Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Gaps, Errors and Corrections of the Schrödinger Equation

Stanislav Ordin

Published Oct 24, 2024• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The “quantum” world, within the framework of which “outstanding” scientific discoveries are being made now, is built on initially laid nonsense. Quantum theory was initially built on incorrect adjustment by Schrödinger of two-dimensional “solutions” of the One-dimensional harmonic oscillator equation. These are the consequences of this fitting and “excited minds.” This is the reason why quantum mechanics is not necessary to UNDERSTAND, but it is necessary to ACCEPT. But they accepted and canonized, as is shown in this work, non-physical, rough, approximate solutions. And it is on the basis of these solutions that electron orbitals, widely used in fundamental and applied science, are constructed. So the “Terrible Secret” of the theorists is that in fact without having a basic model they are exclusively engaged in fitting Schrödinger’ssolutions.

DOI
10.1201/9781003570615-15

Related papers

Quantum Theory Comes in Waves and Particles

Walter A. Harrison

Certainly there is no unique answer to Frank Wilczek’s question, “What Is Quantum Theory?” (Physics Today, June 2000, page 11). I was not certain that a pragmatic answer, which I proposed for a course in applied quantum mechanics, 1 1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, N.J. (2000). would be sustainable for the entire course, but it seems that it was. That answer was the assertion that everything is both a particle and a wave, and that everything else would follow from that one assertion. Planck’s constant arose when the velocity of a wave (the derivative of the frequency with respect to wavenumber) was equated to the velocity of a particle (the derivative of the energy with respect to momentum), so that energy is proportional to frequency and momentum to wavenumber, with the same proportionality constant ħ. When Hamiltonian mechanics was introduced, “everything” became anything that can be described by such mechanics, or anything that satisfies a wave equation. Quantum theory does not say what nature gives, only how to predict the behavior of what is given. If nature serves up particles with half-integral angular momentum, the wavefunction that describes them must go into its negative when they are interchanged, and they therefore obey the Pauli principle.Such principles, which historically arose as independent conjectures, now follow from the one assertion. It is a matter of seeing how this peculiar assertion can turn out to be absolutely true.The relation between quantum theory and the physical world was seen as follows: Quantum theory tells what future scenarios are consistent with some initial information, and what the relative probability of each scenario is. Quantum theory cannot tell more than that, but neither can any other theory.My pragmatic approach may not satisfy everyone’s philosophical needs. But the aim of an applied quantum course is to see how to use the theory and to introduce the many approximations that have made the theory accessible to physicists and engineers. If some basic consequences are difficult to accept, the problem must lie with the initial assertion from which the consequences follow.REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, N.J. (2000). Google ScholarCrossref© 2001 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Jun 1, 2001•0 citations

100 years of quantum mechanics: The months that changed physics

Milan R. Pantić

A hundred years ago, physics underwent one of its most dramatic transformations - a paradigm shift that fundamentally changed our understanding of nature. Over the course of several revolutionary months in 1925 and early 1926, quantum mechanics emerged as a new, foundational theory of the microscopic world. With the publication of key papers by Werner Heisenberg and Erwin Schrödinger, the theoretical framework was established that radically redefined our perception of physical reality. These works demonstrated that atoms and subatomic particles do not obey the laws of classical mechanics, but instead follow entirely new, quantum laws. Born in those intense months, quantum mechanics became one of the cornerstones of modern physics and a lasting source of inspiration in both theoretical and applied sciences. This paradigmatic shift opened new avenues of research and laid the groundwork for scientific discoveries that continue to shape our understanding of nature today. This paper is dedicated to those pivotal historical moments - the months in which science made one of its deepest leaps and most consequential strides in comprehending the world.

Kragujevac Journal of Science•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics: the Schrödinger Equation

