Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

At The Heart Of The Problem

Valerio Scarani

Published Jan 5, 2006• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract ‘When all is said and done, physics is only a description, not an explanation’. I have uttered similar statements many times myself in informal discussions, when my interlocutor happened to slide into an excessive praise of experimental science and an excessive contempt of other forms of human knowledge. In the mouth of Jean-Paul Fragnière, a friend and philosophy teacher who lives in the small Swiss town of Fribourg, this sentence sounds, however, the expression of a different and distant line of thought of a rivalry between human and natural sciences that is still latent in the French-speaking world, a relic of the arrogance of Positivism. We are in the massive building of Saint-Michel College – a sixteenth century Jesuit establishment, a public school for several decades; and though Jean-Paul’s classroom is a modernization of what was the granary, history weighs heavily here. For the first generations of young people educated in this school, heliocentrism was one of the hot topics; now Jean-Paul has invited me to speak to his students about quantum physics.

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780198570479.003.0001

Related papers

Could Feynman have said this? May 2004

N. David Mermin

Fifteen years ago, I mused in a Reference Frame column on how different generations of physicists differed in the degree to which they thought that the interpretation of quantum mechanics remains a serious problem. I declared myself to be among those who feel uncomfortable when asked to articulate what we really think about the quantum theory, adding that “If I were forced to sum up in one sentence what the Copenhagen interpretation says to me, it would be ‘Shut up and calculate!’”

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 5, 2016•0 citations

A tale of two theories

Oliver Linton

It has occurred to me that there is a striking parallel between the current debate on the multiple interpretations of quantum mechanics, and the arguments that raged over the astronomical theories of the solar system, nearly 400 years ago.

Physics World•Apr 1, 2019•0 citations

Let’S Step Back

Valerio Scarani

Abstract Leaving Saint-Michel, I take my leave of Jean-Paul who is going home, and I turn left to walk down the College Steps, a covered lane that descends into the heart of Fribourg. There, in front of the cathedral, three busy roads meet to form a roundabout. I continue my walk along the south side of the cathedral. Cars continue to stream down the road. Now that the roundabout is no longer in view, I cannot know by which route each car has entered it. In order to arrive alongside me, as it does now, this car could have taken three possible paths. I have put myself, in relation to the cars, in a situation of indistinguishability. Well then, why is the road network not a quantum interferometer? The answer is a matter of common sense – the indistinguishability of cars is only apparent, it is due to an ignorance that can easily be overcome. In order to obtain the information about the path by which each car entered the roundabout, it would suffice for me to go back a few paces or to ask the driver – neither of these steps would modify what the destination of the car will be.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 5, 2006•0 citations

Epilogue

Malcolm S. Longair

As expected when I started out on this project, this has proved to be a complex and, at times, difficult story. After all, what was involved was tearing up the foundations of classical physics, which had been extraordinarily successful in explaining the macroscopic world about us, and replacing it by something radically different and non-intuitive in terms of our everyday experience. But the effort involved has been more than repaid by the very much deeper appreciation I have gained of the extraordinary works of the pioneers of quantum mechanics, both the theorists and the experimenters. If the brilliant theoretical researches of Planck, Einstein, Bohr, Heisenberg, Born, Jordan, Schrödinger, Pauli, Dirac and many others form the central core of this story, it should be remembered that their researches were inspired by the equally brilliant achievements of experimental physics. Another huge bonus has been a deepened understanding of quantum mechanics itself – if only I had these insights more than 50 years ago when I first encountered the subject.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 31, 2013•0 citations

The Quantum Zoo: A Tourist's Guide to the Neverending Universe

Marcus Chown

The two towering achievements of modern physics are quantum theory and Einstein's general theory of relativity. Together, they explain virtually everything about the world we live in. But, almost a century after their advent, most people haven&#39t the slightest clue what either is about. Did you know that there's so much empty space inside matter that the entire human race could be squeezed into the volume of a sugar cube? Or that you grow old more quickly on the top floor of a building than on the ground floor? And did you realize that 1% of the static on a TV tuned between stations is the relic of the Big Bang? These and many other remarkable facts about the world are direct consequences of quantum physics and relativity. Quantum theory has literally made the modern world possible. Not only has it given us lasers, computers, and nuclear reactors, but it has provided an explanation of why the sun shines and why the ground beneath our feet is solid. Despite this, however, quantum theory and relativity remain a patchwork of fragmented ideas, vaguely understood at best and often utterly mysterious. They have even gained a reputation of being beyond the understanding of the average person. Author Marcus Chown emphatically disagrees. As Einstein himself said, Most of the fundamental ideas of science are essentially simple and may, as a rule, be expressed in a language comprehensible to everyone. If you think that the marvels of modern physics have passed you by, it is not too late. In Chown's capable hands, quantum physics and relativity are not only painless but downright fun. So sit back, relax, and get comfortable as an adept and experienced science communicator brings you quickly up to speed on some of the greatest ideas in the history of human thought.

