Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.14938

A complete classification of operator controllability for closed three-level quantum systems driven by a single control

Sergey Kuznetsov, Alexander Pechen

quant-phSubmitted Oct 10, 2026• Announced Oct 13, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this work, we study operator controllability of finite-dimensional closed quantum systems driven by a single coherent control. Two general Lie-algebraic results on controllability of such systems are proved. The first gives sufficient conditions under which controllability of the system is preserved when controlled energy-level shifts are added. The second gives a sufficient basis-element condition under which the dynamical Lie algebra contains $\mathfrak{su}(N)$ and the system is therefore operator controllable. These results, together with known controllability conditions, are applied to obtain a complete classification of operator controllability of all three-level quantum systems in terms of their free and interaction Hamiltonian matrix elements. This classification covers all combinations of energy-level and level-spacing degeneracies, two or three allowed transitions, as well as the presence or absence of controlled energy-level shifts, and gives necessary and sufficient conditions for operator controllability in each case.

AI Summary

The paper asks when a closed three-level system driven by one real coherent control, $H+f(t)V$, can implement every unitary up to global phase. It gives necessary and sufficient conditions in terms of Hamiltonian matrix elements, covering energy and transition-frequency degeneracies, two or three allowed transitions, and arbitrary control-induced diagonal shifts. For a connected transition graph, systems with distinct nonzero transition frequencies are controllable. With three distinct equally spaced energies, three allowed transitions always give controllability. With only the two adjacent transitions, controllability holds exactly when their coupling magnitudes differ or the diagonal shifts are not equally spaced. For two degenerate energies, a two-transition system is controllable unless both transitions connect the degenerate pair to the third level and the pair has equal diagonal shifts. With three transitions and $E_i=E_j$, noncontrollability occurs exactly when $r=v_{ij}/(v_{ik}v_{kj})$ is real and $r(|v_{kj}|^2-|v_{ik}|^2)=v_j-v_i$. Disconnected graphs and scalar drift Hamiltonians are uncontrollable. The proofs use dynamical Lie-algebra generation, explicit commutators, and invertible coefficient matrices. Two general sufficient results establish preservation of controllability under specified additions of diagonal shifts, and generation of $\mathfrak{su}(N)$ from a connected graph of available basis elements with both quadratures on at least one edge. Counterexamples show why the shift-preservation assumptions cannot simply be dropped. The complete classification is restricted to closed three-level systems with a single control; admissible controls are assumed to include piecewise-constant functions. It concerns reachability, not control synthesis or implementation resources.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncremental

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Controllability Aspects of Quantum Dynamics: A Unified Approach for Closed and Open Systems

I. Kurniawan, Gunther Dirr, Uwe Helmke

Knowledge about to what extent quantum dynamical systems can be steered by coherent controls is indispensable for future developments in quantum technology. The purpose of this paper is to analyze such controllability aspects for finite dimensional bilinear quantum control systems. We use a unified approach based on Lie-algebraic methods from nonlinear control theory to revisit known and to establish new results for closed and open quantum systems. In particular, we provide a simplified characterization of different notions of controllability for closed quantum systems described by the Liouville-von Neumann equation. We derive new necessary and sufficient conditions for accessibility of open quantum systems modelled by the Lindblad-Kossakowski master equation. To this end, we exploit a well-studied topic of differential geometry, namely the classification of all matrix Lie-groups which act transitively on the Grassmann manifold or the punctured Euclidean space. For the special case of coupled spin-1/2 systems, we obtain a remarkably simple characterization of accessibility. These accessibility results correct and refine previous statements in the quantum control literature.

IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control•Jul 19, 2012•33 citations

Calculations of the controllability Lie algebra for spin quantum systems

Wang Men

Controllability of dynamical systems is a fundamental problem for both classical control as well as quantum control.This paper focuses on investigating the controllability Lie algebra of single-spin and two spin quantum systems.Firstly,based on the equivalent controllability conditions of quantum systems,some general necessary and sufficient conditions related to the basis coefficients are obtained by computing Lie brackets of Hamiltonian operators for single-spin quantum systems.Secondly,the matrix basis of Lie algebra su(4) is generated by Cartan decomposition.Using the matrix basis and employing the controllability theorem of quantum system,a calculation method of multiple Lie brackets for the Hamiltonian operators and a controllability criterion of quantum systems are also put forward in this article.

Control theory & applications•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

On Controllability of $$\boldsymbol{\Lambda}$$- and $$\mathbf{V}$$-Atoms and Other Three-Level Systems with Two Allowed Transitions

Sergei A. Kuznetsov, Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen

A three-level $$\Lambda$$ -atom (resp., $$V$$ -atom) is a three-level quantum system with a forbidden direct transition between the two lowest (resp., highest) energy states. These systems are particular examples of three-level systems with only two allowed transitions and are important in quantum optics, e.g., for modeling electromagnetically induced transparency, etc. For generality, we consider not only $$\Lambda$$ - and $$V$$ -atoms, but all other types of three-level systems with only two allowed transitions between basis states. For the most general case of arbitrary non-zero complex values of the interaction Hamiltonian, we combine in a unified way the description of the structure of the dynamical Lie algebra as well as controllability properties for such systems. It turns out that for non-degenerate transition frequencies the system is completely controllable for any non-zero interaction Hamiltonian, while for the degenerate case the system is either uncontrollable or controllable, depending on the exact values of matrix elements of the free and interaction Hamiltonians.

