Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

AIP conference proceedings

Collisions, indiscernability and the spin-statistics theorem

Michel Gondran, Alexandre Gondran

Published Jan 1, 2012• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We recently proposed a definition of indiscernability in classical mechanics for identical particles prepared in the same manner and without interaction between them [1]. In this paper, we generalize the indiscernability to identical particles in collision. We first consider the elastic collision of pairs of classical particles. We then study the convergence of the quantum indiscernability to the classical indiscernability when the Planck constant h tends to 0. Finally, based on a plausible behavior of the particle during the collision, we propose a possible interpretation of the entanglement phenomenon and of the spin-statistics theorem.

DOI
10.1063/1.4773151

Related papers

Discerned and non-discerned particles in classical mechanics and convergence of quantum mechanics to classical mechanics

Michel Gondran, Alexandre Gondran

We introduce into classical mechanics the concept of nondiscerned particles for particles that are identical, non-interacting and prepared in the same way. The non-discerned particles correspond to an action and a density which satisfy the statistical Hamilton-Jacobi equations and allow to explain the Gibbs paradox. On the other hand, a discerned particle corresponds to a particular action that satisfies the special Hamilton-Jacobi equations. We then study the convergence of quantum mechanics to classical mechanics when ~ tends to 0 by considering two cases : the convergence to non-discerned classical particles and the convergence to a classical discerned particle. Based on these convergences, we propose an updated interpretation of quantum mechanics.

•Jan 1, 2011•7 citations

Identical Particles in Quantum Mechanics Revisited

Robert C. Hilborn, Candice L. Yuca

The treatment of identical particles in quantum mechanics rests on two (related) principles: the spin‐statistics connection and the Symmetrization Postulate. In light of recent theories (such as q‐deformed commutators) that allow for ‘small’ violations of the spin‐statistics connection and the Symmetrization Postulate, we revisit the issue of how quantum mechanics deals with identical particles and how it supports or fails to support various philosophical stances concerning individuality. As a consequence of the expanded possibilities for quantum statistics, we argue that permutation symmetry is best formulated as a formal property of the state function describing the system of particles rather than as a property of the individual particles.1 Introduction2 Philosophical background2.1 Important terminology2.1.1 Identity2.1.2 Indistinguishability2.1.3 Indiscernibility2.2 When are particles indistinguishable?2.3 The Principle of the Identity of Indiscernibles and quantum mechanics2.4 The Principle of the Identity of Indiscernibles and logic2.5 Particle history2.6 Transcendental individuality3 Some quantum formalism3.1 The Principle of Permutation Invariance and the Symmetrization Postulate3.2 The configuration‐space approach3.3 Commutators and anticommutators, and identical particle statistics3.4 Q‐mutators4 Identical particle statistics: a holistic point of view5 Conclusions

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•Sep 1, 2002•20 citations

Quantum Statistics of Identical Particles

J. C. Garrison

Abstract The empirical rule that systems of identical particles always obey either Bose or Fermi statistics is customarily imposed on the theory by adding it to the axioms of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, with the result that other statistical behaviors are excluded a priori. A more general approach is to ask what other many-particle statistics are consistent with the indistinguishability of identical particles. This strategy offers a way to discuss possible violations of the Pauli Exclusion Principle, and it leads to some interesting issues related to preparation of states and a superselection rule arising from invariance under the permutation group.

arXiv:2207.13231•Foundations of Physics•Jul 14, 2022•1 citation

Exclusion Statistics in Classical Mechanics

T. H. Hansson, SERGEI B. ISAKOV, Jon Magne Leinaas +1 more

We present a general method to derive the classical mechanics of a system of identical particles in a way that retains information about quantum statistics. The resulting statistical mechanics can be interpreted as a classical version of Haldane's exclusion statistics.

arXiv:quant-ph/0004108•Apr 28, 2000•2 citations

Quantum Statistical Physics

Nicolas Sator, Nicolas Pavloff, Lénaïc Couëdel

In the previous chapters, the focus was on systems of particles following the law of classical mechanics. Of course, this was mainly done within the framework of classical mechanics but a quantum description of individual (discretised) states was also used, while assuming distinguishability of the particles (for instance, particles located at the nodes of a lattice (spin system, quantum harmonic oscillators,) ). The present chapter as well as Chapters 7 and 8 are dedicated to the study of statistical physics in a fully quantum framework. The first obstacle encountered by a quantum approach is the impossibility to define a quantum phase space (in which the ergodic hypothesis would hold for instance). This problem is inherent to quantum mechanics: because of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, one cannot define both the momentum and the position of a particle. Besides, statistical physics considers systems made of a large number of particles, a priori in mutual interaction. In classical physics, model situations for which the interactions between the constituents of the system are neglected can be studied. In quantum mechanics, the indistinguishability of identical particles makes the study of the problem in the absence of interaction already difficult: even for non-interacting particles, the symmetrisation (or antisymmetrisation) of the wave function of https://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"> N https://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href=" https://s3-euw1-ap-pe-df-pch-content-public-p.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/9781003272427/5ca4d37a-9786-43a3-8b38-8fa9eb3d1a19/content/math_25.tif "/> identical particles induces correlations which have non-trivial thermodynamical effects such as the existence of a “Fermi sea” for fermions (see Section 8.1 ) or the Bose–Einstein condensation phenomenon for bosons (see Section 7.4 ). The present chapter addresses these two points consecutively.

