Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Indistinguishability At A Distance

Valerio Scarani

Published Jan 5, 2006• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract During my first lecture at Saint-Michel College, I had sidestepped the question about randomness that the student had asked. As the reader will recall, it was the experiment of Fig. 1.1, as simple as it was, in which the particles arrived one after the other at a beam splitter. I had said that we do not know how to describe the behaviour of each particle, we do not know why a given particle is reflected rather than transmitted. Is it really uncertain, ran- dom (which is the current opinion among physicists) or is there a mechanism yet to be discovered? I had deliberately turned attention from this problem, in order to concentrate on the experiment of Fig. 1.3, the Mach–Zehnder interferometer. We have seen, then, that quantum randomness is a curious randomness – if we assemble two ‘randomness generators’ (beam splitters) in a certain way, we rediscover the certainty! I briefly remind the assembled students of this, a week later, in the old granary of the College.

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780198570479.003.0006

Related papers

Attempts At Explanation

Valerio Scarani

Abstract During the lectures to the students in Fribourg, as with other people foreign to the world of physics, I have stated that my audience was driven to raise the same questions as the physicists: can we accept randomness in physical phenomena? Is interference determined by the mechanisms, and correlations at a distance by an exchange of information? In the presence of non-separability of physical properties, can we still talk about distinct entities? We feel the need to interpret quantum phenomena because we are not at ease with the indistinguishability principle and with some of its consequences. The unease comes from the fact that this principle, which appears to be omnipresent in the microscopic world, is unknown in everyday life and even seems to contradict our normal perceptions – the reader must recall the game with the sets of cars in Chapter 2. Seen from this point of view, the interpretations can be divided into three broad categories:

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 5, 2006•0 citations

Creating Superposition: The Beam Splitter

Ciaran Hughes, Joshua Isaacson, Anastasia Perry +2 more

Abstract Now that we have explored qubits and the phenomenon of superposition, we can ask the question: how do we know that superposition actually happens? is the evidence that shows that a quantum particle really does exist in two different locations at this same time while in a quantum superposition? The nature of science means that experiments are constantly updating previous results, so are there other interpretations of the experimental results that can explain the data without the need for superposition? In this chapter we’ll explore the experimental evidence interpretations other than quantum superposition. Further, while a flipping coin is a simple model of a qubit, it is not very useful for building a quantum computer because it does not exhibit all of the properties of a true quantum superposition. For example, we cannot manipulate the superposition amplitudes. In this chapter, we will study some real physical examples of quantum particles in a superposition containing two states. These examples include a photon in a beam splitter and the Mach–Zehnder interferometer.

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 2021•2 citations

Let’S Step Back

Valerio Scarani

Abstract Leaving Saint-Michel, I take my leave of Jean-Paul who is going home, and I turn left to walk down the College Steps, a covered lane that descends into the heart of Fribourg. There, in front of the cathedral, three busy roads meet to form a roundabout. I continue my walk along the south side of the cathedral. Cars continue to stream down the road. Now that the roundabout is no longer in view, I cannot know by which route each car has entered it. In order to arrive alongside me, as it does now, this car could have taken three possible paths. I have put myself, in relation to the cars, in a situation of indistinguishability. Well then, why is the road network not a quantum interferometer? The answer is a matter of common sense – the indistinguishability of cars is only apparent, it is due to an ignorance that can easily be overcome. In order to obtain the information about the path by which each car entered the roundabout, it would suffice for me to go back a few paces or to ask the driver – neither of these steps would modify what the destination of the car will be.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 5, 2006•0 citations

The Quantum and the Random: Similarities, Differences, and “Contradictions”

Jan-Åke Larsson

This paper makes an attempt to present Quantum Mechanics in simple terms, but without oversimplification. It will be in essence, a comparison of the usual understanding of randomness to the more difficult notion of “quantumness.” The restricted format of this paper will unfortunately force the presentation to be very terse. But perhaps this paper can be seen as a synopsis of the approach I have in mind.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

