Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Universal Journal of Physics Research

Spin Structures and non-Relativistic Spin Operators

Plamen Neytchev Nechev

Published Aug 30, 2023• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In Quantum Physics, the spin and angular momentum operators are magnitudes introduced by means of a vector transformation law. However, interpreting the eigenvalues of its Z "components" as projections on said axis leads to certain contradictions supposedly avoided by a mandatory (presented as a freely selected) Z's orientation. It is shown that an oriented physical space almost forces us to project the angular momentum's and spin's eigenvalues onto its orientation's 3-form, which sidesteps entering into inconsistencies. The final conclusion is that this "rare" magnitude called spin, downright naturally comes in and plays thanks to the orientation of our three-dimensional space.

DOI
10.31586/ujpr.2023.664

Related papers

The exact meaning of the angular-momentum and spin operators in quantum mechanics

G. Coddens

The theory of angular momentum and spin in quantum mechanics seems to defy common-sense intuition.We render the theory intelligible again by pointing out that this apparent impenetrability merely stems from an {\em undue} parallel interpretation of the algebraic expressions for the angular-momentum and spin operators in the group representation theory of SO(3) and SU(2). E.g. the correct meaning of the quantumoperator ${\hat{L}}_{z} = {\hbar\over{\imath}}\,(x{\partial\over{\partial y}} - y{\partial\over{\partial x}} )$ is not that it is the operatorfor the $z$-component $L_{z}$ of the angular momentum ${\mathbf{L}}$, but rather the expression of the operator for the angular momentum ${\mathbf{L}}$ when it is aligned with the $z$-axis. Hence what we are used to note (erroneously) as ${\hat{L}}_{z}$ is not a scalar but a vector operator.The same applies{\em mutatis mutandis} for the spin operators. In the correct interpretation, the wholealgebraic formalism is just the group representation theory for the rotationsof three-dimensional Euclidean geometry. It is thus mere,elementary high-school mathematics (in a less usual, more technical guise) and as such totally exempt of any physics, let alone quantum mysteries.The change of interpretation has no impact on the algebraic results, such that they remain in agreement with experimental data and the algebra quantum mechanics remains correct. It is all only a matter of the correct geometrical meaning of the algebra.All these statements are proved within the framework of the group representation theory for SO(3) and SU(2) which is the basic tool used to describe rotational motion in quantum mechanics.

•Sep 11, 2021•0 citations

Quantum Theory of Angular Momentum

Ravinder Rupchand Puri

In Chapter 15, we showed that invariance under rotation in real three-dimensional position space transforms the state of a system by a unitary transformation generated by the operator which is the sum of the orbital angular momentum operator, and the spin operator which acts on the internal state of the system. The components of obey the same commutation relations as the corresponding components of. The eigenvalue problem of the orbital angular momentum has been solved in Chapter 14 by working in the position representation. We found that the eigenvalues of are where l = 0, 1, 2,…. However, acts on the internal state of the system and does not have position representative. Hence, for the systems having spin, we need to solve the eigenvalue problem of the angular momentum by invoking only the commutation relations between the components of, the task undertaken in this chapter. We will find that, like the orbital angular momentum, the eigenvalues of are also expressible in the form but, in addition to non-negative integral values, can be a half-odd positive integer. Thus, the spectrum of derived using the commutation relations turns out to be different from that obtained while working in position representation when permissible. This is unlike the case of harmonic oscillator for which the eigenvalues turn out to be same whether the oscillator problem is solved in the position representation (when permissible) or by using only the commutation relations between the harmonic oscillator operators.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 17, 2017•6 citations

