Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The exact meaning of the angular-momentum and spin operators in quantum mechanics

G. Coddens

Published Sep 11, 2021• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

The theory of angular momentum and spin in quantum mechanics seems to defy common-sense intuition.We render the theory intelligible again by pointing out that this apparent impenetrability merely stems from an {\em undue} parallel interpretation of the algebraic expressions for the angular-momentum and spin operators in the group representation theory of SO(3) and SU(2). E.g. the correct meaning of the quantumoperator ${\hat{L}}_{z} = {\hbar\over{\imath}}\,(x{\partial\over{\partial y}} - y{\partial\over{\partial x}} )$ is not that it is the operatorfor the $z$-component $L_{z}$ of the angular momentum ${\mathbf{L}}$, but rather the expression of the operator for the angular momentum ${\mathbf{L}}$ when it is aligned with the $z$-axis. Hence what we are used to note (erroneously) as ${\hat{L}}_{z}$ is not a scalar but a vector operator.The same applies{\em mutatis mutandis} for the spin operators. In the correct interpretation, the wholealgebraic formalism is just the group representation theory for the rotationsof three-dimensional Euclidean geometry. It is thus mere,elementary high-school mathematics (in a less usual, more technical guise) and as such totally exempt of any physics, let alone quantum mysteries.The change of interpretation has no impact on the algebraic results, such that they remain in agreement with experimental data and the algebra quantum mechanics remains correct. It is all only a matter of the correct geometrical meaning of the algebra.All these statements are proved within the framework of the group representation theory for SO(3) and SU(2) which is the basic tool used to describe rotational motion in quantum mechanics.

Related papers

Orbital Angular Momentum

Reinhold A. Bertlmann, Nicolai Friis

Abstract In this chapter we introduce the concept of orbital angular momentum into the mathematical language of quantum mechanics. We discuss the commutation relations of the corresponding operators and their roles as generators of rotations in the context of the theory of Lie groups and Lie algebras, focusing on the three-dimensional rotation group SO(3). We further examine how scalar and vector-valued operators transform under spatial rotations. We then turn to the derivation of the eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of the angular-momentum operators, for which we follow a dual approach in analogy to that employed for the harmonic oscillator in Chapter 5. Using both the algebraic ladder-operator method and an analytical method using spherical polar coordinates we discover the relevant azimuthal and magnetic quantum numbers and their relation to the spherical harmonics and the Legendre polynomials

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 7, 2023•1 citation

Representation of rotations, angular momentum and spin

K. Heyde, John L. Wood

The various representations of rotations in physical space and Hilbert space are developed in detail. This leads to an in-depth treatment of the representation of states of well-defined spin and angular momentum in quantum systems. The peculiarities of the physics of spin— systems (spinors) is outlined. The tensorial character of representations is implicit in the treatment. The Schwinger and Bargmann representations are introduced in some detail; and this leads to SU(2) coherent states (which are important for more advanced group representation theory).

Institute of Physics eBooks•Apr 1, 2020•0 citations

Elementary introduction to the properties of angular momentum operators through three-dimensional rotations

C. Leubner

For pedagogical purposes it is demonstrated that with little effort the customary discussion of rotations in introductory courses can be extended to naturally produce a number of angular momentum operator properties, if coordinate-free rotation operators are used in their exponential form. This form gives rise to a particularly useful coordinate-free representation of the generators of rotations in three-space, from which the student can derive the usual angular momentum formalism for the case j=1 by elementary vector algebra alone. Since in this approach the j=1 formalism appears as a set of relations among simple geometric objects in ordinary space, it admits of a geometric interpretation and will leave the student better prepared for a more profound appreciation of the abstract concepts of the full theory.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1980•0 citations

