Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Identity

Nick Huggett

Published Jan 5, 2010• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum mechanics, like relativity, is a pillar of contemporary physics, with remarkable, puzzling consequences. In these chapters some very simple ‘games’ – distributing prizes of different kinds – are used to explain the implications for ‘identity’. Classical particles have ‘Maxwell‐Boltzmann’ statistics, according to which swapping properties makes a difference; similarly for people, as it makes a difference if we swap bank accounts! Quantum particles with ‘Bose‐Einstein’ statistics (called bosons) or ‘Fermi‐Dirac’ statistics (fermions) are like dollars in bank accounts: if we swap $1 it makes no difference. Chapter 17 shows how Schrödinger used the prize games to argue that – like the dollars – bosons and fermions are not ‘identifiable things’. Chapter 18 extends the models to other possible quantum particles, arguing that quantum mechanics also restricts identity by restricting what states particles can possess together – for instance, Fermi's ‘exclusion principle’, that fermions must be in different states.

DOI
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195379518.003.0017

Related papers

Quarticles

Nick Huggett

Quantum mechanics, like relativity, is a pillar of contemporary physics, with remarkable, puzzling consequences. In these chapters some very simple ‘games’ – distributing prizes of different kinds – are used to explain the implications for ‘identity’. Classical particles have ‘Maxwell‐Boltzmann’ statistics, according to which swapping properties makes a difference; similarly for people, as it makes a difference if we swap bank accounts! Quantum particles with ‘Bose‐Einstein’ statistics (called bosons) or ‘Fermi‐Dirac’ statistics (fermions) are like dollars in bank accounts: if we swap $1 it makes no difference. Chapter 17 shows how Schrödinger used the prize games to argue that – like the dollars – bosons and fermions are not ‘identifiable things’. Chapter 18 extends the models to other possible quantum particles, arguing that quantum mechanics also restricts identity by restricting what states particles can possess together – for instance, Fermi's ‘exclusion principle’, that fermions must be in different states.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 5, 2010•0 citations

Quantum Statistical Physics

Nicolas Sator, Nicolas Pavloff, Lénaïc Couëdel

In the previous chapters, the focus was on systems of particles following the law of classical mechanics. Of course, this was mainly done within the framework of classical mechanics but a quantum description of individual (discretised) states was also used, while assuming distinguishability of the particles (for instance, particles located at the nodes of a lattice (spin system, quantum harmonic oscillators,) ). The present chapter as well as Chapters 7 and 8 are dedicated to the study of statistical physics in a fully quantum framework. The first obstacle encountered by a quantum approach is the impossibility to define a quantum phase space (in which the ergodic hypothesis would hold for instance). This problem is inherent to quantum mechanics: because of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, one cannot define both the momentum and the position of a particle. Besides, statistical physics considers systems made of a large number of particles, a priori in mutual interaction. In classical physics, model situations for which the interactions between the constituents of the system are neglected can be studied. In quantum mechanics, the indistinguishability of identical particles makes the study of the problem in the absence of interaction already difficult: even for non-interacting particles, the symmetrisation (or antisymmetrisation) of the wave function of https://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"> N https://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href=" https://s3-euw1-ap-pe-df-pch-content-public-p.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/9781003272427/5ca4d37a-9786-43a3-8b38-8fa9eb3d1a19/content/math_25.tif "/> identical particles induces correlations which have non-trivial thermodynamical effects such as the existence of a “Fermi sea” for fermions (see Section 8.1 ) or the Bose–Einstein condensation phenomenon for bosons (see Section 7.4 ). The present chapter addresses these two points consecutively.

CRC Press eBooks•Jun 9, 2023•3 citations

Identical Particles

Tao Xiang

For a quantum mechanical system of N particles, the Hamiltonian is a sum of the total kinetic energy and the potential energy. In classical physics, it is possible to keep track of individual particles. A system of N identical particles is said to satisfy Bose-Einstein statistics if its wave function is symmetric under the exchange of particles, and these particles are known as bosons. In the nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, this principle must be accepted as an empirical postulate. In the relativistic quantum theory, it can be proven that half-integer-spin particles cannot be bosons and integer-spin particles cannot be fermions. The Pauli exclusion principle plays a critical role in programming physical properties of electrons or more generally fermions.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 31, 2022•0 citations

From identity to indistinguishability

Enric Pérez Canals

It is widely accepted that the papers by Bose in 1924 and by Einstein in 1924-1925 definitely opened the path to the quantum concept of ‘indistinguishability’. Since then, distinction in physics between ‘identity’ and ‘indistinguishability’ of particles has come to be required. However, even before the rise of quantum physics, Maxwell, Boltzmann and Gibbs, among others, had to tackle the difficulties and paradoxes that appear when counting identical particles. Later, after Sackur’s and Tetrode’s first quantum derivation of the canonical partition function of an ideal gas, much confusion arose around its dependence on the number of molecules in the system. Many other physicists, such as Planck, Lorentz or Schrodinger took part in those debates. In 1921, Ehrenfest and Trkal devoted a whole paper to this subject. Clearly, in the days before Bose’s seminal work, embroiling and misunderstanding were commonplace. In considering the emergence of the distinction between ‘identical’ and ‘indistinguishable’ particles, we will go through the so-called statistical route to quantum mechanics. The first developments in statistical mechanics became immediately confused and entangled with the irruption of quantum physics. In the first quarter of the twentieth century the mutual influence between both disciplines was profuse. We will pay special attention to the story of the so-called ‘Gibbs Paradox.’ We will argue that what is now often known by this name in some textbooks of statistical mechanics did not exist as such in those foundational days.