Angular Momentum

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

In Chapter 1 we discussed the role of linear momentum as the generator of translational displacement in homogeneous space. Likewise, it is instructive to explore the role of angular momentum as the generator of rotational displacements in isotropic space. Not surprisingly, analogies drawn from classical physics are not adequate to describe physical particles and fields. One must therefore redefine angular momentum to describe appropriately the physical properties in nature by quantum mechanics. 4.1 Definition and Properties of Angular Momentu m Kepler orbits of planets around the sun signify our intuitive understanding of angular momentum of an object about a point (Fig. 4.1). It interprets angular momentum as moment of the momentum , expressed as the cross product of the position vector of an object with its instantaneous linear momentum. We recognize it to represent a physical quantity that is conserved in isotropic space. The classical definition of angular momentum is however not sustainable, and not just because simultaneous measurements of position and momentum are incompatible. Physical properties of particles and fields have properties that have no classical analogues. Quantum mechanics acknowledges the intrinsic incompatibility in observations of some physical properties and provides a defensible alternative theory to describe nature. We shall therefore be able to persist with the classical interpretation of angular momentum as the generator of rotation in isotropic space only up to a certain point of our analysis; beyond it, we shall require a worthier mathematical model that is robust enough to describe nature acceptably. We consider an object having an arbitrary shape and subject it to a rotation about an axis through it, such as the one schematically shown in Fig. 4.2a. On turning it through an infinitesimal angle, the shape transforms to. We denote the rotation by an operator and express this operation as With reference to a Cartesian coordinate system, a rotation relocates a point whose position vector is to (Fig. 4.2b): Equation 4.1 tells us that the function has the same value at the new orientation as the function, i.e., as, R being the operator corresponding to the said rotation. We shall refer to such a description of transformation of the function as active . In passive description, an equivalent inverse operation on the coordinate system is employed (Fig. 4.2c), leaving the function itself unchanged. The active and the passive descriptions are equivalent.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations

Whence spin?

Nicholas Zumbulyadis

Abstract The concept of angular momentum in quantum mechanics has many counterintuitive aspects, such as assuming only certain discrete values and only certain orientations in space in the presence of external fields. Spin is more esoteric yet; it is hard to imagine how point‐particles with no spatial extent can have an intrinsic angular momentum. Nevertheless, spin is the most fundamental concept in magnetic resonance. Appreciation of the spin concept requires some understanding of the relativistic quantum mechanics developed by P. A. M. Dirac. The history of the evolution of the spin concept is traced—from the turn‐of‐the‐century observation of the Zeeman effect, through the old and new quantum mechanics, and on to Dirac's theory of the electron, which was published in the late 1920s. The special relativity theory is discussed, and there is a brief explanation of how spin emerges naturally in a relativistically correct formulation of quantum mechanics.

Concepts in Magnetic Resonance•Apr 1, 1991•3 citations

Elementary introduction to the properties of angular momentum operators through three-dimensional rotations

C. Leubner

For pedagogical purposes it is demonstrated that with little effort the customary discussion of rotations in introductory courses can be extended to naturally produce a number of angular momentum operator properties, if coordinate-free rotation operators are used in their exponential form. This form gives rise to a particularly useful coordinate-free representation of the generators of rotations in three-space, from which the student can derive the usual angular momentum formalism for the case j=1 by elementary vector algebra alone. Since in this approach the j=1 formalism appears as a set of relations among simple geometric objects in ordinary space, it admits of a geometric interpretation and will leave the student better prepared for a more profound appreciation of the abstract concepts of the full theory.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1980•0 citations

Do spins have directions?

Diederik Aerts, Massimiliano Sassoli de Bianchi

The standard Bloch sphere representation has been recently generalized to describe not only systems of arbitrary dimension, but also their measurements, in what has been called the extended Bloch representation of quantum mechanics . This model, which offers a solution to the longstanding measurement problem, is based on the hidden-measurement interpretation of quantum mechanics , according to which the Born rule results from our lack of knowledge of the measurement interaction that each time is actualized between the measuring apparatus and the measured entity. In this article, we present the extended Bloch model and use it to investigate, more specifically, the nature of the quantum spin entities and of their relation to our three-dimensional Euclidean theater. Our analysis shows that spin eigenstates cannot generally be associated with directions in the Euclidean space, but only with generalized directions in the Blochean space, which apart from the special case of spin one-half entities, is a space of higher dimensionality. Accordingly, spin entities have to be considered as genuine non-spatial entities. We also show, however, that specific vectors can be identified in the Blochean theater that are isomorphic to the Euclidean space directions, and therefore representative of them, and that spin eigenstates always have a predetermined orientation with respect to them. We use the details of our results to put forward a new view of realism, that we call multiplex realism , providing a specific framework with which to interpret the human observations and understanding of the component parts of the world. Elements of reality can be represented in different theaters, one being our customary Euclidean space, and another one the quantum realm, revealed to us through our sophisticated experiments, whose elements of reality, in the quantum jargon, are the eigenvalues and eigenstates. Our understanding of the component parts of the world can then be guided by looking for the possible connections, in the form of partial morphisms, between the different representations, which is precisely what we do in this article with regard to spin entities.

