Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

CRC Press eBooks

Introduction

Jeffrey Olafsen

Published Jul 26, 2019• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The issue is that one may enter an upper level course on statistical and thermal physics with only an appreciation of the classical macroscopic view never having attached quantum mechanics to anything thermodynamic. Statistical mechanics makes accurate predictions about systems which may contain 1023 or more particles. A sense of disbelief may be partly responsible for the widely held, but, incorrect view that statistical mechanics has to be difficult. A true understanding of entropy only comes from the microscopic treatment of the quantum approach made by statistical mechanics. The more fundamental, issue is that classical statistical mechanics is internally inconsistent, and can only be made to work by the importation from quantum theory of non-classical ideas such as indistinguishability. Gibbs’ paradox, over which the classical books agonize at length, vanishes into thin air in the quantum approach.

DOI
10.1201/9781315156958-1

Related papers

Quantum Statistical Physics

Nicolas Sator, Nicolas Pavloff, Lénaïc Couëdel

In the previous chapters, the focus was on systems of particles following the law of classical mechanics. Of course, this was mainly done within the framework of classical mechanics but a quantum description of individual (discretised) states was also used, while assuming distinguishability of the particles (for instance, particles located at the nodes of a lattice (spin system, quantum harmonic oscillators,) ). The present chapter as well as Chapters 7 and 8 are dedicated to the study of statistical physics in a fully quantum framework. The first obstacle encountered by a quantum approach is the impossibility to define a quantum phase space (in which the ergodic hypothesis would hold for instance). This problem is inherent to quantum mechanics: because of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, one cannot define both the momentum and the position of a particle. Besides, statistical physics considers systems made of a large number of particles, a priori in mutual interaction. In classical physics, model situations for which the interactions between the constituents of the system are neglected can be studied. In quantum mechanics, the indistinguishability of identical particles makes the study of the problem in the absence of interaction already difficult: even for non-interacting particles, the symmetrisation (or antisymmetrisation) of the wave function of https://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"> N https://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href=" https://s3-euw1-ap-pe-df-pch-content-public-p.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/9781003272427/5ca4d37a-9786-43a3-8b38-8fa9eb3d1a19/content/math_25.tif "/> identical particles induces correlations which have non-trivial thermodynamical effects such as the existence of a “Fermi sea” for fermions (see Section 8.1 ) or the Bose–Einstein condensation phenomenon for bosons (see Section 7.4 ). The present chapter addresses these two points consecutively.

CRC Press eBooks•Jun 9, 2023•3 citations

From identity to indistinguishability

Enric Pérez Canals

It is widely accepted that the papers by Bose in 1924 and by Einstein in 1924-1925 definitely opened the path to the quantum concept of ‘indistinguishability’. Since then, distinction in physics between ‘identity’ and ‘indistinguishability’ of particles has come to be required. However, even before the rise of quantum physics, Maxwell, Boltzmann and Gibbs, among others, had to tackle the difficulties and paradoxes that appear when counting identical particles. Later, after Sackur’s and Tetrode’s first quantum derivation of the canonical partition function of an ideal gas, much confusion arose around its dependence on the number of molecules in the system. Many other physicists, such as Planck, Lorentz or Schrodinger took part in those debates. In 1921, Ehrenfest and Trkal devoted a whole paper to this subject. Clearly, in the days before Bose’s seminal work, embroiling and misunderstanding were commonplace. In considering the emergence of the distinction between ‘identical’ and ‘indistinguishable’ particles, we will go through the so-called statistical route to quantum mechanics. The first developments in statistical mechanics became immediately confused and entangled with the irruption of quantum physics. In the first quarter of the twentieth century the mutual influence between both disciplines was profuse. We will pay special attention to the story of the so-called ‘Gibbs Paradox.’ We will argue that what is now often known by this name in some textbooks of statistical mechanics did not exist as such in those foundational days.

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

From classical to quantum statistical mechanics

Giampiero V. M. Esposito, Giuseppe Marmo, George Sudarshan

Classical statistical mechanics tries to derive the macroscopic properties of matter starting from the mechanical laws that rule the behaviour of single particles. To describe equilibrium states, only observables accounting for correlations among states are considered, and only systems consisting of a large number of particles are taken into account. The observables are described by continuous functions on phase space, and the states are represented by linear assignments of a number to each observable. Within the framework of the canonical ensemble, one deals with mechanical systems in thermal equilibrium with a thermal reservoir, and the equilibrium state is reached as a result of the interaction with the external world. The external world may be really external, or equally well, the unrecognized internal degrees of freedom, like in the calculation of viscosity or thermal conductivity. If really only the external world is the cause we may expect some surface dependence while an internal unrecognized degree of freedom would have a volume effect, unless the interactions are long range. The microcanonical ensemble is instead introduced to study isolated mechanical systems, and the equilibrium is viewed as a temporal average, rather than as a limit. Attention is then focused on partition functions, the theorem of equipartition of energy and an elementary theory of specific heats.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 11, 2004•0 citations

