Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Nature

Grandfather paradox

Ian Stewart

Published Apr 1, 2010• 4 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1038/4641398a

Related papers

Escape From Paradox

Anatol Rapoport

Scientific American•Jul 1, 1967•86 citations

The Grandfather Paradox from a Quantum Mechanics and Temporal Causality Perspective

Alan Alejandro Hoyos Rodriguez

This document proposes an ontological framework dependent on observation to address the paradox of the grandfather. Unlike the principles of self-consistency or the interpretations of many worlds, the proposed model denies the existence of unobserved worlds and treats observation as an ontologically creative act. Temporal events that lack observation do not have a defined truth value, avoiding causal contradiction without invoking determinism or ontological proliferation. By integrating modal temporal logic with an observation operator, the paradox dissolves without restricting the agency or assuming pre-existing parallel realities. The framework also has interdisciplinary relevance for causal reconstruction and fact-determination.

•Dec 30, 2025•0 citations

Twin paradox

Physics World•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Transition Matrices and Time Travel

Hwee Kuan Lee

It has been proven by Lee [1] that the grandfather paradox and Deutsch's unproven paradox are precluded for twoand three-state graphical models. We prove that both paradoxes are also precluded for a general n-state model. In addition, we present a new time travel paradox in this paper.

Physics Procedia•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

Proposed Solutions of the Paradox

Alexander Afriat, F. Selleri

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1999•5 citations

How many noisy time machines does it take to make a grandfather paradox?

Zongmin Liu

General relativity admits closed timelike curves, and quantum mechanics on such a loop is widely believed to defuse the grandfather paradox: in the postselected (P-CTC) model, paradoxical histories are simply assigned probability zero. Here we turn that belief into a sharp, quantitative question. We show that the Doeblin information governing the retrocausal capacity of a noisy quantum channel [Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.\ \textbf{136}, 230801 (2026)] has a dual description as the \emph{minimal loop amplitude}: the smallest total probability that any legal intervention can leave on a time loop built from that channel. A grandfather paradox is realizable precisely when this amplitude can be driven to zero. This yields a new invariant of a quantum channel --- its \emph{paradox number} $n_0$, the number of independent time loops needed before some entangled intervention annihilates every consistent history. We prove that any channel with full Choi rank has $n_0=\infty$ (decoherence protects chronology, no matter how many machines are stacked), that ideal machines have $n_0=1$, and, for the experimentally central amplitude-damping (photon-loss) channel, we solve the problem exactly: $n_0(\gamma)=\lceil \ln 2/\ln(1+\sqrt{1-\gamma})\rceil$, a staircase whose first step is the algebraic threshold $\gamma^*=2(\sqrt2-1)$. Equivalently, each loop of transmissivity $\eta$ contributes $\log_2(1+\sqrt{\eta})$ bits toward the single bit that a paradox costs. The proofs are constructive on both sides, and they resolve, for this channel family, the regularization problem left open for the retrocausal capacity.

•Jul 20, 2026•0 citations
This document proposes an ontological framework dependent on observation to address the paradox of the grandfather. Unlike the principles of self-consistency or the interpretations of many worlds, the proposed model denies the existence of unobserved worlds and treats observation as an ontologically creative act. Temporal events that lack observation do not have a defined truth value, avoiding causal contradiction without invoking determinism or ontological proliferation. By integrating modal temporal logic with an observation operator, the paradox dissolves without restricting the agency or assuming pre-existing parallel realities. The framework also has interdisciplinary relevance for causal reconstruction and fact-determination.
General relativity admits closed timelike curves, and quantum mechanics on such a loop is widely believed to defuse the grandfather paradox: in the postselected (P-CTC) model, paradoxical histories are simply assigned probability zero. Here we turn that belief into a sharp, quantitative question. We show that the Doeblin information governing the retrocausal capacity of a noisy quantum channel [Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.\ \textbf{136}, 230801 (2026)] has a dual description as the \emph{minimal loop amplitude}: the smallest total probability that any legal intervention can leave on a time loop built from that channel. A grandfather paradox is realizable precisely when this amplitude can be driven to zero. This yields a new invariant of a quantum channel --- its \emph{paradox number} n0n_0n0​, the number of independent time loops needed before some entangled intervention annihilates every consistent history. We prove that any channel with full Choi rank has n0=∞n_0=\inftyn0​=∞ (decoherence protects chronology, no matter how many machines are stacked), that ideal machines have n0=1n_0=1n0​=1, and, for the experimentally central amplitude-damping (photon-loss) channel, we solve the problem exactly: n0(γ)=⌈ln⁡2/ln⁡(1+1−γ)⌉n_0(\gamma)=\lceil \ln 2/\ln(1+\sqrt{1-\gamma})\rceiln0​(γ)=⌈ln2/ln(1+1−γ​)⌉, a staircase whose first step is the algebraic threshold γ∗=2(2−1)\gamma^*=2(\sqrt2-1)γ∗=2(2​−1). Equivalently, each loop of transmissivity η\etaη contributes log⁡2(1+η)\log_2(1+\sqrt{\eta})log2​(1+η​) bits toward the single bit that a paradox costs. The proofs are constructive on both sides, and they resolve, for this channel family, the regularization problem left open for the retrocausal capacity.