Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC (EUROPE) eBooks

Beyond Complementarity

Ruth E. Kastner

Published Apr 14, 2019• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

It is argued that Niels Bohr ultimately arrived at positivistic and antirealist-flavored statements because of weaknesses in his initial objective of accounting for measurement in physical terms. Bohr’s investigative approach faced a dilemma, the choices being (i) conceptual inconsistency or (ii) taking the classical realm as primitive. In either case, Bohr’s “Complementarity” does not adequately explain or account for the emergence of a macroscopic, classical domain from a microscopic domain described by quantum mechanics. A diagnosis of the basic problem is offered, and an alternative way forward is indicated.

DOI
10.1142/9781786346421_0014

Related papers

Beyond Complementarity

Ruth E. Kastner

It is argued that Niels Bohr ultimately arrived at positivistic and antirealist-flavored statements because of weaknesses in his initial objective of accounting for measurement in physical terms. Bohr's investigative approach faced a dilemma, the choices being (i) conceptual inconsistency or (ii) taking the classical realm as primitive. In either case, Bohr's `Complementarity' does not adequately explain or account for the emergence of a macroscopic, classical domain from a microscopic domain described by quantum mechanics. A diagnosis of the basic problem is offered, and an alternative way forward is indicated.

arXiv:1601.07545•WORLD SCIENTIFIC (EUROPE) eBooks•Nov 14, 2016•2 citations

On Bohr’s Epistemological Contribution to the Quantum-Classical Cut Problems

Manuel Bächtold

Although microscopic systems are described by means of quantum mechanics, the outcomes obtained when performing measurements on such systems “appear” to us as being “classical” (Giulini et al. 2003). This situation is puzzling. How does the classical appearance of these measurement outcomes emerge (problem A)? And why, after all, couldn’t we describe these measurement outcomes by means of quantummechanics (problem B)? Problem A can be tackled within the domain of physics. As a matter of fact, it has been partly solved by means of decoherence theory (Zurek 1981, 1982, 1991; Blanchard et al. 2000; Joos et al. 2003). Problem B falls under the competency of epistemology, as it deals with the respective role of classical physics and quantum mechanics. Concerning this topic of the quantum- classical cut, the contribution of Bohr and especially his thesis of the necessary use of classical concepts have been very influential during the twentieth century. Many scholars in the past have examined Bohr’s writings concerning this thesis (Folse 1985; Honner 1987; Murdoch 1987; Faye 1991; Chevalley 1991; Scheibe 1993). Recently, this thesis has been discussed in relation to decoherence theory. More precisely, Camilleri and Schlosshauer (2015) asked if Bohr’s thesis is challenged by decoherence theory. Their inquiry leads them to conclude that this is not the case. In other words, Bohr’s viewis still defendable. This chapter aims at showing that Bohr’s view is not only defendable but can throw light on the problems associated with the quantum- classical cut. First, I will recall that Bohr’s way of dealing with this cut is not ontological but epistemological. I will then put forward four conceptual distinctions and argue that those are essential to understand and discuss Bohr’s thesis of the necessary use of classical concepts. Finally, on the basis of this clarification, the relation between Bohr’s thesis and decoherence theory will be discussed.

Bloomsbury Academic eBooks•Jan 1, 2017•4 citations

Language and Mind

T. Bergstein

Among philosophers in particular the principle of complementarity has been considered an unreasonable limitation of natural science, and Niels Bohr’s exposition of the inevitability of a statistical description when accounting for atomic phenomena has been regarded as a renouncement directly opposed to the very spirit of scientific investigation. Indeed, fundamental limitations in the range of applicability of the causal spacetime description of physical phenomena do exist, but quantum physics is precisely the generalization of the conceptual frame of classical physics which has converted these limitations into a springboard for investigations which are among the most fruitful in the history of science. Far from raising a barrier for scientific investigation, quantum physics has extended the scope of natural science to a degree that was unimaginable before its advent. Natural science now encompasses such different objects as the constituents of atoms, processes in remote galaxies, and psycho-chemical phenomena in man. Biochemistry and psychopharmacology, for instance, both rely on one of the most important results of quantum physics: the periodical system of the elements, which is fundamental to all modern chemistry. Furthermore atomic physics and chemistry are basic sciences for technology and thus contribute to the continuous development of instruments of observation for all branches of natural science.

•Jan 1, 1972•0 citations

Transcendental Approaches to Quantum Mechanics. Lessons from Bohr

Harald A. Wiltsche, Romanian Society for Phenomenology

The objective of this paper is to offer an analysis of several key elements within Niels Bohr’s transcendental interpretation of quantum mechanics. After some stage setting, I will demonstrate that a transcendental perspective on Bohr offers several advantages over alternative interpretations. Specifically, I will argue that some of his most contentious claims become more plausible when viewed through a transcendental lens. However, despite these strengths, Bohr’s approach faces challenges. Following an evaluation of what I consider to be the primary weakness in his framework, the final section of the paper will explore potential avenues for enhancing the viability of the Bohrian project, with a specific focus on the role of phenomenology as a potential solution.