Sander Bais

The first quarter of the twentieth century saw two great scientific revolutions: firstly relativity, which deeply changed our view of space and time, and secondly quantum mechanics, which deeply changed the way we think about states of matter and energy. Quantum mechanics provided a deep understanding of a wide variety of phenomena, from the most fundamental properties of elementary particles to many aspects of chemistry. Quantum theory opened the door to the micro-cosmos, thereby explaining many of the properties of vastly different types of materials such as insulators, metals, semiconductors and superconductors. Modern physics is still deeply involved in further exploiting the ever-surprising worlds of quantum solids, liquids and gases. The quantum revolution implied a radical shake-up of the foundations of theoretical physics. It was caused among others by the inadequacy of the classical theories of Newton and Maxwell to account for the observed structure of atoms. The atom supposedly consisted of a positively charged nucleus surrounded by a number of negatively charged electrons, exactly compensating the nuclear charge. The problem that arose may be explained as follows. Newton told us that in the proposed configuration the electrons would ‘circle’ very rapidly around the nucleus (like a tiny planetary system), and therefore these electrons would continuously be strongly accelerated. Maxwell, however, told us that an accelerated charge would start radiating and thereby losing energy at an appreciable rate, so that in the end the electrons would fall into the nucleus. A little calculation showed that the lifetime of the atom would be something like a billionth of a second. According to our theoretical knowledge, therefore, atoms would just not exist, bluntly contradicting the observations. Quantum theory came to the rescue. Looking back, one of the outstanding achievements of quantum theory is that it explained the structure but also the stability of atoms and molecules, and therefore of all matter. In quantum theory the atomic bound states of the electrons with the nucleus form a discrete set – the allowed states are quantized, with a stable lowest energy state. The theory is based on a number of postulates which are of great generality, providing a framework that should in principle be applicable to any physical system. To put it briefly: our world is quantum-mechanical.

Amsterdam University Press eBooks•Jun 17, 2005•0 citations

Relativistic Approximations for Quantization and Harmony in the Schrödinger Equation, and Why Mechanics Is Quantized

Antony J. Bourdillon

The initial purpose is to add two physical origins for the outstandingly clear mathematical description that Dirac has left in his Principles of Quantum Mechanics. The first is the “internal motion” in the wave function of the electron that is now expressed through dispersion dynamics; the second is the physical origin for mathematical quantization. Bohr’s model for the hydrogen atom was “the greatest single step in the development of the theory of atomic structure.” It leads to the Schrodinger equation which is non-relativistic, but which conveniently equates together momentum and electrostatic potential in a representation containing mixed powers. Firstly, we show how the equation is expansible to approximate relativistic form by applying solutions for the dilation of time in special relativity, and for the contraction of space. The adaptation is to invariant “harmonic events” that are digitally quantized. Secondly, the internal motion of the electron is described by a stable wave packet that implies wave-particle duality. The duality includes uncertainty that is precisely described with some variance from Heisenberg’s axiomatic limit. Harmonic orbital wave functions are self-constructive. This is the physical origin of quantization.

Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2020•4 citations

Theoretical Background

Anne‐Marie Sapse

Inadequate descriptions of atoms and molecules by the methods of classical physics led researchers to propose new ways to describe physical reality, giving birth to a totally new science, quantum mechanics. The methods of quantum mechanics are based on the introduction of a wave function, whose physical meaning is related to the probability of finding a certain particle, at a certain time in a volume element, positioned between x and x + dx in the x = direction, between y and y + dy in the y = direction, and between z and z + dz in the z = direction at certain time t. This wave function Ψ satisfies the Schrödinger equation, $$ \left( { - \frac{{{\hbar ^2}}}{{2m}}{\nabla ^2} + v} \right)\Psi = {\rm E}\Psi,\hbar = \frac{h}{{2\pi }}, $$ or for short, HΨ = EΨ, where H, the Hamiltonian operator, is defined by the expression $$ H = - \frac{{{\hbar ^2}}}{{2m}}{\nabla ^2} + V; $$ h is Planck’s constant; ∇2 is the sum of the partial second derivatives with respect to x, y, and z; m is the mass of the particle; and V is the potential energy of the system. The Hamiltonian H represents the quantum equivalent of the sum of the kinetic energy and potential energy, with V being the potential energy operator and $$ \frac{{ - {\hbar ^2}}}{{2m}}{\nabla ^2} $$ the kinetic energy operator. Finally, E is the total energy of the system and is a number, not an operator.

