Louis due de Broglie died on 19 March 1987.He was born on 15 August 1892 to a French noble family, the youngest of five children.A very gifted boy, he studied for five years at the Sorbonne, covering history, law and finally science.Drafted in 1913 into the radiotelegraphy corps, he worked throughout the first world war at the Eiffel tower emitter, and also became familiar with the theory of electromagnetic waves.After the war he joined the x-ray laboratory that his elder brother Maurice (a former naval officer) had installed in his mansion near the Champs Elysees in Paris.This was an active laboratory and Louis did some theoretical work on x-rays and atomic structure.He also carefully studied Einstein's work on special relativity and quantum physics.In 1922 he derived Planck's law from statistical physics (two years before Bose).Then came his bold discovery: in the preface to a new edition of his thesis (first written in 1924) he wrote 'After long reflection in solitude and meditation, I suddenly had the idea, during the year 1923, that the discovery made by Einstein in 1905 should be extended to all material particles'.His study of the waves associated with particles was published in two notes, Comptes Rendus Acad.Sci.Paris 177 pp507-10and pp548-50 (1923), in a letter to Nature (1923 112 p540) and in a paper in Phil.Mag.(1924 47 pp446-58).The condition for standing waves on a closed orbit yielded the Bohr-Sommerfeld quantisation.In the second note de Broglie wrote: 'An electron beam travelling through a small enough aperture would show a diffraction phenomenon.This might be the right direction to look for an experimental verification of our ideas'.Immediately Einstein used de Broglie's wave ideas in his paper on the quantum monatomic gas (1925 Sitz.Preuss.Akad.Wiss.p3).Schrodinger (1926 Phys.Zeit.27 p95) did not like the use of Bose statistics in this paper, but he wrote 'the de Broglie-Einstein waves should be taken seriously'.He did: his next paper was the famous one on the hydrogen atom, and soon he proved the equivalence of wave mechanics and quantum mechanics, created the year before by Heisenberg.Elsasser noted (1925) that the Ramsauer effect, and also the Davisson and Kunsman experiments, could be explained with de Broglie waves.Davisson and Germer carried out much more precise and convincing experiments, published in 1927.They were followed by many other experimenters: the first of the resulting publications was a letter to Nature from G P Thomson and A Reid in which de Broglie's name was not even mentioned.De Broglie received the Nobel prize in 1929, whilst Davisson and Thomson received theirs in 1937.Like Einstein and Schrodinger, de Broglie did not agree in 1927 about the nondeterministic interpretation of wave mechanics.Nevertheless, for 25 years he taught an advanced course on the new physics every year, each one being published in book form (many are excellent and several have been translated into English).He worked on a theory of light in which photons are composite particles, and from the age of 60 he again started work on a deterministic wave theory which (like his group of students) will probably be forgotten.De Broglie wrote excellent popular books on modern physics in beautiful French.He received many honours (membership of academies, including the Royal Society, and Honorary Fellowship of The Institute of Physics) and accepted many responsibilities in France, which he assumed with devotion.He led a very simple life, and never married.He felt a high duty to serve science: in 1949 his message to the Lausanne colloquium of the 'Mouvement Europeen' was an eloquent and very prophetic plea for a 'physics laboratory in which it would be possible to work outside and above the national frameworks.As a result of collaboration between a large number of European nations, this organism would have more important resources than national laboratories'.It was influential in the creation of CERN.first Ph D degree in forensic science by the University of Madras, India, for his thesis on aspects of skull identification and individualisation.