Randomness in Classical Mechanics and Quantum Mechanics

Igor V. Volovich

arXiv:0910.5391•Foundations of Physics•Mar 25, 2010•34 citations

At The Heart Of The Problem

Valerio Scarani

Abstract ‘When all is said and done, physics is only a description, not an explanation’. I have uttered similar statements many times myself in informal discussions, when my interlocutor happened to slide into an excessive praise of experimental science and an excessive contempt of other forms of human knowledge. In the mouth of Jean-Paul Fragnière, a friend and philosophy teacher who lives in the small Swiss town of Fribourg, this sentence sounds, however, the expression of a different and distant line of thought of a rivalry between human and natural sciences that is still latent in the French-speaking world, a relic of the arrogance of Positivism. We are in the massive building of Saint-Michel College – a sixteenth century Jesuit establishment, a public school for several decades; and though Jean-Paul’s classroom is a modernization of what was the granary, history weighs heavily here. For the first generations of young people educated in this school, heliocentrism was one of the hot topics; now Jean-Paul has invited me to speak to his students about quantum physics.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 5, 2006•0 citations
Abstract During my first lecture at Saint-Michel College, I had sidestepped the question about randomness that the student had asked. As the reader will recall, it was the experiment of Fig. 1.1, as simple as it was, in which the particles arrived one after the other at a beam splitter. I had said that we do not know how to describe the behaviour of each particle, we do not know why a given particle is reflected rather than transmitted. Is it really uncertain, ran- dom (which is the current opinion among physicists) or is there a mechanism yet to be discovered? I had deliberately turned attention from this problem, in order to concentrate on the experiment of Fig. 1.3, the Mach–Zehnder interferometer. We have seen, then, that quantum randomness is a curious randomness – if we assemble two ‘randomness generators’ (beam splitters) in a certain way, we rediscover the certainty! I briefly remind the assembled students of this, a week later, in the old granary of the College.
Abstract During the lectures to the students in Fribourg, as with other people foreign to the world of physics, I have stated that my audience was driven to raise the same questions as the physicists: can we accept randomness in physical phenomena? Is interference determined by the mechanisms, and correlations at a distance by an exchange of information? In the presence of non-separability of physical properties, can we still talk about distinct entities? We feel the need to interpret quantum phenomena because we are not at ease with the indistinguishability principle and with some of its consequences. The unease comes from the fact that this principle, which appears to be omnipresent in the microscopic world, is unknown in everyday life and even seems to contradict our normal perceptions – the reader must recall the game with the sets of cars in Chapter 2. Seen from this point of view, the interpretations can be divided into three broad categories:
Abstract Now that we have explored qubits and the phenomenon of superposition, we can ask the question: how do we know that superposition actually happens? is the evidence that shows that a quantum particle really does exist in two different locations at this same time while in a quantum superposition? The nature of science means that experiments are constantly updating previous results, so are there other interpretations of the experimental results that can explain the data without the need for superposition? In this chapter we’ll explore the experimental evidence interpretations other than quantum superposition. Further, while a flipping coin is a simple model of a qubit, it is not very useful for building a quantum computer because it does not exhibit all of the properties of a true quantum superposition. For example, we cannot manipulate the superposition amplitudes. In this chapter, we will study some real physical examples of quantum particles in a superposition containing two states. These examples include a photon in a beam splitter and the Mach–Zehnder interferometer.
Abstract Leaving Saint-Michel, I take my leave of Jean-Paul who is going home, and I turn left to walk down the College Steps, a covered lane that descends into the heart of Fribourg. There, in front of the cathedral, three busy roads meet to form a roundabout. I continue my walk along the south side of the cathedral. Cars continue to stream down the road. Now that the roundabout is no longer in view, I cannot know by which route each car has entered it. In order to arrive alongside me, as it does now, this car could have taken three possible paths. I have put myself, in relation to the cars, in a situation of indistinguishability. Well then, why is the road network not a quantum interferometer? The answer is a matter of common sense – the indistinguishability of cars is only apparent, it is due to an ignorance that can easily be overcome. In order to obtain the information about the path by which each car entered the roundabout, it would suffice for me to go back a few paces or to ask the driver – neither of these steps would modify what the destination of the car will be.
Abstract ‘When all is said and done, physics is only a description, not an explanation’. I have uttered similar statements many times myself in informal discussions, when my interlocutor happened to slide into an excessive praise of experimental science and an excessive contempt of other forms of human knowledge. In the mouth of Jean-Paul Fragnière, a friend and philosophy teacher who lives in the small Swiss town of Fribourg, this sentence sounds, however, the expression of a different and distant line of thought of a rivalry between human and natural sciences that is still latent in the French-speaking world, a relic of the arrogance of Positivism. We are in the massive building of Saint-Michel College – a sixteenth century Jesuit establishment, a public school for several decades; and though Jean-Paul’s classroom is a modernization of what was the granary, history weighs heavily here. For the first generations of young people educated in this school, heliocentrism was one of the hot topics; now Jean-Paul has invited me to speak to his students about quantum physics.