Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Asia Joint Conference on Information Security (AsiaJCIS)

Cryptanalysis of PiLike: An Impersonation Attack on the Lightweight Identity-Based Authenticated Key Exchange Protocol Using Bi-ISIS

Hao-Yi Hsu, Hsin‐Yi Lin, Raylin Tso, Tao- Hsiang Chang, Jen-Chieh Hsu

Published Aug 13, 2024• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The proliferation of Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) devices, coupled with their computational constraints, has necessitated robust authenticated key exchange mechanisms to secure communications. To address this issue, Gupta recently introduced a lattice-based lightweight authenticated key exchange protocol, PiLike, in the IEEE Systems Journal. Despite rigorous security proofs being provided, our cryptanalysis unveils a critical vulnerability in their scheme which may cause impersonation attacks. Specifically, in the private key extraction phase, an adversary can leverage secret information obtained during registration to impersonate legitimate users, successfully negotiating session keys while evading detection. In addition to the theoretical analysis, a corresponding concrete experiment was also conducted, showing that the adversary has a 100% success rate in breaking the required security claimed in PiLike. Our findings underscore the urgency to address PiLike's vulnerabilities, ensuring its reliability in safeguarding IIoT communications against conventional and quantum threats.

DOI
10.1109/asiajcis64263.2024.00013

Related papers

PiLike: Post-Quantum Identity-Based Lightweight Authenticated Key Exchange Protocol for IIoT Environments

Daya Sagar Gupta

As an imperative division of the Internet of Things (IoT), Industrial IoT (IIoT) has also attracted full attention. IIoT networks are equipped with various authenticated key exchange techniques under the cumbersome Diffie–Hellman (DH) problems and certificate management overheads. However, DH-type problems are vulnerable to quantum cryptanalysis. In this article, a novel identity-based authenticated key exchange protocol is designed using the concept of lattice cryptography, which enables the different security features in the IIoT in open wireless communication. Due to the lattice hard assumptions, the proposed protocol can withstand a quantum attack. Rigorous formal security analysis has been made, which shows the ability of the proposed protocol to resist existing as well as quantum attacks. Performance results demonstrate that the proposed protocol exhibits better communication, energy consumption, cryptographic key storage, and computation costs than other similar state of the arts.

IEEE Systems Journal•Dec 25, 2023•28 citations

Further Analysis of "Lattice-based key agreement protocol under ring-LWE problem for IoT-enabled smart devices"

Mohammad Reza Saeidi, Hamid Mala

Abstract The increasing interconnectedness of devices via the Internet of Things (IoT) highlights the growing importance of addressing IoT security issues. Authenticated Key Agreement (AKA) protocols ensure secure communication between IoT devices, users, and central servers. Preserving anonymity in AKA protocols is especially crucial given privacy issues and user preferences. The emergence of Shor's algorithm in 1994 and recent advancements in quantum computing have posed a threat to the security of classical AKA schemes relying on integer factorization, discrete logarithm, and other number theory problems. Consequently, researchers have turned their attention to developing quantum-resistant AKA schemes. In this context, Rana and Mishra introduced a lattice-based key agreement protocol under ring-LWE problem for IoT-enabled smart devices. However, a thorough security assessment uncovered vulnerabilities in their protocol, specifically susceptibility to replay and Key Compromise Impersonation (KCI) attacks. Furthermore, their approach reveals potential weaknesses in user impersonation if the user's identity is compromised.

•Sep 27, 2024•2 citations

Security Analysis of a Lightweight Identity-Based Two-Party Authenticated Key Agreement Protocol for IIoT Environments

Yuting Li, Qingfeng Cheng, Wenbo Shi

Internet of Things brings convenience to the social life, at the same time, putting forward higher requirements for the security of data transmission and storage. Security incidents based on industrial Internet of Things have occurred frequently recently, which should be given full consideration. The identity-based authenticated key agreement protocol can solve these security threats to a certain extent. Recently, a lightweight identity-based authenticated key agreement protocol for Industrial Internet of Things, called ID-2PAKA protocol, was claimed to achieve secure authentication and meet security properties. In this paper, we show that the ID-2PAKA protocol is insecure in identity authentication and cannot resisting ephemeral key compromise impersonation attack.

Security and Communication Networks•Feb 27, 2021•18 citations

EdgePQ-Auth: A Lightweight Lattice-based Mutual Authentication and Key Agreement Framework for Quantum-Resilient Edge-IoT Networks

