Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics Today

Quantum Theory Comes in Waves and Particles

Walter A. Harrison

Published Jun 1, 2001• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Certainly there is no unique answer to Frank Wilczek’s question, “What Is Quantum Theory?” (Physics Today, June 2000, page 11). I was not certain that a pragmatic answer, which I proposed for a course in applied quantum mechanics, 1 1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, N.J. (2000). would be sustainable for the entire course, but it seems that it was. That answer was the assertion that everything is both a particle and a wave, and that everything else would follow from that one assertion. Planck’s constant arose when the velocity of a wave (the derivative of the frequency with respect to wavenumber) was equated to the velocity of a particle (the derivative of the energy with respect to momentum), so that energy is proportional to frequency and momentum to wavenumber, with the same proportionality constant ħ. When Hamiltonian mechanics was introduced, “everything” became anything that can be described by such mechanics, or anything that satisfies a wave equation. Quantum theory does not say what nature gives, only how to predict the behavior of what is given. If nature serves up particles with half-integral angular momentum, the wavefunction that describes them must go into its negative when they are interchanged, and they therefore obey the Pauli principle.Such principles, which historically arose as independent conjectures, now follow from the one assertion. It is a matter of seeing how this peculiar assertion can turn out to be absolutely true.The relation between quantum theory and the physical world was seen as follows: Quantum theory tells what future scenarios are consistent with some initial information, and what the relative probability of each scenario is. Quantum theory cannot tell more than that, but neither can any other theory.My pragmatic approach may not satisfy everyone’s philosophical needs. But the aim of an applied quantum course is to see how to use the theory and to introduce the many approximations that have made the theory accessible to physicists and engineers. If some basic consequences are difficult to accept, the problem must lie with the initial assertion from which the consequences follow.REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, N.J. (2000). Google ScholarCrossref© 2001 American Institute of Physics.

DOI
10.1063/1.1387610

Related papers

The Basic Approach

Our goal in this treatment of quantum theory is to provide those aspects of the theory which are most needed for a modem understanding of the world of our experience. Central to this are the many approximations which have turned out to be successful for estimating the properties of matter and predicting the events which occur on a microscopic scale. In that sense the goal is entirely pragmatic, but any study of quantum theory cannot help but raise deep philosophical questions. Perhaps the only real understanding of the theory is through a familiarity with how it works out for many different problems. It seems unlikely that understanding comes from thinking about some complicated extreme case, such as Schroedinger's cat. The approach we take here bypasses much of the question by starting with a single premise of wave-particle duality, from which follows all of quantum theory and its interpretation. Any remaining problems are made moot by the quantum-mechanical view that questions are meaningful only if there is some conceivable experimental way to test the answers. In keeping with this pragmatic approach we will not emphasize mathematical derivations, nor carry out the detailed analysis of harmonic-oscillator states, hydrogen wavefunctions, or angular momentum, which are part of almost all texts in quantum theory. We treat the simplest case in detail, state the general results, and see that they are the plausible generalizations. We leave the more detailed analysis to other texts. The one we used for the course at Stanford was Kroemer's Quantum Mechanics for Engineers and Materials Scientists , which served very well.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jul 1, 2000•0 citations

A simple means for deriving quantum mechanics

Eric Tesse

A type of mechanics will be presented that possesses some distinctive properties. On the one hand, its physical description & rules of operation are readily comprehensible & intuitively clear. On the other, it fully satisfies all observable predictions of non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Within it, particles exist at points in space, follow continuous, piecewise differentiable paths, and their linear momentum is equal to their mass times their velocity along their path. Yet the probabilities for position and momentum, conditioned on the state of the particle's environment, follow the rules of quantum theory. Indeed, all observable consequences of quantum theory are satisfied; particles can be entangled, have intrinsic spin, this spin is not local to the particle, particle identity can effect probabilities, and so forth. All the rules of quantum mechanics are obeyed, and all arise in a straightforward fashion. After this is established, connections will be drawn out between this type of mechanics and other types of quantum worlds; those that obey Bohmian mechanics, stochastic mechanics, the many worlds interpretation, and physical collapse. In the final section, a relativistic version of the mechanics will be presented.