The Gibbs paradox and the distinguishability of identical particles

Marijn A. M. Versteegh, Dennis Dieks

Identical classical particles are distinguishable. This distinguishability affects the number of ways W a macrostate can be realized on the microlevel, and from the relation S=k ln W leads to a nonextensive expression for the entropy. This result is usually considered incorrect because of its inconsistency with thermodynamics. It is sometimes concluded from this inconsistency that identical particles are fundamentally indistinguishable and that quantum mechanics is indispensable for making sense of this inconsistency. In contrast, we argue that the classical statistics of distinguishable particles and the resulting nonextensive entropy function are perfectly acceptable from both a theoretical and an experimental perspective. The inconsistency with thermodynamics can be removed by taking into account that the entropy concept in statistical mechanics is not completely identical to the thermodynamical one. We observe that even identical quantum particles are in some cases distinguishable, and conclude that quantum mechanics is irrelevant to the Gibbs paradox.

arXiv:1012.4111•American Journal of Physics•Jun 17, 2011•45 citations

Introduction

Keith Hannabuss

Abstract In the first quarter of this century physicists were slowly and somewhat reluctantly forced to realize that the view of the physical world, so painstakingly built up over the preceding four centuries, was in serious need of revision. In particular, the laws that governed the motion of particles on the atomic scale were not those of classical mechanics. Physics found itself catapulted into the strange new world of quantum theory in which the very notion of position or velocity of a particle became blurred and statistical laws dominated everything.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 20, 1997•0 citations

The Logic of Identity: Distinguishability and Indistinguishability in Classical and Quantum Physics

Dennis Dieks

The suggestion that particles of the same kind may be indistinguishable in a fundamental sense, even so that challenges to traditional notions of individuality and identity may arise, has first come up in the context of classical statistical mechanics. In particular, the Gibbs paradox has sometimes been interpreted as a sign of the untenability of the classical concept of a particle and as a premonition that quantum theory is needed. This idea of a ‘quantum connection’ stubbornly persists in the literature, even though it has also been criticized frequently. Here we shall argue that although this criticism is justified, the proposed alternative solutions have often been wrong and have not put the paradox in its right perspective. In fact, the Gibbs paradox is unrelated to fundamental issues of particle identity; only distinguishability in a pragmatic sense plays a role (in this we develop ideas of van Kampen [10]), and in principle the paradox always is there as long as the concept of a particle applies at all. In line with this we show that the paradox survives even in quantum mechanics, in spite of the quantum mechanical (anti-)symmetrization postulates.

