Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

How many noisy time machines does it take to make a grandfather paradox?

Zongmin Liu

Published Jul 20, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

General relativity admits closed timelike curves, and quantum mechanics on such a loop is widely believed to defuse the grandfather paradox: in the postselected (P-CTC) model, paradoxical histories are simply assigned probability zero. Here we turn that belief into a sharp, quantitative question. We show that the Doeblin information governing the retrocausal capacity of a noisy quantum channel [Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.\ \textbf{136}, 230801 (2026)] has a dual description as the \emph{minimal loop amplitude}: the smallest total probability that any legal intervention can leave on a time loop built from that channel. A grandfather paradox is realizable precisely when this amplitude can be driven to zero. This yields a new invariant of a quantum channel --- its \emph{paradox number} $n_0$, the number of independent time loops needed before some entangled intervention annihilates every consistent history. We prove that any channel with full Choi rank has $n_0=\infty$ (decoherence protects chronology, no matter how many machines are stacked), that ideal machines have $n_0=1$, and, for the experimentally central amplitude-damping (photon-loss) channel, we solve the problem exactly: $n_0(\gamma)=\lceil \ln 2/\ln(1+\sqrt{1-\gamma})\rceil$, a staircase whose first step is the algebraic threshold $\gamma^*=2(\sqrt2-1)$. Equivalently, each loop of transmissivity $\eta$ contributes $\log_2(1+\sqrt{\eta})$ bits toward the single bit that a paradox costs. The proofs are constructive on both sides, and they resolve, for this channel family, the regularization problem left open for the retrocausal capacity.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.21843789

Related papers

Retrocausal Capacity of a Quantum Channel: Communicating through Noisy Closed Timelike Curves

Kaiyuan Ji, Seth Lloyd, Mark M. Wilde

We study the capacity of a quantum channel for retrocausal communication, where messages are transmitted backward in time, from a sender in the future to a receiver in the past, through a noisy postselected closed timelike curve mathematically represented by the channel. We completely characterize the one-shot retrocausal quantum and classical capacities, and we show that the corresponding asymptotic capacities are equal to the average and sum, respectively, of the channel's max-information and its regularized Doeblin information. This endows these information measures with a novel operational interpretation. Furthermore, our characterization can be generalized beyond quantum channels to all completely positive maps. This imposes information-theoretic limits on transmitting messages via postselected-teleportation-like mechanisms with arbitrary initial- and final-state boundary conditions, including those considered in various black-hole final-state models.

arXiv:2509.08965•Physical Review Letters•Apr 14, 2026•3 citations

Simulation of Closed Timelike Curves in a Darwinian Approach to Quantum Mechanics

Carlos Baladrón, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Closed timelike curves (CTCs) are non-intuitive theoretical solutions of general relativity field equations. The main paradox associated with the physical existence of CTCs, the so-called grandfather paradox, can be satisfactorily solved by a quantum model named Deutsch-CTC. An outstanding theoretical result that has been demonstrated in the Deutsch-CTC model is the computational equivalence of a classical and a quantum computer in the presence of a CTC. In this article, in order to explore the possible implications for the foundations of quantum mechanics of that equivalence, a fundamental particle is modelled as a classical-like system supplemented with an information space in which a randomizer and a classical Turing machine are stored. The particle could then generate quantum behavior in real time in case it was controlled by a classical algorithm coding the rules of quantum mechanics and, in addition, a logical circuit simulating a CTC was present on its information space. The conditions that, through the action of evolution under natural selection, might produce a population of such particles with both elements on their information spaces from initial sheer random behavior are analyzed.

Universe•Jan 22, 2023•3 citations

Quantum causality in closed timelike curves

Sergey M. Korotaev, Evgeniy O. Kiktenko

Abstract Although general relativity allows the existence of closed timelike curves (CTCs), self-consistency problems arise (the ‘grandfather paradox’ among others). It is known that quantum mechanical consideration of the matter formally removes all the paradoxes, but the questions about causal structure remain. On the other hand, the idea of postselected CTCs (P-CTC) in quantum teleportation has know been put forward and experimentally implemented. We consider these problems with the aid of quantum causal analysis, where causality is defined without invoking the time relation. It implements the Cramer principle of weak causality, which admits time reversal in entangled states. We analyze Deutsch CTCs (D-CTC) with different kinds of interactions between the chronology-violating and chronology-respecting particles, with refined inferences about mixedness, quantum/classical correlations, entanglement and thermodynamics in the D-CTC. The main result is that time reversal causality can really exist, however, the final quantum state does not place retrospective constraints on the initial state, instead the final state can influence the state inside the D-CTC. This is effectively the implementation of Novikov self-consistency principle. The P-CTC has radically different properties; in particular, if the initial state was pure, the final state is always pure too. Self-consistency is controlled by the initial state-dependent traversability of the P-CTC.