Lobachevskii Journal of Mathematics•Jun 1, 2023•8 citations

Some Controllable and Uncontrollable Degenerate Four-Level Quantum Systems

Anastasia Aleksandrovna Myachkova, Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen

Abstract We analyze the controllability of three quantum systems that belong to a specific class of four-level quantum systems with twice degenerate highest excited energy level and with forbidden transition between the two remaining non-degenerate levels. For this purpose we perform numerical computation, construct the dynamical Lie algebras generated by all commutators of the free and interaction Hamiltonians, and show that two quantum systems are irreducible and controllable while the third system is reducible and hence uncontrollable. The reducibility and uncontrollability are proved by constructing a conserved Hermitian operator (physical quantity). The controllability is proved by constructing the dynamical Lie algebra and showing that it has maximal rank. These findings indicate that depending on the values of certain particular matrix entries of the interaction Hamiltonian, quantum systems in the class under consideration can be either uncontrollable or controllable.

Proceedings of the Steklov Institute of Mathematics•Jun 1, 2023•3 citations

Geometric quantum control

J. W. Clark, TZYH JONG TARN, Dennis G. Lucarelli

The property of controllability of quantum systems is explored, and conditions for controllability based on Lie-algebraic properties are enunciated. Due consideration is given to the unbounded character of some of the operators that arise and to the generally noncompact nature of the operator algebras associated with the system. Results for both finite and infinite-dimensional systems are provided; in the latter case the results are not limited to cases having purely discrete spectra. The applicability of the results to systems with both bound and scattering states is demonstrated through examples, namely the Poschl-Teller potential and the repulsive radial oscillator, which reveal some of the subtleties of the controllability issue. Attention is also directed to transitivity of the pertinent Lie algebra of a system without drift as a necessary and sufficient condition for its controllability.

IEEE International Workshop on Workload Characterization (WWC)•Apr 23, 2004•3 citations

Identification of dynamical Lie algebras for finite-level quantum control systems

S G Schirmer, I C H Pullen, A. I. Solomon

The problem of identifying the dynamical Lie algebras of finite-level quantum systems subject to external control is considered, with special emphasis on systems that are not completely controllable. In particular, it is shown that the dynamical Lie algebra for an N -level system with symmetrically coupled transitions, such as a system with equally spaced energy levels and uniform transition dipole moments, is a subalgebra of so ( N ) if N = 2ℓ + 1, and a subalgebra of sp(ℓ) if N = 2ℓ. General criteria for obtaining either so (2ℓ + 1) or sp (ℓ) are established.

