Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Birkhäuser Boston eBooks

The Infamous Boundary: Seven Decades of Controversy in Quantum Physics

David Wick

Published Jan 1, 1995• 90 citations
Publisher

Abstract

reprinted in the British trade journal Physics World in 1990, three separate and 5 lengthy replies from establishment physicists were printed in subsequent issues. For outsiders, especially scientists who rely on physicist's theories in their own fields, this situation is disquieting. Moreover, many recall their introduction to quantum mechanics as a startling, if not shocking, experience. A molecular biologist related how he had started in theoretical physics but, after hearing the ideology of quantum mechanics, marched straight to the Reg­ istrar's office and switched fields. A colleague recalled how her undergraduate chemistry professor religiously entertained queries from the class - until one day he began with the words: "No questions will be permitted on today's lecture." The topic, of course, was quantum mechanics. My father, an organic chemist at a Midwestern university, also had to give that dreaded annual lecture. Around age 16, I picked up a little book he used to prepare and was perplexed by the author's tone, which seemed apologetic to the point of pleading. It was my first brush with the quantum theory. 6 Eventually, I went to graduate school in physics. By then I had acquired an historical bent, which developed out of an episode in my freshman year in college. To relieve the tedium of the introductory physics course, I set out to understand Einstein's theory of relativity (the so-called Special Theory of 1905, not the later and more difficult General Theory of 1915). This went badly at first.

DOI
10.1007/978-1-4612-5361-7

Related papers

Many-body physics in condensed matter systems

Marco Polini, Mario P. Tosi

This volume collects the lecture notes of an introductory course on the theory of many-body systems, held at the Scuola Normale Superiore di Pisa. It is mainly addressed to fourth and fifth-year undergraduates and to first-year graduates in physics and chemistry. The book is also suitable for researchers in the field wanting to gain a general introductory overview on its modern focal points. Starting from a set of notes first prepared in 1994, which were mainly focused on conduction electrons in metals and semiconductors, these lecture notes are now being reprinted with some major changes and additions in order to provide the reader with an overview of recent developments in the understanding of low-dimensional electron fluids and of confined quantum gases made from bosonic and fermionic atoms and molecules.The book is divided into seven chapters and includes 18 appendices on specialized topics. The introductory chapter illustrates some of the longstanding problems in many-body physics. Chapters 2, 3 and 4 are mainly devoted to topics concerning electron fluids. A formal presentation of the theory of Green's functions and linear response functions for fermions in chapter 2 is followed by a chapter on electron liquids in the normal state and by a further chapter on the magnetism of conduction electrons and strongly correlated electron fluids. Chapter 5 turns to the formal theory of Green's functions and linear response functions for bosons. And finally, Chapters 6 and 7 are on trapped boson gases and on confined fermion gases and gaseous boson-fermion mixtures.

•Oct 1, 2006•4 citations

Quantum Theory without Observers—Part One

Sheldon Goldstein

Since its inception some 70 years ago and despite its extraordinary predictive successes, quantum mechanics has been plagued by conceptual difficulties. Plainly put, the basic problem is this: It is not at all clear what quantum mechanics is about. What, in fact, does quantum mechanics describe?

Physics Today•Mar 1, 1998•201 citations

Beyond Ideology: Epistemological Foundations of Vladimir Fock's approach to Quantum Theory

Jean‐Philippe Martinez

Vladimir Fock was a Soviet theoretical physicist who, from the 1930s, worked to prove that modern physics was compatible with the Marxist philosophy of dialectical materialism. In 1957, he went to Copenhagen, and a dispute over the interpretation of quantum mechanics began with Niels Bohr. Fock later claimed that he had found points of convergence with his Danish colleague, most of them concerning issues of wording and recognition of the reality of the world independently of our mind. It led to a specific narrative among historians of physics on Fock and his interpretation of quantum mechanics: The Soviet physicist is often described as a member of the Copenhagen school that contributed to the rapprochement of the Soviet philosophy of physics with the ideas of complementarity in stripping away the positivism in its formulation. Our contribution aims to show that this ideological dimension was only one aspect of reality. Returning to the foundations of Fock's epistemology of physics, we argue that he relied on the principles of antireductionism and scientific realism to develop an interpretation of the theory that sought to overcome Bohr's approach and that the differences between the two men cannot be reduced to mere questions of formulation.

