Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

CRC Press eBooks

Time in the QuantÜm World

Derek York

Published Apr 26, 2019• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Isaac Newton, Pierre Laplace and the vast majority of the great scientists of the classical era regarded time as an absolute quantity flowing in some determined way like a great river guided by the solid banks of reality. Einstein shows his special theory of relativity that in fact time is not absolute; there are many rivers of time, each flowing at its own speed. Einstein described Schrodinger’s cat paradox as the ‘prettiest way’ of illustrating his belief that quantum theory, although it is a fantastically successful tool, is not a complete description of reality. The scientific stars were out to laud Schrodinger because, early in 1926, he published an extraordinary equation that codified much of the ghostly behaviour of the microworld. A key fact of quantum life was thus known, but far from understood: in some circumstances, light is best regarded as a wave, whereas in other situations light is far more usefully treated as a shower of minute particles.

DOI
10.1201/9780429187100-12

Related papers

Einstein’s Vision

A. Pais

Abstract Einstein’s lasting conviction that quantum mechanics was not a theory of principle did not impede him from recognizing that this theory was highly successful. As early as 1927, he publicly expressed his judgment that wave mechanics is ‘in amazing agreement with the facts of experience’ [ E1]. In 1936 he wrote, ‘It seems clear … that the Born statistical interpretation of the quantum theory is the only possible one’ [E2], and in 1949 declared, ‘The statistical quantum theory [is] the most successful theory of our period’ [E3]. Then why was he never convinced by it? I believe Einstein indirectly answered this question in his 1933 Spencer lecture-perhaps the clearest and most revealing expression of his way of thinking in later life. The key is to be found in his remarks on Newton and classical mechanics. In this lecture [E4], Einstein noted that ‘Newton felt by no means comfortable about the concept of absolute space, … of absolute rest … [and] about the introduction of action at a distance.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Aug 25, 2005•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics

Susan Loepp, William K. Wootters

The early twentieth century was a revolutionary time in the history of physics. People often think of Einstein's special theory of relativity of 1905, which changed our conceptions of time and space. But among physicists, quantum mechanics is usually regarded as an even more radical change in our thinking about the physical world. Quantum mechanics, which was developed between 1900 and 1926, began as a theory of atoms and light but has now become the framework in terms of which all basic physical theories are expected to be cast. We need quantum ideas not only to understand atoms, molecules, and elementary particles, but also to understand the electronic properties of solids and even certain astronomical phenomena such as the stability of white dwarf stars. The theory was radical in part because it introduced probabilistic behavior as a fundamental aspect of the world, but even more because it seems to allow mutually exclusive situations to exist simultaneously in a "quantum superposition." We will see later that the possibility of quantum superposition is largely responsible for a quantum computer's distinctive advantage over an ordinary computer. The present chapter is devoted to introducing the basic principles of quantum mechanics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 10, 2006•1 citation

Simplifying the equations of relativistic quantum mechanics

Luis Grave de Peralta

I n the early 20th century, the groundbreaking theories of quantum mechanics and special relativity emerged at roughly the same time.At first, both theories appeared to be entirely incompatible with each other.While the quantum equations written out by Erwin Schrödinger and Wolfgang Pauli dealt with the behaviours of electrons, atoms, and molecules moving at speeds encountered in classical physics, the rules of special relativity first imagined by Albert Einstein described the behaviour of matter moving at close to the speed of light.Initially, this apparent clash of theories presented a crisis in physics.However, in the late 1920s, further theoretical work carried out by physicists including Paul Dirac, Oskar Klein, and Walter Gordon culminated in a new set of equations, which proved definitively that quantum mechanics and special relativity are compatible with each other after all. An educational challengeYet with this groundbreaking discovery came an entirely new problem.In adding a new layer of complexity to the equations of non-relativistic quantum mechanics, the more complete theories of relativistic

Research Features•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

BECOMING AS A BRIDGE BETWEEN QUANTUM MECHANICS AND RELATIVITY

Avshalom C. Elitzur, Shahar Dolev

Time’s apparent “flow” is often dismissed in physical theory. We propose to take it as a real property of reality and show how the addition of this assumption to physics’ prevailing postulate yields a new framework within which relativity and quantum theories are in harmony with one another.