Physica Scripta•Jun 10, 2015•10 citations

Closed Timelike Curves via Postselection: Theory and Experimental Test of Consistency

Seth Lloyd, Lorenzo Maccone, Raúl García−Patrón +8 more

Closed timelike curves (CTCs) are trajectories in spacetime that effectively travel backwards in time: a test particle following a CTC can interact with its former self in the past. A widely accepted quantum theory of CTCs was proposed by Deutsch. Here we analyze an alternative quantum formulation of CTCs based on teleportation and postselection, and show that it is inequivalent to Deutsch's. The predictions or retrodictions of our theory can be simulated experimentally: we report the results of an experiment illustrating how in our particular theory the "grandfather paradox" is resolved.

arXiv:1005.2219•Physical Review Letters•Jan 27, 2011•173 citations

Paradox Constraining Time Causal Structures: Retrocausal Consistency in Quantum Entanglement

Robinson, Evan

We propose that quantum entanglement, Einstein–Rosen bridges, and post-selected closed timelike curves are interconnected manifestations of a unified causal-consistency mechanism in quantum gravity. In this framework—Paradox-Constraining Time-Causal Structures (PCTCS)—entanglement supplies retrocausal boundary constraints, ER bridges provide geometric connectivity, and P-CTCs eliminate paradoxical histories via post-selection. This model preserves causality without requiring faster-than-light signaling and offers testable predictions in entangled photon experiments and quantum-computer simulations.

•Nov 28, 2025•0 citations

What if we have only one universe and closed timelike curves exist

Minseong Kim

David Deutsch provided us one possible solution to the grandfather paradox, Deutsch's closed timelike curves, or simply Deutsch CTC. Deutsch states that this gives us a tool to test many-worlds (Everettian) hypothesis since Deutsch CTC requires Everettian understanding. This paper explores the possibility of co-existence of Deutsch CTC with contextual/epistemic understanding of quantum mechanics. Then this paper presents the irrelevance hypothesis and the hypothetical application to quantum complexity theory.

