Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Over Any Distance In “No Time”: Bell’s Theorem And The Aspect And Gisin Experiments

Robert L. Nadeau, Menas C. Kafatos

Published Dec 2, 1999• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract The great debate between Bohr and Einstein began at the fifth Solvay Congress in 1927 and continued intermittently until Einstein’s death in 1955. The argument took the form of thought experiments in which Einstein would try to demonstrate that it was theoretically possible to measure, or at least determine precise values for, two complementary constructs in quantum physics, like position and momentum, simultaneously. Bohr would then respond with a careful analysis of the conditions and results in Einstein’s thought experiments and demonstrate that there were fundamental ambiguities he had failed to resolve. Although both men would have despised the use of the term, Bohr was the winner on all counts. Eventually, the dialogue revolved around the issue of realism, and it is this issue that Einstein felt would decide the correctness of quantum theory.

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780195132564.003.0004

Related papers

The Debate between Einstein and Bohr, or How to Interpret Quantum Mechanics

P. Marage, Grégoire Wallenborn

The famous debate between Einstein and Bohr began at the Solvay Council in 1927. The debate was about the interpretation of quantum mechanics, but also addressed the fundamental question of what the purpose and aim of a physical theory should be. Their conflicting positions were based on two diametrically opposed philosophical approaches to the fundamental problems of physics. The many books popularising quantum mechanics quite rightly place the emphasis on the problem of interpretation: they discuss the opposing positions of Einstein’s “realism” and the “Copenhagen interpretation” of which Bohr is seen as the leading protagonist.

Birkhäuser Basel eBooks•Jan 1, 1999•5 citations

EPR and Bell Theorem

Muhammad Suhail Zubairy

The first round of the Einstein–Bohr debates took place when Einstein challenged Bohr’s principle of complementarity at the Solvay conference in 1927 and Bohr successfully defended it. The most serious challenge, however, came in 1935 when a paper by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) argued that quantum mechanics was incomplete through a gedanken experiment motivating an approach based on hidden variables. In this chapter, EPR’s arguments about the incompleteness of quantum mechanics and Bohr’s reply to them are presented. The ultimate answer came almost 30 years later, almost ten years after Einstein’s death, and was nothing that Einstein would have expected. Bell’s inequality and the subsequent Bell-CHSH inequality, that are satisfied by all theories based on the “self-evident truths” of reality and locality are discussed. The startling results that quantum mechanics violates Bell’s inequality and the experimental results are in agreement with the prediction of quantum mechanics are presented.

Oxford University Press eBooks•May 7, 2020•0 citations

Incompatible Conceptions

Jim Baggott, John L. Heilbron

Abstract Einstein was not in the audience at Bohr’s Como lecture, and their debate was joined in earnest at the fifth Solvay conference in Brussels in October 1927. All of quantum theory’s founders were present. Einstein excused himself for not having mastered the theory, and introduced a simple electron diffraction thought experiment for which he offered two conceptions. In the first, the wavefunction does not describe individual events and is purely statistical. In the second, the wavefunction does describe individual events, its modulus-square giving the probability of detecting the next diffracted electron at a specific position. In his view, the second conception could not stand, as it implies a ‘very peculiar mechanism of action at a distance’. Outside the conference room Einstein peppered Bohr with thought experiments devised to reveal the theory’s confusions or contradictions. The exchanges between them went on like a game of chess, with Bohr emerging the victor.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 25, 2024•0 citations

Is reality really real?

Muhammad Suhail Zubairy

Abstract The first round of the Einstein–Bohr debates took place when Einstein challenged Bohr’s principle of complementarity at the Solvay conference in 1927 and Bohr successfully defended it. The most serious challenge, however, came in 1935 through a paper by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) when they argued about the incompleteness of quantum mechanics through a gedanken experiment motivating an approach based on hidden variables. In this chapter, the EPR argument about the incompleteness of quantum mechanics and Bohr’s reply to it, are presented. The ultimate answer came almost 30 years later, almost ten years after Einstein’s death, and the answer was nothing what Einstein would have expected. Bell’s inequality and the subsequent Bell–CHSH inequality, that are satisfied by all theories based on the “self-evident truths” of reality and locality are discussed. The startling result that quantum mechanics violates Bell’s inequality and that the experimental results are in agreement with the prediction of quantum mechanics is presented.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations

