Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Theoretical Aspects of Rationality and Knowledge

Knowledge in quantum systems

Ron van der Meyden, Manas Patra

Published Jan 1, 2003• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

This paper applies to quantum systems a modelling for the logic of knowledge, originally developed for reasoning about distributed systems, but since then applied to game theory, computer security and artificial intelligence. A formal model of quantum message passing systems is developed and the question of how one might define the semantics of a modal operator for knowledge in this model is considered. It is argued that there are at least two plausible semantics, depending on whether the agents are permitted to make use of their quantum state in determining what they know, and on whether one is dealing with single instances of quantum systems, or ensembles. The framework is illustrated using a number of examples from the quantum computing literature, including protocols for quantum key distribution and teleportation.

DOI
10.1145/846255.846257

Related papers

Knowledge in quantum systems

Ron van der Meyden, Manas K. Patra

This paper applies to quantum systems a modelling for the logic of knowledge, originally developed for reasoning about distributed systems, but since then applied to game theory, computer security and artificial intelligence. A formal model of quantum message passing systems is developed and the question of how one might define the semantics of a modal operator for knowledge in this model is considered. It is argued that there are at least two plausible semantics, depending on whether the agents are permitted to make use of their quantum state in determining what they know, and on whether one is dealing with single instances of quantum systems, or ensembles. The framework is illustrated using a number of examples from the quantum computing literature, including protocols for quantum key distribution and teleportation.

Theoretical Aspects of Rationality and Knowledge•Jun 20, 2003•20 citations

Reasoning about quantum knowledge

Ellie D’Hondt, Prakash Panangaden

We construct a formal framework for investigating epistemic and temporal notions in the context of distributed quantum computation. While we rely on structures developed earlier, we stress that our notion of quantum knowledge makes sense more generally in any agent-based model for distributed quantum systems. Several arguments are given to support our view that an agent's possibility relation should not be based on the reduced density matrix, but rather on local classical states and local quantum operations. In this way, we are able to analyse distributed primitives such as superdense coding and teleportation, obtaining interesting conclusions as to how the knowledge of individual agents evolves. We show explicitly that the knowledge transfer in teleportation is essentially classical, in that eventually, the receiving agent knows that its state is equal to the initial state of the sender. The relevant epistemic statements for teleportation deal with this correlation rather than with the actual quantum state, which is unknown throughout the protocol.

arXiv:quant-ph/0507176•Jul 19, 2005•3 citations

Classical Knowledge for Quantum Cryptographic Reasoning

Vincent Danos, Ellie D’Hondt

We prove that quantum key distribution is secure against several types of attacks within the framework of classical knowledge knowledge for quantum systems, a formal model which was developed in [D'Hondt, E. and P. Panangaden, Reasoning about quantum knowledge, in: Proceedings of the 25th Conference on Foundations of Software Technology and Theoretical Computer Science, LNCS 3821, 2005, p. 0544c (to appear), quant-ph/0507176]. In particular we rephrase security as a logical property and use meta-logic reasoning on the finite state machine corresponding to the quantum key distribution protocol. While these security issues have been studied before, it is the logical-based approach that is original here.

Electronic Notes in Theoretical Computer Science•Nov 1, 2008•3 citations

Quantum teleportation and quantum epistemic semantics

Enrico G. Beltrametti, Maria L. Dalla Chiara, Roberto Giuntini +1 more

Abstract Quantum information gives rise to some puzzling epistemic problems that can be interestingly investigated from a logical point of view. A characteristic example is represented by teleportation phenomena, where knowledge and actions of observers (epistemic agents) play a relevant role. By abstracting from teleportation, we propose a simplified semantics for a language that consists of two parts: 1)the quantum computational sub-language, whose sentences α represent pieces of quantum information (which are supposed to be stored by some quantum systems)2)the classical epistemic sub-language, whose atomic sentences have the following forms: agent a has a probabilistic information about the sentence α; agent a knows the sentence α. Interestingly enough, some conceptual difficulties of standard epistemic logics can be avoided in this framework.

Mathematica Slovaca•Dec 1, 2012•12 citations

Classical Knowledge for Quantum Security

Ellie D’Hondt, Mehrnoosh Sadrzadeh

We propose a decision procedure for analysing security of quantum cryptographic protocols, combining an algebraic logic rewrite system with an operational semantics for quantum distributed computations. We apply our approach to reasoning about security properties of a recently developed quantum secret sharing protocol.

Electronic Notes in Theoretical Computer Science•Feb 1, 2011•2 citations

Fitch's knowability axioms are incompatible with quantum theory

Patrick Thomas Fraser, Nuriya Nurgalieva, Lídia del Rio

How can we consistently model the knowledge of the natural world provided by physical theories? Philosophers frequently use epistemic logic to model reasoning and knowledge abstractly, and to formally study the ramifications of epistemic assumptions. One famous example is Fitch's paradox, which begins with minimal knowledge axioms and derives the counter-intuitive result that agent knows every true statement. Accounting for knowledge that arises from physical theories complicates matters further. For example, quantum mechanics allows observers to model other agents as quantum systems themselves, and to make predictions about measurements performed on each others' memories. Moreover, complex thought experiments in which agents' memories are modelled as quantum systems show that multi-agent reasoning chains can yield paradoxical results. Here, we bridge the gap between quantum paradoxes and foundational problems in epistemic logic, by relating the assumptions behind the recent Frauchiger-Renner quantum thought experiment and the axioms for knowledge used in Fitch's knowability paradox. Our results indicate that agents' knowledge of quantum systems must violate at least one of the following assumptions: it cannot be distributive over conjunction, have a kind of internal continuity, and yield a constructive interpretation all at once. Indeed, knowledge provided by quantum mechanics apparently contradicts traditional notions of how knowledge behaves; for instance, it may not be possible to universally assign objective truth values to claims about agent knowledge. We discuss the relations of this work to results in quantum contextuality and explore possible modifications to standard epistemic logic that could make it consistent with quantum theory.