quant-pharXiv:2602.04524•Feb 5, 2026•0 citations

Particle Interference without Waves

Marcello Cini

After eighty years of Quantum Mechanics (QM) we have learned to live with wave functions without worrying about their physical nature. This attitude is certainly justifled by the extraordinary success of the theory in predicting and explaining not only all the phenomena encountered in the domain of microphysics, but also some spectacular nonclassical macroscopic behaviors of matter. Nevertheless one cannot ignore that the wave{particle duality of quantum objects not only still raises conceptual problems among the members of the small community of physicists who are still interested in the foundations of our basic theory of matter, but also induces thousands and thousands of physics students all around the world to ask each year, at their flrst impact with Quantum Mechanics, embarrassing questions to their teachers without receiving really convincing answers. Remember that Feynman once said \It is fair to say that nobody understands

•Jan 1, 2006•5 citations

Approaches for improving students' understanding of quantum mechanics

Walter A. Harrison

A quite different approach from the one presented by the authors of “Improving Students’ Understanding of Quantum Mechanics” may be appropriate at least for some classes of students. It might be called the pragmatic approach, teaching students to deal with a wide variety of problems while minimizing philosophical discussion. I took this approach for several years while teaching a course for graduate engineers at Stanford. 1 1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, NJ (2000). The resulting course was surprisingly orthogonal to the traditional quantum course. Solving the Schrödinger equation became a minimal part of the subject; rather, tight-binding expansions allowed the student to use simple algebra to obtain a meaningful understanding of atoms, molecules, and solids. Transition rates and shake-off excitations provided understanding of a wide variety of phenomena.I took the defensible stance that all of quantum mechanics is the direct consequence of a single assertion, wave–particle duality. The uncertainty principle and the Pauli principle are consequences, not independent conjectures. Quantum theory does not tell us that there will be a particle of spin ½ with the mass and charge of an electron, but it indicates how such a particle will behave if there is one. When the consequences seem puzzling, it is fair to say that one is simply having difficulty with the starting assertion.REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, NJ (2000). Google ScholarCrossref© 2007 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Mar 1, 2007•1 citation

Now you see it, now you don’t Quantum theory: science and the invention of concepts

PETER T. LANDSBERG

Quantum theory characterizes a quantum system by a so-called wave function. Quantum states can be independent of time. Because quantum mechanics offers ‘only’ probabilities for the outcomes of experiments, it is profoundly different from classical mechanics. Quantum mechanics works and appears to be correct, but it does not go as far as X mechanics would go. ‘Hard-nosed’ physicists include many who work on the structure of the nucleus and on elementary particles, those who try to bring about nuclear fusion for the production of electricity, people working on semiconductors, lasers and quantum optics. To them quantum mechanics is a beautiful and reliable theoretical tool, and that is that. Particles collaborating in a single quantum state of a large system are said to be coherent. The wave nature of electrons, and hence of other material particles, having been accepted, the more formal development of a new mechanics had to follow.

CRC Press eBooks•Apr 30, 2019•0 citations

Classical Quantum Mechanics

Randell L Mills

Despite its successes, quantum mechanics (QM) has remained mysterious to all who have encountered it. Starting with Bohr and progressing into the present, the departure from intuitive, physical reality has widened. The connection between QM and reality is more than just a “philosophical” issue. It reveals that QM is not a correct or complete theory of the physical world and that inescapable internal inconsistencies and incongruities arise when attempts are made to treat it as physical as opposed to a purely mathematical “tool.” Some of these issues are discussed in a review by F. Laloe [Am. J. Phys. 69, 655 (2001)]. In an attempt to provide some physical insight into atomic problems and starting with the same essential physics as Bohr of e moving in the Coulombic field of the proton and the wave equation as modified by Schrodinger, a classical approach is explored that yields a remarkably accurate model and provides insight into physics on the atomic level. The proverbial view, deeply seated in the wave-particle duality notion, that there is no large-scale physical counterpart to the nature of the electron may not be correct. Physical laws and intuition may be restored when dealing with the wave equation and quantummechanical problems. Specifically, a theory of classical quantum mechanics (CQM) is derived from first principles that successfully applies physical laws on all scales. Rather than using the postulated Schrodinger boundary condition “Ψ → 0 as r → ∞,” which leads to a purely mathematical model of the electron, the constraint is based on experimental observation. Using Maxwell’s equations, the classical wave equation is solved with the constraint that the bound (n = 1)state electron cannot radiate energy. By further application of Maxwell’s equations to electromagnetic and gravitational fields at particle production, the Schwarzschild metric is derived from the classical wave equation, which modifies general relativity to include conservation of spacetime in addition to momentum and matter/energy. The result gives a natural relationship among Maxwell’s equations, special relativity, and general relativity. CQM holds over a scale of spacetime of 85 orders of magnitude — it correctly predicts the nature of the universe from the scale of the quarks to that of the cosmos. A review is given by G. Landvogt [Internat. J. Hydrogen Energy 28, 1155 (2003)].

