What does it mean for the physically motivated computational complexity class $\mathcal{BQP}$ and the logically motivated class $\mathcal{NP}$ to be incomparable, from a physical perspective? Although it is unlikely that quantum computers can solve $\mathcal{NP}$-complete problems in polynomial time, yet it may be instructive to see how a physical theory (denoted $\Theta^{(\mathcal{NP})}$ or $\Theta^{(\mathcal{PSPACE})}$) for which $\mathcal{NP}$ or even $\mathcal{PSPACE}$, respectively, constitutes an efficient model of computation, would compare with quantum theory. The present work explores this question, after briefly reviewing some complexity results indicative of the incomparability of $\mathcal{BQP}$ and $\mathcal{NP}$. We argue that theories $\Theta^{(\mathcal{NP})}$ or $\Theta^{(\mathcal{PSPACE})}$ effectively feature degrees of nonlinearity. Thus, the linearity of quantum theory prevents complete problems in these complexity classes to be efficiently solvable on a quantum computer. On the other hand, the exponentiality of quantum theory endows quantum computers with a certain strength going beyond $\mathcal{NP}$ or even $\mathcal{PH}$. Thus the contrasting roles of the empowerment provided by quantum mechanical exponentiality and the limitation imposed by quantum mechanical linearity seem to be at the heart of the incomparability of the classes $\mathcal{BQP}$ and $\mathcal{NP}$. Quanta 2025; 14: 38–47.
What does it mean for the physically motivated computational complexity class BQP and the logically motivated class NP to be incomparable, from a physical perspective? Although it is unlikely that quantum computers can solve NP-complete problems in polynomial time, yet it may be instructive to see how a physical theory (denoted Θ(NP) or Θ(PSPACE)) for which NP or even PSPACE, respectively, constitutes an efficient model of computation, would compare with quantum theory. The present work explores this question, after briefly reviewing some complexity results indicative of the incomparability of BQP and NP. We argue that theories Θ(NP) or Θ(PSPACE) effectively feature degrees of nonlinearity. Thus, the linearity of quantum theory prevents complete problems in these complexity classes to be efficiently solvable on a quantum computer. On the other hand, the exponentiality of quantum theory endows quantum computers with a certain strength going beyond NP or even PH. Thus the contrasting roles of the empowerment provided by quantum mechanical exponentiality and the limitation imposed by quantum mechanical linearity seem to be at the heart of the incomparability of the classes BQP and NP. Quanta 2025; 14: 38–47.
We explore the space "just above" BQP by defining a complexity class naCQP (non-adaptive Collapse-free Quantum Polynomial time) which is larger than BQP but does not contain NP relative to an oracle. The class is defined by imagining that quantum computers can perform (non-adaptive) measurements that do not collapse the wavefunction. This non-physical model of computation can efficiently solve problems such as Graph Isomorphism and Approximate Shortest Vector which are believed to be intractable for quantum computers. Furthermore, it can search an unstructured N-element list in Õ(N1/3) time, but no faster than Ω(N1/4), and hence cannot solve NP-hard problems in a black box manner. In short, this model of computation is more powerful than standard quantum computation, but only slightly so. This is surprising as most modifications of BQP increase the power of quantum computation to NP or beyond.
The complexity class PSPACE includes all computational problems that can be solved by a classical computer with polynomial memory. All PSPACE problems are known to be solvable by a quantum computer too with polynomial memory and are, thus, known to be in BQPSPACE. Here, we present a polynomial time quantum algorithm for a PSPACE-complete problem, implying that PSPACE is equal to the class BQP of all problems solvable by a quantum computer in polynomial time. In particular, we outline a BQP algorithm for the PSPACE-complete problem of evaluating a full binary NAND tree. An existing best of quadratic speedup is achieved using quantum walks for this problem, so that the complexity is still exponential in the problem size. By contrast, we achieve an exponential speedup for the problem, allowing for solving it in polynomial time. There are many real-world applications of our result, such as strategy games like chess or Go. As an example, in quantum sensing, the problem of quantum illumination, that is treated as that of channel discrimination, is PSPACE-complete. Our work implies that quantum channel discrimination, and so, quantum illumination, can be performed efficiently by a quantum computer.