Beyond the Bohr–Einstein debate

Guido Bacciagaluppi, Antony Valentini

The fifth Solvay conference is usually remembered for the clash that took place between Bohr and Einstein, supposedly concerning in particular the possibility of breaking the uncertainty relations. It might be assumed that this clash took the form of an official debate that was the centrepiece of the conference. However, no record of any such debate appears in the published proceedings, where both Bohr and Einstein are in fact relatively silent.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Oct 22, 2009•0 citations

Introduction to Quantum Information and Quantum Computing

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

When Einstein died, his greatest rival, Bohr, found for him words of moving admiration. When a few years later Bohr in turn died, someone took a photograph of the blackboard in his study. There's a drawing on it. A drawing of the ‘light-filled box’ in Einstein's thought experiment. To the very last, the desire to challenge oneself and understand more. And to the very last: doubt. —Carlo Rovelli In this chapter we shall study how quantum entanglement is tested in a laboratory experiment, and how it empowers us to boost computing powers to unprecedented levels. We develop our notion of reality from our day-to-day experiences. Quantum theory is largely counterintuitive because it conflicts with our naïve and untutored perceptions of position and momentum. It accounts for physical events in the universe with enduring cogency; but it demands reconciliation with the principle of uncertainty and a consequent statistical description of nature. Quantum theory has impacted science, technology, and also human lifestyle, notwithstanding the fact that relations such as Eq. 1.105 (Chapter 1) and Eq. 3.3 (Chapter 3) characterize quantum theory as essentially probabilistic . Einstein's famous quote “ God does not play dice ” grossly undervalues his unease, and also his insight, in quantum physics. Bohr's proverbial response “ it is not your job to tell God what to do ,” on the other hand, underscores not just his confidence in quantum theory but also his extraordinary insight in an exhaustive discernment of the laws of nature. The previous ten chapters are inspired by the triumph of quantum mechanics. In the present chapter, we revisit a few elements of the Bohr–Einstein deliberations and also the works of John Bell three decades later, which provided a methodology, based on which experiments could be performed to obtain clarity on the probability conundrum in quantum theory. In the meantime, intellectual churning over half a century since the Bohr–Einstein debates led to a deeper understanding of the principle of superposition and entanglement . The Bohr–Einstein debates immortalized the fifth Solvay conference held in 1927 [1], but continued through subsequent years, with two major publications in 1935 – one by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen [2], and the other by Bohr [3] – providing major landmarks. In-depth analysis of the works triggered by Einstein and Bohr, and later by John Bell [4], has now emerged as a robust cornerstone of quantum information science and quantum computing, heralding the second quantum revolution.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•3 citations
Abstract The great debate between Bohr and Einstein began at the fifth Solvay Congress in 1927 and continued intermittently until Einstein’s death in 1955. The argument took the form of thought experiments in which Einstein would try to demonstrate that it was theoretically possible to measure, or at least determine precise values for, two complementary constructs in quantum physics, like position and momentum, simultaneously. Bohr would then respond with a careful analysis of the conditions and results in Einstein’s thought experiments and demonstrate that there were fundamental ambiguities he had failed to resolve. Although both men would have despised the use of the term, Bohr was the winner on all counts. Eventually, the dialogue revolved around the issue of realism, and it is this issue that Einstein felt would decide the correctness of quantum theory.
The famous debate between Einstein and Bohr began at the Solvay Council in 1927. The debate was about the interpretation of quantum mechanics, but also addressed the fundamental question of what the purpose and aim of a physical theory should be. Their conflicting positions were based on two diametrically opposed philosophical approaches to the fundamental problems of physics. The many books popularising quantum mechanics quite rightly place the emphasis on the problem of interpretation: they discuss the opposing positions of Einstein’s “realism” and the “Copenhagen interpretation” of which Bohr is seen as the leading protagonist.