arXiv:1501.00693•Soft Computing•Nov 4, 2015•27 citations
In Quantum Physics, the spin and angular momentum operators are magnitudes introduced by means of a vector transformation law. However, interpreting the eigenvalues of its Z "components" as projections on said axis leads to certain contradictions supposedly avoided by a mandatory (presented as a freely selected) Z's orientation. It is shown that an oriented physical space almost forces us to project the angular momentum's and spin's eigenvalues onto its orientation's 3-form, which sidesteps entering into inconsistencies. The final conclusion is that this "rare" magnitude called spin, downright naturally comes in and plays thanks to the orientation of our three-dimensional space.
The theory of angular momentum and spin in quantum mechanics seems to defy common-sense intuition.We render the theory intelligible again by pointing out that this apparent impenetrability merely stems from an {\em undue} parallel interpretation of the algebraic expressions for the angular-momentum and spin operators in the group representation theory of SO(3) and SU(2). E.g. the correct meaning of the quantumoperator L^z=ℏı (x∂∂y−y∂∂x){\hat{L}}_{z} = {\hbar\over{\imath}}\,(x{\partial\over{\partial y}} - y{\partial\over{\partial x}} )L^z​=ℏ​(x∂y∂​−y∂x∂​) is not that it is the operatorfor the zzz-component LzL_{z}Lz​ of the angular momentum L{\mathbf{L}}L, but rather the expression of the operator for the angular momentum L{\mathbf{L}}L when it is aligned with the zzz-axis. Hence what we are used to note (erroneously) as L^z{\hat{L}}_{z}L^z​ is not a scalar but a vector operator.The same applies{\em mutatis mutandis} for the spin operators. In the correct interpretation, the wholealgebraic formalism is just the group representation theory for the rotationsof three-dimensional Euclidean geometry. It is thus mere,elementary high-school mathematics (in a less usual, more technical guise) and as such totally exempt of any physics, let alone quantum mysteries.The change of interpretation has no impact on the algebraic results, such that they remain in agreement with experimental data and the algebra quantum mechanics remains correct. It is all only a matter of the correct geometrical meaning of the algebra.All these statements are proved within the framework of the group representation theory for SO(3) and SU(2) which is the basic tool used to describe rotational motion in quantum mechanics.
In Chapter 15, we showed that invariance under rotation in real three-dimensional position space transforms the state of a system by a unitary transformation generated by the operator which is the sum of the orbital angular momentum operator, and the spin operator which acts on the internal state of the system. The components of obey the same commutation relations as the corresponding components of. The eigenvalue problem of the orbital angular momentum has been solved in Chapter 14 by working in the position representation. We found that the eigenvalues of are where l = 0, 1, 2,…. However, acts on the internal state of the system and does not have position representative. Hence, for the systems having spin, we need to solve the eigenvalue problem of the angular momentum by invoking only the commutation relations between the components of, the task undertaken in this chapter. We will find that, like the orbital angular momentum, the eigenvalues of are also expressible in the form but, in addition to non-negative integral values, can be a half-odd positive integer. Thus, the spectrum of derived using the commutation relations turns out to be different from that obtained while working in position representation when permissible. This is unlike the case of harmonic oscillator for which the eigenvalues turn out to be same whether the oscillator problem is solved in the position representation (when permissible) or by using only the commutation relations between the harmonic oscillator operators.
In Chapter 1 we discussed the role of linear momentum as the generator of translational displacement in homogeneous space. Likewise, it is instructive to explore the role of angular momentum as the generator of rotational displacements in isotropic space. Not surprisingly, analogies drawn from classical physics are not adequate to describe physical particles and fields. One must therefore redefine angular momentum to describe appropriately the physical properties in nature by quantum mechanics. 