Berichte zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte•Dec 1, 2019•4 citations

Quantum rules

Jim Baggott

Abstract The development of quantum theory was driven by a consistently repeated failure of classical physics to accommodate the results of ever more sophisticated experiments on the microphysical world of radiation, elementary particles, atoms, and molecules. Each break-through in the development of the theory’s conceptual structure was followed (sometimes very rapidly) by new experimental data that just did not fit, pointing to the need for yet further refinements. As is typical in such a radical change in the approach to acquiring scientific understanding, old and often unsuitable concepts were forced into service to meet the needs of the new description. Confusion reigned. The major figures in the theory’s early development took up radically different positions on the theory’s interpretation, and, as we will see, the debate became polarized in ways that remain relevant today.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Nov 6, 2003•0 citations

Integrating classical and quantum algorithms with machine learning and tensor networks

Abid Khan

This dissertation explores innovative intersections of machine learning (ML) and quantum computing with electron microscopy and quantum simulations, aiming to address and overcome significant challenges in physics and chemistry.First, we introduce a cycle generative adversarial network (CycleGAN) equipped with a reciprocal space discriminator for electron microscopy, which enables the autonomous identification of single atom defects in massive datasets.This method underscores a pivotal advancement towards the automation of materials research by allowing the generation of images that are indistinguishable from real data, thereby facilitating rapid and accurate ML applications in electron microscopy.Furthermore, we delve into the realm of quantum computing to enhance molecular dynamics simulations.By leveraging transfer learning, we train models to predict molecular potential energy surfaces with unprecedented accuracy, utilizing data from Density Functional Theory (DFT) and refining it with output from Variational Quantum Eigensolvers (VQE).This dual-step training I joined The University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (UIUC) as an undergraduate in 2012.I will have departed from this institution in 2024.This twelve-year training to become a computational physicist would not have been possible without the incredible support of the people in my life.My journey into the world of physics research began in the summer after my first year of undergrad under the guidance of Professor Karin Dahmen.Her mentorship introduced me to physics research and instilled the confidence to pursue the field further.In the summer after my sophomore year, I transitioned from analyzing slip statistics in nanocrystals to performing simulations and visualizations of binary black hole mergers, marking the beginning of my work with Professor Stuart Shapiro.For the remaining 3 years of my undergraduate and 2 years into my graduate career, Stu pushed me to limits I did not think I could reach, both as a physicist and a computer scientist, and consistently conveyed to me how impactful my work is to his group and the scientific community.In addition to Stu, I had tremendous support and encouragement from my collaborators Milton Ruiz, Antonios Tsokaros, and Vasileios Paschalidis.My experience working with Stu formed my drive to push and demand more of myself.While in the beginning stages of my graduate career, I was particularly interested in the graduate quantum mechanics course taught by Professor Bryan Clark, who first introduced me to quantum computing and quantum information.That class, more than any other, had my undivided attention, as it was the first time I encountered merging the theory of computation with the theory of physics.With many overlapping interests, Bryan welcomed me into his group, where I began to explore the world of developing and applying classical and quantum algorithms to physics.I was free to pursue all my interests with Bryan, and he entertained all my ideas, no matter how bizarre.During this time, I met many collaborators who have helped me shape my ideas into impactful

•May 20, 2024•0 citations

Fundamental considerations inspired by quantum physics

Anton Zeilinger

I have been interested in quantum mechanics or, synonymously, quantum physics since the very days when I first learned about them as a student. The initial impression was that of an immense mathematical beauty of the formalism of quantum mechanics. The second impression was the fantastic agreement of the theoretical predictions of quantum physics for experiments, and the third and somewhat surprising impression was that there was widespread disagreement about the interpretation of the new theory.