Abstract Erwin Schrödinger was born on 12 August 1887 in Vienna. His father was a Viennese and came from a very cultured family. The ancestors of his mother came from England which explains why Schrodinger spoke and wrote a practically flawless English. The relationship between father and son was excellent. To the growing boy the father was friend and teacher and he never tired of answering the inquisitive questions which the bright and interested boy produced in plenty. His elementary education was private and was carried out at home. At the age of 11 he entered the Akademische Gymnasium, a first-class grammar school which emphasized classical education, Latin and Greek. In spite of his main interest in mathematics and physics he loved the old languages as well as classical German and foreign poetry, and he was an addict of the famous Burgtheater in Vienna. He entered the University of Vienna in 1906. His great and beloved teacher there was F. Hasenohrl who had just succeeded to the chair of Boltzmann and who considered it his privilege and duty to continue the work of this great theoretical physicist. Hasenohrl was a very gifted physicist indeed and probably he would have been capable of great achievements had he not been killed in 1916 serving at the Italian front. He exercised a profound and lasting influence on the student Schrodinger. When much later Schrodinger received the Nobel Prize he said: ‘had Hasenohrl not been killed so young he would now be here in my place.’ Schrodinger himself served during the war as an artillery officer in Italy. From 1910 onwards his first publications began to appear. They were concerned with statistical problems, dielectrics, magnetism, and so on. Later on he also worked on X-ray diffraction in lattices, following the great discovery of von Laue in 1912.
In loving memory of Asher Peres, we discuss a most important and influential paper written in 1935 by his thesis supervisor and mentor Nathan Rosen, together with Albert Einstein and Boris Podolsky. In that paper, the trio known as EPR questioned the completeness of quantum mechanics. The authors argued that the then-new theory should not be considered final because they believed it incapable of describing physical reality. The epic battle between Einstein and Bohr intensified following the latter's response later the same year. Three decades elapsed before John S. Bell gave a devastating proof that the EPR argument was fatally flawed. The modest purpose of our paper is to give a critical analysis of the original EPR paper and point out its logical shortcomings in a way that could have been done 70 years ago, with no need to wait for Bell's theorem. We also present an overview of Bohr's response in the interest of showing how it failed to address the gist of the EPR argument.
Irving John Good once titled a paper, “46,656 Varieties of Bayesians.” With little stretch of the imagination, one can believe that a similar paper on the interpretations of quantum mechanics exists somewhere out there too. And that may be true even though 46,656 is greater than the whole membership of the American Physical Society! It is no wonder that taking a stand on quantum foundations is treacherous business. Nevertheless, in the March 2000 issue of Physics Today, Asher Peres and I flouted the usual rewards of a calm life and did just that. Our article was titled, “Quantum Theory Needs No ‘Interpretation’.”
On 25 March 1935, the Physical Review received a paper from Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky, and Nathan Rosen, with the title “Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete?” A few days later, on 30 March 1935, I was born. My life with Einstein was off to a promising start. Some would call it an inauspicious start. Abraham Pais, for example, says in his otherwise admirable biography of Einstein [1] that “the only part of this article that will ultimately survive, I believe, is this last phrase [ No reasonable definition of reality could be expected to permit this ], which so poignantly summarizes Einstein's views on quantum mechanics in his later years.” But today, in this centenary of the Einstein annus mirabilis, as the EPR paper and I both turn 70, it is, in fact, the most cited of all Einstein's papers [2]. The debate over its conceptual implications rages hotter than ever, and for the first time, practical (well, for the moment still gedanken practical) applications of the EPR effect have emerged in cryptography and in other areas of quantum information processing. Being only five weeks old, I was unprepared to pay attention to the article that appeared in the New York Times on 4 May 1935 under an elaborate set of headlines and subheads: And I was completely oblivious to the stern rebuke from Einstein himself, published three days later in the Times , which declared that “any information upon which the article … is based was given to you without my authority. It is my invariable practice to discuss scientific matters only in the appropriate forum and I deprecate advance publication of any announcement in regard to such matters in the secular press.” Apparently Podolsky had tipped off the Times to the article, which did not appear in the sacred press until the 15 May issue of Physical Review. It is not clear that Einstein ever forgave him, and I wish I had been old enough to send Podolsky a cross letter myself. Anyone growing up in America in the 1940s knew that the preeminent genius of our age, and perhaps of any other, lived in Princeton, New Jersey, had a predilection for baggy sweaters, and was always badly in need of a haircut—as far ahead of his time in dress and grooming as he was ahead in science during his 1905 annus mirabilis.