arXiv:quant-ph/0203104•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Feb 25, 2002•28 citations
In this work, we study operator controllability of finite-dimensional closed quantum systems driven by a single coherent control. Two general Lie-algebraic results on controllability of such systems are proved. The first gives sufficient conditions under which controllability of the system is preserved when controlled energy-level shifts are added. The second gives a sufficient basis-element condition under which the dynamical Lie algebra contains su(N)\mathfrak{su}(N)su(N) and the system is therefore operator controllable. These results, together with known controllability conditions, are applied to obtain a complete classification of operator controllability of all three-level quantum systems in terms of their free and interaction Hamiltonian matrix elements. This classification covers all combinations of energy-level and level-spacing degeneracies, two or three allowed transitions, as well as the presence or absence of controlled energy-level shifts, and gives necessary and sufficient conditions for operator controllability in each case.
The paper asks when a closed three-level system driven by one real coherent control, H+f(t)VH+f(t)VH+f(t)V, can implement every unitary up to global phase. It gives necessary and sufficient conditions in terms of Hamiltonian matrix elements, covering energy and transition-frequency degeneracies, two or three allowed transitions, and arbitrary control-induced diagonal shifts.
For a connected transition graph, systems with distinct nonzero transition frequencies are controllable. With three distinct equally spaced energies, three allowed transitions always give controllability. With only the two adjacent transitions, controllability holds exactly when their coupling magnitudes differ or the diagonal shifts are not equally spaced. For two degenerate energies, a two-transition system is controllable unless both transitions connect the degenerate pair to the third level and the pair has equal diagonal shifts. With three transitions and Ei=EjE_i=E_jEi​=Ej​, noncontrollability occurs exactly when r=vij/(vikvkj)r=v_{ij}/(v_{ik}v_{kj})r=vij​/(vik​vkj​) is real and r(∣vkj∣2−∣vik∣2)=vj−vir(|v_{kj}|^2-|v_{ik}|^2)=v_j-v_ir(∣vkj​∣2−∣vik​∣2)=vj​−vi​. Disconnected graphs and scalar drift Hamiltonians are uncontrollable.
The proofs use dynamical Lie-algebra generation, explicit commutators, and invertible coefficient matrices. Two general sufficient results establish preservation of controllability under specified additions of diagonal shifts, and generation of su(N)\mathfrak{su}(N)su(N) from a connected graph of available basis elements with both quadratures on at least one edge. Counterexamples show why the shift-preservation assumptions cannot simply be dropped.
The complete classification is restricted to closed three-level systems with a single control; admissible controls are assumed to include piecewise-constant functions. It concerns reachability, not control synthesis or implementation resources.
Knowledge about to what extent quantum dynamical systems can be steered by coherent controls is indispensable for future developments in quantum technology. The purpose of this paper is to analyze such controllability aspects for finite dimensional bilinear quantum control systems. We use a unified approach based on Lie-algebraic methods from nonlinear control theory to revisit known and to establish new results for closed and open quantum systems. In particular, we provide a simplified characterization of different notions of controllability for closed quantum systems described by the Liouville-von Neumann equation. We derive new necessary and sufficient conditions for accessibility of open quantum systems modelled by the Lindblad-Kossakowski master equation. To this end, we exploit a well-studied topic of differential geometry, namely the classification of all matrix Lie-groups which act transitively on the Grassmann manifold or the punctured Euclidean space. For the special case of coupled spin-1/2 systems, we obtain a remarkably simple characterization of accessibility. These accessibility results correct and refine previous statements in the quantum control literature.
Controllability of dynamical systems is a fundamental problem for both classical control as well as quantum control.This paper focuses on investigating the controllability Lie algebra of single-spin and two spin quantum systems.Firstly,based on the equivalent controllability conditions of quantum systems,some general necessary and sufficient conditions related to the basis coefficients are obtained by computing Lie brackets of Hamiltonian operators for single-spin quantum systems.Secondly,the matrix basis of Lie algebra su(4) is generated by Cartan decomposition.Using the matrix basis and employing the controllability theorem of quantum system,a calculation method of multiple Lie brackets for the Hamiltonian operators and a controllability criterion of quantum systems are also put forward in this article.
On Controllability of Λ\boldsymbol{\Lambda}Λ- and V\mathbf{V}V-Atoms and Other Three-Level Systems with Two Allowed Transitions
A three-level Λ\LambdaΛ -atom (resp., VVV -atom) is a three-level quantum system with a forbidden direct transition between the two lowest (resp., highest) energy states. These systems are particular examples of three-level systems with only two allowed transitions and are important in quantum optics, e.g., for modeling electromagnetically induced transparency, etc. For generality, we consider not only Λ\LambdaΛ - and VVV -atoms, but all other types of three-level systems with only two allowed transitions between basis states. For the most general case of arbitrary non-zero complex values of the interaction Hamiltonian, we combine in a unified way the description of the structure of the dynamical Lie algebra as well as controllability properties for such systems. It turns out that for non-degenerate transition frequencies the system is completely controllable for any non-zero interaction Hamiltonian, while for the degenerate case the system is either uncontrollable or controllable, depending on the exact values of matrix elements of the free and interaction Hamiltonians.
Abstract We analyze the controllability of three quantum systems that belong to a specific class of four-level quantum systems with twice degenerate highest excited energy level and with forbidden transition between the two remaining non-degenerate levels. For this purpose we perform numerical computation, construct the dynamical Lie algebras generated by all commutators of the free and interaction Hamiltonians, and show that two quantum systems are irreducible and controllable while the third system is reducible and hence uncontrollable. The reducibility and uncontrollability are proved by constructing a conserved Hermitian operator (physical quantity). The controllability is proved by constructing the dynamical Lie algebra and showing that it has maximal rank. These findings indicate that depending on the values of certain particular matrix entries of the interaction Hamiltonian, quantum systems in the class under consideration can be either uncontrollable or controllable.
The property of controllability of quantum systems is explored, and conditions for controllability based on Lie-algebraic properties are enunciated. Due consideration is given to the unbounded character of some of the operators that arise and to the generally noncompact nature of the operator algebras associated with the system. Results for both finite and infinite-dimensional systems are provided; in the latter case the results are not limited to cases having purely discrete spectra. The applicability of the results to systems with both bound and scattering states is demonstrated through examples, namely the Poschl-Teller potential and the repulsive radial oscillator, which reveal some of the subtleties of the controllability issue. Attention is also directed to transitivity of the pertinent Lie algebra of a system without drift as a necessary and sufficient condition for its controllability.
The problem of identifying the dynamical Lie algebras of finite-level quantum systems subject to external control is considered, with special emphasis on systems that are not completely controllable. In particular, it is shown that the dynamical Lie algebra for an N -level system with symmetrically coupled transitions, such as a system with equally spaced energy levels and uniform transition dipole moments, is a subalgebra of so ( N ) if N = 2ℓ + 1, and a subalgebra of sp(ℓ) if N = 2ℓ. General criteria for obtaining either so (2ℓ + 1) or sp (ℓ) are established.