Birkhäuser Boston eBooks•Jan 1, 2000•2 citations

TOWARDS A MEANINGFUL INTRODUCTION TO THE SCHRÖDINGER EQUATION THROUGH HISTORICAL AND HEURISTIC APPROACHES

Georgios R. Tsaparlis

The Schrödinger equation is the foundation of quantum mechanics and the starting point for any improvement to the description of submicroscopic physical and chemical systems. Although it cannot be proved or derived strictly, it has associated with it various formulations and ‘derivations’. In this work, we study the physical and mathematical evidence that make the Schrödinger equation plausible. First, we make an approach from the historical perspective, and study the methods of the pioneers Schrödinger, Heisenberg, and Dirac. Turning to modern treatments, we review numerous heuristic introductions to quantum mechanics and make a synthesis of the various methods into a coherent and meaningful whole. [Chem. Educ. Res. Pract. Eur.: 2001, 2, 203-213]

Chemistry Education Research and Practice•Jan 1, 2001•18 citations
The “quantum” world, within the framework of which “outstanding” scientific discoveries are being made now, is built on initially laid nonsense. Quantum theory was initially built on incorrect adjustment by Schrödinger of two-dimensional “solutions” of the One-dimensional harmonic oscillator equation. These are the consequences of this fitting and “excited minds.” This is the reason why quantum mechanics is not necessary to UNDERSTAND, but it is necessary to ACCEPT. But they accepted and canonized, as is shown in this work, non-physical, rough, approximate solutions. And it is on the basis of these solutions that electron orbitals, widely used in fundamental and applied science, are constructed. So the “Terrible Secret” of the theorists is that in fact without having a basic model they are exclusively engaged in fitting Schrödinger’ssolutions.
Certainly there is no unique answer to Frank Wilczek’s question, “What Is Quantum Theory?” (Physics Today, June 2000, page 11). I was not certain that a pragmatic answer, which I proposed for a course in applied quantum mechanics, 1 1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, N.J. (2000). would be sustainable for the entire course, but it seems that it was. That answer was the assertion that everything is both a particle and a wave, and that everything else would follow from that one assertion. Planck’s constant arose when the velocity of a wave (the derivative of the frequency with respect to wavenumber) was equated to the velocity of a particle (the derivative of the energy with respect to momentum), so that energy is proportional to frequency and momentum to wavenumber, with the same proportionality constant ħ. When Hamiltonian mechanics was introduced, “everything” became anything that can be described by such mechanics, or anything that satisfies a wave equation. Quantum theory does not say what nature gives, only how to predict the behavior of what is given. If nature serves up particles with half-integral angular momentum, the wavefunction that describes them must go into its negative when they are interchanged, and they therefore obey the Pauli principle.Such principles, which historically arose as independent conjectures, now follow from the one assertion. It is a matter of seeing how this peculiar assertion can turn out to be absolutely true.The relation between quantum theory and the physical world was seen as follows: Quantum theory tells what future scenarios are consistent with some initial information, and what the relative probability of each scenario is. Quantum theory cannot tell more than that, but neither can any other theory.My pragmatic approach may not satisfy everyone’s philosophical needs. But the aim of an applied quantum course is to see how to use the theory and to introduce the many approximations that have made the theory accessible to physicists and engineers. If some basic consequences are difficult to accept, the problem must lie with the initial assertion from which the consequences follow.REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, N.J. (2000). Google ScholarCrossref© 2001 American Institute of Physics.
A hundred years ago, physics underwent one of its most dramatic transformations - a paradigm shift that fundamentally changed our understanding of nature. Over the course of several revolutionary months in 1925 and early 1926, quantum mechanics emerged as a new, foundational theory of the microscopic world. With the publication of key papers by Werner Heisenberg and Erwin Schrödinger, the theoretical framework was established that radically redefined our perception of physical reality. These works demonstrated that atoms and subatomic particles do not obey the laws of classical mechanics, but instead follow entirely new, quantum laws. Born in those intense months, quantum mechanics became one of the cornerstones of modern physics and a lasting source of inspiration in both theoretical and applied sciences. This paradigmatic shift opened new avenues of research and laid the groundwork for scientific discoveries that continue to shape our understanding of nature today. This paper is dedicated to those pivotal historical moments - the months in which science made one of its deepest leaps and most consequential strides in comprehending the world.
