Unconventional compute methods and future challenges for superconducting digital computing
George Michelogiannakis, Anastasiia Butko, Patricia Gonzalez-Guerrero, Dilip P. Vasudevan, Meriam Gay Bautista, Carl R. Grace, Panagiotis G. Zarkos, John M. Shalf
Superconducting digital computing (SDC) based on Josephson junctions (JJs) offers significant potential for enhancing compute throughput and reducing energy consumption compared to conventional room-temperature CMOS-based approaches. Current superconducting logic families exhibit diverse characteristics in clocking strategies, power management, and information encoding techniques. This paper reviews recent advancements in unconventional computing methods specifically designed for superconducting digital circuits, emphasizing temporal computing and pulse-train representations. Notable techniques include race logic (RL), temporal pulse train computing (U-SFQ), and temporal multipliers, each offering unique performance and area advantages suited to superconducting implementations. Additionally, this paper reviews innovations in superconducting coarse-grain reconfigurable architectures (CGRA), superconducting-specific on-chip communication architectures, cryogenic sensor interfaces, and quantum computing control electronics. Finally, we highlight research challenges that should be addressed to facilitate the widespread adoption of superconducting digital computing.
Superconducting digital computing (SDC) based on Josephson junctions (JJs) offers significant potential for enhancing compute throughput and reducing energy consumption compared to conventional room-temperature CMOS-based approaches. Current superconducting logic families exhibit diverse characteristics in clocking strategies, power management, and information encoding techniques. This paper reviews recent advancements in unconventional computing methods specifically designed for superconducting digital circuits, emphasizing temporal computing and pulse-train representations. Notable techniques include race logic (RL), temporal pulse train computing (U-SFQ), and temporal multipliers, each offering unique performance and area advantages suited to superconducting implementations. Additionally, this paper reviews innovations in superconducting coarse-grain reconfigurable architectures (CGRA), superconducting-specific on-chip communication architectures, cryogenic sensor interfaces, and quantum computing control electronics. Finally, we highlight research challenges that should be addressed to facilitate the widespread adoption of superconducting digital computing.
Quantum electronic circuits where the logic information is processed and stored in single flux quanta promise efficient computation in a performance/power metric, and thus are of utmost interest as possible replacement or enhancement of CMOS. Several electronic device families leverage superconducting materials and transitions between resistive and superconducting states. Information is coded into bits with deterministic values - as opposed to qubits used in quantum computing. As an example, information can be coded into pulses. Logic gates can be modeled as finite-state machines, that emit logic outputs in response to inputs. The most natural realization of such circuits is through synchronous implementations, where a clock stimulus is transmitted to every logic gate and where logic depth is balanced at every input to achieve full synchrony. Novel superconducting realization families try to go beyond the limitations of synchronous logic with approaches reminiscent of asynchronous design style and leveraging information coding. Moreover, some superconducting families exploit adiabatic operation, in the search for minimizing energy consumption. Design automation for quantum electronic logic families is still in its infancy, but important results have been achieved in terms of automatic balancing and fanout management. The combination of these problems with logic restructuring poses new challenges, as the overall problem is more complex as compared to CMOS and algorithms and tools cannot be just adapted. This presentation will cover recent advancement in design automation for superconducting electronic circuits as well as address future developments in the field.
Superconducting (SC) electronics have emerged as a promising platform for high-speed, energy-efficient computing and quantum information processing. This work, centered on NbTiN, presents recent advances in material science and fabrication methods leading to significant improvements in performance, scalability and vertical integration. We specifically report on fabrication and characterization of key components, including Josephson junctions (JJs), flux trapping structures and SC interconnects. Together, these efforts represent critical steps towards realizing practical, complex, dense and large-scale SC integrated circuits.