Angular Momentum

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

In Chapter 1 we discussed the role of linear momentum as the generator of translational displacement in homogeneous space. Likewise, it is instructive to explore the role of angular momentum as the generator of rotational displacements in isotropic space. Not surprisingly, analogies drawn from classical physics are not adequate to describe physical particles and fields. One must therefore redefine angular momentum to describe appropriately the physical properties in nature by quantum mechanics. 4.1 Definition and Properties of Angular Momentu m Kepler orbits of planets around the sun signify our intuitive understanding of angular momentum of an object about a point (Fig. 4.1). It interprets angular momentum as moment of the momentum , expressed as the cross product of the position vector of an object with its instantaneous linear momentum. We recognize it to represent a physical quantity that is conserved in isotropic space. The classical definition of angular momentum is however not sustainable, and not just because simultaneous measurements of position and momentum are incompatible. Physical properties of particles and fields have properties that have no classical analogues. Quantum mechanics acknowledges the intrinsic incompatibility in observations of some physical properties and provides a defensible alternative theory to describe nature. We shall therefore be able to persist with the classical interpretation of angular momentum as the generator of rotation in isotropic space only up to a certain point of our analysis; beyond it, we shall require a worthier mathematical model that is robust enough to describe nature acceptably. We consider an object having an arbitrary shape and subject it to a rotation about an axis through it, such as the one schematically shown in Fig. 4.2a. On turning it through an infinitesimal angle, the shape transforms to. We denote the rotation by an operator and express this operation as With reference to a Cartesian coordinate system, a rotation relocates a point whose position vector is to (Fig. 4.2b): Equation 4.1 tells us that the function has the same value at the new orientation as the function, i.e., as, R being the operator corresponding to the said rotation. We shall refer to such a description of transformation of the function as active . In passive description, an equivalent inverse operation on the coordinate system is employed (Fig. 4.2c), leaving the function itself unchanged. The active and the passive descriptions are equivalent.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations

Angular Momentum

Tao Xiang

The angular momentum plays an important role in quantum mechanics. It is no longer an ordinary vector, instead it is a vector operator, whose three components do not commute with each other. In quantum mechanics, the angular momentum becomes a vector operator. A general angular momentum is defined as a vector operator whose components are Hermitian operators satisfying the commutation relations similar to those for the orbital angular momentum. In order to obtain the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions, it is more convenient to express the orbital angular momentum operators in spherical polar coordinates. Spin angular momentum is an intrinsic property of elementary particles. In quantum computing, a qubit or quantum bit is a quantum version of the classical binary bit physically realized in a two-state quantum-mechanical system.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 31, 2022•0 citations

Spin Structures and non-Relativistic Spin Operators

Plamen Neytchev Nechev

In Quantum Physics, the spin and angular momentum operators are magnitudes introduced by means of a vector transformation law. However, interpreting the eigenvalues of its Z "components" as projections on said axis leads to certain contradictions supposedly avoided by a mandatory (presented as a freely selected) Z's orientation. It is shown that an oriented physical space almost forces us to project the angular momentum's and spin's eigenvalues onto its orientation's 3-form, which sidesteps entering into inconsistencies. The final conclusion is that this "rare" magnitude called spin, downright naturally comes in and plays thanks to the orientation of our three-dimensional space.

