We explore the space "just above" BQP by defining a complexity class naCQP (non-adaptive Collapse-free Quantum Polynomial time) which is larger than BQP but does not contain NP relative to an oracle. The class is defined by imagining that quantum computers can perform (non-adaptive) measurements that do not collapse the wavefunction. This non-physical model of computation can efficiently solve problems such as Graph Isomorphism and Approximate Shortest Vector which are believed to be intractable for quantum computers. Furthermore, it can search an unstructured N-element list in Õ(N1/3) time, but no faster than Ω(N1/4), and hence cannot solve NP-hard problems in a black box manner. In short, this model of computation is more powerful than standard quantum computation, but only slightly so. This is surprising as most modifications of BQP increase the power of quantum computation to NP or beyond.
We explore the space "just above" BQP by defining a complexity class naCQP (non-adaptive Collapse-free Quantum Polynomial time) which is larger than BQP but does not contain NP relative to an oracle. The class is defined by imagining that quantum computers can perform (non-adaptive) measurements that do not collapse the wavefunction. This non-physical model of computation can efficiently solve problems such as Graph Isomorphism and Approximate Shortest Vector which are believed to be intractable for quantum computers. Furthermore, it can search an unstructured N-element list in Õ(N1/3) time, but no faster than Ω(N1/4), and hence cannot solve NP-hard problems in a black box manner. In short, this model of computation is more powerful than standard quantum computation, but only slightly so. This is surprising as most modifications of BQP increase the power of quantum computation to NP or beyond.
We explore the space "just above" BQP by defining a complexity class PDQP (Product Dynamical Quantum Polynomial time) which is larger than BQP but does not contain NP relative to an oracle. The class is defined by imagining that quantum computers can perform measurements that do not collapse the wavefunction. This (non-physical) model of computation can efficiently solve problems such as Graph Isomorphism and Approximate Shortest Vector which are believed to be intractable for quantum computers. Furthermore, it can search an unstructured N-element list in O~(N^{1/3}) time, but no faster than Ω(N^{1/4}), and hence cannot solve NP-hard problems in a black box manner. In short, this model of computation is more powerful than standard quantum computation, but only slightly so. Our work is inspired by previous work of Aaronson on the power of sampling the histories of hidden variables. However Aaronson's work contains an error in its proof of the lower bound for search, and hence it is unclear whether or not his model allows for search in logarithmic time. Our work can be viewed as a conceptual simplification of Aaronson's approach, with a provable polynomial lower bound for search.
Quantum computers are believed to be strictly more computationally powerful than classical computers, but not so much more powerful that they can solve NP-complete problems eciently. This is because of the result that a quantum computer takes ( N 1=2 ) time to search an unstructured N-element list for a particular marked item, as opposed to poly(logN) time for a nondeterministic computer. On the other hand, many seemingly innocuous modications of quantum mechanics increase the power of quantum computers drastically enough that they can solve NP-complete problems eciently [3]. This paper denes a model of computation slightly more powerful than quantum computation, but only slightly so. In particular, we show that by allowing \non-collapsing measurements, we can solve eciently problems such as Graph Isomorphism and Approximate Shortest Vector which are believed to be intractable for quantum computers. We can also search an unstructured N-element list for a particular marked item in ~ O(N 1=3 ) time, but no faster than ( N 1=4 ).
Quantum computers are widely believed have an advantage over classical computers, and some have even published some empirical evidence that this is the case. However, these publications do not include a rigorous proof of this advantage, which would have to minimally state that the class of problems decidable by a quantum computer in polynomial time, BQP, contains problems that are not in the class of problems decidable by a classical computer with similar time bounds, P. Here, I provide the proof of a stronger result that implies this result: BQP contains problems that lie beyond the much larger classical computing class NP. This proves that quantum computation is able to efficiently solve problems which are far beyond the capabilities of classical computers.
The complexity class of the problems that can be solved by a quantum algorithm in a non-adaptive collapse-free model is called naCQP. This class was introduced in 2016 by Aaronson et al. intended to be a slightly larger class than BQP: larger enough to include important NP-intermediate candidate problems, but likely not to include NP-complete problems. Aaronson et al. (2016) showed that there is an oracle A for which NPA ⊈ naCQPA; and Hepp et al. (2025) showed that relative to an oracle A chosen uniformly at random, (UP ∩ coUP)A ⊈ naCQPA with probability 1, being UP ∩ coUP a subclass of NP. Amongst the NP-intermediate candidate problems in naCQP is the entire class SZK, of the problems that admit a statistical zero-knowledge interactive proof system. The relation between QSZK, which is the class of the problems that admit a quantum zero-knowledge interactive proof system, and naCQP is unknown, with some believing that there is an oracle A for which QSZKA ⊈ naCQPA. A promise problem complete for QSZK is the trace distance distinguishability of mixed quantum states. We show that this problem, when restricted to pure quantum states, is in naCQP.
Aaronson, Bouland, Fitzsimons and Lee introduced the complexity class PDQP (which was original labeled naCQP), an alteration of BQP enhanced with the ability to obtain non-collapsing measurements, samples of quantum states without collapsing them. Although PDQP contains SZK, it still requires Ω(N1/4) queries to solve unstructured search. We formulate an alternative equivalent definition of PDQP, which we use to prove the positive weighted adversary lower-bounding method, establishing multiple tighter bounds and a trade-off between queries and non-collapsing measurements. We utilize the technique in order to analyze the query complexity of the well-studied majority and element distinctness problems. Additionally, we prove a tight Θ(N1/3) bound on search. Furthermore, we use the lower-bound to explore PDQP under query restrictions, finding that when combined with non-adaptive queries, we limit the speed-up in several cases.
The central problem in computer science is the conjecture that two complexity classes, P (polynomial time) and NP (nondeterministic polynomial time-roughly those decision problems for which a proposed solution can be checked in polynomial time), are distinct in the standard Turing model of computation: P not equal NP. As a generality, we propose that each physical theory supports computational models whose power is limited by the physical theory. It is well known that classical physics supports a multitude of implementation of the Turing machine. Non-Abelian topological quantum field theories exhibit the mathematical features necessary to support a model capable of solving all #P problems, a computationally intractable class, in polynomial time. Specifically, Witten [Witten, E. (1989) Commun. Math. Phys. 121, 351-391] has identified expectation values in a certain SU(2)-field theory with values of the Jones polynomial [Jones, V. (1985) Bull. Am. Math. Soc. 12, 103-111] that are #P-hard [Jaeger, F., Vertigen, D. & Welsh, D. (1990) Math. Proc. Comb. Philos. Soc. 108, 35-53]. This suggests that some physical system whose effective Lagrangian contains a non-Abelian topological term might be manipulated to serve as an analog computer capable of solving NP or even #P-hard problems in polynomial time. Defining such a system and addressing the accuracy issues inherent in preparation and measurement is a major unsolved problem.