S. Ganeshmoorthy, S. Abishek, S. Barath Aswin +3 more

The rapid proliferation of Internet of Things (IoT) devices in smart cities, industrial automation, and healthcare systems has significantly increased the demand for secure and efficient communication mechanisms. However, the emergence of quantum computing poses a serious threat to conventional public-key cryptographic schemes, potentially compromising the confidentiality and authenticity of IoT communications. Existing authentication and key agreement protocols primarily rely on classical cryptographic algorithms, which are vulnerable to quantum attacks and often impose considerable computational and communication overhead on resource-constrained IoT devices. Furthermore, many current solutions fail to provide a balanced trade-off between security strength and energy efficiency in edge-enabled IoT environments. To address these challenges, this paper proposes EdgePQ-Auth, a lightweight lattice-based mutual authentication and key agreement framework designed for quantum-resilient Edge-IoT networks. The proposed framework consists of four modules: Device Registration, Mutual Authentication, Post-Quantum Key Agreement (PQKA), and Secure Data Transmission using Symmetric Encryption. By leveraging lattice-based cryptography for authentication and session key establishment while utilizing lightweight symmetric encryption for subsequent communications, the framework minimizes computational burden on IoT devices and delegates intensive operations to the edge gateway. The proposed scheme ensures resistance against replay, impersonation, man-in-the-middle, and quantum-enabled attacks while maintaining low resource consumption. Experimental evaluation demonstrates that EdgePQ-Auth achieves superior performance in terms of authentication latency, communication overhead, and energy consumption compared with existing PQ IoT security protocols. The results indicate that the proposed framework provides an effective and scalable solution for securing next-generation quantum-resilient Edge-IoT deployments.

International Conference on Intelligent Cyber Physical Systems and Internet of Things (ICoICI)•Sep 1, 2026•0 citations

MAKE-IT—A Lightweight Mutual Authentication and Key Exchange Protocol for Industrial Internet of Things

Karanjeet Choudhary, Gurjot Singh Gaba, İsmail Bütün +1 more

Continuous development of the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) has opened up enormous opportunities for the engineers to enhance the efficiency of the machines. Despite the development, many industry administrators still fear to use Internet for operating their machines due to untrusted nature of the communication channel. The utilization of internet for managing industrial operations can be widespread adopted if the authentication of the entities are performed and trust is ensured. The traditional schemes with their inherent security issues and other complexities, cannot be directly deployed to resource constrained network devices. Therefore, we have proposed a strong mutual authentication and secret key exchange protocol to address the vulnerabilities of the existing schemes. We have used various cryptography operations such as hashing, ciphering, and so forth, for providing secure mutual authentication and secret key exchange between different entities to restrict unauthorized access. Performance and security analysis clearly demonstrates that the proposed work is energy efficient (computation and communication inexpensive) and more robust against the attacks in comparison to the traditional schemes.

Sensors•Sep 10, 2020•36 citations

Review on cryptosystems-based authenticated key exchange techniques for IIoT

K. Somasena Reddy, Pravin Mundhe

With the advent of Industry 4.0, the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) is emerging as a crucial growing technology. However, the complexities in current production systems have become a common practice for interconnected domains to collaborate in the manufacturing of products. To accomplish this, devices situated in various domains must efficiently communicate and exchange data. Generally, there is a lack of mutual trust between different domains, making it challenging to establish a secure communication mechanism among distributed entities. Unauthorized access of users in real-time monitoring IIoT systems will question its security and privacy. Even it causes an issue in IIoT by threatening an industry’s production. Consequently, there is a need to establish a secure, authenticated key agreement protocol to address these security and privacy concerns in IIoT. Numerous key agreement and user authentication schemes have been developed for IoT-based environments. This review work is developed by considering such schemes for IIoT; that is, it is typically developed by analyzing 50 research papers based on cryptosystem-based authenticated key exchange techniques for IIoT. Initially, the review is developed by explaining general processes involved in cryptosystem-based authenticated key exchange techniques for IIoT.

