Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum Information Processing

"Fight alone" to "win–win cooperation": a quantum stag hunt game model for analyzing cooperative R&D between enterprises

D. Huang, Bin-qiang Tan

Published Jul 29, 2024• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Cooperative R&D has become one of the effective ways for enterprises to improve R&D efficiency and break the bottleneck of R&D resources, but cooperation between enterprises often falls into difficulties due to various factors. Given this, we use the quantum game to study the incentive mechanism of forming cooperative R&D strategic alliances between enterprises, first we establish a stag-hunt game model based on cooperative R&D and independent R&D, then expand the classical strategy to the quantum strategy space, and discuss the strategic characteristics of whether to consider state entanglement, and finally conducts case study to verify the effectiveness of the model. The results show that in the non-entangled scenario or non-quantum scenario, it is difficult to achieve the Pareto optimal result that both sides in full cooperation, because the full-effort one need to bear the risk of betrayal by the on-effort one. However, in the context of maximally entangled quantum game, the risk causing by the defector is borne by himself rather than the cooperator, so both parties will adopt a complete cooperative R&D strategy to achieve a win-win situation. Based on these findings, we establish three incentive mechanisms: information sharing, performance evaluation and responsibility constraint, which provides theoretical guidance for the formation and stability of enterprise cooperative R&D strategic alliance. Furthermore, our research can be extended to other fields, such as the issues of multilateral cooperation between major powers.

DOI
10.1007/s11128-024-04483-x

Related papers

Research on Repeated Quantum Games with Public Goods under Strong Reciprocity

Simo Sun, Yadong Shu, Jinxiu Pi +1 more

We developed a repeated quantum game of public goods by using quantum entanglement and strong reciprocity mechanisms. Utilizing the framework of quantum game analysis, a comparative investigation incorporating both entangled and non-entangled states reveals that the player will choose a fully cooperative strategy when the expected cooperation strategy of the competitor exceeds a certain threshold. When the entanglement of states is not considered, the prisoner’s dilemma still exists, and the cooperating party must bear the cost of defactoring the quantum strategy themselves; when considering the entanglement of states, the benefits of both parties in the game are closely related, forming a community of benefits. By signing a strong reciprocity contract, the degree of cooperation between the game parties can be considered using the strong reciprocity entanglement contract mechanism. The party striving to cooperate does not have to bear the risk of the other party’s defector, and to some extent, it can solve the prisoner’s dilemma problem. Finally, taking the public goods green planting industry project as an example, by jointly entrusting a third party to determine and sign a strong reciprocity entanglement contract, both parties can ensure a complete quantum strategy to maximize cooperation and achieve Pareto optimality, ultimately enabling the long-term and stable development of the public goods industry project.

Axioms•Nov 10, 2023•0 citations

The Rule for Evolution of Cooperation in Quantum Games

Z. W. Sun

Cooperation is essential to biological organizations and human society.In this paper, the conditions of dilemmas resolving by quantum strategies in the three games, Prisoners' Dilemma, Chicken Game and Stag Hunt, are presented.The rule for the evolution of cooperation in general quantum games, b/c > coth 2 γ, is put forward.The formation of the rule is similar to those of the five rules in the classical game theory summarized by Nowak.b/c is still the benefit-to-cost ratio of the altruistic act, while γ is a measure for the game's entanglement.The rule is the prerequisite for the realization of cooperation in quantum games.

Acta Physica Polonica A•Aug 1, 2009•6 citations

General Analysis of Incentive Mechanisms for Peer-to-Peer Transmissions: A Quantum Game Perspective

Weiman Sun, Shengling Wang

The peer-to-peer transmission is a mainstream in challenged network environments. Yet, the free rider phenomenon in peer-to peer transmissions presses a need for incentive mechanisms to stimulate contributions of data transmission. As a result, it is imperative to answer the questions: whether and to what extent an incentive mechanism can invoke such contributions? To answer these questions, we employ an n-player continuous quantum game model to analyze extrinsic incentive mechanisms (promoting cooperative behaviors by offering rewards), and use the quantum prisoner's dilemma model to analyze intrinsic incentive mechanisms (encouraging reciprocal cooperation by exploiting internal bounds). To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to analyze incentive mechanisms for peer-to-peer transmissions from a quantum game perspective. Such a perspective is adopted because the extended strategy space in the quantum game broadens the range for searching optimal strategies and the introduction of entanglement makes the proposed analytical frameworks more practical due to the consideration of the peers' relationships in decision-making. Our proposed quantum game-based analytical frameworks are generic because they are compatible with classic game-based schemes. Our analytical results can provide straightforward insights on evaluating the potential of incentive mechanisms and can serve as important references for designing new incentive mechanisms.

