Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

Coup de Grâce (with however a loophole)

Published Mar 1, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

After the Big Book classification, we were left with only two physical PHV-theories: The double solution and the pilot wave. To these, we must also add stochastic quantum mechanics, sharing a sufficient amount of ingredients with the causal theories of Louis de Broglie and of Bohm to be allowed to enter the same family. To end this book, we have to definitely decide, if possible, whether the family is valuable or not, whether we still want to live with it or not, or whether we must definitely leave away or not. I shall mainly focus on Bohm’s pilot wave, for convenience and for being specific, but the arguments we shall meet concerning this causal theory could be applied, mutatis mutandis , to the double solution and to stochastic quantum mechanics as well. To be fair, I shall begin to defend Bohm’s pilot wave but, at the end, with clarity, but charity and a bit of sadness, I shall have to blow a coup de grâce (although offering a loophole).

DOI
10.1142/9789819806492_0017

Related papers

Pilot Wave

It is easy to pass from the double solution exposed in the previous chapter to the pilot wave to be discussed in the present one. Essentially, what we have to do is to forget anything concerning the second solution, that is to say concerning the u -waves and their singularities, and to preserve the first solution Ψ and the guidance formula driving the underlying hidden objective particles. Then, these particles are piloted by the wave Ψ, hence the name of the theory. We are still left with two versions, the pilot wave theory of Louis de Broglie, and the pilot wave theory of Bohm. They essentially differ by the epistemological status of Ψ, subjective for Louis de Broglie and objective for Bohm, and by the fact that Bohm developed the theory much further, up to its logical conclusion, as he wrote. In particular, objections which have been addressed to the version by Louis de Broglie have been successfully enough answered by Bohm. Therefore, to avoid any inconvenient redundancy on this matter, we shall now on discuss Bohm’s version, and the terminology “pilot wave”, excepted possibly when specified otherwise, will refer to this version.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 1, 2025•0 citations

The Pilot Wave Theory of Louis de Broglie and David Bohm

Franck Laloë

The frontiers collection•Jan 1, 2017•3 citations

Other Hidden-Variables Theories

We now have in mind emblematic and paradigmatic examples of hidden-variables theories, namely the double solution of Louis de Broglie, the pilot wave declined into two versions, first the version of Louis de Broglie, then the more achieved version of Bohm, all of these with objective particles as beables, followed by various variants or more elaborated theories, with possibly fields as beables. We are now going to enter a short chapter, short indeed, but sufficient and compulsory, to complement our luggage with a few more suitcases, before attacking the problems of hidden variables from more universal standpoints.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 1, 2025•0 citations

Hidden Variables in Quantum Mechanics: A Journey Into de Broglie-Bohm Pilot-Wave Theory

Andréa Oldofredi

arXiv:2608.18829•Elsevier eBooks•Oct 23, 2026•0 citations

Epilogue

Malcolm S. Longair

As expected when I started out on this project, this has proved to be a complex and, at times, difficult story. After all, what was involved was tearing up the foundations of classical physics, which had been extraordinarily successful in explaining the macroscopic world about us, and replacing it by something radically different and non-intuitive in terms of our everyday experience. But the effort involved has been more than repaid by the very much deeper appreciation I have gained of the extraordinary works of the pioneers of quantum mechanics, both the theorists and the experimenters. If the brilliant theoretical researches of Planck, Einstein, Bohr, Heisenberg, Born, Jordan, Schrödinger, Pauli, Dirac and many others form the central core of this story, it should be remembered that their researches were inspired by the equally brilliant achievements of experimental physics. Another huge bonus has been a deepened understanding of quantum mechanics itself – if only I had these insights more than 50 years ago when I first encountered the subject.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 31, 2013•0 citations

On the Incompatibility of Quantum Mechanics and the de Broglie-Bohm Theory II

Partha Ghose

•Mar 22, 2001•3 citations
After the Big Book classification, we were left with only two physical PHV-theories: The double solution and the pilot wave. To these, we must also add stochastic quantum mechanics, sharing a sufficient amount of ingredients with the causal theories of Louis de Broglie and of Bohm to be allowed to enter the same family. To end this book, we have to definitely decide, if possible, whether the family is valuable or not, whether we still want to live with it or not, or whether we must definitely leave away or not. I shall mainly focus on Bohm’s pilot wave, for convenience and for being specific, but the arguments we shall meet concerning this causal theory could be applied, mutatis mutandis , to the double solution and to stochastic quantum mechanics as well. To be fair, I shall begin to defend Bohm’s pilot wave but, at the end, with clarity, but charity and a bit of sadness, I shall have to blow a coup de grâce (although offering a loophole).
It is easy to pass from the double solution exposed in the previous chapter to the pilot wave to be discussed in the present one. Essentially, what we have to do is to forget anything concerning the second solution, that is to say concerning the u -waves and their singularities, and to preserve the first solution Ψ and the guidance formula driving the underlying hidden objective particles. Then, these particles are piloted by the wave Ψ, hence the name of the theory. We are still left with two versions, the pilot wave theory of Louis de Broglie, and the pilot wave theory of Bohm. They essentially differ by the epistemological status of Ψ, subjective for Louis de Broglie and objective for Bohm, and by the fact that Bohm developed the theory much further, up to its logical conclusion, as he wrote. In particular, objections which have been addressed to the version by Louis de Broglie have been successfully enough answered by Bohm. Therefore, to avoid any inconvenient redundancy on this matter, we shall now on discuss Bohm’s version, and the terminology “pilot wave”, excepted possibly when specified otherwise, will refer to this version.
We now have in mind emblematic and paradigmatic examples of hidden-variables theories, namely the double solution of Louis de Broglie, the pilot wave declined into two versions, first the version of Louis de Broglie, then the more achieved version of Bohm, all of these with objective particles as beables, followed by various variants or more elaborated theories, with possibly fields as beables. We are now going to enter a short chapter, short indeed, but sufficient and compulsory, to complement our luggage with a few more suitcases, before attacking the problems of hidden variables from more universal standpoints.
As expected when I started out on this project, this has proved to be a complex and, at times, difficult story. After all, what was involved was tearing up the foundations of classical physics, which had been extraordinarily successful in explaining the macroscopic world about us, and replacing it by something radically different and non-intuitive in terms of our everyday experience. But the effort involved has been more than repaid by the very much deeper appreciation I have gained of the extraordinary works of the pioneers of quantum mechanics, both the theorists and the experimenters. If the brilliant theoretical researches of Planck, Einstein, Bohr, Heisenberg, Born, Jordan, Schrödinger, Pauli, Dirac and many others form the central core of this story, it should be remembered that their researches were inspired by the equally brilliant achievements of experimental physics. Another huge bonus has been a deepened understanding of quantum mechanics itself – if only I had these insights more than 50 years ago when I first encountered the subject.