Physics Essays•Dec 1, 2003•27 citations
Certainly there is no unique answer to Frank Wilczek’s question, “What Is Quantum Theory?” (Physics Today, June 2000, page 11). I was not certain that a pragmatic answer, which I proposed for a course in applied quantum mechanics, 1 1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, N.J. (2000). would be sustainable for the entire course, but it seems that it was. That answer was the assertion that everything is both a particle and a wave, and that everything else would follow from that one assertion. Planck’s constant arose when the velocity of a wave (the derivative of the frequency with respect to wavenumber) was equated to the velocity of a particle (the derivative of the energy with respect to momentum), so that energy is proportional to frequency and momentum to wavenumber, with the same proportionality constant ħ. When Hamiltonian mechanics was introduced, “everything” became anything that can be described by such mechanics, or anything that satisfies a wave equation. Quantum theory does not say what nature gives, only how to predict the behavior of what is given. If nature serves up particles with half-integral angular momentum, the wavefunction that describes them must go into its negative when they are interchanged, and they therefore obey the Pauli principle.Such principles, which historically arose as independent conjectures, now follow from the one assertion. It is a matter of seeing how this peculiar assertion can turn out to be absolutely true.The relation between quantum theory and the physical world was seen as follows: Quantum theory tells what future scenarios are consistent with some initial information, and what the relative probability of each scenario is. Quantum theory cannot tell more than that, but neither can any other theory.My pragmatic approach may not satisfy everyone’s philosophical needs. But the aim of an applied quantum course is to see how to use the theory and to introduce the many approximations that have made the theory accessible to physicists and engineers. If some basic consequences are difficult to accept, the problem must lie with the initial assertion from which the consequences follow.REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, N.J. (2000). Google ScholarCrossref© 2001 American Institute of Physics.
Our goal in this treatment of quantum theory is to provide those aspects of the theory which are most needed for a modem understanding of the world of our experience. Central to this are the many approximations which have turned out to be successful for estimating the properties of matter and predicting the events which occur on a microscopic scale. In that sense the goal is entirely pragmatic, but any study of quantum theory cannot help but raise deep philosophical questions. Perhaps the only real understanding of the theory is through a familiarity with how it works out for many different problems. It seems unlikely that understanding comes from thinking about some complicated extreme case, such as Schroedinger's cat. The approach we take here bypasses much of the question by starting with a single premise of wave-particle duality, from which follows all of quantum theory and its interpretation. Any remaining problems are made moot by the quantum-mechanical view that questions are meaningful only if there is some conceivable experimental way to test the answers. In keeping with this pragmatic approach we will not emphasize mathematical derivations, nor carry out the detailed analysis of harmonic-oscillator states, hydrogen wavefunctions, or angular momentum, which are part of almost all texts in quantum theory. We treat the simplest case in detail, state the general results, and see that they are the plausible generalizations. We leave the more detailed analysis to other texts. The one we used for the course at Stanford was Kroemer's Quantum Mechanics for Engineers and Materials Scientists , which served very well.
A type of mechanics will be presented that possesses some distinctive properties. On the one hand, its physical description & rules of operation are readily comprehensible & intuitively clear. On the other, it fully satisfies all observable predictions of non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Within it, particles exist at points in space, follow continuous, piecewise differentiable paths, and their linear momentum is equal to their mass times their velocity along their path. Yet the probabilities for position and momentum, conditioned on the state of the particle's environment, follow the rules of quantum theory. Indeed, all observable consequences of quantum theory are satisfied; particles can be entangled, have intrinsic spin, this spin is not local to the particle, particle identity can effect probabilities, and so forth. All the rules of quantum mechanics are obeyed, and all arise in a straightforward fashion. After this is established, connections will be drawn out between this type of mechanics and other types of quantum worlds; those that obey Bohmian mechanics, stochastic mechanics, the many worlds interpretation, and physical collapse. In the final section, a relativistic version of the mechanics will be presented.
