We now have in mind emblematic and paradigmatic examples of hidden-variables theories, namely the double solution of Louis de Broglie, the pilot wave declined into two versions, first the version of Louis de Broglie, then the more achieved version of Bohm, all of these with objective particles as beables, followed by various variants or more elaborated theories, with possibly fields as beables. We are now going to enter a short chapter, short indeed, but sufficient and compulsory, to complement our luggage with a few more suitcases, before attacking the problems of hidden variables from more universal standpoints.
We now have in mind emblematic and paradigmatic examples of hidden-variables theories, namely the double solution of Louis de Broglie, the pilot wave declined into two versions, first the version of Louis de Broglie, then the more achieved version of Bohm, all of these with objective particles as beables, followed by various variants or more elaborated theories, with possibly fields as beables. We are now going to enter a short chapter, short indeed, but sufficient and compulsory, to complement our luggage with a few more suitcases, before attacking the problems of hidden variables from more universal standpoints.
It is easy to pass from the double solution exposed in the previous chapter to the pilot wave to be discussed in the present one. Essentially, what we have to do is to forget anything concerning the second solution, that is to say concerning the u -waves and their singularities, and to preserve the first solution Ψ and the guidance formula driving the underlying hidden objective particles. Then, these particles are piloted by the wave Ψ, hence the name of the theory. We are still left with two versions, the pilot wave theory of Louis de Broglie, and the pilot wave theory of Bohm. They essentially differ by the epistemological status of Ψ, subjective for Louis de Broglie and objective for Bohm, and by the fact that Bohm developed the theory much further, up to its logical conclusion, as he wrote. In particular, objections which have been addressed to the version by Louis de Broglie have been successfully enough answered by Bohm. Therefore, to avoid any inconvenient redundancy on this matter, we shall now on discuss Bohm’s version, and the terminology “pilot wave”, excepted possibly when specified otherwise, will refer to this version.
After the Big Book classification, we were left with only two physical PHV-theories: The double solution and the pilot wave. To these, we must also add stochastic quantum mechanics, sharing a sufficient amount of ingredients with the causal theories of Louis de Broglie and of Bohm to be allowed to enter the same family. To end this book, we have to definitely decide, if possible, whether the family is valuable or not, whether we still want to live with it or not, or whether we must definitely leave away or not. I shall mainly focus on Bohm’s pilot wave, for convenience and for being specific, but the arguments we shall meet concerning this causal theory could be applied, mutatis mutandis , to the double solution and to stochastic quantum mechanics as well. To be fair, I shall begin to defend Bohm’s pilot wave but, at the end, with clarity, but charity and a bit of sadness, I shall have to blow a coup de grâce (although offering a loophole).
(Paris: Belin, 1987), 161-78; R. Maiocchi, 'Paul Langevin's Epistemological Considerations on Quantum Mechanics and their Repercussions upon the French before the Last War', Scientia, Vol. 110 (1975), 519-38. 6. Cross, op. cit. note 1, 759. 7. See J.S. Bell, 'On the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Paradox', Physics, Vol. 1 (1964), 195-200; and Bell, 'On the Problem of Hidden Variables in Quantum Theory', Review of Modern Physics, Vol. 38 (1966), 447-52. 8. See J.S. Bell's papers on 'de Broglie-Bohm, Delayed-Choice Double-Slit Experiment, and Density Matrix', 'On the Impossible Pilot Wave' and 'Beables for Quantum Theory', all in his Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989), 111-16, 159-68, 173-81. 9. A. Shimony, 'John Stewart Bell: 1928-1990', Foundations of Physics, Vol. 21, No. 5 (1991), 509-12. 10. Y. Ben-Dov, 'Bell's Version of the Pilot-Wave Theory', Fundamenta Scientiae, Vol. 8, Nos 3/4 (1987), 331-3.
We have touched many times upon the problem of WP-Dualism. Now we shall analyse the problem, by starting with what is chronologically the first discussion about it. An organic answer to the problem came from de Broglie, but, for many reasons yet to be analysed in greater depth, it was not accepted by the majority of physicists. This theory was later included in the theoretical program of the Hidden-Variable theory by David Bohm, so that one normally speaks of the ‘de Broglie-Bohm Pilot wave’. However, de Broglie's proposal was directed more toward the problem of WP-Dualism as such, while Bohm's proposal was directed more toward the construction of a deterministic theory by contesting the completeness of QM — and here the point of departure is more Einstein's Ignorance interpretation [see proposition 6.3: p. 106] and the historical article of Einstein/Podolsky/Rosen [EINSTEIN et al . 1935]. As a consequence of the Hidden Variable theory the problem of non-locality was posed. The problem of the WP-Dualism and that of Hidden Variable theories (and non-locality) are theoretically different and hence they require different examinations. Therefore we divide all matter into three different parts: in this part we shall discuss de Broglie's theory and the problem of WP-Dualism; in part VIII, the problem of completeness and determinism (Bohm's Hidden Variable theory); in part IX the problem of separability and non locality. While part VIII, and especially chapter 33, is devoted to an interpretation of QM particles, we discuss in particular here what quantum waves are; if they are classical entities, if and how they can be ontologically interpreted, and what a quantum state is. We shall confirm our main distinction between states and observables. • We begin [in chapter 28 ] with the classical discussion stimulated by de Broglie with his proposal of the double solution theory — a proposal following which both particles and waves always exist together. Then more recent proposals concerning the nature of quantum waves and of quantum states are discussed (non-analytical solutions, empty waves, ontological interpretation of waves based on protective measurements). • Three-valued logic [ chapter 29 ] represents to a certain extent the opposite point of view relative to de Broglie's: the microentities are not determined in themselves (neither corpuscular nor wave-like), and, only under very specific circumstances (measurements), can the truth or falsehood of propositions about the values of observables be decided. Even if three-valued logic is chronological precedent to the matter of the precedent chapter, for systematical reasons it seemed better to discuss it after the latter. • Then in chapter 30 the relationship between which-path information and superposition is discussed, and very recent (proposed and performed) experiments are reported; finally we begin to discuss an ontological interpretation.