The central problem in computer science is the conjecture that two complexity classes, P (polynomial time) and NP (nondeterministic polynomial time-roughly those decision problems for which a proposed solution can be checked in polynomial time), are distinct in the standard Turing model of computation: P not equal NP. As a generality, we propose that each physical theory supports computational models whose power is limited by the physical theory. It is well known that classical physics supports a multitude of implementation of the Turing machine. Non-Abelian topological quantum field theories exhibit the mathematical features necessary to support a model capable of solving all #P problems, a computationally intractable class, in polynomial time. Specifically, Witten [Witten, E. (1989) Commun. Math. Phys. 121, 351-391] has identified expectation values in a certain SU(2)-field theory with values of the Jones polynomial [Jones, V. (1985) Bull. Am. Math. Soc. 12, 103-111] that are #P-hard [Jaeger, F., Vertigen, D. & Welsh, D. (1990) Math. Proc. Comb. Philos. Soc. 108, 35-53]. This suggests that some physical system whose effective Lagrangian contains a non-Abelian topological term might be manipulated to serve as an analog computer capable of solving NP or even #P-hard problems in polynomial time. Defining such a system and addressing the accuracy issues inherent in preparation and measurement is a major unsolved problem.
Quantum computers are widely believed have an advantage over classical computers, and some have even published some empirical evidence that this is the case. However, these publications do not include a rigorous proof of this advantage, which would have to minimally state that the class of problems decidable by a quantum computer in polynomial time, BQP, contains problems that are not in the class of problems decidable by a classical computer with similar time bounds, P. Here, I provide the proof of a stronger result that implies this result: BQP contains problems that lie beyond the much larger classical computing class NP. This proves that quantum computation is able to efficiently solve problems which are far beyond the capabilities of classical computers.
Quantum computation was envisioned by Feynman as a valuable means of solving quantum problems [1]. The question is, how do we prove the superiority of quantum computing over classical devices? A common misconception in describing the power of a quantum computer over a classical computer is that quantum bits can be prepared in a superposition of an exponential number of states, which cannot be achieved with classical bits. This statement is certainly true, but it does not tell us, specifically, what problems quantum computers can efficiently solve while classical computers fail to do so. In fact, based exactly on the technique of Feynman's path integral, the output (i.e. transition amplitude) of any quantum circuit can be calculated classically with a polynomial amount of memory (although the temporal cost would be exponential). Therefore any quantum computation can be simulated classically; the key question is about the efficiency. Much effort has been made trying to pin down the power of quantum computers based on the machinery of the computational complexity theory. In particular, the class of computational (decision) problems that can be solved efficiently by a quantum computer is called BQP (bounded-error quantum polynomial time); the counterpart for classical computers is called P (polynomial time). Of course, BQP cannot be less than P; in principle quantum computers can simulate classical computers efficiently. The point is that the foundation of quantum computation cannot be established without a proof showing that BQP is strictly larger than P (i.e. BQP ≠ P). In this sense, this question is as interesting as the famous challenge of proving P ≠ NP (non-deterministic polynomial time). A well known instance of an NP problem is the factoring problem; Shor's quantum algorithm is capable of solving the factoring problem in polynomial time, which is not achievable with the best classical algorithm discovered so far. However, we still cannot rigorously exclude the possibility of the existence of an efficient classical algorithm for factoring. Although again without a proof, it is commonly believed that quantum computers are unable to solve some of the NP problems. In fact, the proof of this statement (if true) provides a possible path to prove P ≠ NP. A potentially less demanding question would be, when do we expect a quantum computer to be able to perform some well defined tasks (not necessarily related to any practical problem) that cannot be simulated with any currently available classical device, within a reasonable time? Once achieved, the status is called ‘quantum supremacy' [2]. One may ask, what about Grover's search algorithm, which provides a quadratic speedup over the classical search? Can we say that we can already achieve quantum supremacy with Grover's algorithm? The problem is that, instead of taking the large-N limit, quantum supremacy requires us to determine the actual number of qubits and gates that can no longer be simulated by classical computers within a reasonable time. To elaborate further, we remark that there can be two notions of classical simulation, namely ‘strong simulation' versus ‘weak simulation'. Strong simulation refers to the cases of calculating the