The first quarter of the twentieth century saw two great scientific revolutions: firstly relativity, which deeply changed our view of space and time, and secondly quantum mechanics, which deeply changed the way we think about states of matter and energy. Quantum mechanics provided a deep understanding of a wide variety of phenomena, from the most fundamental properties of elementary particles to many aspects of chemistry. Quantum theory opened the door to the micro-cosmos, thereby explaining many of the properties of vastly different types of materials such as insulators, metals, semiconductors and superconductors. Modern physics is still deeply involved in further exploiting the ever-surprising worlds of quantum solids, liquids and gases. The quantum revolution implied a radical shake-up of the foundations of theoretical physics. It was caused among others by the inadequacy of the classical theories of Newton and Maxwell to account for the observed structure of atoms. The atom supposedly consisted of a positively charged nucleus surrounded by a number of negatively charged electrons, exactly compensating the nuclear charge. The problem that arose may be explained as follows. Newton told us that in the proposed configuration the electrons would ‘circle’ very rapidly around the nucleus (like a tiny planetary system), and therefore these electrons would continuously be strongly accelerated. Maxwell, however, told us that an accelerated charge would start radiating and thereby losing energy at an appreciable rate, so that in the end the electrons would fall into the nucleus. A little calculation showed that the lifetime of the atom would be something like a billionth of a second. According to our theoretical knowledge, therefore, atoms would just not exist, bluntly contradicting the observations. Quantum theory came to the rescue. Looking back, one of the outstanding achievements of quantum theory is that it explained the structure but also the stability of atoms and molecules, and therefore of all matter. In quantum theory the atomic bound states of the electrons with the nucleus form a discrete set – the allowed states are quantized, with a stable lowest energy state. The theory is based on a number of postulates which are of great generality, providing a framework that should in principle be applicable to any physical system. To put it briefly: our world is quantum-mechanical.
The initial purpose is to add two physical origins for the outstandingly clear mathematical description that Dirac has left in his Principles of Quantum Mechanics. The first is the “internal motion” in the wave function of the electron that is now expressed through dispersion dynamics; the second is the physical origin for mathematical quantization. Bohr’s model for the hydrogen atom was “the greatest single step in the development of the theory of atomic structure.” It leads to the Schrodinger equation which is non-relativistic, but which conveniently equates together momentum and electrostatic potential in a representation containing mixed powers. Firstly, we show how the equation is expansible to approximate relativistic form by applying solutions for the dilation of time in special relativity, and for the contraction of space. The adaptation is to invariant “harmonic events” that are digitally quantized. Secondly, the internal motion of the electron is described by a stable wave packet that implies wave-particle duality. The duality includes uncertainty that is precisely described with some variance from Heisenberg’s axiomatic limit. Harmonic orbital wave functions are self-constructive. This is the physical origin of quantization.
Inadequate descriptions of atoms and molecules by the methods of classical physics led researchers to propose new ways to describe physical reality, giving birth to a totally new science, quantum mechanics. The methods of quantum mechanics are based on the introduction of a wave function, whose physical meaning is related to the probability of finding a certain particle, at a certain time in a volume element, positioned between x and x + dx in the x = direction, between y and y + dy in the y = direction, and between z and z + dz in the z = direction at certain time t. This wave function Ψ satisfies the Schrödinger equation, (−ℏ22m∇2+v)Ψ=EΨ,ℏ=h2π, \left( { - \frac{{{\hbar ^2}}}{{2m}}{\nabla ^2} + v} \right)\Psi = {\rm E}\Psi,\hbar = \frac{h}{{2\pi }}, (−2mℏ2​∇2+v)Ψ=EΨ,ℏ=2πh​, or for short, HΨ = EΨ, where H, the Hamiltonian operator, is defined by the expression H=−ℏ22m∇2+V; H = - \frac{{{\hbar ^2}}}{{2m}}{\nabla ^2} + V; H=−2mℏ2​∇2+V; h is Planck’s constant; ∇2 is the sum of the partial second derivatives with respect to x, y, and z; m is the mass of the particle; and V is the potential energy of the system. The Hamiltonian H represents the quantum equivalent of the sum of the kinetic energy and potential energy, with V being the potential energy operator and −ℏ22m∇2 \frac{{ - {\hbar ^2}}}{{2m}}{\nabla ^2} 2m−ℏ2​∇2 the kinetic energy operator. Finally, E is the total energy of the system and is a number, not an operator.
The Schrödinger equation is the foundation of quantum mechanics and the starting point for any improvement to the description of submicroscopic physical and chemical systems. Although it cannot be proved or derived strictly, it has associated with it various formulations and ‘derivations’. In this work, we study the physical and mathematical evidence that make the Schrödinger equation plausible. First, we make an approach from the historical perspective, and study the methods of the pioneers Schrödinger, Heisenberg, and Dirac. Turning to modern treatments, we review numerous heuristic introductions to quantum mechanics and make a synthesis of the various methods into a coherent and meaningful whole. [Chem. Educ. Res. Pract. Eur.: 2001, 2, 203-213]