•Sep 1, 2020•2 citations
This paper applies to quantum systems a modelling for the logic of knowledge, originally developed for reasoning about distributed systems, but since then applied to game theory, computer security and artificial intelligence. A formal model of quantum message passing systems is developed and the question of how one might define the semantics of a modal operator for knowledge in this model is considered. It is argued that there are at least two plausible semantics, depending on whether the agents are permitted to make use of their quantum state in determining what they know, and on whether one is dealing with single instances of quantum systems, or ensembles. The framework is illustrated using a number of examples from the quantum computing literature, including protocols for quantum key distribution and teleportation.
This paper applies to quantum systems a modelling for the logic of knowledge, originally developed for reasoning about distributed systems, but since then applied to game theory, computer security and artificial intelligence. A formal model of quantum message passing systems is developed and the question of how one might define the semantics of a modal operator for knowledge in this model is considered. It is argued that there are at least two plausible semantics, depending on whether the agents are permitted to make use of their quantum state in determining what they know, and on whether one is dealing with single instances of quantum systems, or ensembles. The framework is illustrated using a number of examples from the quantum computing literature, including protocols for quantum key distribution and teleportation.
We construct a formal framework for investigating epistemic and temporal notions in the context of distributed quantum computation. While we rely on structures developed earlier, we stress that our notion of quantum knowledge makes sense more generally in any agent-based model for distributed quantum systems. Several arguments are given to support our view that an agent's possibility relation should not be based on the reduced density matrix, but rather on local classical states and local quantum operations. In this way, we are able to analyse distributed primitives such as superdense coding and teleportation, obtaining interesting conclusions as to how the knowledge of individual agents evolves. We show explicitly that the knowledge transfer in teleportation is essentially classical, in that eventually, the receiving agent knows that its state is equal to the initial state of the sender. The relevant epistemic statements for teleportation deal with this correlation rather than with the actual quantum state, which is unknown throughout the protocol.
We prove that quantum key distribution is secure against several types of attacks within the framework of classical knowledge knowledge for quantum systems, a formal model which was developed in [D'Hondt, E. and P. Panangaden, Reasoning about quantum knowledge, in: Proceedings of the 25th Conference on Foundations of Software Technology and Theoretical Computer Science, LNCS 3821, 2005, p. 0544c (to appear), quant-ph/0507176]. In particular we rephrase security as a logical property and use meta-logic reasoning on the finite state machine corresponding to the quantum key distribution protocol. While these security issues have been studied before, it is the logical-based approach that is original here.
Abstract Quantum information gives rise to some puzzling epistemic problems that can be interestingly investigated from a logical point of view. A characteristic example is represented by teleportation phenomena, where knowledge and actions of observers (epistemic agents) play a relevant role. By abstracting from teleportation, we propose a simplified semantics for a language that consists of two parts: 1)the quantum computational sub-language, whose sentences α represent pieces of quantum information (which are supposed to be stored by some quantum systems)2)the classical epistemic sub-language, whose atomic sentences have the following forms: agent a has a probabilistic information about the sentence α; agent a knows the sentence α. Interestingly enough, some conceptual difficulties of standard epistemic logics can be avoided in this framework.
How can we consistently model the knowledge of the natural world provided by physical theories? Philosophers frequently use epistemic logic to model reasoning and knowledge abstractly, and to formally study the ramifications of epistemic assumptions. One famous example is Fitch's paradox, which begins with minimal knowledge axioms and derives the counter-intuitive result that agent knows every true statement. Accounting for knowledge that arises from physical theories complicates matters further. For example, quantum mechanics allows observers to model other agents as quantum systems themselves, and to make predictions about measurements performed on each others' memories. Moreover, complex thought experiments in which agents' memories are modelled as quantum systems show that multi-agent reasoning chains can yield paradoxical results. Here, we bridge the gap between quantum paradoxes and foundational problems in epistemic logic, by relating the assumptions behind the recent Frauchiger-Renner quantum thought experiment and the axioms for knowledge used in Fitch's knowability paradox. Our results indicate that agents' knowledge of quantum systems must violate at least one of the following assumptions: it cannot be distributive over conjunction, have a kind of internal continuity, and yield a constructive interpretation all at once. Indeed, knowledge provided by quantum mechanics apparently contradicts traditional notions of how knowledge behaves; for instance, it may not be possible to universally assign objective truth values to claims about agent knowledge. We discuss the relations of this work to results in quantum contextuality and explore possible modifications to standard epistemic logic that could make it consistent with quantum theory.