Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Space, Time, and the Quantum

Published Mar 25, 2004• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract I thought today that I would stress the positive side of quantum theory. We began our meeting with the principle of skepticism. In order to be skeptical of something, first you must notice it. It’s very hard to be skeptical of things you do not notice. The hardest part of each dramatic change that has occurred in physics since 1600 has been to become aware of the assumptions of the old theory that had to be given up. The most confusing state of affairs is during the early days of a new theory, when you still cling to some of the old assumptions, and yet some re- wards of the new theory are attracting you further. I used to think of 1924, the year in which Heisenberg discovered the quantum theory, as a kind of abyss, a Grand Canyon, separating the old physics from the new, or a desert separating two fertile regions. But this is too symmetric. The two sides of an abyss are on the same level. The two sides of a desert are symmetric in respect to each other.

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780195159943.003.0004

Related papers

Quantum rules

Jim Baggott

Abstract The development of quantum theory was driven by a consistently repeated failure of classical physics to accommodate the results of ever more sophisticated experiments on the microphysical world of radiation, elementary particles, atoms, and molecules. Each break-through in the development of the theory’s conceptual structure was followed (sometimes very rapidly) by new experimental data that just did not fit, pointing to the need for yet further refinements. As is typical in such a radical change in the approach to acquiring scientific understanding, old and often unsuitable concepts were forced into service to meet the needs of the new description. Confusion reigned. The major figures in the theory’s early development took up radically different positions on the theory’s interpretation, and, as we will see, the debate became polarized in ways that remain relevant today.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Nov 6, 2003•0 citations

The Mysterious “Land” of Quantum Physics

Zohar Maliniak

Physics is the human attempt to discover the unchanging laws of the universe. Since the Greek thinkers 2,000 years ago, every now and then there have been changes in the physical laws that scientists once thought were unchangeable. These are times when humans discover a new “land,” in which unexpected phenomena challenge and contradict current thinking. About 120 years ago, one of the biggest of these changes revealed a new and exciting land—a land that we are still exploring today. In this article, I will describe some of the strange phenomena of this new land, called quantum physics, and how it forced us to change the way we think about the world in terms of energy, scientific measurements, and the reality of the objects around us. As no one—even the best physicists in the world—knows exactly what it really means, I will leave it to you to decide!

Frontiers for Young Minds•Jul 7, 2023•0 citations

Skepticism of quantum computing

Scott Aaronson

Last chapter, we talked about whether quantum states should be thought of as exponentially long vectors, and I brought up class BQP/qpoly and concepts like quantum advice. Actually, I’d say that the main reason why I care is something I didn't mention last time, which is that it relates to whether we should expect quantum computing to be fundamentally possible or not. There are people, like Leonid Levin and Oded Goldreich, who just take it as obvious that quantum computing must be impossible. Part of their argument is that it's extravagant to imagine a world where describing the state of 200 particles takes more bits then there are particles in the universe. To them, this is a clear indication something is going to break down. So part of the reason that I like to study the power of quantum proofs and quantum advice is that it helps us answer the question of whether we really should think of a quantum state as encoding an exponential amount of information.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 14, 2013•1 citation

Investigating the World, Pondering the Mind

Abstract I think of the development of physics as the growth of relativism. Every increase in relativism is an increase in our understanding of the complexity of the observer, of a number of possible observers, and of the influence of the observer upon the phenomenon. Quantum theory is only the latest stage in this growth of relativism. It is by no means the end of our understanding of the importance of the observer or the experimenter. In fact, I think it’s no longer proper to speak of the observer because that still carries the old implication of someone who observes from outside the phenomenon without changing it. In quantum theory we only have experimenters, people who do things. One of the lessons of relativism is that one should be very careful about assuming the existence of things that in principle cannot be seen. Evidently one of these things is the universe. It’s a physical impossibility, as a matter of principle, for any experimenter to have complete information about the universe. Every experimenter begins by ignoring large parts of the universe, namely, himself or herself. You turn your attention to something by omitting from your attention much more. It is quite possible that the universe will go the way of absolute time or absolute state. I don’t think we have reached the end of this growth in relativism.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 25, 2004•0 citations

Structure of the quantum world

Roger Penrose

Abstract Quantum theory provides a superb description of physical reality on a small scale, yet it contains many mysteries. Without doubt, it is hard to come to terms with the workings of this theory, and it is particularly difficult to make sense of the kind of ‘physical reality’—or lack of it—that it seems to imply for our world. Taken at its face value, the theory seems to lead to a philosophical standpoint that many (including myself) find deeply unsatisfying. At best, and taking its descriptions at their most literal, it provides us with a very strange view of the world indeed. At worst, and taking literally the proclamations of some of its most famous protagonists, it provides us with no view of the world at all.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Aug 22, 1996•1 citation

Fundamental considerations inspired by quantum physics

Anton Zeilinger

I have been interested in quantum mechanics or, synonymously, quantum physics since the very days when I first learned about them as a student. The initial impression was that of an immense mathematical beauty of the formalism of quantum mechanics. The second impression was the fantastic agreement of the theoretical predictions of quantum physics for experiments, and the third and somewhat surprising impression was that there was widespread disagreement about the interpretation of the new theory.

