Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Proceedings of the Steklov Institute of Mathematics

Some Controllable and Uncontrollable Degenerate Four-Level Quantum Systems

Anastasia Aleksandrovna Myachkova, Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen

Published Jun 1, 2023• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract We analyze the controllability of three quantum systems that belong to a specific class of four-level quantum systems with twice degenerate highest excited energy level and with forbidden transition between the two remaining non-degenerate levels. For this purpose we perform numerical computation, construct the dynamical Lie algebras generated by all commutators of the free and interaction Hamiltonians, and show that two quantum systems are irreducible and controllable while the third system is reducible and hence uncontrollable. The reducibility and uncontrollability are proved by constructing a conserved Hermitian operator (physical quantity). The controllability is proved by constructing the dynamical Lie algebra and showing that it has maximal rank. These findings indicate that depending on the values of certain particular matrix entries of the interaction Hamiltonian, quantum systems in the class under consideration can be either uncontrollable or controllable.

DOI
10.1134/s0081543823020165

Related papers

On Controllability of $$\boldsymbol{\Lambda}$$- and $$\mathbf{V}$$-Atoms and Other Three-Level Systems with Two Allowed Transitions

Sergei A. Kuznetsov, Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen

A three-level $$\Lambda$$ -atom (resp., $$V$$ -atom) is a three-level quantum system with a forbidden direct transition between the two lowest (resp., highest) energy states. These systems are particular examples of three-level systems with only two allowed transitions and are important in quantum optics, e.g., for modeling electromagnetically induced transparency, etc. For generality, we consider not only $$\Lambda$$ - and $$V$$ -atoms, but all other types of three-level systems with only two allowed transitions between basis states. For the most general case of arbitrary non-zero complex values of the interaction Hamiltonian, we combine in a unified way the description of the structure of the dynamical Lie algebra as well as controllability properties for such systems. It turns out that for non-degenerate transition frequencies the system is completely controllable for any non-zero interaction Hamiltonian, while for the degenerate case the system is either uncontrollable or controllable, depending on the exact values of matrix elements of the free and interaction Hamiltonians.

Lobachevskii Journal of Mathematics•Jun 1, 2023•8 citations

A complete classification of operator controllability for closed three-level quantum systems driven by a single control

Sergey Kuznetsov, Alexander Pechen

In this work, we study operator controllability of finite-dimensional closed quantum systems driven by a single coherent control. Two general Lie-algebraic results on controllability of such systems are proved. The first gives sufficient conditions under which controllability of the system is preserved when controlled energy-level shifts are added. The second gives a sufficient basis-element condition under which the dynamical Lie algebra contains $\mathfrak{su}(N)$ and the system is therefore operator controllable. These results, together with known controllability conditions, are applied to obtain a complete classification of operator controllability of all three-level quantum systems in terms of their free and interaction Hamiltonian matrix elements. This classification covers all combinations of energy-level and level-spacing degeneracies, two or three allowed transitions, as well as the presence or absence of controlled energy-level shifts, and gives necessary and sufficient conditions for operator controllability in each case.

quant-pharXiv:2610.14938•Oct 13, 2026•1 citation

Uncontrollable quantum systems: A classification scheme based on Lie subalgebras

Thomas Polack, Haim Suchowski, David J. Tannor

It is well known that a finite level quantum system is controllable if and only if the Lie algebra of its generators has full rank. When the rank of the Lie algebra is not full, there is a rich mathematical and physical structure to the subalgebra that to date has been analyzed only in special cases. We show that uncontrollable systems can be classified into reducible and irreducible ones. The irreducible class is the more subtle and can be related to a notion of generalized entanglement. We give a general prescription for revealing irreducible uncontrollable systems: the fundamental representation of $\text{su}(N)$, where $N$ is the number of levels, must remain irreducible in the subalgebra of $\text{su}(N)$. We illustrate the concepts with a variety of physical examples.