•Mar 15, 2006•1 citation

Prologue

Jim Baggott, John L. Heilbron

Abstract Our drama deals with the distinctly human compulsion to divide the world into domains of experience, like religion and physics, defined by rules and expectations. Fundamentalists pursue the illusory goal of a final theory of everything belonging to a domain. Their aim is closure – to declare that no plausible alternatives are possible. Neils Bohr sought to close the domain of quantum mechanics within a few years of its discovery. Albert Einstein objected to this hasty surrender of the possibility of alternatives more in keeping with classical intuition. Bohr’s efforts to achieve closure in the face of Einstein’s attempts to prise it open framed one of the most dramatic debates of twentieth-century science, and led to experimental discoveries that deepened the mystery and may yet profoundly impact our lives.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 25, 2024•0 citations
Abstract ‘When all is said and done, physics is only a description, not an explanation’. I have uttered similar statements many times myself in informal discussions, when my interlocutor happened to slide into an excessive praise of experimental science and an excessive contempt of other forms of human knowledge. In the mouth of Jean-Paul Fragnière, a friend and philosophy teacher who lives in the small Swiss town of Fribourg, this sentence sounds, however, the expression of a different and distant line of thought of a rivalry between human and natural sciences that is still latent in the French-speaking world, a relic of the arrogance of Positivism. We are in the massive building of Saint-Michel College – a sixteenth century Jesuit establishment, a public school for several decades; and though Jean-Paul’s classroom is a modernization of what was the granary, history weighs heavily here. For the first generations of young people educated in this school, heliocentrism was one of the hot topics; now Jean-Paul has invited me to speak to his students about quantum physics.
Abstract Leaving Saint-Michel, I take my leave of Jean-Paul who is going home, and I turn left to walk down the College Steps, a covered lane that descends into the heart of Fribourg. There, in front of the cathedral, three busy roads meet to form a roundabout. I continue my walk along the south side of the cathedral. Cars continue to stream down the road. Now that the roundabout is no longer in view, I cannot know by which route each car has entered it. In order to arrive alongside me, as it does now, this car could have taken three possible paths. I have put myself, in relation to the cars, in a situation of indistinguishability. Well then, why is the road network not a quantum interferometer? The answer is a matter of common sense – the indistinguishability of cars is only apparent, it is due to an ignorance that can easily be overcome. In order to obtain the information about the path by which each car entered the roundabout, it would suffice for me to go back a few paces or to ask the driver – neither of these steps would modify what the destination of the car will be.
As expected when I started out on this project, this has proved to be a complex and, at times, difficult story. After all, what was involved was tearing up the foundations of classical physics, which had been extraordinarily successful in explaining the macroscopic world about us, and replacing it by something radically different and non-intuitive in terms of our everyday experience. But the effort involved has been more than repaid by the very much deeper appreciation I have gained of the extraordinary works of the pioneers of quantum mechanics, both the theorists and the experimenters. If the brilliant theoretical researches of Planck, Einstein, Bohr, Heisenberg, Born, Jordan, Schrödinger, Pauli, Dirac and many others form the central core of this story, it should be remembered that their researches were inspired by the equally brilliant achievements of experimental physics. Another huge bonus has been a deepened understanding of quantum mechanics itself – if only I had these insights more than 50 years ago when I first encountered the subject.
The two towering achievements of modern physics are quantum theory and Einstein's general theory of relativity. Together, they explain virtually everything about the world we live in. But, almost a century after their advent, most people haven&#39t the slightest clue what either is about. Did you know that there's so much empty space inside matter that the entire human race could be squeezed into the volume of a sugar cube? Or that you grow old more quickly on the top floor of a building than on the ground floor? And did you realize that 1% of the static on a TV tuned between stations is the relic of the Big Bang? These and many other remarkable facts about the world are direct consequences of quantum physics and relativity. Quantum theory has literally made the modern world possible. Not only has it given us lasers, computers, and nuclear reactors, but it has provided an explanation of why the sun shines and why the ground beneath our feet is solid. Despite this, however, quantum theory and relativity remain a patchwork of fragmented ideas, vaguely understood at best and often utterly mysterious. They have even gained a reputation of being beyond the understanding of the average person. Author Marcus Chown emphatically disagrees. As Einstein himself said, Most of the fundamental ideas of science are essentially simple and may, as a rule, be expressed in a language comprehensible to everyone. If you think that the marvels of modern physics have passed you by, it is not too late. In Chown's capable hands, quantum physics and relativity are not only painless but downright fun. So sit back, relax, and get comfortable as an adept and experienced science communicator brings you quickly up to speed on some of the greatest ideas in the history of human thought.
Abstract Our drama deals with the distinctly human compulsion to divide the world into domains of experience, like religion and physics, defined by rules and expectations. Fundamentalists pursue the illusory goal of a final theory of everything belonging to a domain. Their aim is closure – to declare that no plausible alternatives are possible. Neils Bohr sought to close the domain of quantum mechanics within a few years of its discovery. Albert Einstein objected to this hasty surrender of the possibility of alternatives more in keeping with classical intuition. Bohr’s efforts to achieve closure in the face of Einstein’s attempts to prise it open framed one of the most dramatic debates of twentieth-century science, and led to experimental discoveries that deepened the mystery and may yet profoundly impact our lives.