Superconductive electronics offers a unique combination of high bandwidth and low power for mission critical hardware such as digital processors at 20 to 100 GHz, microwatt per bit analog to digital converters, large digital switches at multi-Gb/s data rates, and low noise parametric amplifiers. This cryogenic technology, typically operating at a few degrees or a few tens of degrees Kelvin, depends upon the unique physics of superconducting materials such as Nb, NbN, and YBaCuO, and the fundamental circuit element, the Josephson junction (JJ) to create unique architectures of unprecedented design efficiency and performance. These circuits are based on the single flux quantum (SFQ) logic family, a technology that has no parallel in semiconductor electronics. Digital data is transmitted by voltage pulses with amplitude less than 1 mV, but at extremely high speeds. Individual gates have been operated as high as 370 GHz. In this paper, we present a brief overview of superconductive digital technology, describe some recent circuits, and discuss how the challenges to superconductive technology are being met, including the use of multi-chip module (MCM) technology, and the potential use of III-V HBT and HEMT circuits to provide interface drivers and amplifiers, possibly operated cryogenically.
Superconducting qubits based on Josephson junctions are one of the leading candidates for building a largescale quantum information processor. There have been significant advances in the performance of superconducting qubits over the past decade and there is currently rapid progress in the development of systems with up to tens of qubits. In order to build to yet larger systems, new techniques will need to be developed to address the overhead requirements for room-temperature electronics hardware and cryostat wiring for controlling and reading out large numbers of qubits. One approach to this challenge involves implementing more of the qubit control and readout in the low-temperature environment. I will describe our efforts on integrating superconducting classical digital circuitry with superconducting qubits for coherent control and readout.
Large-scale computing system characteristics vary by application class, but power and energy use has become a major problem for all classes. Superconducting computing may be able to serve the needs of these systems significantly better than conventional technology. Recent developments in single flux quantum circuit technology for digital logic include variants with greatly improved energy efficiency. Concepts were investigated for computing systems capable of performance in the range from 1 to 1000 PFLOP/s. The concept systems were constrained to use existing commercial cryogenic refrigerators and Nb superconducting technology. In order to meet the performance goals, cache and main memory capable of operating at cryogenic temperatures will be required. Superconducting computing is shown to be potentially competitive on the basis of power and energy efficiency if key component technologies can meet specific goals. Potential advantages of superconducting computing are identified as well as areas requiring further development.
With operating frequencies reaching hundreds of gigahertz and switching energies in the attojoule range, superconducting electronics has become one of the leading candidates among beyond CMOS technologies. The practical implementation of large scale superconducting digital systems is constrained by multiple challenges, including limited power delivery efficiency, restricted scalability and integration density, and the absence of mature electronic design automation tools for large scale circuit design. In this dissertation, modeling, analysis, and design methodologies are presented that address the scalability and integration density challenges of superconducting digital technologies. A methodology for thermal analysis is introduced to describe heat generation and propagation in rapid single flux quantum (RSFQ) circuits. The modeling approach provides temperature estimates that agree with numerical simulations while maintaining low computational cost, enabling temperature-aware design of RSFQ circuit structures and large scale layouts. By quantifying thermal effects on chip, this method supports reliable operation of digital circuits and guides the scaling of integration density in superconducting systems. To further improve scalability of superconducting digital circuits, the use of Josephson junctions with ferromagnetic barriers is investigated. Replacing the insulating barrier with a ferromagnetic layer modifies the current–phase relationship, enabling π-, 2ϕ-, and ϕ-junction operation. These junctions allow inductorless flux quantum storage, intrinsic bias, and phase logic, offering new approaches for area efficient and energy efficient computing with superconducting devices. An inductorless dynamic logic family based on bistable 2ϕ-junctions is proposed, exhibiting improved scalability compared with conventional RSFQ circuits. To enable accurate circuit analysis, a compact Verilog-A model of 2ϕ-junctions is developed. The model reproduces experimentally observed behavior of junctions with weak ferromagnetic and ferromagnetic insulator barriers, and simulations reveal the influence of harmonic components on switching dynamics, margins, and circuit robustness. A variation-aware design methodology is introduced for circuits employing superconductor-erromagnet-superconductor π-junctions. Sensitivities of the critical current density to process and temperature variations are quantified and margins are established for reliable circuit operation. It is shown that magnetic scattering, in particular spin-flip scattering, is the dominant source of parameter sensitivity in junctions with weak ferromagnetic barriers. Material and fabrication choices that enable better control of this parameter are therefore critical for improving reproducibility and reliable device performance. Together, the modeling and design methodologies developed in this dissertation contribute to improving the scalability and reliability of superconducting digital systems, supporting the advancement of high speed, energy efficient computing technologies.