Libreria Editrice Vaticana eBooks•Dec 3, 2025•0 citations
Abstract I thought today that I would stress the positive side of quantum theory. We began our meeting with the principle of skepticism. In order to be skeptical of something, first you must notice it. It’s very hard to be skeptical of things you do not notice. The hardest part of each dramatic change that has occurred in physics since 1600 has been to become aware of the assumptions of the old theory that had to be given up. The most confusing state of affairs is during the early days of a new theory, when you still cling to some of the old assumptions, and yet some re- wards of the new theory are attracting you further. I used to think of 1924, the year in which Heisenberg discovered the quantum theory, as a kind of abyss, a Grand Canyon, separating the old physics from the new, or a desert separating two fertile regions. But this is too symmetric. The two sides of an abyss are on the same level. The two sides of a desert are symmetric in respect to each other.
Abstract The development of quantum theory was driven by a consistently repeated failure of classical physics to accommodate the results of ever more sophisticated experiments on the microphysical world of radiation, elementary particles, atoms, and molecules. Each break-through in the development of the theory’s conceptual structure was followed (sometimes very rapidly) by new experimental data that just did not fit, pointing to the need for yet further refinements. As is typical in such a radical change in the approach to acquiring scientific understanding, old and often unsuitable concepts were forced into service to meet the needs of the new description. Confusion reigned. The major figures in the theory’s early development took up radically different positions on the theory’s interpretation, and, as we will see, the debate became polarized in ways that remain relevant today.
Physics is the human attempt to discover the unchanging laws of the universe. Since the Greek thinkers 2,000 years ago, every now and then there have been changes in the physical laws that scientists once thought were unchangeable. These are times when humans discover a new “land,” in which unexpected phenomena challenge and contradict current thinking. About 120 years ago, one of the biggest of these changes revealed a new and exciting land—a land that we are still exploring today. In this article, I will describe some of the strange phenomena of this new land, called quantum physics, and how it forced us to change the way we think about the world in terms of energy, scientific measurements, and the reality of the objects around us. As no one—even the best physicists in the world—knows exactly what it really means, I will leave it to you to decide!
Last chapter, we talked about whether quantum states should be thought of as exponentially long vectors, and I brought up class BQP/qpoly and concepts like quantum advice. Actually, I’d say that the main reason why I care is something I didn't mention last time, which is that it relates to whether we should expect quantum computing to be fundamentally possible or not. There are people, like Leonid Levin and Oded Goldreich, who just take it as obvious that quantum computing must be impossible. Part of their argument is that it's extravagant to imagine a world where describing the state of 200 particles takes more bits then there are particles in the universe. To them, this is a clear indication something is going to break down. So part of the reason that I like to study the power of quantum proofs and quantum advice is that it helps us answer the question of whether we really should think of a quantum state as encoding an exponential amount of information.
Abstract I think of the development of physics as the growth of relativism. Every increase in relativism is an increase in our understanding of the complexity of the observer, of a number of possible observers, and of the influence of the observer upon the phenomenon. Quantum theory is only the latest stage in this growth of relativism. It is by no means the end of our understanding of the importance of the observer or the experimenter. In fact, I think it’s no longer proper to speak of the observer because that still carries the old implication of someone who observes from outside the phenomenon without changing it. In quantum theory we only have experimenters, people who do things. One of the lessons of relativism is that one should be very careful about assuming the existence of things that in principle cannot be seen. Evidently one of these things is the universe. It’s a physical impossibility, as a matter of principle, for any experimenter to have complete information about the universe. Every experimenter begins by ignoring large parts of the universe, namely, himself or herself. You turn your attention to something by omitting from your attention much more. It is quite possible that the universe will go the way of absolute time or absolute state. I don’t think we have reached the end of this growth in relativism.
Abstract Quantum theory provides a superb description of physical reality on a small scale, yet it contains many mysteries. Without doubt, it is hard to come to terms with the workings of this theory, and it is particularly difficult to make sense of the kind of ‘physical reality’—or lack of it—that it seems to imply for our world. Taken at its face value, the theory seems to lead to a philosophical standpoint that many (including myself) find deeply unsatisfying. At best, and taking its descriptions at their most literal, it provides us with a very strange view of the world indeed. At worst, and taking literally the proclamations of some of its most famous protagonists, it provides us with no view of the world at all.
I have been interested in quantum mechanics or, synonymously, quantum physics since the very days when I first learned about them as a student. The initial impression was that of an immense mathematical beauty of the formalism of quantum mechanics. The second impression was the fantastic agreement of the theoretical predictions of quantum physics for experiments, and the third and somewhat surprising impression was that there was widespread disagreement about the interpretation of the new theory.