IEEE International Conference on Distributed Computing Systems (ICDCS)•Jun 1, 2017•4 citations

Hybrid Quantum Games

Shuliang Li, D. Huang

By incorporating payoff matrix and population evolution of open systems and proposing density games, pioneering effort has been made to break the following two basic assumptions of evolutionary game theory over the past decades: the payoff from the game determines the reproductive rate of individuals, and the total population size remains constant by a variable called the death rate. On the other hand, most studies on strategic interactions in game theories consider independent individual strategies as the basic unit of analyses. This is in fact not always true in human interaction strategies. It has been unclear that how subjective non-independent species with strategic interactions in open dynamic systems evolve. In this paper, we create the new concept of hybrid quantum games, and propose an open quantum dynamic symbiosis model for exploring the evolution of this type of species under unclosed social settings. We show that the stability conditions of the model with non-independent strategic interactions are influenced by the specific symbiosis states, game payoff matrix and quantum entanglement. The stability conditions of the competition scenario are more stringent than those of the cooperation one. Our system dynamics simulation study demonstrates and verifies the dynamic changes for the population sizes of two different species in the theoretical model, on the basis of the stability conditions of the competition and cooperation scenarios. Our model combines quantum games, game payoff matrix and symbiosis equations organically, and can provide insights into competition, cooperation and symbiosis mechanisms in open systems with subjective non-independent strategies considered.

•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

Study of quantum games

Ahmad Razavi

Game theory is the study of strategic competition used in many branches of science. In general, a game is a match between two or more players and each wants to maximize his or her score. In a game, the player’s score depends on their strategies. The goal is to find the optimized decision, with regard to the payoff, in conformity with the rules of the game. This thesis considers the games with two players who know both their own and their rival’s payoff. However, they do not know the strategy chosen by the opponent.\nIn a classical game, the options of players are referred to as cooperation and defect. Quantum game theory is a generalization of classical game theory. In quantum games a linear combination of two options specify the strategy based on qubit. The quantum domain is characterized by entanglement. The quantum entanglement coefficient (y) varies from 0 to . The game is in the classical regime when y is smaller than a threshold. Quantum entanglement is intrinsically non-local.\nIn an iterated game tournament, 63 different strategies contest with four known strategies. Depending on the result, they are divided to a number of groups. The competition specifies which group of strategies can obtain a higher score.\nOther types of games are discussed in the thesis. They are known as incomplete information games. In these games one player has two payoff matrixes, and the rival does not know which of them is used. We discuss the advantage of using quantum strategy over the classical game, particular in avoiding the dilemma in classical games.

•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations

Quantum Game Analysis on Extrinsic Incentive Mechanisms for P2P Services

Shengling Wang, Weiman Sun, Liran Ma +2 more

Peer-to-peer (P2P) services such as mobile P2P transmissions and resource sharing, provide efficient methods to deliver data without the deployment of any central server. Nevertheless, the free-riding phenomenon inherit in such services presses a need for incentive mechanisms to stimulate contributions of data transmissions or sharing. As a result, it is imperative to answer the following questions: whether, and if so to what extent, an incentive mechanism can invoke such contributions? To answerthese questions, we employ an n-player continuous quantum game model to analyze the general extrinsic incentive mechanisms as well as the reputation-based incentive mechanisms, a typical class of extrinsic incentive mechanisms. We focus on studying the extrinsic incentive mechanisms in this paper due to their wide scope of applications stemming from the fact that they promote cooperative behaviors by offering rewards rather than depending on the internal bounds (e.g., social ties) among peers, which may not always exist between any pair of peers. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to analyze the extrinsic incentive mechanisms for P2P services from a quantum game perspective. Such a perspective is adopted because the extended strategy space in the quantum game broadens the range for searching optimal strategies and the introduction of entanglement makes the proposed analytical frameworks more practical due to the consideration of the peers' relationships imposed by the rewards in extrinsic incentive mechanisms. Our quantum game-based analytical framework is generic because it is compatible with classic game-based schemes. The analytical results can provide a straightforward insight on evaluating the potential of the extrinsic incentive mechanisms and can serve as important references for designing new extrinsic incentive mechanisms.