Hermann Anton Haus, an Institute Professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), was to have been a Keynote Speaker at the Fluctuations and Noise in Photonics and Quantum Optics Conference, from which the papers in this special issue derive. Sadly, on May 21, 2003 – less than two weeks before the conference – Professor Haus succumbed to a heart attack after arriving home in Lexington, Massachusetts, from his regular, 15-mile commute by bicycle from MIT. He was 77. Throughout his lengthy and illustrious career, Professor Haus had repeatedly and very successfully addressed problems of fluctuations and noise, with special focus on the fundamental issues that arise in quantum optics. To honour Professor Haus' legacy to our technical community, this special issue of Journal of Optics B: Quantum and Semiclassical Optics is dedicated to his memory. Professor Haus was born in Ljubljana, Slovenia, in the former Yugoslavia, on 8 August 1925. After attending the Technische Hochschule, Graz, and the Technische Hochschule, Wien, in Austria, he received his Bachelor of Science degree from Union College in Schenectady, New York in 1949. In 1951, he graduated from Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute with a Master of Science in Electrical Engineering, and came to MIT, where he earned his Doctorate of Science and joined the faculty in 1954. He was promoted to Associate Professor in 1958, to Professor in 1962, and to Elihu Thomson Professor in 1973. In 1986, he was conferred the honour of Institute Professor. Professor Haus had a lifelong fascination with noise. While still an undergraduate at Union College, he became aware of Norbert Wiener's theories of statistical phenomena – the new mathematics needed to understand and quantify the random fluctuations we refer to as noise. So it was that noise theory formed the core of Professor Haus' research during the 1950s: noise in electron beams, noise in microwave amplifiers, and noise in amplifier cascades. Two of his notable achievements from that era are his elegant four-terminal impedance transformation for the treatment of noise in electron beams [1], and the single noise measure for optimizing linear amplifier cascades that he developed with Richard B Adler [2]. In 1960 the first working laser was reported, and Professor Haus' noise work shifted from microwaves to higher frequencies – light waves – and to the most fundamental source of fluctuations, the inescapable noise introduced by quantum mechanics. In 1962, he and Charles H Townes used the number-phase uncertainty principle to derive the sensitivity advantage that optical homodyne detection enjoys over optical heterodyne detection [3]. That same year he and James A Mullen tied the fundamental noise limits on linear amplification to the quadrature-noise uncertainty principle [4]. Four years later he and Charles Freed reported the first measurements of photoelectron statistics for a laser operating below and above its oscillation threshold [5]. All three of these works have continuing echoes through more recent research on the quantum theory of coherent detection, the noise limits of phase-insensitive and phase-sensitive amplifiers, and quantum noise measurements via photodetection. It took some time for laser technology to fulfil its initial promise of inexpensive, long-haul, broadband communications, and Professor Haus' work on modelocked, distributed-feedback, and soliton lasers played no small role in that development. Nevertheless, from the 1980s onward, Professor Haus' research interest returned again and again to quantum noise. In collaboration with colleagues from the Raytheon Company he showed that their ring-laser gyroscope was operating at the noise limit set by the number-phase uncertainty principle [6]. In collaboration with Nobuyuki Imoto and Yoshihisa Yamamoto from Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Research Laboratories he proposed a practical route to the quantum nondemolition (QND) measurement of photon number [7]. Together with James P Gordon he elucidated the quantum timing jitter that afflicts soliton propagation down optically-amplified fibre lines [8]. He and Masataka Shirasaki introduced the nonlinear Sagnac loop as a technique for generating squeezed states in optical fibre [9]. Together with his student Yinchieh Lai, Professor Haus established a physically-motivated decomposition that accounts for the various noise contributions seen in soliton squeezing [10]. The impact of these works has continued to reverberate through more recent efforts devoted to optical QND