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Fermi–Dirac and Bose–Einstein Statistics

P. J. Shepherd

This chapter begins with a derivation of the Gibbs grand canonical probability distribution. The section on systems of noninteractive particles considers a single particle in the gas and treats it as a system itself, in thermal equilibrium with the reservoir of temperature. An equation for expressing the coefficient a in the Boltzmann single-particle state probability distribution in terms of the chemical potential of the gas is derived using the concept of the grand canonical ensemble. The chapter then discusses the indistinguishability of identical particles by considering a system of two identical noninteracting particles. Wave function equations for two noninteracting bosons as well as for two noninteracting identical fermions are presented. The chapter explains the Fermi-Dirac and Bose-Einstein distributions, and shows how to find the entropy of a system of noninteracting fermions or bosons.

Wiley eBooks•Jan 10, 2013•0 citations

Identical Quantum Particles as Distinguishable Objects

Dennis Dieks, Andrea Lubberdink

Abstract According to classical physics particles are basic building blocks of the world. These classical particles are distinguishable objects, individuated by unique combinations of physical properties. By contrast, in quantum mechanics the received view is that particles of the same kind (“identical particles”) are physically indistinguishable from each other and lack identity. This doctrine rests on the quantum mechanical (anti)symmetrization postulates together with the “factorist” assumption that each single particle is represented in exactly one factor space of the tensor product Hilbert space of a many-particle system. Even though standard in theoretical physics and the philosophy of physics, the assumption of factorism and the ensuing indistinguishability of particles are problematic. Particle indistinguishability is irreconcilable with the everyday meaning of “particle”, and also with how this term is used in the practice of physics. Moreover, it is a consequence of the standard view that identical quantum particles remain indistinguishable even in the classical limit, which makes a smooth transition to the classical particle concept impossible. Lubberdink (1998; 2009) and Dieks and Lubberdink (2011) have proposed an alternative conception of quantum particles that does not rely on factorism and avoids these difficulties. We further explain and discuss this alternative framework here. One of its key consequences is that particles in quantum theory are not fundamental but emergent; another that once they have emerged, quantum particles are always physically distinguishable and thus possess a physically grounded identity.