Libreria Editrice Vaticana eBooks•Dec 3, 2025•0 citations
reprinted in the British trade journal Physics World in 1990, three separate and 5 lengthy replies from establishment physicists were printed in subsequent issues. For outsiders, especially scientists who rely on physicist's theories in their own fields, this situation is disquieting. Moreover, many recall their introduction to quantum mechanics as a startling, if not shocking, experience. A molecular biologist related how he had started in theoretical physics but, after hearing the ideology of quantum mechanics, marched straight to the Reg­ istrar's office and switched fields. A colleague recalled how her undergraduate chemistry professor religiously entertained queries from the class - until one day he began with the words: "No questions will be permitted on today's lecture." The topic, of course, was quantum mechanics. My father, an organic chemist at a Midwestern university, also had to give that dreaded annual lecture. Around age 16, I picked up a little book he used to prepare and was perplexed by the author's tone, which seemed apologetic to the point of pleading. It was my first brush with the quantum theory. 6 Eventually, I went to graduate school in physics. By then I had acquired an historical bent, which developed out of an episode in my freshman year in college. To relieve the tedium of the introductory physics course, I set out to understand Einstein's theory of relativity (the so-called Special Theory of 1905, not the later and more difficult General Theory of 1915). This went badly at first.
This volume collects the lecture notes of an introductory course on the theory of many-body systems, held at the Scuola Normale Superiore di Pisa. It is mainly addressed to fourth and fifth-year undergraduates and to first-year graduates in physics and chemistry. The book is also suitable for researchers in the field wanting to gain a general introductory overview on its modern focal points. Starting from a set of notes first prepared in 1994, which were mainly focused on conduction electrons in metals and semiconductors, these lecture notes are now being reprinted with some major changes and additions in order to provide the reader with an overview of recent developments in the understanding of low-dimensional electron fluids and of confined quantum gases made from bosonic and fermionic atoms and molecules.The book is divided into seven chapters and includes 18 appendices on specialized topics. The introductory chapter illustrates some of the longstanding problems in many-body physics. Chapters 2, 3 and 4 are mainly devoted to topics concerning electron fluids. A formal presentation of the theory of Green's functions and linear response functions for fermions in chapter 2 is followed by a chapter on electron liquids in the normal state and by a further chapter on the magnetism of conduction electrons and strongly correlated electron fluids. Chapter 5 turns to the formal theory of Green's functions and linear response functions for bosons. And finally, Chapters 6 and 7 are on trapped boson gases and on confined fermion gases and gaseous boson-fermion mixtures.
Vladimir Fock was a Soviet theoretical physicist who, from the 1930s, worked to prove that modern physics was compatible with the Marxist philosophy of dialectical materialism. In 1957, he went to Copenhagen, and a dispute over the interpretation of quantum mechanics began with Niels Bohr. Fock later claimed that he had found points of convergence with his Danish colleague, most of them concerning issues of wording and recognition of the reality of the world independently of our mind. It led to a specific narrative among historians of physics on Fock and his interpretation of quantum mechanics: The Soviet physicist is often described as a member of the Copenhagen school that contributed to the rapprochement of the Soviet philosophy of physics with the ideas of complementarity in stripping away the positivism in its formulation. Our contribution aims to show that this ideological dimension was only one aspect of reality. Returning to the foundations of Fock's epistemology of physics, we argue that he relied on the principles of antireductionism and scientific realism to develop an interpretation of the theory that sought to overcome Bohr's approach and that the differences between the two men cannot be reduced to mere questions of formulation.
Abstract The development of quantum theory was driven by a consistently repeated failure of classical physics to accommodate the results of ever more sophisticated experiments on the microphysical world of radiation, elementary particles, atoms, and molecules. Each break-through in the development of the theory’s conceptual structure was followed (sometimes very rapidly) by new experimental data that just did not fit, pointing to the need for yet further refinements. As is typical in such a radical change in the approach to acquiring scientific understanding, old and often unsuitable concepts were forced into service to meet the needs of the new description. Confusion reigned. The major figures in the theory’s early development took up radically different positions on the theory’s interpretation, and, as we will see, the debate became polarized in ways that remain relevant today.
This dissertation explores innovative intersections of machine learning (ML) and quantum computing with electron microscopy and quantum simulations, aiming to address and overcome significant challenges in physics and chemistry.First, we introduce a cycle generative adversarial network (CycleGAN) equipped with a reciprocal space discriminator for electron microscopy, which enables the autonomous identification of single atom defects in massive datasets.This method underscores a pivotal advancement towards the automation of materials research by allowing the generation of images that are indistinguishable from real data, thereby facilitating rapid and accurate ML applications in electron microscopy.Furthermore, we delve into the realm of quantum computing to enhance molecular dynamics simulations.By leveraging transfer learning, we train models to predict molecular potential energy surfaces with unprecedented accuracy, utilizing data from Density Functional Theory (DFT) and refining it with output from Variational Quantum Eigensolvers (VQE).This dual-step training I joined The University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (UIUC) as an undergraduate in 2012.I will have departed from this institution in 2024.This twelve-year training to become a computational physicist would not have been possible without the incredible support of the people in my life.My journey into the world of physics research began in the summer after my first year of undergrad under the guidance of Professor Karin Dahmen.Her mentorship introduced me to physics research and instilled the confidence to pursue the field further.In the summer after my sophomore year, I transitioned from analyzing slip statistics in nanocrystals to performing simulations and visualizations of binary black hole mergers, marking the beginning of my work with Professor Stuart Shapiro.For the remaining 3 years of my undergraduate and 2 years into my graduate career, Stu pushed me to limits I did not think I could reach, both as a physicist and a computer scientist, and consistently conveyed to me how impactful my work is to his group and the scientific community.In addition to Stu, I had tremendous support and encouragement from my collaborators Milton Ruiz, Antonios Tsokaros, and Vasileios Paschalidis.My experience working with Stu formed my drive to push and demand more of myself.While in the beginning stages of my graduate career, I was particularly interested in the graduate quantum mechanics course taught by Professor Bryan Clark, who first introduced me to quantum computing and quantum information.That class, more than any other, had my undivided attention, as it was the first time I encountered merging the theory of computation with the theory of physics.With many overlapping interests, Bryan welcomed me into his group, where I began to explore the world of developing and applying classical and quantum algorithms to physics.I was free to pursue all my interests with Bryan, and he entertained all my ideas, no matter how bizarre.During this time, I met many collaborators who have helped me shape my ideas into impactful
I have been interested in quantum mechanics or, synonymously, quantum physics since the very days when I first learned about them as a student. The initial impression was that of an immense mathematical beauty of the formalism of quantum mechanics. The second impression was the fantastic agreement of the theoretical predictions of quantum physics for experiments, and the third and somewhat surprising impression was that there was widespread disagreement about the interpretation of the new theory.