4.1 Definition and Properties of Angular Momentu m Kepler orbits of planets around the sun signify our intuitive understanding of angular momentum of an object about a point (Fig. 4.1). It interprets angular momentum as moment of the momentum , expressed as the cross product of the position vector of an object with its instantaneous linear momentum. We recognize it to represent a physical quantity that is conserved in isotropic space. The classical definition of angular momentum is however not sustainable, and not just because simultaneous measurements of position and momentum are incompatible. Physical properties of particles and fields have properties that have no classical analogues. Quantum mechanics acknowledges the intrinsic incompatibility in observations of some physical properties and provides a defensible alternative theory to describe nature. We shall therefore be able to persist with the classical interpretation of angular momentum as the generator of rotation in isotropic space only up to a certain point of our analysis; beyond it, we shall require a worthier mathematical model that is robust enough to describe nature acceptably. We consider an object having an arbitrary shape and subject it to a rotation about an axis through it, such as the one schematically shown in Fig. 4.2a. On turning it through an infinitesimal angle, the shape transforms to. We denote the rotation by an operator and express this operation as With reference to a Cartesian coordinate system, a rotation relocates a point whose position vector is to (Fig. 4.2b): Equation 4.1 tells us that the function has the same value at the new orientation as the function, i.e., as, R being the operator corresponding to the said rotation. We shall refer to such a description of transformation of the function as active . In passive description, an equivalent inverse operation on the coordinate system is employed (Fig. 4.2c), leaving the function itself unchanged. The active and the passive descriptions are equivalent.
Abstract The concept of angular momentum in quantum mechanics has many counterintuitive aspects, such as assuming only certain discrete values and only certain orientations in space in the presence of external fields. Spin is more esoteric yet; it is hard to imagine how point‐particles with no spatial extent can have an intrinsic angular momentum. Nevertheless, spin is the most fundamental concept in magnetic resonance. Appreciation of the spin concept requires some understanding of the relativistic quantum mechanics developed by P. A. M. Dirac. The history of the evolution of the spin concept is traced—from the turn‐of‐the‐century observation of the Zeeman effect, through the old and new quantum mechanics, and on to Dirac's theory of the electron, which was published in the late 1920s. The special relativity theory is discussed, and there is a brief explanation of how spin emerges naturally in a relativistically correct formulation of quantum mechanics.
For pedagogical purposes it is demonstrated that with little effort the customary discussion of rotations in introductory courses can be extended to naturally produce a number of angular momentum operator properties, if coordinate-free rotation operators are used in their exponential form. This form gives rise to a particularly useful coordinate-free representation of the generators of rotations in three-space, from which the student can derive the usual angular momentum formalism for the case j=1 by elementary vector algebra alone. Since in this approach the j=1 formalism appears as a set of relations among simple geometric objects in ordinary space, it admits of a geometric interpretation and will leave the student better prepared for a more profound appreciation of the abstract concepts of the full theory.
The standard Bloch sphere representation has been recently generalized to describe not only systems of arbitrary dimension, but also their measurements, in what has been called the extended Bloch representation of quantum mechanics . This model, which offers a solution to the longstanding measurement problem, is based on the hidden-measurement interpretation of quantum mechanics , according to which the Born rule results from our lack of knowledge of the measurement interaction that each time is actualized between the measuring apparatus and the measured entity. In this article, we present the extended Bloch model and use it to investigate, more specifically, the nature of the quantum spin entities and of their relation to our three-dimensional Euclidean theater. Our analysis shows that spin eigenstates cannot generally be associated with directions in the Euclidean space, but only with generalized directions in the Blochean space, which apart from the special case of spin one-half entities, is a space of higher dimensionality. Accordingly, spin entities have to be considered as genuine non-spatial entities. We also show, however, that specific vectors can be identified in the Blochean theater that are isomorphic to the Euclidean space directions, and therefore representative of them, and that spin eigenstates always have a predetermined orientation with respect to them. We use the details of our results to put forward a new view of realism, that we call multiplex realism , providing a specific framework with which to interpret the human observations and understanding of the component parts of the world. Elements of reality can be represented in different theaters, one being our customary Euclidean space, and another one the quantum realm, revealed to us through our sophisticated experiments, whose elements of reality, in the quantum jargon, are the eigenvalues and eigenstates. Our understanding of the component parts of the world can then be guided by looking for the possible connections, in the form of partial morphisms, between the different representations, which is precisely what we do in this article with regard to spin entities.