Information Security Journal A Global Perspective•May 31, 2025•0 citations
The proliferation of Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) devices, coupled with their computational constraints, has necessitated robust authenticated key exchange mechanisms to secure communications. To address this issue, Gupta recently introduced a lattice-based lightweight authenticated key exchange protocol, PiLike, in the IEEE Systems Journal. Despite rigorous security proofs being provided, our cryptanalysis unveils a critical vulnerability in their scheme which may cause impersonation attacks. Specifically, in the private key extraction phase, an adversary can leverage secret information obtained during registration to impersonate legitimate users, successfully negotiating session keys while evading detection. In addition to the theoretical analysis, a corresponding concrete experiment was also conducted, showing that the adversary has a 100% success rate in breaking the required security claimed in PiLike. Our findings underscore the urgency to address PiLike's vulnerabilities, ensuring its reliability in safeguarding IIoT communications against conventional and quantum threats.
As an imperative division of the Internet of Things (IoT), Industrial IoT (IIoT) has also attracted full attention. IIoT networks are equipped with various authenticated key exchange techniques under the cumbersome Diffie–Hellman (DH) problems and certificate management overheads. However, DH-type problems are vulnerable to quantum cryptanalysis. In this article, a novel identity-based authenticated key exchange protocol is designed using the concept of lattice cryptography, which enables the different security features in the IIoT in open wireless communication. Due to the lattice hard assumptions, the proposed protocol can withstand a quantum attack. Rigorous formal security analysis has been made, which shows the ability of the proposed protocol to resist existing as well as quantum attacks. Performance results demonstrate that the proposed protocol exhibits better communication, energy consumption, cryptographic key storage, and computation costs than other similar state of the arts.
Abstract The increasing interconnectedness of devices via the Internet of Things (IoT) highlights the growing importance of addressing IoT security issues. Authenticated Key Agreement (AKA) protocols ensure secure communication between IoT devices, users, and central servers. Preserving anonymity in AKA protocols is especially crucial given privacy issues and user preferences. The emergence of Shor's algorithm in 1994 and recent advancements in quantum computing have posed a threat to the security of classical AKA schemes relying on integer factorization, discrete logarithm, and other number theory problems. Consequently, researchers have turned their attention to developing quantum-resistant AKA schemes. In this context, Rana and Mishra introduced a lattice-based key agreement protocol under ring-LWE problem for IoT-enabled smart devices. However, a thorough security assessment uncovered vulnerabilities in their protocol, specifically susceptibility to replay and Key Compromise Impersonation (KCI) attacks. Furthermore, their approach reveals potential weaknesses in user impersonation if the user's identity is compromised.
Internet of Things brings convenience to the social life, at the same time, putting forward higher requirements for the security of data transmission and storage. Security incidents based on industrial Internet of Things have occurred frequently recently, which should be given full consideration. The identity-based authenticated key agreement protocol can solve these security threats to a certain extent. Recently, a lightweight identity-based authenticated key agreement protocol for Industrial Internet of Things, called ID-2PAKA protocol, was claimed to achieve secure authentication and meet security properties. In this paper, we show that the ID-2PAKA protocol is insecure in identity authentication and cannot resisting ephemeral key compromise impersonation attack.
The rapid proliferation of Internet of Things (IoT) devices in smart cities, industrial automation, and healthcare systems has significantly increased the demand for secure and efficient communication mechanisms. However, the emergence of quantum computing poses a serious threat to conventional public-key cryptographic schemes, potentially compromising the confidentiality and authenticity of IoT communications. Existing authentication and key agreement protocols primarily rely on classical cryptographic algorithms, which are vulnerable to quantum attacks and often impose considerable computational and communication overhead on resource-constrained IoT devices. Furthermore, many current solutions fail to provide a balanced trade-off between security strength and energy efficiency in edge-enabled IoT environments. To address these challenges, this paper proposes EdgePQ-Auth, a lightweight lattice-based mutual authentication and key agreement framework designed for quantum-resilient Edge-IoT networks. The proposed framework consists of four modules: Device Registration, Mutual Authentication, Post-Quantum Key Agreement (PQKA), and Secure Data Transmission using Symmetric Encryption. By leveraging lattice-based cryptography for authentication and session key establishment while utilizing lightweight symmetric encryption for subsequent communications, the framework minimizes computational burden on IoT devices and delegates intensive operations to the edge gateway. The proposed scheme ensures resistance against replay, impersonation, man-in-the-middle, and quantum-enabled attacks while maintaining low resource consumption. Experimental evaluation demonstrates that EdgePQ-Auth achieves superior performance in terms of authentication latency, communication overhead, and energy consumption compared with existing PQ IoT security protocols. The results indicate that the proposed framework provides an effective and scalable solution for securing next-generation quantum-resilient Edge-IoT deployments.
Continuous development of the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) has opened up enormous opportunities for the engineers to enhance the efficiency of the machines. Despite the development, many industry administrators still fear to use Internet for operating their machines due to untrusted nature of the communication channel. The utilization of internet for managing industrial operations can be widespread adopted if the authentication of the entities are performed and trust is ensured. The traditional schemes with their inherent security issues and other complexities, cannot be directly deployed to resource constrained network devices. Therefore, we have proposed a strong mutual authentication and secret key exchange protocol to address the vulnerabilities of the existing schemes. We have used various cryptography operations such as hashing, ciphering, and so forth, for providing secure mutual authentication and secret key exchange between different entities to restrict unauthorized access. Performance and security analysis clearly demonstrates that the proposed work is energy efficient (computation and communication inexpensive) and more robust against the attacks in comparison to the traditional schemes.
With the advent of Industry 4.0, the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) is emerging as a crucial growing technology. However, the complexities in current production systems have become a common practice for interconnected domains to collaborate in the manufacturing of products. To accomplish this, devices situated in various domains must efficiently communicate and exchange data. Generally, there is a lack of mutual trust between different domains, making it challenging to establish a secure communication mechanism among distributed entities. Unauthorized access of users in real-time monitoring IIoT systems will question its security and privacy. Even it causes an issue in IIoT by threatening an industry’s production. Consequently, there is a need to establish a secure, authenticated key agreement protocol to address these security and privacy concerns in IIoT. Numerous key agreement and user authentication schemes have been developed for IoT-based environments. This review work is developed by considering such schemes for IIoT; that is, it is typically developed by analyzing 50 research papers based on cryptosystem-based authenticated key exchange techniques for IIoT. Initially, the review is developed by explaining general processes involved in cryptosystem-based authenticated key exchange techniques for IIoT.