Journal for General Philosophy of Science•Jun 24, 2020•55 citations
Quantum mechanics, like relativity, is a pillar of contemporary physics, with remarkable, puzzling consequences. In these chapters some very simple ‘games’ – distributing prizes of different kinds – are used to explain the implications for ‘identity’. Classical particles have ‘Maxwell‐Boltzmann’ statistics, according to which swapping properties makes a difference; similarly for people, as it makes a difference if we swap bank accounts! Quantum particles with ‘Bose‐Einstein’ statistics (called bosons) or ‘Fermi‐Dirac’ statistics (fermions) are like dollars in bank accounts: if we swap $1 it makes no difference. Chapter 17 shows how Schrödinger used the prize games to argue that – like the dollars – bosons and fermions are not ‘identifiable things’. Chapter 18 extends the models to other possible quantum particles, arguing that quantum mechanics also restricts identity by restricting what states particles can possess together – for instance, Fermi's ‘exclusion principle’, that fermions must be in different states.
Quantum mechanics, like relativity, is a pillar of contemporary physics, with remarkable, puzzling consequences. In these chapters some very simple ‘games’ – distributing prizes of different kinds – are used to explain the implications for ‘identity’. Classical particles have ‘Maxwell‐Boltzmann’ statistics, according to which swapping properties makes a difference; similarly for people, as it makes a difference if we swap bank accounts! Quantum particles with ‘Bose‐Einstein’ statistics (called bosons) or ‘Fermi‐Dirac’ statistics (fermions) are like dollars in bank accounts: if we swap $1 it makes no difference. Chapter 17 shows how Schrödinger used the prize games to argue that – like the dollars – bosons and fermions are not ‘identifiable things’. Chapter 18 extends the models to other possible quantum particles, arguing that quantum mechanics also restricts identity by restricting what states particles can possess together – for instance, Fermi's ‘exclusion principle’, that fermions must be in different states.
In the previous chapters, the focus was on systems of particles following the law of classical mechanics. Of course, this was mainly done within the framework of classical mechanics but a quantum description of individual (discretised) states was also used, while assuming distinguishability of the particles (for instance, particles located at the nodes of a lattice (spin system, quantum harmonic oscillators,) ). The present chapter as well as Chapters 7 and 8 are dedicated to the study of statistical physics in a fully quantum framework. The first obstacle encountered by a quantum approach is the impossibility to define a quantum phase space (in which the ergodic hypothesis would hold for instance). This problem is inherent to quantum mechanics: because of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, one cannot define both the momentum and the position of a particle. Besides, statistical physics considers systems made of a large number of particles, a priori in mutual interaction. In classical physics, model situations for which the interactions between the constituents of the system are neglected can be studied. In quantum mechanics, the indistinguishability of identical particles makes the study of the problem in the absence of interaction already difficult: even for non-interacting particles, the symmetrisation (or antisymmetrisation) of the wave function of https://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"> N https://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href=" https://s3-euw1-ap-pe-df-pch-content-public-p.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/9781003272427/5ca4d37a-9786-43a3-8b38-8fa9eb3d1a19/content/math_25.tif "/> identical particles induces correlations which have non-trivial thermodynamical effects such as the existence of a “Fermi sea” for fermions (see Section 8.1 ) or the Bose–Einstein condensation phenomenon for bosons (see Section 7.4 ). The present chapter addresses these two points consecutively.
For a quantum mechanical system of N particles, the Hamiltonian is a sum of the total kinetic energy and the potential energy. In classical physics, it is possible to keep track of individual particles. A system of N identical particles is said to satisfy Bose-Einstein statistics if its wave function is symmetric under the exchange of particles, and these particles are known as bosons. In the nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, this principle must be accepted as an empirical postulate. In the relativistic quantum theory, it can be proven that half-integer-spin particles cannot be bosons and integer-spin particles cannot be fermions. The Pauli exclusion principle plays a critical role in programming physical properties of electrons or more generally fermions.
It is widely accepted that the papers by Bose in 1924 and by Einstein in 1924-1925 definitely opened the path to the quantum concept of ‘indistinguishability’. Since then, distinction in physics between ‘identity’ and ‘indistinguishability’ of particles has come to be required. However, even before the rise of quantum physics, Maxwell, Boltzmann and Gibbs, among others, had to tackle the difficulties and paradoxes that appear when counting identical particles. Later, after Sackur’s and Tetrode’s first quantum derivation of the canonical partition function of an ideal gas, much confusion arose around its dependence on the number of molecules in the system. Many other physicists, such as Planck, Lorentz or Schrodinger took part in those debates. In 1921, Ehrenfest and Trkal devoted a whole paper to this subject. Clearly, in the days before Bose’s seminal work, embroiling and misunderstanding were commonplace. In considering the emergence of the distinction between ‘identical’ and ‘indistinguishable’ particles, we will go through the so-called statistical route to quantum mechanics. The first developments in statistical mechanics became immediately confused and entangled with the irruption of quantum physics. In the first quarter of the twentieth century the mutual influence between both disciplines was profuse. We will pay special attention to the story of the so-called ‘Gibbs Paradox.’ We will argue that what is now often known by this name in some textbooks of statistical mechanics did not exist as such in those foundational days.
This chapter begins with a derivation of the Gibbs grand canonical probability distribution. The section on systems of noninteractive particles considers a single particle in the gas and treats it as a system itself, in thermal equilibrium with the reservoir of temperature. An equation for expressing the coefficient a in the Boltzmann single-particle state probability distribution in terms of the chemical potential of the gas is derived using the concept of the grand canonical ensemble. The chapter then discusses the indistinguishability of identical particles by considering a system of two identical noninteracting particles. Wave function equations for two noninteracting bosons as well as for two noninteracting identical fermions are presented. The chapter explains the Fermi-Dirac and Bose-Einstein distributions, and shows how to find the entropy of a system of noninteracting fermions or bosons.
Abstract According to classical physics particles are basic building blocks of the world. These classical particles are distinguishable objects, individuated by unique combinations of physical properties. By contrast, in quantum mechanics the received view is that particles of the same kind (“identical particles”) are physically indistinguishable from each other and lack identity. This doctrine rests on the quantum mechanical (anti)symmetrization postulates together with the “factorist” assumption that each single particle is represented in exactly one factor space of the tensor product Hilbert space of a many-particle system. Even though standard in theoretical physics and the philosophy of physics, the assumption of factorism and the ensuing indistinguishability of particles are problematic. Particle indistinguishability is irreconcilable with the everyday meaning of “particle”, and also with how this term is used in the practice of physics. Moreover, it is a consequence of the standard view that identical quantum particles remain indistinguishable even in the classical limit, which makes a smooth transition to the classical particle concept impossible. Lubberdink (1998; 2009) and Dieks and Lubberdink (2011) have proposed an alternative conception of quantum particles that does not rely on factorism and avoids these difficulties. We further explain and discuss this alternative framework here. One of its key consequences is that particles in quantum theory are not fundamental but emergent; another that once they have emerged, quantum particles are always physically distinguishable and thus possess a physically grounded identity.