Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

Excess Baggage

James B. Hartle

Published Dec 9, 2020• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Many advances in physics have in common that some idea which was previously accepted as fundamental, general and inescapable was subsequently seen to be consequent, special and dispensable. The idea was not truly a general feature of the world, but only perceived to be general because of our special place in the universe and the limited range of our experience. It was excess baggage which had to be jettisoned to reach a more general perspective. This article discusses excess baggage from the perspective of quantum cosmology which aims for a theory of the universe’s quantum initial state. We seek to answer the question: “Which features of our current theoretical framework are fundamental and which reflect our special position in the universe or its special initial condition?” Past instances of cosmological excess baggage are reviewed, such as the idea that the Earth was at the center of the universe or that the second law of thermodynamics was fundamental. Examples of excess baggage in our current understanding are the notion that measurement is central to formulating quantum mechanics, a fundamental quantum mechanical arrow of time, and the idea that a preferred time is needed to formulate quantum theory. We speculate on candidates for future excess baggage.

DOI
10.1142/9789811216404_0002

Related papers

Excess Baggage

James B. Hartle

Many advances in physics have in common that some idea which was previously accepted as fundamental, general, and inescapable was subsequently seen to be consequent, special, and dispensable. The idea was not truly a general feature of the world, but only perceived to be general because of our special place in the universe and the limited range of our experience. It was excess baggage which had to be jettisoned to reach a more a more general perspective. This article discusses excess baggage from the perspective of quantum cosmology which aims at a theory of the universe's quantum initial state. We seek to answer the question `Which features of our current theoretical framework are fundamental and which reflect our special position in the universe or its special initial condition?' Past instances of cosmological excess baggage are reviewed such as the idea that the Earth was at the center of the universe or that the second law of thermodynamics was fundamental. Examples of excess baggage in our current understanding of quantum cosmology are the notion that measurement is central to formulating quantum mechanics, a fundamental quantum mechanical arrow of time, and the idea that a preferred time is needed to formulate quantum theory. We speculate on candidates for future excess baggage. (This article appeared in 1991 but is posted here for accessibility and possible current interest.)

arXiv:gr-qc/0508001•Jul 30, 2005•14 citations

Quantum physics and human language

James B Hartle

Human languages employ constructions that tacitly assume specific properties of the limited range of phenomena they evolved to describe. These assumed properties are true features of that limited context, but may not be general or precise properties of all the physical situations allowed by fundamental physics. In brief, human languages contain `excess baggage' that must be qualified, discarded, or otherwise reformed to give a clear account in the context of fundamental physics of even the everyday phenomena that the languages evolved to describe. The surest route to clarity is to express the constructions of human languages in the language of fundamental physical theory, not the other way around. These ideas are illustrated by an analysis of the verb `to happen' and the word `reality' in special relativity and the modern quantum mechanics of closed systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0610131•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Mar 7, 2007•33 citations

Quantum Physics and Human Language

James B. Hartle

Human languages employ constructions that tacitly assume specific properties of the limited range of phenomena they have evolved to describe. These assumed properties are true features of that limited context, but may not be general or precise properties of all the physical situations allowed by fundamental physics. In brief, human languages contain “excess baggage” that must be qualified, discarded, or otherwise reformed to give a clear account, in the context of fundamental physics, of even the everyday phenomena that languages have evolved to describe. The surest route to clarity is to express the constructions of human languages in the language of fundamental physical theory, not the other way around. These ideas are illustrated by an analysis of the verb “to happen” and the word “reality” in special relativity and the modern quantum mechanics of closed systems.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Dec 9, 2020•3 citations

The Quantum Universe: Essays on Quantum Mechanics, Quantum Cosmology and Physics in General

James B. Hartle

Computability and physical theories / R. Geroch and J.B. Hartle -- Excess baggage -- Sources of predictability -- The no-boundary wave function of the universe -- Scientific knowledge from the perspective of quantum cosmology -- The physics of 'now' -- The quantum mechanics of closed systems -- The spacetime approach to quantum mechanics -- Quantum physics and human language -- Quantum pasts and the utility of history -- The quasiclassical realms of this quantum universe -- Living in a superposition -- The quantum mechanical arrows of time -- Why our universe is comprehensible -- Quantum cosmology : problems for the 21st century -- Anthropic reasoning and quantum cosmology -- Are we typical? / J.B. Hartle and M. Srednicki -- Science in a very large universe / M. Srednicki and J.B. Hartle -- The observer strikes back / J.B. Hartle and T. Hertog -- Quantum multiverses -- Quantum mechanics at the Planck scale -- The state of the universe -- The impact of cosmology on quantum mechanics -- Murray Gell-Mann : a short appreciation -- Working with Stephen Hawking