IEEE Transactions on Parallel and Distributed Systems•Aug 5, 2019•7 citations
Abstract Cooperative R&D has become one of the effective ways for enterprises to improve R&D efficiency and break the bottleneck of R&D resources, but cooperation between enterprises often falls into difficulties due to various factors. Given this, we use the quantum game to study the incentive mechanism of forming cooperative R&D strategic alliances between enterprises, first we establish a stag-hunt game model based on cooperative R&D and independent R&D, then expand the classical strategy to the quantum strategy space, and discuss the strategic characteristics of whether to consider state entanglement, and finally conducts case study to verify the effectiveness of the model. The results show that in the non-entangled scenario or non-quantum scenario, it is difficult to achieve the Pareto optimal result that both sides in full cooperation, because the full-effort one need to bear the risk of betrayal by the on-effort one. However, in the context of maximally entangled quantum game, the risk causing by the defector is borne by himself rather than the cooperator, so both parties will adopt a complete cooperative R&D strategy to achieve a win-win situation. Based on these findings, we establish three incentive mechanisms: information sharing, performance evaluation and responsibility constraint, which provides theoretical guidance for the formation and stability of enterprise cooperative R&D strategic alliance. Furthermore, our research can be extended to other fields, such as the issues of multilateral cooperation between major powers.
We developed a repeated quantum game of public goods by using quantum entanglement and strong reciprocity mechanisms. Utilizing the framework of quantum game analysis, a comparative investigation incorporating both entangled and non-entangled states reveals that the player will choose a fully cooperative strategy when the expected cooperation strategy of the competitor exceeds a certain threshold. When the entanglement of states is not considered, the prisoner’s dilemma still exists, and the cooperating party must bear the cost of defactoring the quantum strategy themselves; when considering the entanglement of states, the benefits of both parties in the game are closely related, forming a community of benefits. By signing a strong reciprocity contract, the degree of cooperation between the game parties can be considered using the strong reciprocity entanglement contract mechanism. The party striving to cooperate does not have to bear the risk of the other party’s defector, and to some extent, it can solve the prisoner’s dilemma problem. Finally, taking the public goods green planting industry project as an example, by jointly entrusting a third party to determine and sign a strong reciprocity entanglement contract, both parties can ensure a complete quantum strategy to maximize cooperation and achieve Pareto optimality, ultimately enabling the long-term and stable development of the public goods industry project.
Cooperation is essential to biological organizations and human society.In this paper, the conditions of dilemmas resolving by quantum strategies in the three games, Prisoners' Dilemma, Chicken Game and Stag Hunt, are presented.The rule for the evolution of cooperation in general quantum games, b/c > coth 2 γ, is put forward.The formation of the rule is similar to those of the five rules in the classical game theory summarized by Nowak.b/c is still the benefit-to-cost ratio of the altruistic act, while γ is a measure for the game's entanglement.The rule is the prerequisite for the realization of cooperation in quantum games.
The peer-to-peer transmission is a mainstream in challenged network environments. Yet, the free rider phenomenon in peer-to peer transmissions presses a need for incentive mechanisms to stimulate contributions of data transmission. As a result, it is imperative to answer the questions: whether and to what extent an incentive mechanism can invoke such contributions? To answer these questions, we employ an n-player continuous quantum game model to analyze extrinsic incentive mechanisms (promoting cooperative behaviors by offering rewards), and use the quantum prisoner's dilemma model to analyze intrinsic incentive mechanisms (encouraging reciprocal cooperation by exploiting internal bounds). To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to analyze incentive mechanisms for peer-to-peer transmissions from a quantum game perspective. Such a perspective is adopted because the extended strategy space in the quantum game broadens the range for searching optimal strategies and the introduction of entanglement makes the proposed analytical frameworks more practical due to the consideration of the peers' relationships in decision-making. Our proposed quantum game-based analytical frameworks are generic because they are compatible with classic game-based schemes. Our analytical results can provide straightforward insights on evaluating the potential of incentive mechanisms and can serve as important references for designing new incentive mechanisms.