Endophysics, Time, Quantum and the Subjective•Oct 1, 2005•24 citations

Through Two Doors at Once: The Elegant Experiment That Captures the Enigma of Our Quantum Reality

Anil Ananthaswamy

The intellectual adventure story of the "double-slit" experiment, showing how a sunbeam split into two paths first challenged our understanding of light and then the nature of reality itself--and continues to almost 200 years later.Many of the greatest scientific minds have grappled with this experiment. Thomas Young devised it in the early 1800s to show that light behaves like a wave, and in doing so opposed Isaac Newton's view that light is made of particles. But then Albert Einstein showed that light comes in quanta, or particles. Quantum mechanics was born. This led to a fierce debate between Einstein and Niels Bohr over the nature of reality--subatomic bits of matter and its interaction with light--again as revealed by the double-slit experiment. Richard Feynman held that it embodies the central mystery of the quantum world. Decade after decade, hypothesis after hypothesis, scientists have returned to this ingenious experiment to help them answer deeper and deeper questions about the fabric of the universe.How can a single particle behave both like a particle and a wave? Does a particle, or indeed reality, exist before we look at it, or does looking create reality, as the textbook "Copenhagen interpretation" of quantum mechanics seems to suggest? How can particles influence each other faster than the speed of light? Is there a place where the quantum world ends and the familiar classical world of our daily lives begins, and if so, can we find it? And if there's no such place, then does the universe split into two each time a particle goes through the double-slit?Through Two Doors at Once celebrates the elegant simplicity of an iconic experiment and its profound reach. With his extraordinarily gifted eloquence, Anil Ananthaswamy travels around the world, through history and down to the smallest scales of physical reality we have yet fathomed. It is the most fantastic voyage you can take.