•Jul 13, 2020•0 citations

Time Symmetry and Asymmetry in Quantum Mechanics and Quantum Cosmology

Murray Gell‐Mann, James B. Hartle

We investigate the origin of the arrow of time in quantum mechanics in the context of quantum cosmology. The ``Copenhagen'' quantum mechanics of measured subsystems incorporates a fundamental arrow of time. Extending discussions of Aharonov, Bergmann and Lebovitz, Griffiths, and others we investigate a generalized quantum mechanics for cosmology that utilizes both an initial and a final density matrix to give a time-neutral formulation without a fundamental arrow of time. Time asymmetries can arise for particular universes from differences between their initial and final conditions. Theories for both would be a goal of quantum cosmology. A special initial condition and a final condition of indifference would be sufficient to explain the observed time asymmetries of the universe. In this essay we ask under what circumstances a completely time symmetric universe, with T-symmetric initial and final condition, could be consistent with the time asymmetries of the limited domain of our experience. We discuss the approach to equilibrium, the electromagnetic system, and T-violation in the weak interactions in such universes. The decoherence of alternatives that is necessary for the prediction of probabilities in the quantum mechanics of closed systems is the origin of a fundamental limitation on quantum cosmologies with initial and final conditions. The initial and final density matrices cannot both be pure; if they are there is no decoherence and no prediction.

arXiv:gr-qc/9304023•Apr 18, 1993•57 citations

Scientific Knowledge from the Perspective of Quantum Cosmology

James B. Hartle

Existing physical theories do not predict every feature of our experience but only certain regularities of that experience. That difference between what could be observed and what can be predicted is one kind of limit on scientific knowledge. Such limits are inevitable if the world is complex and the laws governing the regularities of that world are simple. Another kind of limit on scientific knowledge arises because even simple theories may require intractable or impossible computations to yield specific predictions. A third kind of limit concerns our ability to know theories through the process of induction and test. Quantum cosmology -- that part of science concerned with the quantum origin of the universe and its subsequent evolution -- displays all three kinds of limits. This paper briefly describes quantum cosmology and discusses these limits. The place of the other sciences in this most comprehensive of physical frameworks is described.