Studia Phaenomenologica•Jan 1, 2024•1 citation

The lesson of quantum theory : Niels Bohr Centenary Symposium, October 3-7, 1985

Jorrit de Boer, Erik Dal, Ole Ulfbeck +1 more

Part I. Niels Bohr. Communications delivered to the Royal Danish Academy of sciences and letters, October 3, 1985 (edited by E. Dal). Niels Bohr and The Royal Danish Academy of Sciences and Letters (B. Strmgren). Epistemological considerations (H.B.G. Casimir). Part II. The Lesson of Quantum Theory. Proceedings of the Niels Bohr centenary symposium, October 4-7, 1985 (edited by J. de Boer and O. Ulfbeck). The Lesson of Quantum Theory. Measurement in quantum theory and the problem of complex systems (P.W. Anderson). Quantum mechanics at the macroscopic level (A.J. Leggett). Strange quantum numbers in condensed matter and field theory (J.R. Schrieffer). The study of the nucleus as a theme in contemporary physics (B.R. Mottelson). ``Complementarity'' between energy and temperature (J. Lindhard). Radiation by uniformly moving sources (V.L. Ginzburg). Does elementary particle physics have a future? (S.L. Glashow). Observability of quarks (J.D. Bojrken). The transformation of elementary particle physics into many-body physics (L. Van Hove). Physics in terms of difference equations (T.D. Lee). Some lessons of renormalization theory (A.S. Wightman). Particles, fields and now strings (S. Weinberg). Collective and planetary motion in atoms (R.S. Berry). Unity of Knowledge. The origin and evolution of large-scale structure in the universe (W.L.W. Sargent). Molecular replication and the origins of life (L.E. Orgel). Physics, biological computation and complementarity (J.J. Hopfield). Complementarity in linguistic observation, description and explanation (W.U. Dressler). Niels Bohr. Great connections come alive: Bohr, Ehrenfest and Einstein (M.J. Klein). Niels Bohr and nuclear weapons (M. Gowing). Niels Bohr: The man and his legacy (J.A. Wheeler). Mellem Spog og Alvor: Personal recollections about Niels Bohr (H.B.G. Casimir). Part III. Jest and Earnest. AAddresses presented at the evening gathering in Ny Carlsberg Glyptoteket, October 7, 1985. (edited by J. de Boer and O. Ulfbeck). Parentesen (A. Aaboe). Truth and clarity (R. Peierls). Niels Bohr, the quantum and the world (V.F. Weisskopf).

•Jan 1, 1986•4 citations

Knowledge and Description: Bohr's Epistemology

John T. Sanders

In this paper, I try to explain the philosophical problems that Niels Bohr felt had been exposed by the discovery of the "quantum of action," and by the emergence of the quantum theory that arose in large part as a result of his efforts. I won't have space to make the case adequately here, but my own view is that we have not yet fully digested the message brought to us by Bohr's "Copenhagen Interpretation" of Quantum Mechanics, and I suspect that it will finally prove to be every bit as revolutionary as Bohr thought it was.

