Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

The Nature of Light

Brian Culshaw

Published Jul 23, 2020• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Chapter 2 : explores the nature of light and the much debated question – should we regard light as an electromagnetic wave (including as a current though a conducting material) or as a particle? The key lies in the fact that (usually) light can be regarded as transmitted as a wave and (usually) light can be regarded as detected as a particle. We explore the implications and conclude that the answer lies in the specific question being asked!

DOI
10.1017/9781316659182.003

Related papers

The Nature of Light

Brian Culshaw

The question ‘is light a ray, a wave or a particle?’ has long fascinated philosophers and has intensified since the concept of the photon first emerged at the beginning of the twentieth century. The pragmatic answer to the question is ‘it depends what you are looking for’ and is really about how best to conceptualise light in particular circumstances. We have already mentioned such distinctions briefly in Chapter 1. This chapter will extend these basic concepts to introduce the material which follows in later chapters.

SPIE eBooks•Oct 5, 2020•0 citations

The Nature of Light

George Asimellis

The very nature of light has been the subject of philosophical consideration since antiquity. As a physical entity, many people have suggested that light has a corpuscular nature, formed of particles, while others have proposed a wave nature instead. Physical entities can be classified as either waves or particles. Waves spread out in space (diffraction), can pass through obstacles, and can be added to other waves (superposition). Particles, on the other hand, move in straight lines due to their inertia unless a force is exerted upon them. If they encounter an obstacle, they simply reverse direction. Light has both properties at the same time! So the questions to ask are: How is light classified? What is light, which we cannot see, but thanks to it, we see?

•Aug 13, 2020•0 citations

Electromagnetic Radiation — A Particle

Edward K. Yeargers

Having just described electromagnetic radiation as a wave, it may seem a bit peculiar to embark on a particle description of that radiation. Perhaps it will help to recall from Chapter 2 that our perception of something depends in part on the means we use to perceive it and that we used a specific experiment (interference) to define the wave property. There is no reason to believe that one human-invented experiment is the only one that can be used to describe electromagnetic radiation. In fact, the Einstein photoelectric effect, described next, is consistent with light being a particle.

CRC Press eBooks•Jan 18, 2018•0 citations

The Photon as a Mass Particle Associated with a Wave

Adnan Salih Al-Ithawi

Neither the pure wave theory nor the pure particle theory can explain the nature of light. Light must be both a particle and a wave. It is a wave because it exhibits interference effects. At the same time, the fact that the photographs contain discrete dots is a direct demonstration that light refuses to be split into units of less than a single photon. We found a general equations that solved all the problems in the current theories for the photon and explained the nature of light by suggesting new hypotheses. According to our results, the photon is a particle which has mass and associated with a wave. The results of the research proved that the refractive index of materials varies with the natural mass of the photon.

International journal of optics and applications•Jan 1, 2015•7 citations

Light and Vacuum: The Wave–Particle Nature of the Light and the Quantum Vacuum. Electromagnetic Theory and Quantum Electrodynamics Beyond the Standard Model

Constantin Meis

"Light and Vacuum presents a synthesis of selected fundamental topics of electromagnetic wave theory and quantum electrodynamics (QED) and analyzes the main theoretical difficulties encountered to ensure a coherent mathematical description of the simultaneous wave–particle nature of light, put in evidence by the experiments. The notion and the role of the quantum vacuum, strongly related to light, are extensively investigated. Classical electrodynamics issued from Maxwell's equations revealed the necessity of introducing the notion of volume for an electromagnetic wave to stand entailing precise values of cut-off wavelengths to account for the shape and dimensions of the surrounding space. Conversely, in QED, light is considered to be composed of point particles disregarding the conceptual question on how the frequency of oscillating electric and magnetic fields may be attributed to a point particle. To conciliate these concepts, the book provides a comprehensive overview of the author's work, including innovative contributions on the quantization of the vector potential amplitude at a single photon state, the non-local simultaneous wave–particle mathematical representation of the photon and finally the quantum vacuum. The purpose of the advanced elaborations is to raise questions, give hints and answers, and finally aspire for further theoretical and experimental studies in order to improve our knowledge and understanding on the real essence of Light and Vacuum. In this new edition, the bibliography has been widely enriched. Improvements have been made to the various chapters, taking into account the actual status of the knowledge in this field."--Publisher's website

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Feb 6, 2017•17 citations

Chapter 2: Quantum mechanics and the Schrödinger equation

Alfio Borzì, Gabriele Ciaramella, M. Sprengel

Scientists and philosophers have debated over the nature of light for thousands of years, and, for much of that time, the argument has been over whether light is made of particles or waves. However, as Einstein wrote, “We have two contradictory pictures of reality [particles and waves]; separately neither of them fully explains the phenomena of light, but together they do.”

Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics eBooks•Jul 6, 2017•1 citation
Chapter 2 : explores the nature of light and the much debated question – should we regard light as an electromagnetic wave (including as a current though a conducting material) or as a particle? The key lies in the fact that (usually) light can be regarded as transmitted as a wave and (usually) light can be regarded as detected as a particle. We explore the implications and conclude that the answer lies in the specific question being asked!
The question ‘is light a ray, a wave or a particle?’ has long fascinated philosophers and has intensified since the concept of the photon first emerged at the beginning of the twentieth century. The pragmatic answer to the question is ‘it depends what you are looking for’ and is really about how best to conceptualise light in particular circumstances. We have already mentioned such distinctions briefly in Chapter 1. This chapter will extend these basic concepts to introduce the material which follows in later chapters.
The very nature of light has been the subject of philosophical consideration since antiquity. As a physical entity, many people have suggested that light has a corpuscular nature, formed of particles, while others have proposed a wave nature instead. Physical entities can be classified as either waves or particles. Waves spread out in space (diffraction), can pass through obstacles, and can be added to other waves (superposition). Particles, on the other hand, move in straight lines due to their inertia unless a force is exerted upon them. If they encounter an obstacle, they simply reverse direction. Light has both properties at the same time! So the questions to ask are: How is light classified? What is light, which we cannot see, but thanks to it, we see?
Having just described electromagnetic radiation as a wave, it may seem a bit peculiar to embark on a particle description of that radiation. Perhaps it will help to recall from Chapter 2 that our perception of something depends in part on the means we use to perceive it and that we used a specific experiment (interference) to define the wave property. There is no reason to believe that one human-invented experiment is the only one that can be used to describe electromagnetic radiation. In fact, the Einstein photoelectric effect, described next, is consistent with light being a particle.
Neither the pure wave theory nor the pure particle theory can explain the nature of light. Light must be both a particle and a wave. It is a wave because it exhibits interference effects. At the same time, the fact that the photographs contain discrete dots is a direct demonstration that light refuses to be split into units of less than a single photon. We found a general equations that solved all the problems in the current theories for the photon and explained the nature of light by suggesting new hypotheses. According to our results, the photon is a particle which has mass and associated with a wave. The results of the research proved that the refractive index of materials varies with the natural mass of the photon.
"Light and Vacuum presents a synthesis of selected fundamental topics of electromagnetic wave theory and quantum electrodynamics (QED) and analyzes the main theoretical difficulties encountered to ensure a coherent mathematical description of the simultaneous wave–particle nature of light, put in evidence by the experiments. The notion and the role of the quantum vacuum, strongly related to light, are extensively investigated. Classical electrodynamics issued from Maxwell's equations revealed the necessity of introducing the notion of volume for an electromagnetic wave to stand entailing precise values of cut-off wavelengths to account for the shape and dimensions of the surrounding space. Conversely, in QED, light is considered to be composed of point particles disregarding the conceptual question on how the frequency of oscillating electric and magnetic fields may be attributed to a point particle. To conciliate these concepts, the book provides a comprehensive overview of the author's work, including innovative contributions on the quantization of the vector potential amplitude at a single photon state, the non-local simultaneous wave–particle mathematical representation of the photon and finally the quantum vacuum. The purpose of the advanced elaborations is to raise questions, give hints and answers, and finally aspire for further theoretical and experimental studies in order to improve our knowledge and understanding on the real essence of Light and Vacuum. In this new edition, the bibliography has been widely enriched. Improvements have been made to the various chapters, taking into account the actual status of the knowledge in this field."--Publisher's website