•Aug 7, 2018•19 citations

Albert Einstein to Max Born

Albert Einstein

Translated by Irene Born Newton-John In this letter to his old friend, now at Edinburgh University, Einstein first responds to Born’s description of a local physician “who wouldn’t hurt a fly, but [states] that no sacrifice is too great [for] the realization of Marxist ideals, not even the destruction of millions of human lives.” And then it’s back to the old quarrel about quantum mechanics. (See Born’s comment below.) Princeton, 15 September 1950Dear Born,… People such as your Bolshevik doctor come by their fantastic attitude as a result of their objection to the harshness, injustice and absurdity of our own social order (escape from reality). If he happened to be living in Russia, no doubt he would be a rebel there as well, only in that case he would take care not to tell you about it. Nevertheless it seems to me that our own people here [in the US] make an even worse job of their foreign policy than the Russians. And the idiotic public can be talked into anything. And they really are very shortsighted, for technological superiority is transitory, and if it comes to an all-out conflict, the decisive factor is sheer numerical superiority.There is nothing analogous in relativity to what I call incompleteness of description in the quantum theory. Briefly it is because the ψ-function is incapable of describing certain qualities of an individual system, whose “reality” none of us doubt (such as a microscopic parameter). Take a (macroscopic) body that can rotate freely about an axis. Its state is fully determined by an angle. Let the initial conditions (angle and angular momentum) be defined as precisely as the quantum theory allows. The Schrödinger equation then gives the ψ-function for any subsequent time interval. If this is sufficiently large, all angles become (in practice) equally probable. But if an observation is made (e.g. by flashing a torch), a definite angle is found (with sufficient accuracy). This does not prove that the angle had a definite value before it was observed—but we believe this to be the case, because we are committed to the requirements of reality on the macroscopic scale. Thus, the ψ-function does not express the real state of affairs perfectly in this case. This is what I call “incomplete description.”So far, you may not object. But you will probably take the position that a complete description would be useless because there is no mathematical relationship for such a case. I do not say that I am able to disprove this view. But my instinct tells me that a complete formulation of the relationships is tied up with complete description of its factual state. I am convinced of this although, up to now, success is against it. I also believe that the current formulation is true in the same sense as e.g. thermodynamics, i.e. as far as the concepts used are inadequate. I do not expect to convince you, or anybody else. I just want you to understand the way I think.I see from … your letter that you, too, take the quantum theoretical description as incomplete (referring to an ensemble). But you are, after all, convinced that no (complete) laws exist for a complete description, according to the positivistic maxim: esse est percipi [to be is to be perceived]. Well, this is a programmatic attitude, not knowledge. This is where our attitudes really differ. For the time being, I am alone in my views—as Leibniz was with respect to the absolute space of Newton’s theory.… I have not changed my attitude to the Germans, which, by the way, dates not just from the Nazi period. All human beings are more or less the same from birth. The Germans, however, have a far more dangerous tradition than any of the other so-called civilized nations.Kind regards,Yours,A. E. Born’s 1969 comment: 1 1. M. Born, The Born–Einstein Letters 1916–1955: Friendship, Politics and Physics in Uncertain Times, Macmillan, New York (2005), p. 184 Original letter © Hebrew University of Jerusalem. This is probably the clearest presentation of Einstein’s philosophy of reality. … He calls my way of describing the physical world “incomplete.” In his eyes, that is a flaw which he hopes to see removed, while I am prepared to put up with it. I have in fact always regarded it as a step forward, because an exact description of the state of a physical system presupposes that one can make statements of infinite precision about it, and this seems absurd to me. REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<CITING ARTICLES1. M. Born, The Born–Einstein Letters 1916–1955: Friendship, Politics and Physics in Uncertain Times, Macmillan, New York (2005), p. 184 Original letter © Hebrew University of Jerusalem. Google Scholar© 2005 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Aug 1, 2005•3 citations
Isaac Newton, Pierre Laplace and the vast majority of the great scientists of the classical era regarded time as an absolute quantity flowing in some determined way like a great river guided by the solid banks of reality. Einstein shows his special theory of relativity that in fact time is not absolute; there are many rivers of time, each flowing at its own speed. Einstein described Schrodinger’s cat paradox as the ‘prettiest way’ of illustrating his belief that quantum theory, although it is a fantastically successful tool, is not a complete description of reality. The scientific stars were out to laud Schrodinger because, early in 1926, he published an extraordinary equation that codified much of the ghostly behaviour of the microworld. A key fact of quantum life was thus known, but far from understood: in some circumstances, light is best regarded as a wave, whereas in other situations light is far more usefully treated as a shower of minute particles.
Abstract Einstein’s lasting conviction that quantum mechanics was not a theory of principle did not impede him from recognizing that this theory was highly successful. As early as 1927, he publicly expressed his judgment that wave mechanics is ‘in amazing agreement with the facts of experience’ [ E1]. In 1936 he wrote, ‘It seems clear … that the Born statistical interpretation of the quantum theory is the only possible one’ [E2], and in 1949 declared, ‘The statistical quantum theory [is] the most successful theory of our period’ [E3]. Then why was he never convinced by it? I believe Einstein indirectly answered this question in his 1933 Spencer lecture-perhaps the clearest and most revealing expression of his way of thinking in later life. The key is to be found in his remarks on Newton and classical mechanics. In this lecture [E4], Einstein noted that ‘Newton felt by no means comfortable about the concept of absolute space, … of absolute rest … [and] about the introduction of action at a distance.
The early twentieth century was a revolutionary time in the history of physics. People often think of Einstein's special theory of relativity of 1905, which changed our conceptions of time and space. But among physicists, quantum mechanics is usually regarded as an even more radical change in our thinking about the physical world. Quantum mechanics, which was developed between 1900 and 1926, began as a theory of atoms and light but has now become the framework in terms of which all basic physical theories are expected to be cast. We need quantum ideas not only to understand atoms, molecules, and elementary particles, but also to understand the electronic properties of solids and even certain astronomical phenomena such as the stability of white dwarf stars. The theory was radical in part because it introduced probabilistic behavior as a fundamental aspect of the world, but even more because it seems to allow mutually exclusive situations to exist simultaneously in a "quantum superposition." We will see later that the possibility of quantum superposition is largely responsible for a quantum computer's distinctive advantage over an ordinary computer. The present chapter is devoted to introducing the basic principles of quantum mechanics.
