One hundred years ago the physics that would be necessary to understand how quantum computers work, much less how to build them, did not exist. In the early 1920s electrons were viewed as tiny negatively charged particles—microscopically small spheres—with energies and locations within an atom that were well defined. In Niels Bohr’s Nobel-prize-winning atomic model, electrons moved in orbits around the nucleus with their energy and position both known with, to many scientists, reassuring certainty. Quantum computers rely for their operation on the uncertainty, the “weirdness”, that happens on the atomic scale and below.
One hundred years ago the physics that would be necessary to understand how quantum computers work, much less how to build them, did not exist. In the early 1920s electrons were viewed as tiny negatively charged particles—microscopically small spheres—with energies and locations within an atom that were well defined. In Niels Bohr’s Nobel-prize-winning atomic model, electrons moved in orbits around the nucleus with their energy and position both known with, to many scientists, reassuring certainty. Quantum computers rely for their operation on the uncertainty, the “weirdness”, that happens on the atomic scale and below.
The turn of the XXth century witnessed a revolution in physics comparable to Isaac Newton’s discovery of the universal laws of mechanics and of gravitation three centuries earlier. The world required to be described in novel terms, as the immutable, deterministic view of our familiar universe had given way to a new world picture, one which featured chance, flux, and an incessant upsurge of waves of matter. Such a worldview was so radically new and counterintuitive that it gave rise to strong debates, to the effect that Albert Einstein himself tried to oppose it on the grounds that “God does not play dice”. In spite of the intense debates that accompanied its emergence, quantum mechanics quickly proved an incredibly efficacious new tool to understand and to predict a wide array of new phenomena. It was so successful that in no time it broke free from the environment of research labs to become part of daily life, making it possible, for example, to understand why some materials were conductors, while others were insulators. Along with it, came, too, the discovery of transistors, on which much of modern electronics rests. It also led to understand how novel materials known as superconductors allow the transport of electricity with no loss, thus paving the way for new developments in the fields of medical imagery or energy distribution. Other aspects of the quantum theory led to the development of atomic clocks of astounding accuracy, which would be wrong by no more than fifteen seconds, had they been set at the beginning of the universe. A hundred years later, at the turn of the XXIst century, Quantum mechanics has lost none of its astounding power. Contemporary research has undertaken the task of exploring its less immediately perceptible aspects. Groundbreaking developments have ensued, such as the teleportation of grains of light or the possibility, once predicted by the great physicist Richard Feynman, to build, one day, novel computers which, unlike the ones we are familiar with today, will be able to process innumerable numbers of operations in parallel. The Wright Colloquium will be for us the occasion to explore, in the company of five internationallyknown specialists in the field, some of the fascinating aspects of quantum mechanics. We will appraise how efficiently quantum physics can describe our world, and confront its limitation when it is faced with the infinitely small (in relation to recent experiments carried out at the CERN) as with the incommensurably large scale of sidereal spaces. We will appreciate the extent to which quantum physics already has impacted our everyday lives, and evoke the way in which novel fields such as quantum computers and quantum information will entail profound changes in the future. The quantum adventure has only just begun! Monday 15 November 2010 - 18h30 Jochen Mannhart Center for Electronic Correlations and Magnetism, University of Augsburg, Germany Quantum Physics on the Scale of Daily Life Tuesday 16 November 2010 - 18h30 Wolfgang Ketterle Nobel Laureate 2001 (Physics), Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, U.S.A. When freezing cold is not cold enough New forms of matter close to absolute zero temperature Wednesday 17 November 2010 - 18h30 David Gross Nobel Laureate 2004 (Physics), Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of California, Santa-Barbara, U.S.A. Quantum Mechanics of the Very, Very Small and the Very, Very Large Thursday 18 November 2010 - 18h30 Alain Aspect CNRS senior scientist and Professor Institut d'Optique and Ecole Polytechnique Palaiseau, France. From Einstein’s intuition to quantum bits: a new quantum age? Vendredi 19 novembre 2010 - 18h30 Rainer Blatt Institute of Quantum Optics and Quantum Information, Austrian Academy of Sciences and University of Innsbruck, Austria The Quantum Way of Doing Computations
Science has developed through a variety of investigations more or less over the time scale of human existence. On this scale, quantum mechanics is an extremely young field, existing essentially only about a century. Black-body radiation had been studied for many years prior to Planck’s discovery, but it lacked an adequate theory. One of the early theories was due to Wien, but it was approximate, and it was discovered that it really didn’t fit to the observations. It was known that when light was shone upon the surface of a metal, or some other conducting medium, electrons could be emitted from the surface provided that the frequency of the incident light was sufficiently high. The anomaly of light and particles having both wavelike and particle-like properties was confusing to the world of the early twentieth century and, not in the least, to the scientists of the day.