transition probabilities, or expectation values of observables, to a high accuracy in polynomial time. Weak simulation requires the probability distributions to be accurately reproduced, which involves ‘sampling' the different outcomes of the quantum devices. Some quantum circuits that cannot be strongly simulated with an efficient classical means may have efficient classical methods for weak simulation [3]. However, we should be careful about the accuracy requirement in the simulation tasks. For example, for many decision problems, it may be sufficient to determine the transition amplitudes to within an additive error, instead of multiplicative error. In other words, the classical simulability of quantum computational problems depends on the accuracy requirement. Currently, there are three popular approaches for achieving quantum supremacy (see Fig. 1), namely (i) boson sampling [4], (ii) sampling IQP (instantaneous quantum polynomial) circuits [5], and (iii) sampling chaotic quantum circuits [6]. In all of these approaches, distributions of different bit strings or photon numbers are sampled from the quantum devices. Furthermore, they all involve the assumption that classical computers are unable to efficiently determine the transition amplitudes, and/or reproduce (or approximate) the distributions of quantum devices performing these tasks, in the sense of both strong and weak simulations. Three different approaches for achieving quantum supremacy: (a) boson sampling; (b) IQP circuits; (c) chaotic quantum circuits. In boson sampling, single photons are injected into different modes of a linear optical network. The task is to determine the photon distributions at the output ports. The key feature of boson sampling is that the transition amplitudes are related to the permanents of complex matrices, which are in general very difficult to calculate exactly, or approximate to within an multiplicative error; these problems belong to the #P-hard complexity class. Moreover, efficient weak simulation of boson sampling is believed to be impossible, unless the polynomial hierarchy collapses to its third level. However, a recent numerical study suggests that, in order to achieve quantum supremacy with boson sampling, one needs to simultaneously generate at least 50 or more single photons, which is still highly technologically challenging. An interesting question is whether linear optics, in the setting of boson sampling, can be applied to solve decision problems. In this case, the transition amplitudes may need to be determined to an additive error. However, we found that a large class of decision problems associated with boson sampling can be simulated by a classical computer [7], settling an open problem [8] by Aaronson and Hance. IQP circuits represent a simplified quantum-circuit model. The initial state starts from the all-zero state, |000…0〉, followed by applying Hadamard gates to each qubit. Then, diagonal gates are applied to the qubits, followed by applying Hadamard gates to each qubit again. The argument of showing the complexity in simulating IQP circuits is similar to that of boson sampling. In fact, the complexity of boson sampling was inspired by the complexity results of IQP circuits. However, when subject to noise, IQP circuits may become classically simulable [9]. Lastly, chaotic quantum circuits refer to the class of quantum circuits where two-qubit gates are applied regularly, while single-qubit gates are applied randomly from a gate set. The output distributions of these circuits approach the so-called Porter–Thomas distribution, which is a characteristic feature of quantum chaos. Recently, there have been several numerical investigations aiming to explore the ultimate limit of classical computing in simulating low-depth quantum circuits. For the ideal cases, one needs to consider both the qubit number and circuit depth for benchmarking quantum supremacy. However, in the presence of noise, these chaotic circuits may also become classically simulable for high-depth circuits [10]. Finally, other than these three approaches, one should expect that quantum supremacy can be achieved for many practical applications, e.g. simulation of quantum chemistry or quantum machine learning. When will it happen? Only time will tell!
We analyze the power of the recently proposed Lorentz quantum computer (LQC), a theoretical model leveraging hyperbolic bits (hybits) governed by complex Lorentz transformations. We define the complexity class BLQP (bounded-error Lorentz quantum polynomial-time) and demonstrate its equivalence to the complexity class P♯P (the class of problems solvable by a deterministic polynomial-time Turing machine with access to a ♯P oracle). LQC algorithms are shown to solve NP-hard problems, such as the maximum independent set (MIS), in polynomial time, thereby placing NP and co-NP within BLQP. Furthermore, we establish that LQC can efficiently simulate quantum computing with postselection (PostBQP), while the reverse is not possible, highlighting LQC's unique "super-postselection" capability. By proving BLQP =P♯P, we situate the entire polynomial hierarchy (PH) within BLQP and reveal profound connections between computational complexity and physical frameworks like Lorentz quantum mechanics. These results underscore LQC's theoretical superiority over conventional quantum computing models and its potential to redefine boundaries in complexity theory.