I n the early 20th century, the groundbreaking theories of quantum mechanics and special relativity emerged at roughly the same time.At first, both theories appeared to be entirely incompatible with each other.While the quantum equations written out by Erwin Schrödinger and Wolfgang Pauli dealt with the behaviours of electrons, atoms, and molecules moving at speeds encountered in classical physics, the rules of special relativity first imagined by Albert Einstein described the behaviour of matter moving at close to the speed of light.Initially, this apparent clash of theories presented a crisis in physics.However, in the late 1920s, further theoretical work carried out by physicists including Paul Dirac, Oskar Klein, and Walter Gordon culminated in a new set of equations, which proved definitively that quantum mechanics and special relativity are compatible with each other after all. An educational challengeYet with this groundbreaking discovery came an entirely new problem.In adding a new layer of complexity to the equations of non-relativistic quantum mechanics, the more complete theories of relativistic
The intellectual adventure story of the "double-slit" experiment, showing how a sunbeam split into two paths first challenged our understanding of light and then the nature of reality itself--and continues to almost 200 years later.Many of the greatest scientific minds have grappled with this experiment. Thomas Young devised it in the early 1800s to show that light behaves like a wave, and in doing so opposed Isaac Newton's view that light is made of particles. But then Albert Einstein showed that light comes in quanta, or particles. Quantum mechanics was born. This led to a fierce debate between Einstein and Niels Bohr over the nature of reality--subatomic bits of matter and its interaction with light--again as revealed by the double-slit experiment. Richard Feynman held that it embodies the central mystery of the quantum world. Decade after decade, hypothesis after hypothesis, scientists have returned to this ingenious experiment to help them answer deeper and deeper questions about the fabric of the universe.How can a single particle behave both like a particle and a wave? Does a particle, or indeed reality, exist before we look at it, or does looking create reality, as the textbook "Copenhagen interpretation" of quantum mechanics seems to suggest? How can particles influence each other faster than the speed of light? Is there a place where the quantum world ends and the familiar classical world of our daily lives begins, and if so, can we find it? And if there's no such place, then does the universe split into two each time a particle goes through the double-slit?Through Two Doors at Once celebrates the elegant simplicity of an iconic experiment and its profound reach. With his extraordinarily gifted eloquence, Anil Ananthaswamy travels around the world, through history and down to the smallest scales of physical reality we have yet fathomed. It is the most fantastic voyage you can take.
Translated by Irene Born Newton-John In this letter to his old friend, now at Edinburgh University, Einstein first responds to Born’s description of a local physician “who wouldn’t hurt a fly, but [states] that no sacrifice is too great [for] the realization of Marxist ideals, not even the destruction of millions of human lives.” And then it’s back to the old quarrel about quantum mechanics. (See Born’s comment below.) Princeton, 15 September 1950Dear Born,… People such as your Bolshevik doctor come by their fantastic attitude as a result of their objection to the harshness, injustice and absurdity of our own social order (escape from reality). If he happened to be living in Russia, no doubt he would be a rebel there as well, only in that case he would take care not to tell you about it. Nevertheless it seems to me that our own people here [in the US] make an even worse job of their foreign policy than the Russians. And the idiotic public can be talked into anything. And they really are very shortsighted, for technological superiority is transitory, and if it comes to an all-out conflict, the decisive factor is sheer numerical superiority.There is nothing analogous in relativity to what I call incompleteness of description in the quantum theory. Briefly it is because the ψ-function is incapable of describing certain qualities of an individual system, whose “reality” none of us doubt (such as a microscopic parameter). Take a (macroscopic) body that can rotate freely about an axis. Its state is fully determined by an angle. Let the initial conditions (angle and angular momentum) be defined as precisely as the quantum theory allows. The Schrödinger equation then gives the ψ-function for any subsequent time interval. If this is sufficiently large, all angles become (in practice) equally probable. But if an observation is made (e.g. by flashing a torch), a definite angle is found (with sufficient accuracy). This does not prove that the angle had a definite value before it was observed—but we believe this to be the case, because we are committed to the requirements of reality on the macroscopic scale. Thus, the ψ-function does not express the real state of affairs perfectly in this case. This is what I call “incomplete description.”So far, you may not object. But you will probably take the position that a complete description would be useless because there is no mathematical relationship for such a case. I do not say that I am able to disprove this view. But my instinct tells me that a complete formulation of the relationships is tied up with complete description of its factual state. I am convinced of this although, up to now, success is against it. I also believe that the current formulation is true in the same sense as e.g. thermodynamics, i.e. as far as the concepts used are inadequate. I do not expect to convince you, or anybody else. I just want you to understand the way I think.I see from … your letter that you, too, take the quantum theoretical description as incomplete (referring to an ensemble). But you are, after all, convinced that no (complete) laws exist for a complete description, according to the positivistic maxim: esse est percipi [to be is to be perceived]. Well, this is a programmatic attitude, not knowledge. This is where our attitudes really differ. For the time being, I am alone in my views—as Leibniz was with respect to the absolute space of Newton’s theory.… I have not changed my attitude to the Germans, which, by the way, dates not just from the Nazi period. All human beings are more or less the same from birth. The Germans, however, have a far more dangerous tradition than any of the other so-called civilized nations.Kind regards,Yours,A. E. Born’s 1969 comment: 1 1. M. Born, The Born–Einstein Letters 1916–1955: Friendship, Politics and Physics in Uncertain Times, Macmillan, New York (2005), p. 184 Original letter © Hebrew University of Jerusalem. This is probably the clearest presentation of Einstein’s philosophy of reality. … He calls my way of describing the physical world “incomplete.” In his eyes, that is a flaw which he hopes to see removed, while I am prepared to put up with it. I have in fact always regarded it as a step forward, because an exact description of the state of a physical system presupposes that one can make statements of infinite precision about it, and this seems absurd to me. REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<CITING ARTICLES1. M. Born, The Born–Einstein Letters 1916–1955: Friendship, Politics and Physics in Uncertain Times, Macmillan, New York (2005), p. 184 Original letter © Hebrew University of Jerusalem. Google Scholar© 2005 American Institute of Physics.