In 1912 Niels Bohr developed his model of the atom, in which electrons are allowed only certain discrete orbits. Transitions between these orbits may take place only when the atom absorbs or emits quantized packets of energy E = hc. This explains the spectral lines given o ® by an excited element, such as described by Rydberg's formula for the series of spectral lines for hydrogen. Less than a year after Bohr published his theory, J. Franck1 and G. Hertz2 proved it experimentally, earning themselves the 1925 Nobel Prize in Physics. They boiled electrons o ® a hot ¯lament K, used a potential Ub to accelerate them through a vapor of an element toward a grid A (v. Fig. 1), and looked for them on a plate M, with a small retarding potential V0 = 1.5 V, to stop electrons whose kinetic energy was below a certain value. Figure 1: Circuit diagram for the Franck-Hertz experiment If the kinetic energy of the electrons is too small to excite the atoms in the vapor, the electrons collide elastically and lose almost no energy, as required by the conservation of energy and momentum, and a large current is detected at plate M. If, on the other hand, the electrons gain just enough kinetic energy 1James Franck, American (German-born) physicist, 1882-1964 2Gustav Hertz, German physicist, 1887-1975, nephew of Heinrich Hertz, who discovered radio waves
Abstract As the end of the nineteenth century, the search for Nature’s basic laws seemed close to its goal. There was a sense of a task accomplished. Physics presented an orderly scene that fit the proper Victorian mood of the day. Objects both on Earth and in the heavens behaved in accord with Newton’s laws. So, presumably, did atoms. The nature of atoms was unclear. But to most scientists the rest of the job of describing the universe seemed a filling in of the details of the Great Machine.
One of the reasons for 1932 Nobel Prize for physics is “for the creation of quantum mechanics”. As well-known, the most famous contribution of Heisenberg is therefore one of the most importment reasons for Heisenberg was awarded the Nobel Prize is the creation of principle. While, this paper points out that the original principle is improper. Considering all the possible situations (including the case that people can create laws), the author presents certainty-uncertainty with general form and variable dimension fractal form. According to the classification of Neutrosophy, certainty-uncertainty can be divided into three principles in different conditions: certainty principle, namely a particle’s position and momentum can be known simultaneously; uncertainty principle, namely a particle’s position and momentum cannot be known simultaneously; and neutral (fuzzy) indeterminacy principle, namely whether or not a particle’s position and momentum can be known simultaneously is undetermined. The special cases of certainty-uncertainty include the original principle and Ozawa inequality. In addition, in accordance with the original discussing high-speed particle’s speed and track with Newton mechanics is unreasonable; but according to certainty-uncertainty Newton mechanics can be used to discuss the problem of gravitational defection of a photon orbit around the Sun (it gives the same result of deflection angle as given by general relativity). Finally, for the reason that in physics the principles, laws and the like that are regardless of the principle (law) of conservation of energy may be invalid; therefore certainty-uncertainty should be restricted (or constrained) by principle (law) of conservation of energy, and thus it can satisfy the principle (law) of conservation of energy.
What is it about quantum mechanics that continues to make its interpretation so difficult and controversial? It is now more than 70 years after its inception and at least half a century since the verification of its predictions of physical phenomena that range from the motion of electrons in solids to the basic structure and properties of the atomic nucleus. After reading the first half of this book one could be forgiven for believing that it has been just our unwillingness or inability to understand properly what Niels Bohr said from the beginning, and to update these ideas in the light of later experience. The aim of the present book is to do just this: to restate the Copenhagen interpretation and to show us how it has been developed to take modern results and ideas into account.