measurements, long-haul soliton transmission systems, and Sagnac loop quantum-noise manipulation. During the last decade of Professor Haus' life, he revisited – in very modern terms – some topics that he had studied early in his career. In a collaboration between his group and researchers at Bell Laboratories he used amplified spontaneous emission noise measurements to accurately predict the performance of a 10-Gbit/s optically-preamplified receiver [11], thus reprising – in the context of broadband optical communications – issues of photodetection noise statistics that he had confronted 30 years earlier with Charles Freed. In an invited paper he described a single noise figure for amplification that is valid from radio to optical frequencies [12], i.e., in both the classical and quantum regimes, thus bringing him back, full circle, to his earliest interest in amplifier noise measures. The culmination of his life's work, however, was his book, Electromagnetic Noise and Quantum Optical Measurements. Published in 2000 [13], it is a distillation of 45 years of his research. Generations of students to come will learn quantum noise from this masterwork. Professor Haus authored or co-authored five books, published more than 300 articles, and presented his work at virtually every major conference and symposium on lasers, quantum electronics, and quantum optics around the world. He was one of very few engineers in the USA to become a member of both the National Academy of Engineering and the National Academy of Sciences. He was a Fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, the American Physical Society, the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, and the Optical Society of America. He received Guggenheim and Fulbright Fellowships and several honorary degrees, including one from the University of Vienna, and he received the Austrian government's Wittgenstein Prize for outstanding contributions to humanity. Professor Haus was selected by his MIT colleagues for the 1982–1983 James R Killian Faculty Achievement Award, the highest honour that the MIT faculty bestows. In 1984, the Optical Society of America recognized Professor Haus' contributions with its Frederic Ives Medal, the Society's highest award. In 1995, Professor Haus was awarded the National Medal of Science by President William Jefferson Clinton. In a 1998 interview, Professor Haus was asked about his philosophy of life. He replied, 'Try to do your best, because that's all part of the fun. The greatest thing is that once in a while something clicks. It happens every three of four years. It can't happen more often than that, except for some exceptional people.' Things clicked for Hermann Anton Haus. This happened not just once, not just every three or four years, but regularly and throughout his long career. He was a truly exceptional man. Jeffrey H Shapiro Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, USA References [1] Haus H A 1955 Noise in one-dimensional electron beams J. Appl. Phys. 26 560–71 [2] Haus H A and Adler R B 1958 Optimum noise performance of linear amplifiers Proc. IRE 46 1519–33 [3] Haus H A and Townes C H 1962 Comment on `Noise in photoelectric mixing' Proc. IRE 50 1544 [4] Haus H A and Mullen J A 1962 Quantum noise in linear amplifiers Phys. Rev. 128 2407–13 [5] Freed C and Haus H A 1966 Photoelectron statistics produced by a laser operating below and above the threshold of oscillation IEEE J. Quantum Electron. QE-2 190–5 [6] Dorschner T A , Haus H A, Holz M, Smith I W and Statz H 1980 Laser gyro at quantum limit IEEE J. Quantum Electron. QE-16 1376–9 [7] Imoto N, Haus H A and Yamamoto Y 1985 Quantum nondemolition measurement of the photon number via the optical Kerr effect Phys. Rev. A 32 2287-92 [8] Gordon J P and Haus H A 1986 Random walk of coherently amplified solitons in optical fiber transmission Opt. Lett. 11 665–7 [9] Shirasaki M and Haus H A 1990 Squeezing of pulses in a nonlinear interferometer J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 7 30–4 [10] Haus H A and Lai Y 1990 Quantum theory of soliton squeezing: a linearized approach J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 7 386–92 [11] Wong W S, Haus H A, Jiang L A, Hansen P B and Margalit M 1998 Photon statistics of amplified spontaneous emission noise in a 10-Gbit/s optically preamplified direct-detection receiver Opt. Lett. 23 1832–34 [12] Haus H A 2000 Noise figure definition valid from RF to optical frequencies IEEE J. Sel. Topics Quantum Electron. 6 240–7 [13] Haus H A 2000 Electromagnetic Noise and Quantum Optical Measurements (Berlin: Springer)