I have been interested in quantum mechanics or, synonymously, quantum physics since the very days when I first learned about them as a student. The initial impression was that of an immense mathematical beauty of the formalism of quantum mechanics. The second impression was the fantastic agreement of the theoretical predictions of quantum physics for experiments, and the third and somewhat surprising impression was that there was widespread disagreement about the interpretation of the new theory.
I have been interested in quantum mechanics or, synonymously, quantum physics since the very days when I first learned about them as a student. The initial impression was that of an immense mathematical beauty of the formalism of quantum mechanics. The second impression was the fantastic agreement of the theoretical predictions of quantum physics for experiments, and the third and somewhat surprising impression was that there was widespread disagreement about the interpretation of the new theory.
Recent years have seen increased interest towards quantum physics education research, and the topic has been studied from many perspectives both empirically and theoretically. The consensus of previous studies has been that the theory poses an exceptional challenge for learning and teaching, warranting more attention and further research. This dissertation aims to contribute to this discussion by asking what the underlying reasons for these challenges are and how they could potentially be alleviated. On one hand, the topic is approached from an interpretational point of view, considering the ontological foundations of the theory. It is argued that many of the fundamental difficulties in learning and teaching quantum mechanics stem from the ontological foundations of the theory. On the other hand, the historical development and the mathematical structure of the theory are discussed from an educational point of view. The dissertation consists of five articles that explore the above themes from different perspectives. The first study considers the development of one historical formulation of quantum mechanics, namely matrix mechanics. In general, the historical development of quantum theory has been complex and meandering, and its results may seem confusing to students. In our study, we discuss the use of matrix mechanics in quantum mechanics instruction to provide students with a clearer picture of the theory, its historical development, and the relations between its various formulations and used formalisms. The second and third studies add to the discussion on the roles of mathematics in physics and physics education. In quantum mechanics, the role of mathematics is especially pronounced, as the understanding of the theory heavily relies on its mathematical framework. Therefore, we argue that the focus of quantum mechanics instruction should be shifted away from calculational aspects to a more integrated approach that treats the conceptual and mathematical sides of the theory intertwined. In our studies, we provide an overview of the roles assigned to mathematics in previous physics education research literature and present our own layered characterisation of the roles, aiming at diversifying the discussion on the roles of mathematics within the physics education research community and in physics instruction. The fourth and fifth studies empirically examine the challenges of quantum mechanics instruction in the context of an introductory quantum mechanics course. In the fourth study, we explore the effect of initial mathematics knowledge and self-efficacy on student learning, while in the fifth study, we consider the effects of the instructional approach and different teaching strategies on student conceptual knowledge and self-efficacy. The specific focus is on the impact of implementing a new instructional approach, the so-called spin first approach, that emphasises the mathematical basis and conceptual understanding of the theory instead of repeated mathematical calculations. Our results show that the spin-first approach, combined with an active learning model, is able to foster a high level of student self-efficacy and conceptual learning. Quantum mechanics is one of the most successful theories in the history of physics. Nevertheless, learning and teaching its basic principles continue to pose significant challenges for both instructors and students. In this dissertation, we argue for an approach to teaching the theory that places greater emphasis on its mathematical foundations and treats physics and mathematics as intertwined disciplines.
When investigating various interpretations of quantum mechanics one notices that each interpretation contains an element which escapes a complete and full description. This element is always associated with the stochasticity of the individual event in the quantum measurement process. It appears that the implications of this limit to any description of the world has not been sufficiently appreciated with notable exceptions of, for example, Heisenberg, Pauli and Wheeler. If we assume that a deeper foundation of quantum mechanics is possible, the question arises which features such a philosophical foundation might have. It is suggested that the objective randomness of the individual quantum event is a necessity of a description of the world in view of the significant influence the observer in quantum mechanics has. It is also suggested that the austerity of the Copenhagen interpretation should serve as a guiding principle in a search for deeper understanding. In recent years, a significant increase of interest in the foundations of quantum mechanics can be observed. This increase is certainly related to the immense progress made during the last two decades in experiments with individual quantum systems. This technological progress has made it possible to really perform more and more of the famous gedanken experiments which were so important in the early days of the theory. Not only did these experiments confirm the theory in every detail, they also opened up avenues for new experimental directions which might even lead some day to new technology. While such applications are certainly still far away, areas like quantum cryptography[1], quantum computation[2] and interaction-free measurement[3], just to name a few examples, certainly deserve the attention they receive. All this activity has also drawn more attention to the problems of understanding and interpreting quantum mechanics. It seems that there, a definitive consensus has not yet been reached. As witnesses quote authorities like Feynman as saying[4]: I think can safely say that nobody today understands quantum mechanics, whereby he apparently included himself, or like Roger Penrose[5], who describes his opinion remarking that while the theory agrees incredibly well with experiment and while it is of profound mathematical beauty, it makes absolutely no sense. Why did even physicists who have contributed so significantly to quantum theory Feynman was even rewarded the Nobel Prize for one of its mathematical formulations choose such emphatic and strong formulations? Why is it that the average physicist hears very little about such problems during his/her education? Why is the comprehension of the theory very often focused on formalism while questions that probe for deeper meaning are usually not tackled? To take a closer look at the situation, let us turn to a brief analysis of the interpretation of quantum mechanics. We note that there are at least two levels of interpreting a formalism, a physical theory. The first, basic, level supplies the rules that determine which element of the formalism corresponds to which measurable quantity or to which observable fact in a concrete experimental situation. Theses rules are a large, mostly not explicated but only implicit, set of instructions. These instructions concern the manner of working with the statements of the theory in order to obtain predictions for future experiments or events, and they concern the instructions on how to proceed in experiment in order to demonstrate or test a theoretical
Abstract It can easily be argued that a fully mature and complete knowledge of quantum mechanics should include historical, axiomatic, formal mathematical, and even philosophical background to the subject. However, for a student approaching quantum theory for the first time in a serious way, it can be the case that an approach utilizing his or her existing knowledge of, and intuition for, classical physics (including mechanics, wave physics, and electricity and magnetism) as well as emphasizing connections to experimental results can be the most pro- ductive. That, at least, is the point of view adopted in this text and can be illustrated by a focus on the following general topics:
In a period when a limited domain of physical phenomena is exciting wide fervent interest and commanding intensive study, and continues for years to monopolize the attention of many brilliant theorists, sometimes it is the fortune of an ingenious mind to express or interpret or picture the already-discovered laws in a new way which makes so greatly favourable an impression, that in a moment it sweeps its rivals from the field. The new theory may not lead to more or better agreements with experience than did its predecessors; it need not make predictions which they were incapable of making; its mathematical processes may be identical with theirs, the old symbols reappearing with new names in the old equations. Contrariwise it may be born well endowed with these advantages which normally decide the contest between old theories and new, yet owe its victory not to them at all. It triumphs because it seems natural or sensible or reasonable or elegant or beautiful-words said of a theory which fulfils some deep-seated demand or evades some deep-rooted prejudice in the minds of its judges. Later its vogue may pass, not through the disclosure of any intrinsic defect, but because the physicists of the rising generation do not share the prejudices and the predilections of those who first applauded it. The kinetic theory of gases was welcomed by a generation which wished to believe in atoms; the electromagnetic theory by people prejudiced against the notion of action at a distance; the quantum-theory has always had to do battle against those who yearn for continuity in their images of Nature, and the theory to which these pages are devoted has captivated the world of physics in a few brief months because it seems to promise a fulfilment of that long-baffled and insuppressible desire.