•Jan 1, 1998•0 citations
It is argued that Niels Bohr ultimately arrived at positivistic and antirealist-flavored statements because of weaknesses in his initial objective of accounting for measurement in physical terms. Bohr’s investigative approach faced a dilemma, the choices being (i) conceptual inconsistency or (ii) taking the classical realm as primitive. In either case, Bohr’s “Complementarity” does not adequately explain or account for the emergence of a macroscopic, classical domain from a microscopic domain described by quantum mechanics. A diagnosis of the basic problem is offered, and an alternative way forward is indicated.
It is argued that Niels Bohr ultimately arrived at positivistic and antirealist-flavored statements because of weaknesses in his initial objective of accounting for measurement in physical terms. Bohr's investigative approach faced a dilemma, the choices being (i) conceptual inconsistency or (ii) taking the classical realm as primitive. In either case, Bohr's `Complementarity' does not adequately explain or account for the emergence of a macroscopic, classical domain from a microscopic domain described by quantum mechanics. A diagnosis of the basic problem is offered, and an alternative way forward is indicated.
Although microscopic systems are described by means of quantum mechanics, the outcomes obtained when performing measurements on such systems “appear” to us as being “classical” (Giulini et al. 2003). This situation is puzzling. How does the classical appearance of these measurement outcomes emerge (problem A)? And why, after all, couldn’t we describe these measurement outcomes by means of quantummechanics (problem B)? Problem A can be tackled within the domain of physics. As a matter of fact, it has been partly solved by means of decoherence theory (Zurek 1981, 1982, 1991; Blanchard et al. 2000; Joos et al. 2003). Problem B falls under the competency of epistemology, as it deals with the respective role of classical physics and quantum mechanics. Concerning this topic of the quantum- classical cut, the contribution of Bohr and especially his thesis of the necessary use of classical concepts have been very influential during the twentieth century. Many scholars in the past have examined Bohr’s writings concerning this thesis (Folse 1985; Honner 1987; Murdoch 1987; Faye 1991; Chevalley 1991; Scheibe 1993). Recently, this thesis has been discussed in relation to decoherence theory. More precisely, Camilleri and Schlosshauer (2015) asked if Bohr’s thesis is challenged by decoherence theory. Their inquiry leads them to conclude that this is not the case. In other words, Bohr’s viewis still defendable. This chapter aims at showing that Bohr’s view is not only defendable but can throw light on the problems associated with the quantum- classical cut. First, I will recall that Bohr’s way of dealing with this cut is not ontological but epistemological. I will then put forward four conceptual distinctions and argue that those are essential to understand and discuss Bohr’s thesis of the necessary use of classical concepts. Finally, on the basis of this clarification, the relation between Bohr’s thesis and decoherence theory will be discussed.
Among philosophers in particular the principle of complementarity has been considered an unreasonable limitation of natural science, and Niels Bohr’s exposition of the inevitability of a statistical description when accounting for atomic phenomena has been regarded as a renouncement directly opposed to the very spirit of scientific investigation. Indeed, fundamental limitations in the range of applicability of the causal spacetime description of physical phenomena do exist, but quantum physics is precisely the generalization of the conceptual frame of classical physics which has converted these limitations into a springboard for investigations which are among the most fruitful in the history of science. Far from raising a barrier for scientific investigation, quantum physics has extended the scope of natural science to a degree that was unimaginable before its advent. Natural science now encompasses such different objects as the constituents of atoms, processes in remote galaxies, and psycho-chemical phenomena in man. Biochemistry and psychopharmacology, for instance, both rely on one of the most important results of quantum physics: the periodical system of the elements, which is fundamental to all modern chemistry. Furthermore atomic physics and chemistry are basic sciences for technology and thus contribute to the continuous development of instruments of observation for all branches of natural science.
The objective of this paper is to offer an analysis of several key elements within Niels Bohr’s transcendental interpretation of quantum mechanics. After some stage setting, I will demonstrate that a transcendental perspective on Bohr offers several advantages over alternative interpretations. Specifically, I will argue that some of his most contentious claims become more plausible when viewed through a transcendental lens. However, despite these strengths, Bohr’s approach faces challenges. Following an evaluation of what I consider to be the primary weakness in his framework, the final section of the paper will explore potential avenues for enhancing the viability of the Bohrian project, with a specific focus on the role of phenomenology as a potential solution.
Part I. Niels Bohr. Communications delivered to the Royal Danish Academy of sciences and letters, October 3, 1985 (edited by E. Dal). Niels Bohr and The Royal Danish Academy of Sciences and Letters (B. Strmgren). Epistemological considerations (H.B.G. Casimir). Part II. The Lesson of Quantum Theory. Proceedings of the Niels Bohr centenary symposium, October 4-7, 1985 (edited by J. de Boer and O. Ulfbeck). The Lesson of Quantum Theory. Measurement in quantum theory and the problem of complex systems (P.W. Anderson). Quantum mechanics at the macroscopic level (A.J. Leggett). Strange quantum numbers in condensed matter and field theory (J.R. Schrieffer). The study of the nucleus as a theme in contemporary physics (B.R. Mottelson). ``Complementarity'' between energy and temperature (J. Lindhard). Radiation by uniformly moving sources (V.L. Ginzburg). Does elementary particle physics have a future? (S.L. Glashow). Observability of quarks (J.D. Bojrken). The transformation of elementary particle physics into many-body physics (L. Van Hove). Physics in terms of difference equations (T.D. Lee). Some lessons of renormalization theory (A.S. Wightman). Particles, fields and now strings (S. Weinberg). Collective and planetary motion in atoms (R.S. Berry). Unity of Knowledge. The origin and evolution of large-scale structure in the universe (W.L.W. Sargent). Molecular replication and the origins of life (L.E. Orgel). Physics, biological computation and complementarity (J.J. Hopfield). Complementarity in linguistic observation, description and explanation (W.U. Dressler). Niels Bohr. Great connections come alive: Bohr, Ehrenfest and Einstein (M.J. Klein). Niels Bohr and nuclear weapons (M. Gowing). Niels Bohr: The man and his legacy (J.A. Wheeler). Mellem Spog og Alvor: Personal recollections about Niels Bohr (H.B.G. Casimir). Part III. Jest and Earnest. AAddresses presented at the evening gathering in Ny Carlsberg Glyptoteket, October 7, 1985. (edited by J. de Boer and O. Ulfbeck). Parentesen (A. Aaboe). Truth and clarity (R. Peierls). Niels Bohr, the quantum and the world (V.F. Weisskopf).
In this paper, I try to explain the philosophical problems that Niels Bohr felt had been exposed by the discovery of the "quantum of action," and by the emergence of the quantum theory that arose in large part as a result of his efforts. I won't have space to make the case adequately here, but my own view is that we have not yet fully digested the message brought to us by Bohr's "Copenhagen Interpretation" of Quantum Mechanics, and I suspect that it will finally prove to be every bit as revolutionary as Bohr thought it was.