Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

New directions in the philosophy of science

Indiscernibility of Quantum Particles: A Road to Orthodoxy

Tomasz Bigaj

Published Jan 1, 2022• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/978-3-030-74870-8_2

Related papers

Identity and Indiscernibility in Quantum Mechanics

Tomasz Bigaj

New directions in the philosophy of science•Jan 1, 2022•30 citations

Quantum Theory and the Identity of Indiscernibles Revisited

Allen Ginsberg

Philosophy of Science•Sep 1, 1981•30 citations

Quantum indiscernibility without vague identity

Joanna Odrowąż‐Sypniewska

Analysis•Jan 1, 2001•4 citations

Collisions, indiscernability and the spin-statistics theorem

Michel Gondran, Alexandre Gondran

We recently proposed a definition of indiscernability in classical mechanics for identical particles prepared in the same manner and without interaction between them [1]. In this paper, we generalize the indiscernability to identical particles in collision. We first consider the elastic collision of pairs of classical particles. We then study the convergence of the quantum indiscernability to the classical indiscernability when the Planck constant h tends to 0. Finally, based on a plausible behavior of the particle during the collision, we propose a possible interpretation of the entanglement phenomenon and of the spin-statistics theorem.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

How to think about indiscernible particles

Daniel Joseph Giglio

Permutation symmetries which arise in quantum mechanics pose an intriguing problem. It is not clear that particles which exhibit permutation symmetries (i.e. particles which are indiscernible, meaning that they can be swapped with each other without this yielding a new physical state) qualify as "objects" in any reasonable sense of the term. One solution to this puzzle, which I attribute to W.V. Quine, would have us eliminate such particles from our ontology altogether in order to circumvent the metaphysical vexations caused by permutation symmetries. In this essay I argue that Quine's solution is too rash, and in its place I suggest a novel solution based on altering some of the language of quantum mechanics. Before launching into the technical details of indiscernible particles, however, I begin this essay with some remarks on the methodology - instrumentalism - which motivates my arguments.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Indistinguishable Quantum Particles

Lecture notes in physics. M, Monographs•Jan 1, 1997•0 citations
We recently proposed a definition of indiscernability in classical mechanics for identical particles prepared in the same manner and without interaction between them [1]. In this paper, we generalize the indiscernability to identical particles in collision. We first consider the elastic collision of pairs of classical particles. We then study the convergence of the quantum indiscernability to the classical indiscernability when the Planck constant h tends to 0. Finally, based on a plausible behavior of the particle during the collision, we propose a possible interpretation of the entanglement phenomenon and of the spin-statistics theorem.
Permutation symmetries which arise in quantum mechanics pose an intriguing problem. It is not clear that particles which exhibit permutation symmetries (i.e. particles which are indiscernible, meaning that they can be swapped with each other without this yielding a new physical state) qualify as "objects" in any reasonable sense of the term. One solution to this puzzle, which I attribute to W.V. Quine, would have us eliminate such particles from our ontology altogether in order to circumvent the metaphysical vexations caused by permutation symmetries. In this essay I argue that Quine's solution is too rash, and in its place I suggest a novel solution based on altering some of the language of quantum mechanics. Before launching into the technical details of indiscernible particles, however, I begin this essay with some remarks on the methodology - instrumentalism - which motivates my arguments.