Universal Journal of Physics Research•Aug 30, 2023•0 citations
The theory of angular momentum and spin in quantum mechanics seems to defy common-sense intuition.We render the theory intelligible again by pointing out that this apparent impenetrability merely stems from an {\em undue} parallel interpretation of the algebraic expressions for the angular-momentum and spin operators in the group representation theory of SO(3) and SU(2). E.g. the correct meaning of the quantumoperator L^z=ℏı (x∂∂y−y∂∂x){\hat{L}}_{z} = {\hbar\over{\imath}}\,(x{\partial\over{\partial y}} - y{\partial\over{\partial x}} )L^z​=ℏ​(x∂y∂​−y∂x∂​) is not that it is the operatorfor the zzz-component LzL_{z}Lz​ of the angular momentum L{\mathbf{L}}L, but rather the expression of the operator for the angular momentum L{\mathbf{L}}L when it is aligned with the zzz-axis. Hence what we are used to note (erroneously) as L^z{\hat{L}}_{z}L^z​ is not a scalar but a vector operator.The same applies{\em mutatis mutandis} for the spin operators. In the correct interpretation, the wholealgebraic formalism is just the group representation theory for the rotationsof three-dimensional Euclidean geometry. It is thus mere,elementary high-school mathematics (in a less usual, more technical guise) and as such totally exempt of any physics, let alone quantum mysteries.The change of interpretation has no impact on the algebraic results, such that they remain in agreement with experimental data and the algebra quantum mechanics remains correct. It is all only a matter of the correct geometrical meaning of the algebra.All these statements are proved within the framework of the group representation theory for SO(3) and SU(2) which is the basic tool used to describe rotational motion in quantum mechanics.
Abstract In this chapter we introduce the concept of orbital angular momentum into the mathematical language of quantum mechanics. We discuss the commutation relations of the corresponding operators and their roles as generators of rotations in the context of the theory of Lie groups and Lie algebras, focusing on the three-dimensional rotation group SO(3). We further examine how scalar and vector-valued operators transform under spatial rotations. We then turn to the derivation of the eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of the angular-momentum operators, for which we follow a dual approach in analogy to that employed for the harmonic oscillator in Chapter 5. Using both the algebraic ladder-operator method and an analytical method using spherical polar coordinates we discover the relevant azimuthal and magnetic quantum numbers and their relation to the spherical harmonics and the Legendre polynomials
The various representations of rotations in physical space and Hilbert space are developed in detail. This leads to an in-depth treatment of the representation of states of well-defined spin and angular momentum in quantum systems. The peculiarities of the physics of spin— systems (spinors) is outlined. The tensorial character of representations is implicit in the treatment. The Schwinger and Bargmann representations are introduced in some detail; and this leads to SU(2) coherent states (which are important for more advanced group representation theory).
For pedagogical purposes it is demonstrated that with little effort the customary discussion of rotations in introductory courses can be extended to naturally produce a number of angular momentum operator properties, if coordinate-free rotation operators are used in their exponential form. This form gives rise to a particularly useful coordinate-free representation of the generators of rotations in three-space, from which the student can derive the usual angular momentum formalism for the case j=1 by elementary vector algebra alone. Since in this approach the j=1 formalism appears as a set of relations among simple geometric objects in ordinary space, it admits of a geometric interpretation and will leave the student better prepared for a more profound appreciation of the abstract concepts of the full theory.
In Chapter 1 we discussed the role of linear momentum as the generator of translational displacement in homogeneous space. Likewise, it is instructive to explore the role of angular momentum as the generator of rotational displacements in isotropic space. Not surprisingly, analogies drawn from classical physics are not adequate to describe physical particles and fields. One must therefore redefine angular momentum to describe appropriately the physical properties in nature by quantum mechanics. 4.1 Definition and Properties of Angular Momentu m Kepler orbits of planets around the sun signify our intuitive understanding of angular momentum of an object about a point (Fig. 4.1). It interprets angular momentum as moment of the momentum , expressed as the cross product of the position vector of an object with its instantaneous linear momentum. We recognize it to represent a physical quantity that is conserved in isotropic space. The classical definition of angular momentum is however not sustainable, and not just because simultaneous measurements of position and momentum are incompatible. Physical properties of particles and fields have properties that have no classical analogues. Quantum mechanics acknowledges the intrinsic incompatibility in observations of some physical properties and provides a defensible alternative theory to describe nature. We shall therefore be able to persist with the classical interpretation of angular momentum as the generator of rotation in isotropic space only up to a certain point of our analysis; beyond it, we shall require a worthier mathematical model that is robust enough to describe nature acceptably. We consider an object having an arbitrary shape and subject it to a rotation about an axis through it, such as the one schematically shown in Fig. 4.2a. On turning it through an infinitesimal angle, the shape transforms to. We denote the rotation by an operator and express this operation as With reference to a Cartesian coordinate system, a rotation relocates a point whose position vector is to (Fig. 4.2b): Equation 4.1 tells us that the function has the same value at the new orientation as the function, i.e., as, R being the operator corresponding to the said rotation. We shall refer to such a description of transformation of the function as active . In passive description, an equivalent inverse operation on the coordinate system is employed (Fig. 4.2c), leaving the function itself unchanged. The active and the passive descriptions are equivalent.
The angular momentum plays an important role in quantum mechanics. It is no longer an ordinary vector, instead it is a vector operator, whose three components do not commute with each other. In quantum mechanics, the angular momentum becomes a vector operator. A general angular momentum is defined as a vector operator whose components are Hermitian operators satisfying the commutation relations similar to those for the orbital angular momentum. In order to obtain the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions, it is more convenient to express the orbital angular momentum operators in spherical polar coordinates. Spin angular momentum is an intrinsic property of elementary particles. In quantum computing, a qubit or quantum bit is a quantum version of the classical binary bit physically realized in a two-state quantum-mechanical system.
In Quantum Physics, the spin and angular momentum operators are magnitudes introduced by means of a vector transformation law. However, interpreting the eigenvalues of its Z "components" as projections on said axis leads to certain contradictions supposedly avoided by a mandatory (presented as a freely selected) Z's orientation. It is shown that an oriented physical space almost forces us to project the angular momentum's and spin's eigenvalues onto its orientation's 3-form, which sidesteps entering into inconsistencies. The final conclusion is that this "rare" magnitude called spin, downright naturally comes in and plays thanks to the orientation of our three-dimensional space.