•May 13, 2014•13 citations
The issue is that one may enter an upper level course on statistical and thermal physics with only an appreciation of the classical macroscopic view never having attached quantum mechanics to anything thermodynamic. Statistical mechanics makes accurate predictions about systems which may contain 1023 or more particles. A sense of disbelief may be partly responsible for the widely held, but, incorrect view that statistical mechanics has to be difficult. A true understanding of entropy only comes from the microscopic treatment of the quantum approach made by statistical mechanics. The more fundamental, issue is that classical statistical mechanics is internally inconsistent, and can only be made to work by the importation from quantum theory of non-classical ideas such as indistinguishability. Gibbs’ paradox, over which the classical books agonize at length, vanishes into thin air in the quantum approach.
In the previous chapters, the focus was on systems of particles following the law of classical mechanics. Of course, this was mainly done within the framework of classical mechanics but a quantum description of individual (discretised) states was also used, while assuming distinguishability of the particles (for instance, particles located at the nodes of a lattice (spin system, quantum harmonic oscillators,) ). The present chapter as well as Chapters 7 and 8 are dedicated to the study of statistical physics in a fully quantum framework. The first obstacle encountered by a quantum approach is the impossibility to define a quantum phase space (in which the ergodic hypothesis would hold for instance). This problem is inherent to quantum mechanics: because of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, one cannot define both the momentum and the position of a particle. Besides, statistical physics considers systems made of a large number of particles, a priori in mutual interaction. In classical physics, model situations for which the interactions between the constituents of the system are neglected can be studied. In quantum mechanics, the indistinguishability of identical particles makes the study of the problem in the absence of interaction already difficult: even for non-interacting particles, the symmetrisation (or antisymmetrisation) of the wave function of https://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"> N https://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href=" https://s3-euw1-ap-pe-df-pch-content-public-p.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/9781003272427/5ca4d37a-9786-43a3-8b38-8fa9eb3d1a19/content/math_25.tif "/> identical particles induces correlations which have non-trivial thermodynamical effects such as the existence of a “Fermi sea” for fermions (see Section 8.1 ) or the Bose–Einstein condensation phenomenon for bosons (see Section 7.4 ). The present chapter addresses these two points consecutively.
It is widely accepted that the papers by Bose in 1924 and by Einstein in 1924-1925 definitely opened the path to the quantum concept of ‘indistinguishability’. Since then, distinction in physics between ‘identity’ and ‘indistinguishability’ of particles has come to be required. However, even before the rise of quantum physics, Maxwell, Boltzmann and Gibbs, among others, had to tackle the difficulties and paradoxes that appear when counting identical particles. Later, after Sackur’s and Tetrode’s first quantum derivation of the canonical partition function of an ideal gas, much confusion arose around its dependence on the number of molecules in the system. Many other physicists, such as Planck, Lorentz or Schrodinger took part in those debates. In 1921, Ehrenfest and Trkal devoted a whole paper to this subject. Clearly, in the days before Bose’s seminal work, embroiling and misunderstanding were commonplace. In considering the emergence of the distinction between ‘identical’ and ‘indistinguishable’ particles, we will go through the so-called statistical route to quantum mechanics. The first developments in statistical mechanics became immediately confused and entangled with the irruption of quantum physics. In the first quarter of the twentieth century the mutual influence between both disciplines was profuse. We will pay special attention to the story of the so-called ‘Gibbs Paradox.’ We will argue that what is now often known by this name in some textbooks of statistical mechanics did not exist as such in those foundational days.
Classical statistical mechanics tries to derive the macroscopic properties of matter starting from the mechanical laws that rule the behaviour of single particles. To describe equilibrium states, only observables accounting for correlations among states are considered, and only systems consisting of a large number of particles are taken into account. The observables are described by continuous functions on phase space, and the states are represented by linear assignments of a number to each observable. Within the framework of the canonical ensemble, one deals with mechanical systems in thermal equilibrium with a thermal reservoir, and the equilibrium state is reached as a result of the interaction with the external world. The external world may be really external, or equally well, the unrecognized internal degrees of freedom, like in the calculation of viscosity or thermal conductivity. If really only the external world is the cause we may expect some surface dependence while an internal unrecognized degree of freedom would have a volume effect, unless the interactions are long range. The microcanonical ensemble is instead introduced to study isolated mechanical systems, and the equilibrium is viewed as a temporal average, rather than as a limit. Attention is then focused on partition functions, the theorem of equipartition of energy and an elementary theory of specific heats.
Identical classical particles are distinguishable. This distinguishability affects the number of ways W a macrostate can be realized on the microlevel, and from the relation S=k ln W leads to a nonextensive expression for the entropy. This result is usually considered incorrect because of its inconsistency with thermodynamics. It is sometimes concluded from this inconsistency that identical particles are fundamentally indistinguishable and that quantum mechanics is indispensable for making sense of this inconsistency. In contrast, we argue that the classical statistics of distinguishable particles and the resulting nonextensive entropy function are perfectly acceptable from both a theoretical and an experimental perspective. The inconsistency with thermodynamics can be removed by taking into account that the entropy concept in statistical mechanics is not completely identical to the thermodynamical one. We observe that even identical quantum particles are in some cases distinguishable, and conclude that quantum mechanics is irrelevant to the Gibbs paradox.
Abstract In the first quarter of this century physicists were slowly and somewhat reluctantly forced to realize that the view of the physical world, so painstakingly built up over the preceding four centuries, was in serious need of revision. In particular, the laws that governed the motion of particles on the atomic scale were not those of classical mechanics. Physics found itself catapulted into the strange new world of quantum theory in which the very notion of position or velocity of a particle became blurred and statistical laws dominated everything.
The suggestion that particles of the same kind may be indistinguishable in a fundamental sense, even so that challenges to traditional notions of individuality and identity may arise, has first come up in the context of classical statistical mechanics. In particular, the Gibbs paradox has sometimes been interpreted as a sign of the untenability of the classical concept of a particle and as a premonition that quantum theory is needed. This idea of a ‘quantum connection’ stubbornly persists in the literature, even though it has also been criticized frequently. Here we shall argue that although this criticism is justified, the proposed alternative solutions have often been wrong and have not put the paradox in its right perspective. In fact, the Gibbs paradox is unrelated to fundamental issues of particle identity; only distinguishability in a pragmatic sense plays a role (in this we develop ideas of van Kampen [10]), and in principle the paradox always is there as long as the concept of a particle applies at all. In line with this we show that the paradox survives even in quantum mechanics, in spite of the quantum mechanical (anti-)symmetrization postulates.