After eighty years of Quantum Mechanics (QM) we have learned to live with wave functions without worrying about their physical nature. This attitude is certainly justifled by the extraordinary success of the theory in predicting and explaining not only all the phenomena encountered in the domain of microphysics, but also some spectacular nonclassical macroscopic behaviors of matter. Nevertheless one cannot ignore that the wave{particle duality of quantum objects not only still raises conceptual problems among the members of the small community of physicists who are still interested in the foundations of our basic theory of matter, but also induces thousands and thousands of physics students all around the world to ask each year, at their flrst impact with Quantum Mechanics, embarrassing questions to their teachers without receiving really convincing answers. Remember that Feynman once said \It is fair to say that nobody understands
A quite different approach from the one presented by the authors of “Improving Students’ Understanding of Quantum Mechanics” may be appropriate at least for some classes of students. It might be called the pragmatic approach, teaching students to deal with a wide variety of problems while minimizing philosophical discussion. I took this approach for several years while teaching a course for graduate engineers at Stanford. 1 1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, NJ (2000). The resulting course was surprisingly orthogonal to the traditional quantum course. Solving the Schrödinger equation became a minimal part of the subject; rather, tight-binding expansions allowed the student to use simple algebra to obtain a meaningful understanding of atoms, molecules, and solids. Transition rates and shake-off excitations provided understanding of a wide variety of phenomena.I took the defensible stance that all of quantum mechanics is the direct consequence of a single assertion, wave–particle duality. The uncertainty principle and the Pauli principle are consequences, not independent conjectures. Quantum theory does not tell us that there will be a particle of spin ½ with the mass and charge of an electron, but it indicates how such a particle will behave if there is one. When the consequences seem puzzling, it is fair to say that one is simply having difficulty with the starting assertion.REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, NJ (2000). Google ScholarCrossref© 2007 American Institute of Physics.
Quantum theory characterizes a quantum system by a so-called wave function. Quantum states can be independent of time. Because quantum mechanics offers ‘only’ probabilities for the outcomes of experiments, it is profoundly different from classical mechanics. Quantum mechanics works and appears to be correct, but it does not go as far as X mechanics would go. ‘Hard-nosed’ physicists include many who work on the structure of the nucleus and on elementary particles, those who try to bring about nuclear fusion for the production of electricity, people working on semiconductors, lasers and quantum optics. To them quantum mechanics is a beautiful and reliable theoretical tool, and that is that. Particles collaborating in a single quantum state of a large system are said to be coherent. The wave nature of electrons, and hence of other material particles, having been accepted, the more formal development of a new mechanics had to follow.
Despite its successes, quantum mechanics (QM) has remained mysterious to all who have encountered it. Starting with Bohr and progressing into the present, the departure from intuitive, physical reality has widened. The connection between QM and reality is more than just a “philosophical” issue. It reveals that QM is not a correct or complete theory of the physical world and that inescapable internal inconsistencies and incongruities arise when attempts are made to treat it as physical as opposed to a purely mathematical “tool.” Some of these issues are discussed in a review by F. Laloe [Am. J. Phys. 69, 655 (2001)]. In an attempt to provide some physical insight into atomic problems and starting with the same essential physics as Bohr of e moving in the Coulombic field of the proton and the wave equation as modified by Schrodinger, a classical approach is explored that yields a remarkably accurate model and provides insight into physics on the atomic level. The proverbial view, deeply seated in the wave-particle duality notion, that there is no large-scale physical counterpart to the nature of the electron may not be correct. Physical laws and intuition may be restored when dealing with the wave equation and quantummechanical problems. Specifically, a theory of classical quantum mechanics (CQM) is derived from first principles that successfully applies physical laws on all scales. Rather than using the postulated Schrodinger boundary condition “Ψ → 0 as r → ∞,” which leads to a purely mathematical model of the electron, the constraint is based on experimental observation. Using Maxwell’s equations, the classical wave equation is solved with the constraint that the bound (n = 1)state electron cannot radiate energy. By further application of Maxwell’s equations to electromagnetic and gravitational fields at particle production, the Schwarzschild metric is derived from the classical wave equation, which modifies general relativity to include conservation of spacetime in addition to momentum and matter/energy. The result gives a natural relationship among Maxwell’s equations, special relativity, and general relativity. CQM holds over a scale of spacetime of 85 orders of magnitude — it correctly predicts the nature of the universe from the scale of the quarks to that of the cosmos. A review is given by G. Landvogt [Internat. J. Hydrogen Energy 28, 1155 (2003)].