Physical Review A•May 6, 2009•39 citations

On Controllability of a Highly Degenerate Four-Level Quantum System with a ‘‘Chained’’ Coupling Hamiltonian

Sergey Kuznetsov, Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen

Abstract Last decades have faced considerable interest in various problems of quantum control. One of them is to determine which quantum systems are controllable, meaning that all possible states of such systems can be reached from any initial one under available controls. This paper focuses on controllability exploration of a specific four-level quantum system with three levels having the same energy and driven by an electromagnetic control field which allows transitions only between adjacent basis states. Such systems appear in the analysis of higher order traps in quantum control landscapes. This paper explores a few properties of the system, including a proof it is completely controllable for any complex values of the non-zero matrix elements of the interaction Hamiltonian.

Lobachevskii Journal of Mathematics•Jul 1, 2022•4 citations

Quantifying State Space Accessibility through Operator Commutation Relations

Revista, Zen, PHYSICS, 10

The ability to navigate and control the state space of a quantum system is fundamental to quantum computing, quantum information processing, and advanced spectroscopy. This paper explores a rigorous mathematical framework for quantifying state space accessibility by leveraging the theory of operator commutation relations, particularly within the context of Lie algebras. We demonstrate that the span of iterated commutators of system Hamiltonians and control operators forms a dynamical Lie algebra, whose dimension and structure directly dictate the reachable states and unitary transformations. For closed quantum systems, the Lie algebra rank condition provides a powerful criterion for complete controllability, asserting that if the dynamical Lie algebra spans the entire space of anti-Hermitian operators, then any state can be reached from any other, and any unitary operation can be implemented. For open quantum systems, while environmental interactions introduce decoherence and dissipation, the Lie algebraic approach can still offer insights into the attainable subspaces and the limits of control, often involving Lie semigroups and Lie wedges. We present methods to analyze the accessibility of both pure and mixed states, illustrating how the algebraic properties encoded in commutation relations provide a precise measure of the manipulability of quantum systems. The implications extend to the design of robust quantum control protocols, optimized state preparation, and the development of error-resilient quantum technologies.

•Nov 28, 2025•0 citations

Dynamical invariants for quantum control of four-level systems

Utkan Güngördü, Yidun Wan, M. A. Fasihi +1 more

We present a Lie-algebraic classification and detailed construction of the dynamical invariants, also known as Lewis-Riesenfeld invariants, of the four-level systems including two-qubit systems which are most relevant and sufficiently general for quantum control and computation. These invariants not only solve the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation of four-level systems exactly but also enable the control, and hence quantum computation based on which, of four-level systems fast and beyond adiabatic regimes.