•Mar 21, 2016•0 citations
General relativity admits closed timelike curves, and quantum mechanics on such a loop is widely believed to defuse the grandfather paradox: in the postselected (P-CTC) model, paradoxical histories are simply assigned probability zero. Here we turn that belief into a sharp, quantitative question. We show that the Doeblin information governing the retrocausal capacity of a noisy quantum channel [Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.\ \textbf{136}, 230801 (2026)] has a dual description as the \emph{minimal loop amplitude}: the smallest total probability that any legal intervention can leave on a time loop built from that channel. A grandfather paradox is realizable precisely when this amplitude can be driven to zero. This yields a new invariant of a quantum channel --- its \emph{paradox number} n0n_0n0​, the number of independent time loops needed before some entangled intervention annihilates every consistent history. We prove that any channel with full Choi rank has n0=∞n_0=\inftyn0​=∞ (decoherence protects chronology, no matter how many machines are stacked), that ideal machines have n0=1n_0=1n0​=1, and, for the experimentally central amplitude-damping (photon-loss) channel, we solve the problem exactly: n0(γ)=⌈ln⁡2/ln⁡(1+1−γ)⌉n_0(\gamma)=\lceil \ln 2/\ln(1+\sqrt{1-\gamma})\rceiln0​(γ)=⌈ln2/ln(1+1−γ​)⌉, a staircase whose first step is the algebraic threshold γ∗=2(2−1)\gamma^*=2(\sqrt2-1)γ∗=2(2​−1). Equivalently, each loop of transmissivity η\etaη contributes log⁡2(1+η)\log_2(1+\sqrt{\eta})log2​(1+η​) bits toward the single bit that a paradox costs. The proofs are constructive on both sides, and they resolve, for this channel family, the regularization problem left open for the retrocausal capacity.
We study the capacity of a quantum channel for retrocausal communication, where messages are transmitted backward in time, from a sender in the future to a receiver in the past, through a noisy postselected closed timelike curve mathematically represented by the channel. We completely characterize the one-shot retrocausal quantum and classical capacities, and we show that the corresponding asymptotic capacities are equal to the average and sum, respectively, of the channel's max-information and its regularized Doeblin information. This endows these information measures with a novel operational interpretation. Furthermore, our characterization can be generalized beyond quantum channels to all completely positive maps. This imposes information-theoretic limits on transmitting messages via postselected-teleportation-like mechanisms with arbitrary initial- and final-state boundary conditions, including those considered in various black-hole final-state models.
Closed timelike curves (CTCs) are non-intuitive theoretical solutions of general relativity field equations. The main paradox associated with the physical existence of CTCs, the so-called grandfather paradox, can be satisfactorily solved by a quantum model named Deutsch-CTC. An outstanding theoretical result that has been demonstrated in the Deutsch-CTC model is the computational equivalence of a classical and a quantum computer in the presence of a CTC. In this article, in order to explore the possible implications for the foundations of quantum mechanics of that equivalence, a fundamental particle is modelled as a classical-like system supplemented with an information space in which a randomizer and a classical Turing machine are stored. The particle could then generate quantum behavior in real time in case it was controlled by a classical algorithm coding the rules of quantum mechanics and, in addition, a logical circuit simulating a CTC was present on its information space. The conditions that, through the action of evolution under natural selection, might produce a population of such particles with both elements on their information spaces from initial sheer random behavior are analyzed.
Abstract Although general relativity allows the existence of closed timelike curves (CTCs), self-consistency problems arise (the ‘grandfather paradox’ among others). It is known that quantum mechanical consideration of the matter formally removes all the paradoxes, but the questions about causal structure remain. On the other hand, the idea of postselected CTCs (P-CTC) in quantum teleportation has know been put forward and experimentally implemented. We consider these problems with the aid of quantum causal analysis, where causality is defined without invoking the time relation. It implements the Cramer principle of weak causality, which admits time reversal in entangled states. We analyze Deutsch CTCs (D-CTC) with different kinds of interactions between the chronology-violating and chronology-respecting particles, with refined inferences about mixedness, quantum/classical correlations, entanglement and thermodynamics in the D-CTC. The main result is that time reversal causality can really exist, however, the final quantum state does not place retrospective constraints on the initial state, instead the final state can influence the state inside the D-CTC. This is effectively the implementation of Novikov self-consistency principle. The P-CTC has radically different properties; in particular, if the initial state was pure, the final state is always pure too. Self-consistency is controlled by the initial state-dependent traversability of the P-CTC.
Closed timelike curves (CTCs) are trajectories in spacetime that effectively travel backwards in time: a test particle following a CTC can interact with its former self in the past. A widely accepted quantum theory of CTCs was proposed by Deutsch. Here we analyze an alternative quantum formulation of CTCs based on teleportation and postselection, and show that it is inequivalent to Deutsch's. The predictions or retrodictions of our theory can be simulated experimentally: we report the results of an experiment illustrating how in our particular theory the "grandfather paradox" is resolved.
We propose that quantum entanglement, Einstein–Rosen bridges, and post-selected closed timelike curves are interconnected manifestations of a unified causal-consistency mechanism in quantum gravity. In this framework—Paradox-Constraining Time-Causal Structures (PCTCS)—entanglement supplies retrocausal boundary constraints, ER bridges provide geometric connectivity, and P-CTCs eliminate paradoxical histories via post-selection. This model preserves causality without requiring faster-than-light signaling and offers testable predictions in entangled photon experiments and quantum-computer simulations.
David Deutsch provided us one possible solution to the grandfather paradox, Deutsch's closed timelike curves, or simply Deutsch CTC. Deutsch states that this gives us a tool to test many-worlds (Everettian) hypothesis since Deutsch CTC requires Everettian understanding. This paper explores the possibility of co-existence of Deutsch CTC with contextual/epistemic understanding of quantum mechanics. Then this paper presents the irrelevance hypothesis and the hypothetical application to quantum complexity theory.