The first round of the Einstein–Bohr debates took place when Einstein challenged Bohr’s principle of complementarity at the Solvay conference in 1927 and Bohr successfully defended it. The most serious challenge, however, came in 1935 when a paper by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) argued that quantum mechanics was incomplete through a gedanken experiment motivating an approach based on hidden variables. In this chapter, EPR’s arguments about the incompleteness of quantum mechanics and Bohr’s reply to them are presented. The ultimate answer came almost 30 years later, almost ten years after Einstein’s death, and was nothing that Einstein would have expected. Bell’s inequality and the subsequent Bell-CHSH inequality, that are satisfied by all theories based on the “self-evident truths” of reality and locality are discussed. The startling results that quantum mechanics violates Bell’s inequality and the experimental results are in agreement with the prediction of quantum mechanics are presented.
Abstract Einstein was not in the audience at Bohr’s Como lecture, and their debate was joined in earnest at the fifth Solvay conference in Brussels in October 1927. All of quantum theory’s founders were present. Einstein excused himself for not having mastered the theory, and introduced a simple electron diffraction thought experiment for which he offered two conceptions. In the first, the wavefunction does not describe individual events and is purely statistical. In the second, the wavefunction does describe individual events, its modulus-square giving the probability of detecting the next diffracted electron at a specific position. In his view, the second conception could not stand, as it implies a ‘very peculiar mechanism of action at a distance’. Outside the conference room Einstein peppered Bohr with thought experiments devised to reveal the theory’s confusions or contradictions. The exchanges between them went on like a game of chess, with Bohr emerging the victor.
Abstract The first round of the Einstein–Bohr debates took place when Einstein challenged Bohr’s principle of complementarity at the Solvay conference in 1927 and Bohr successfully defended it. The most serious challenge, however, came in 1935 through a paper by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) when they argued about the incompleteness of quantum mechanics through a gedanken experiment motivating an approach based on hidden variables. In this chapter, the EPR argument about the incompleteness of quantum mechanics and Bohr’s reply to it, are presented. The ultimate answer came almost 30 years later, almost ten years after Einstein’s death, and the answer was nothing what Einstein would have expected. Bell’s inequality and the subsequent Bell–CHSH inequality, that are satisfied by all theories based on the “self-evident truths” of reality and locality are discussed. The startling result that quantum mechanics violates Bell’s inequality and that the experimental results are in agreement with the prediction of quantum mechanics is presented.
When Einstein died, his greatest rival, Bohr, found for him words of moving admiration. When a few years later Bohr in turn died, someone took a photograph of the blackboard in his study. There's a drawing on it. A drawing of the ‘light-filled box’ in Einstein's thought experiment. To the very last, the desire to challenge oneself and understand more. And to the very last: doubt. —Carlo Rovelli In this chapter we shall study how quantum entanglement is tested in a laboratory experiment, and how it empowers us to boost computing powers to unprecedented levels. We develop our notion of reality from our day-to-day experiences. Quantum theory is largely counterintuitive because it conflicts with our naïve and untutored perceptions of position and momentum. It accounts for physical events in the universe with enduring cogency; but it demands reconciliation with the principle of uncertainty and a consequent statistical description of nature. Quantum theory has impacted science, technology, and also human lifestyle, notwithstanding the fact that relations such as Eq. 1.105 (Chapter 1) and Eq. 3.3 (Chapter 3) characterize quantum theory as essentially probabilistic . Einstein's famous quote “ God does not play dice ” grossly undervalues his unease, and also his insight, in quantum physics. Bohr's proverbial response “ it is not your job to tell God what to do ,” on the other hand, underscores not just his confidence in quantum theory but also his extraordinary insight in an exhaustive discernment of the laws of nature. The previous ten chapters are inspired by the triumph of quantum mechanics. In the present chapter, we revisit a few elements of the Bohr–Einstein deliberations and also the works of John Bell three decades later, which provided a methodology, based on which experiments could be performed to obtain clarity on the probability conundrum in quantum theory. In the meantime, intellectual churning over half a century since the Bohr–Einstein debates led to a deeper understanding of the principle of superposition and entanglement . The Bohr–Einstein debates immortalized the fifth Solvay conference held in 1927 [1], but continued through subsequent years, with two major publications in 1935 – one by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen [2], and the other by Bohr [3] – providing major landmarks. In-depth analysis of the works triggered by Einstein and Bohr, and later by John Bell [4], has now emerged as a robust cornerstone of quantum information science and quantum computing, heralding the second quantum revolution.