CRC Press eBooks•Jun 9, 2023•3 citations

Discerned and Non-Discerned Particles in Classical Mechanics and Quantum Mechanics Interpretation

Michel Gondran, Alexandre Gondran

We introduce into classical mechanics the concept of non-discerned particles for particles that are identical, non-interacting and prepared in the same way. The non-discerned particles correspond to an action and a density which satisfy the statistical Hamilton-Jacobi equations and allow to explain the Gibbs paradox in a simple manner. On the other hand, a discerned particle corresponds to a particular action that satisfies the local Hamilton-Jacobi equations. We then study the convergence of quantum mechanics to classical mechanics when hbar -> 0 by considering the convergence for the two cases. These results provide an argument for a renewed interpretation of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1008.0936•Aug 5, 2010•0 citations
We recently proposed a definition of indiscernability in classical mechanics for identical particles prepared in the same manner and without interaction between them [1]. In this paper, we generalize the indiscernability to identical particles in collision. We first consider the elastic collision of pairs of classical particles. We then study the convergence of the quantum indiscernability to the classical indiscernability when the Planck constant h tends to 0. Finally, based on a plausible behavior of the particle during the collision, we propose a possible interpretation of the entanglement phenomenon and of the spin-statistics theorem.
We introduce into classical mechanics the concept of nondiscerned particles for particles that are identical, non-interacting and prepared in the same way. The non-discerned particles correspond to an action and a density which satisfy the statistical Hamilton-Jacobi equations and allow to explain the Gibbs paradox. On the other hand, a discerned particle corresponds to a particular action that satisfies the special Hamilton-Jacobi equations. We then study the convergence of quantum mechanics to classical mechanics when ~ tends to 0 by considering two cases : the convergence to non-discerned classical particles and the convergence to a classical discerned particle. Based on these convergences, we propose an updated interpretation of quantum mechanics.
The treatment of identical particles in quantum mechanics rests on two (related) principles: the spin‐statistics connection and the Symmetrization Postulate. In light of recent theories (such as q‐deformed commutators) that allow for ‘small’ violations of the spin‐statistics connection and the Symmetrization Postulate, we revisit the issue of how quantum mechanics deals with identical particles and how it supports or fails to support various philosophical stances concerning individuality. As a consequence of the expanded possibilities for quantum statistics, we argue that permutation symmetry is best formulated as a formal property of the state function describing the system of particles rather than as a property of the individual particles.1 Introduction2 Philosophical background2.1 Important terminology2.1.1 Identity2.1.2 Indistinguishability2.1.3 Indiscernibility2.2 When are particles indistinguishable?2.3 The Principle of the Identity of Indiscernibles and quantum mechanics2.4 The Principle of the Identity of Indiscernibles and logic2.5 Particle history2.6 Transcendental individuality3 Some quantum formalism3.1 The Principle of Permutation Invariance and the Symmetrization Postulate3.2 The configuration‐space approach3.3 Commutators and anticommutators, and identical particle statistics3.4 Q‐mutators4 Identical particle statistics: a holistic point of view5 Conclusions
Abstract The empirical rule that systems of identical particles always obey either Bose or Fermi statistics is customarily imposed on the theory by adding it to the axioms of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, with the result that other statistical behaviors are excluded a priori. A more general approach is to ask what other many-particle statistics are consistent with the indistinguishability of identical particles. This strategy offers a way to discuss possible violations of the Pauli Exclusion Principle, and it leads to some interesting issues related to preparation of states and a superselection rule arising from invariance under the permutation group.
In the previous chapters, the focus was on systems of particles following the law of classical mechanics. Of course, this was mainly done within the framework of classical mechanics but a quantum description of individual (discretised) states was also used, while assuming distinguishability of the particles (for instance, particles located at the nodes of a lattice (spin system, quantum harmonic oscillators,) ). The present chapter as well as Chapters 7 and 8 are dedicated to the study of statistical physics in a fully quantum framework. The first obstacle encountered by a quantum approach is the impossibility to define a quantum phase space (in which the ergodic hypothesis would hold for instance). This problem is inherent to quantum mechanics: because of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, one cannot define both the momentum and the position of a particle. Besides, statistical physics considers systems made of a large number of particles, a priori in mutual interaction. In classical physics, model situations for which the interactions between the constituents of the system are neglected can be studied. In quantum mechanics, the indistinguishability of identical particles makes the study of the problem in the absence of interaction already difficult: even for non-interacting particles, the symmetrisation (or antisymmetrisation) of the wave function of https://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"> N https://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href=" https://s3-euw1-ap-pe-df-pch-content-public-p.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/9781003272427/5ca4d37a-9786-43a3-8b38-8fa9eb3d1a19/content/math_25.tif "/> identical particles induces correlations which have non-trivial thermodynamical effects such as the existence of a “Fermi sea” for fermions (see Section 8.1 ) or the Bose–Einstein condensation phenomenon for bosons (see Section 7.4 ). The present chapter addresses these two points consecutively.
We introduce into classical mechanics the concept of non-discerned particles for particles that are identical, non-interacting and prepared in the same way. The non-discerned particles correspond to an action and a density which satisfy the statistical Hamilton-Jacobi equations and allow to explain the Gibbs paradox in a simple manner. On the other hand, a discerned particle corresponds to a particular action that satisfies the local Hamilton-Jacobi equations. We then study the convergence of quantum mechanics to classical mechanics when hbar -> 0 by considering the convergence for the two cases. These results provide an argument for a renewed interpretation of quantum mechanics.