arXiv:gr-qc/9601046•WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Dec 9, 2020•23 citations
Many advances in physics have in common that some idea which was previously accepted as fundamental, general and inescapable was subsequently seen to be consequent, special and dispensable. The idea was not truly a general feature of the world, but only perceived to be general because of our special place in the universe and the limited range of our experience. It was excess baggage which had to be jettisoned to reach a more general perspective. This article discusses excess baggage from the perspective of quantum cosmology which aims for a theory of the universe’s quantum initial state. We seek to answer the question: “Which features of our current theoretical framework are fundamental and which reflect our special position in the universe or its special initial condition?” Past instances of cosmological excess baggage are reviewed, such as the idea that the Earth was at the center of the universe or that the second law of thermodynamics was fundamental. Examples of excess baggage in our current understanding are the notion that measurement is central to formulating quantum mechanics, a fundamental quantum mechanical arrow of time, and the idea that a preferred time is needed to formulate quantum theory. We speculate on candidates for future excess baggage.
Many advances in physics have in common that some idea which was previously accepted as fundamental, general, and inescapable was subsequently seen to be consequent, special, and dispensable. The idea was not truly a general feature of the world, but only perceived to be general because of our special place in the universe and the limited range of our experience. It was excess baggage which had to be jettisoned to reach a more a more general perspective. This article discusses excess baggage from the perspective of quantum cosmology which aims at a theory of the universe's quantum initial state. We seek to answer the question `Which features of our current theoretical framework are fundamental and which reflect our special position in the universe or its special initial condition?' Past instances of cosmological excess baggage are reviewed such as the idea that the Earth was at the center of the universe or that the second law of thermodynamics was fundamental. Examples of excess baggage in our current understanding of quantum cosmology are the notion that measurement is central to formulating quantum mechanics, a fundamental quantum mechanical arrow of time, and the idea that a preferred time is needed to formulate quantum theory. We speculate on candidates for future excess baggage. (This article appeared in 1991 but is posted here for accessibility and possible current interest.)
Human languages employ constructions that tacitly assume specific properties of the limited range of phenomena they evolved to describe. These assumed properties are true features of that limited context, but may not be general or precise properties of all the physical situations allowed by fundamental physics. In brief, human languages contain `excess baggage' that must be qualified, discarded, or otherwise reformed to give a clear account in the context of fundamental physics of even the everyday phenomena that the languages evolved to describe. The surest route to clarity is to express the constructions of human languages in the language of fundamental physical theory, not the other way around. These ideas are illustrated by an analysis of the verb `to happen' and the word `reality' in special relativity and the modern quantum mechanics of closed systems.
Human languages employ constructions that tacitly assume specific properties of the limited range of phenomena they have evolved to describe. These assumed properties are true features of that limited context, but may not be general or precise properties of all the physical situations allowed by fundamental physics. In brief, human languages contain “excess baggage” that must be qualified, discarded, or otherwise reformed to give a clear account, in the context of fundamental physics, of even the everyday phenomena that languages have evolved to describe. The surest route to clarity is to express the constructions of human languages in the language of fundamental physical theory, not the other way around. These ideas are illustrated by an analysis of the verb “to happen” and the word “reality” in special relativity and the modern quantum mechanics of closed systems.
Computability and physical theories / R. Geroch and J.B. Hartle -- Excess baggage -- Sources of predictability -- The no-boundary wave function of the universe -- Scientific knowledge from the perspective of quantum cosmology -- The physics of 'now' -- The quantum mechanics of closed systems -- The spacetime approach to quantum mechanics -- Quantum physics and human language -- Quantum pasts and the utility of history -- The quasiclassical realms of this quantum universe -- Living in a superposition -- The quantum mechanical arrows of time -- Why our universe is comprehensible -- Quantum cosmology : problems for the 21st century -- Anthropic reasoning and quantum cosmology -- Are we typical? / J.B. Hartle and M. Srednicki -- Science in a very large universe / M. Srednicki and J.B. Hartle -- The observer strikes back / J.B. Hartle and T. Hertog -- Quantum multiverses -- Quantum mechanics at the Planck scale -- The state of the universe -- The impact of cosmology on quantum mechanics -- Murray Gell-Mann : a short appreciation -- Working with Stephen Hawking
We investigate the origin of the arrow of time in quantum mechanics in the context of quantum cosmology. The ``Copenhagen'' quantum mechanics of measured subsystems incorporates a fundamental arrow of time. Extending discussions of Aharonov, Bergmann and Lebovitz, Griffiths, and others we investigate a generalized quantum mechanics for cosmology that utilizes both an initial and a final density matrix to give a time-neutral formulation without a fundamental arrow of time. Time asymmetries can arise for particular universes from differences between their initial and final conditions. Theories for both would be a goal of quantum cosmology. A special initial condition and a final condition of indifference would be sufficient to explain the observed time asymmetries of the universe. In this essay we ask under what circumstances a completely time symmetric universe, with T-symmetric initial and final condition, could be consistent with the time asymmetries of the limited domain of our experience. We discuss the approach to equilibrium, the electromagnetic system, and T-violation in the weak interactions in such universes. The decoherence of alternatives that is necessary for the prediction of probabilities in the quantum mechanics of closed systems is the origin of a fundamental limitation on quantum cosmologies with initial and final conditions. The initial and final density matrices cannot both be pure; if they are there is no decoherence and no prediction.
Existing physical theories do not predict every feature of our experience but only certain regularities of that experience. That difference between what could be observed and what can be predicted is one kind of limit on scientific knowledge. Such limits are inevitable if the world is complex and the laws governing the regularities of that world are simple. Another kind of limit on scientific knowledge arises because even simple theories may require intractable or impossible computations to yield specific predictions. A third kind of limit concerns our ability to know theories through the process of induction and test. Quantum cosmology -- that part of science concerned with the quantum origin of the universe and its subsequent evolution -- displays all three kinds of limits. This paper briefly describes quantum cosmology and discusses these limits. The place of the other sciences in this most comprehensive of physical frameworks is described.