arXiv:1205.3034•Physical Review A•Dec 14, 2012•48 citations
Abstract We analyze the controllability of three quantum systems that belong to a specific class of four-level quantum systems with twice degenerate highest excited energy level and with forbidden transition between the two remaining non-degenerate levels. For this purpose we perform numerical computation, construct the dynamical Lie algebras generated by all commutators of the free and interaction Hamiltonians, and show that two quantum systems are irreducible and controllable while the third system is reducible and hence uncontrollable. The reducibility and uncontrollability are proved by constructing a conserved Hermitian operator (physical quantity). The controllability is proved by constructing the dynamical Lie algebra and showing that it has maximal rank. These findings indicate that depending on the values of certain particular matrix entries of the interaction Hamiltonian, quantum systems in the class under consideration can be either uncontrollable or controllable.
On Controllability of Λ\boldsymbol{\Lambda}Λ- and V\mathbf{V}V-Atoms and Other Three-Level Systems with Two Allowed Transitions
A three-level Λ\LambdaΛ -atom (resp., VVV -atom) is a three-level quantum system with a forbidden direct transition between the two lowest (resp., highest) energy states. These systems are particular examples of three-level systems with only two allowed transitions and are important in quantum optics, e.g., for modeling electromagnetically induced transparency, etc. For generality, we consider not only Λ\LambdaΛ - and VVV -atoms, but all other types of three-level systems with only two allowed transitions between basis states. For the most general case of arbitrary non-zero complex values of the interaction Hamiltonian, we combine in a unified way the description of the structure of the dynamical Lie algebra as well as controllability properties for such systems. It turns out that for non-degenerate transition frequencies the system is completely controllable for any non-zero interaction Hamiltonian, while for the degenerate case the system is either uncontrollable or controllable, depending on the exact values of matrix elements of the free and interaction Hamiltonians.
In this work, we study operator controllability of finite-dimensional closed quantum systems driven by a single coherent control. Two general Lie-algebraic results on controllability of such systems are proved. The first gives sufficient conditions under which controllability of the system is preserved when controlled energy-level shifts are added. The second gives a sufficient basis-element condition under which the dynamical Lie algebra contains su(N)\mathfrak{su}(N)su(N) and the system is therefore operator controllable. These results, together with known controllability conditions, are applied to obtain a complete classification of operator controllability of all three-level quantum systems in terms of their free and interaction Hamiltonian matrix elements. This classification covers all combinations of energy-level and level-spacing degeneracies, two or three allowed transitions, as well as the presence or absence of controlled energy-level shifts, and gives necessary and sufficient conditions for operator controllability in each case.
It is well known that a finite level quantum system is controllable if and only if the Lie algebra of its generators has full rank. When the rank of the Lie algebra is not full, there is a rich mathematical and physical structure to the subalgebra that to date has been analyzed only in special cases. We show that uncontrollable systems can be classified into reducible and irreducible ones. The irreducible class is the more subtle and can be related to a notion of generalized entanglement. We give a general prescription for revealing irreducible uncontrollable systems: the fundamental representation of su(N)\text{su}(N)su(N), where NNN is the number of levels, must remain irreducible in the subalgebra of su(N)\text{su}(N)su(N). We illustrate the concepts with a variety of physical examples.
Abstract Last decades have faced considerable interest in various problems of quantum control. One of them is to determine which quantum systems are controllable, meaning that all possible states of such systems can be reached from any initial one under available controls. This paper focuses on controllability exploration of a specific four-level quantum system with three levels having the same energy and driven by an electromagnetic control field which allows transitions only between adjacent basis states. Such systems appear in the analysis of higher order traps in quantum control landscapes. This paper explores a few properties of the system, including a proof it is completely controllable for any complex values of the non-zero matrix elements of the interaction Hamiltonian.
The ability to navigate and control the state space of a quantum system is fundamental to quantum computing, quantum information processing, and advanced spectroscopy. This paper explores a rigorous mathematical framework for quantifying state space accessibility by leveraging the theory of operator commutation relations, particularly within the context of Lie algebras. We demonstrate that the span of iterated commutators of system Hamiltonians and control operators forms a dynamical Lie algebra, whose dimension and structure directly dictate the reachable states and unitary transformations. For closed quantum systems, the Lie algebra rank condition provides a powerful criterion for complete controllability, asserting that if the dynamical Lie algebra spans the entire space of anti-Hermitian operators, then any state can be reached from any other, and any unitary operation can be implemented. For open quantum systems, while environmental interactions introduce decoherence and dissipation, the Lie algebraic approach can still offer insights into the attainable subspaces and the limits of control, often involving Lie semigroups and Lie wedges. We present methods to analyze the accessibility of both pure and mixed states, illustrating how the algebraic properties encoded in commutation relations provide a precise measure of the manipulability of quantum systems. The implications extend to the design of robust quantum control protocols, optimized state preparation, and the development of error-resilient quantum technologies.
We present a Lie-algebraic classification and detailed construction of the dynamical invariants, also known as Lewis-Riesenfeld invariants, of the four-level systems including two-qubit systems which are most relevant and sufficiently general for quantum control and computation. These invariants not only solve the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation of four-level systems exactly but also enable the control, and hence quantum computation based on which, of four-level systems fast and beyond adiabatic regimes.