By incorporating payoff matrix and population evolution of open systems and proposing density games, pioneering effort has been made to break the following two basic assumptions of evolutionary game theory over the past decades: the payoff from the game determines the reproductive rate of individuals, and the total population size remains constant by a variable called the death rate. On the other hand, most studies on strategic interactions in game theories consider independent individual strategies as the basic unit of analyses. This is in fact not always true in human interaction strategies. It has been unclear that how subjective non-independent species with strategic interactions in open dynamic systems evolve. In this paper, we create the new concept of hybrid quantum games, and propose an open quantum dynamic symbiosis model for exploring the evolution of this type of species under unclosed social settings. We show that the stability conditions of the model with non-independent strategic interactions are influenced by the specific symbiosis states, game payoff matrix and quantum entanglement. The stability conditions of the competition scenario are more stringent than those of the cooperation one. Our system dynamics simulation study demonstrates and verifies the dynamic changes for the population sizes of two different species in the theoretical model, on the basis of the stability conditions of the competition and cooperation scenarios. Our model combines quantum games, game payoff matrix and symbiosis equations organically, and can provide insights into competition, cooperation and symbiosis mechanisms in open systems with subjective non-independent strategies considered.
Game theory is the study of strategic competition used in many branches of science. In general, a game is a match between two or more players and each wants to maximize his or her score. In a game, the player’s score depends on their strategies. The goal is to find the optimized decision, with regard to the payoff, in conformity with the rules of the game. This thesis considers the games with two players who know both their own and their rival’s payoff. However, they do not know the strategy chosen by the opponent.\nIn a classical game, the options of players are referred to as cooperation and defect. Quantum game theory is a generalization of classical game theory. In quantum games a linear combination of two options specify the strategy based on qubit. The quantum domain is characterized by entanglement. The quantum entanglement coefficient (y) varies from 0 to . The game is in the classical regime when y is smaller than a threshold. Quantum entanglement is intrinsically non-local.\nIn an iterated game tournament, 63 different strategies contest with four known strategies. Depending on the result, they are divided to a number of groups. The competition specifies which group of strategies can obtain a higher score.\nOther types of games are discussed in the thesis. They are known as incomplete information games. In these games one player has two payoff matrixes, and the rival does not know which of them is used. We discuss the advantage of using quantum strategy over the classical game, particular in avoiding the dilemma in classical games.
Peer-to-peer (P2P) services such as mobile P2P transmissions and resource sharing, provide efficient methods to deliver data without the deployment of any central server. Nevertheless, the free-riding phenomenon inherit in such services presses a need for incentive mechanisms to stimulate contributions of data transmissions or sharing. As a result, it is imperative to answer the following questions: whether, and if so to what extent, an incentive mechanism can invoke such contributions? To answerthese questions, we employ an n-player continuous quantum game model to analyze the general extrinsic incentive mechanisms as well as the reputation-based incentive mechanisms, a typical class of extrinsic incentive mechanisms. We focus on studying the extrinsic incentive mechanisms in this paper due to their wide scope of applications stemming from the fact that they promote cooperative behaviors by offering rewards rather than depending on the internal bounds (e.g., social ties) among peers, which may not always exist between any pair of peers. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to analyze the extrinsic incentive mechanisms for P2P services from a quantum game perspective. Such a perspective is adopted because the extended strategy space in the quantum game broadens the range for searching optimal strategies and the introduction of entanglement makes the proposed analytical frameworks more practical due to the consideration of the peers' relationships imposed by the rewards in extrinsic incentive mechanisms. Our quantum game-based analytical framework is generic because it is compatible with classic game-based schemes. The analytical results can provide a straightforward insight on evaluating the potential of the extrinsic incentive mechanisms and can serve as important references for designing new extrinsic incentive mechanisms.