the total entropy being conserved in a closed system, entropy can flow internally between subsystems; however, we show that this flow is not limited only to physical correlations as the literature suggest. The nonlinear dependence of entropy on the density matrix introduces new types of correlations with no analogue in physical quantities. Evolving a number of replicas simultaneously makes it possible for them to exchange particles between different replicas. We will summarize some of the recent news about entropy in some example quantum devices. Moreover, we take a quick look at a new correspondence that was recently proposed that provides an interesting link between quantum information theory and quantum physics. The mere existence of such a correspondence allows for exploring new physical phenomena as the result of controlling entanglement in a quantum device.
Abstract Many of the quantities that matter in quantum technology, e.g. entropy, entanglement, etc., cannot be associated with operator observables, because they depend non-linearly on the quantum state’s density matrix. The non-linearity provokes another bigger issue: Standard open-system equations evolve just one copy of that matrix, so we cannot track how such elusive quantities change. A recent formalism by Ansari and Nazarov sidestepped this by evolving multiple virtual replicas at once, but only in the weak-coupling regime. Here, we remove that limitation. Our generalized, multi-replicative master equation follows entropy flow and other vital metrics even when a quantum device interacts strongly with a classical environment. We show quantum coherence and hybridization jointly act to inhibit the net transfer of entropy, effectively introducing a “bottleneck” in the thermodynamic process. This sharper view of quantum–classical hybridization points the way toward more robust, resource-aware quantum hardware.
This paper explores the potential of utilizing measurements of information entropy-related physical quantities as a novel approach to predict and control quantum state correlations. The central argument posits that precise determination of entropy-related parameters within a system can directly influence the associated quantum entanglement and correlations. We propose a new measurement device designed to simultaneously quantify entropy, energy, and other relevant physical attributes. This device, when coupled with a theoretical framework, offers a mechanism for manipulating quantum correlations by modulating these measured quantities. The research introduces a fundamentally new perspective on quantum control, shifting the focus from traditional methods to a measurement-based approach leveraging the intrinsic information content of a quantum system. The paper details the theoretical underpinnings, outlines the design considerations for the measurement device, and discusses the potential implications for advancements in quantum computing and communication.
Abstract Entropy has played an essential role in the history of physics. Its mathematical definition and applications have changed over time till today. In this paper, we first review the historical evolution of these various points of view, from the thermodynamic definition to information entropy from Shannon in classical physics, up to the modern concept of Neumann’s quantum entropy. As a specific example, we consider entanglement entropy and compare the phase space approach in classical physics to the Hilbert space approach in quantum physics in simple model systems. We derive a general expression for the entanglement entropy of fermions and bosons in arbitrary partitions of Hilbert space, valid beyond the thermodynamic limit. Next, we compare thermodynamic heat engines with quantum heat engines. Finally, we proceed to the more general concept of quantum (computational) complexity and argue, using the concept of entanglement entropy, that the Heisenberg time in classically chaotic systems coincides with the time when maximal complexity is reached in the quantum case for systems with all–all interactions.
We evaluate entropy production in a photovoltaic cell that is modeled by four electronic levels resonantly coupled to thermally populated field modes at different temperatures. We use a formalism recently proposed, the so-called multiple parallel worlds, to consistently address the nonlinearity of entropy in terms of density matrix. Our result shows that entropy production is the difference between two flows: a semiclassical flow that linearly depends on occupational probabilities, and another flow that depends nonlinearly on quantum coherence and has no semiclassical analog. We show that entropy production in the cells depends on environmentally induced decoherence time and energy detuning. We characterize regimes where reversal flow of information takes place from a cold to hot bath. Interestingly, we identify a lower bound on entropy production, which sets limitations on the statistics of dissipated heat in the cells.
We present two theorems demonstrating non-perturbatively the decrease under relevant renormalization group (RG) flow of two quantities, ceffc_{\text{eff}}ceff​ and geffg_{\text{eff}}geff​ characterizing, respectively, the universal information content of the Shannon entropy of the measurement record for two different types of measurement-dominated criticality. First, we demonstrate the decrease of the "effective central charge" ceffc_{\text{eff}}ceff​ of 2D2D2D replica field theories in the R→1R\rightarrow1R→1 replica limit that govern the long-distance physics of weakly monitored 2D2D2D classical critical systems (Baysian inference problems) studied recently in the literature [arXiv:2504.01264; arXiv:2504.12385; arXiv:2504.08888]. In particular, we show that ceffc_{\text{eff}}ceff​ is less\textit{less}less than the central charge ccc of the unmeasured critical system. We refer to this result as the "ccc-effective theorem''. In addition, we present an analogous "ggg-effective theorem" demonstrating the decrease under RG flow of the effective "Affleck-Ludwig'' boundary entropy ln⁡geff\ln g_\text{eff}lngeff​, quantifying a corresponding contribution to the Shannon entropy for analogous 2D2D2D defect\textit{defect}defect replica field theories in the R→1R\rightarrow1R→1 replica limit, which govern the long-distance physics in the problem of performing weak quantum\textit{quantum}quantum measurements on one-dimensional quantum critical ground states. Lastly, we discuss a possible consequence of our theorems for classical systems with generic uncorrelated impurity-type quenched disorder, according to which, under a certain assumption, and as opposed to problems with measurement-induced randomness, the corresponding universal quantities ceff(R→0)c_{\text{eff}}^{(R\rightarrow0)}ceff(R→0)​ and geff(R→0)g_{\text{eff}}^{(R\rightarrow0)}geff(R→0)​ in the R→0R\rightarrow0R→0 replica limit would increase\textit{increase}increase under RG flow.
The notion of Shannon entropy is crucial for the theory of classical information. In quantum information theory, an analogous key role is played by the von Neumann entropy: quantum information processing is closely related to entropy dynamics. This reveals a direct link with the theory of quantum chaotic systems, which can be characterized by a positive entropy production. Furthermore, noise, which inevitably affects any quantum system, can be modeled by a random quantum operation or by coupling to an environment in a generic chaotic state. In this contribution, we emphasize the universality of quantum chaotic dynamics and discuss its implications for quantum information processing.