Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science

Cryptography from Sunspots: How to Use an Imperfect Reference String

Ran Canetti, Rafael Pass, Abhi A. Shelat

Published Oct 1, 2007• 48 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The common reference string (CRS) model equips all protocol participants with a common string that is sampled from a pre-specified distribution, say the uniform distribution. This model enables otherwise-impossible cryptographic goals such as removing interaction from protocols and guaranteeing composable security. However, knowing the precise distribution of the reference string seems crucial for all known protocols in this model, in the sense that current security analyses fail when the actual distribution of the reference string is allowed to differ from the specified one even by a small amount. This fact rules out many potential implementations of the CRS model, such as measurements of physical phenomena (like sunspots), or alternatively using random sources that might be adversarially influenced. We study the possibility of obtaining universally composable (UC) security in a relaxed variant of the CRS model, where the reference string it taken from an adversarially specified distribution that's unknown to the protocol. On the positive side, we demonstrate that UC general secure computation is obtainable even when the reference string is taken from an arbitrary, adversarially chosen distribution, as long as (a) this distribution has some minimal min-entropy, (b) it has not too long a description, (c) it is efficiently samplable, and (d) the sampling algorithm is known to the adversary (and simulator). On the negative side, we show that if any one of these four conditions is removed then genera! UC secure computation becomes essentially impossible.

DOI
10.1109/focs.2007.70

Related papers

Obtaining Universally Composable Security: Towards the Bare Bones of Trust.

Ran Canetti

A desirable goal for cryptographic protocols is to guarantee security when the protocol is composed with other protocol instances. Universally Composable (UC) security provides this guarantee in a strong sense: A UC-secure protocol maintains its security properties even when composed concurrently with an unbounded number of instances of arbitrary protocols. However, many interesting cryptographic tasks are provably impossible to realize with UC security in the standard, “plain” model of computation. Impossibility holds even if ideally authenticated communication channels are provided. In contrast, it has been demonstrated that general secure computation can be obtained in a number of idealized models. Each one of these models represents a form of trust that is put in some of the system’s components. This survey examines and compares some of these trust models, both from the point of view of their sufficiency for building UC secure protocols, and from the point of view of their practical realizability. We start with the common reference string (CRS) model, and then describe several relaxations and alternatives including the Defective CRS model, the key registration models, the hardware token model, the global and augmented CRS models, and a timing assumption. Finally, we briefly touch upon trust models for obtaining authenticated communication.

•Jan 1, 2007•5 citations

Universally Composable Protocols with Relaxed Set-Up Assumptions

Boaz Barak, Ran Canetti, Jesper Buus Nielsen +1 more

A desirable goal for cryptographic protocols is to guarantee security when the protocol is composed with other protocol instances. Universally composable (UC) protocols provide this guarantee in a strong sense: A protocol remains secure even when composed concurrently with an unbounded number of instances of arbitrary protocols. However, UC protocols for carrying out general tasks are known to exist only if a majority of the participants are honest, or in the common reference string (CRS) model where all parties are assumed to have access to a common string that is drawn from some pre-defined distribution. Furthermore, carrying out many interesting tasks in a UC manner and without honest majority or set-up assumptions is impossible, even if ideally authenticated communication is provided. A natural question is thus whether there exist more relaxed set-up assumptions than the CRS model that still allow for UC protocols. We answer this question in the affirmative: we propose alternative and relaxed set-up assumptions and show that they suffice for reproducing the general feasibility results for UC protocols in the CRS model. These alternative assumptions have the flavor of a "public-key infrastructure": parties have registered public keys, no single registration authority needs to be fully trusted, and no single piece of information has to be globally trusted and available. In addition, unlike known protocols in the CRS model, the proposed protocols guarantee some basic level of security even if the set-up assumption is violated.

Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science•Dec 23, 2004•219 citations

Universally Composable Multi-Party Computation with an Unreliable Common Reference String.

Vipul Goyal, Jonathan I. Katz

Abstract. Universally composable (UC) multi-party computation has been studied in two settings. When a majority of parties are honest, UC multi-party computation is possible without any assumptions. Without a majority of honest parties, UC multi-party computation is impossible in the plain model, but feasibility results have been obtained in various augmented models. The most popular such model posits a common reference string (CRS) available to parties executing the protocol. In either of the above settings, some assumption regarding the protocol execution is made: i.e., that many parties are honest in the first case, or that a legitimately-chosen string is available in the second. If this assumption is incorrect then all security is lost. A natural question is whether it is possible to design protocols secure if either one of these assumptions holds, i.e., a protocol which is secure if either at most s players are dishonest or if up to t> s players are dishonest but the CRS is chosen in the prescribed manner. We show that such protocols exist if and only if s + t < n. 1

•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations

Practical UC security with a Global Random Oracle.

Ran Canetti, Abhishek Jain, Alessandra Scafuro

We show that there exist commitment, zero-knowledge and general function evaluation pro-tocols with universally composable security, in a model where all parties and all protocols have access to a single, global, random oracle and no other trusted setup. This model provides sig-nificantly stronger composable security guarantees than the traditional random oracle model of Bellare and Rogaway [CCS’93] or even the common reference string model. Indeed, these latter models provide no security guarantees in the presence of arbitrary protocols that use the same random oracle (or reference string or hash function). Furthermore, our protocols are highly efficient. Specifically, in the interactive setting, our commitment and general computation protocols are much more efficient than the best known ones due to Lindell [Crypto’11,’13] which are secure in the common reference string model. In the non-interactive setting, our protocols are slightly less efficient than the best known ones presented by Afshar et al. [Eurocrypt ’14] but do away with the need to rely on a non-global (programmable) reference string. 1

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Non-interactive and reusable non-malleable commitment schemes

Ivan Damgård, Jens Groth

We consider non-malleable (NM) and universally composable (UC) commitment schemes in the common reference string (CRS) model. We show how to construct non-interactive NM commitments that remain non-malleable even if the adversary has access to an arbitrary number of commitments from honest players - rather than one, as in several previous schemes. We show this is a strictly stronger security notion. Our construction is the first non-interactive scheme achieving this that can be based on the minimal assumption of existence of one-way functions. But it can also be instantiated in a very efficient version based on the strong RSA assumption. For UC commitments, we show that existence of a UC commitment scheme in the CRS model (interactive or not) implies key exchange and - for a uniform reference string - even implies oblivious transfer. This indicates that UC commitment is a strictly stronger primitive than NM. Finally, we show that our strong RSA based construction can be used to improve the most efficient known UC commitment scheme so it can work with a CRS of size independent of the number of players, without loss of efficiency.

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•Jan 1, 2003•118 citations

An Efficient Non-interactive Universally Composable String-Commitment Scheme

Ryo Nishimaki, Eiichiro Fujisaki, Keisuke Tanaka

This paper presents a new non-interactive string-commitment scheme that achieves universally composable security. Security is proven under the decisional composite residuosity (DCR) assumption (or the decisional Diffie-Hellman (DDH) assumption) in the common reference string (CRS) model. The universal composability (UC) is a very strong security notion. If cryptographic protocols are proven secure in the UC framework, then they remain secure even if they are composed with arbitrary protocols and polynomially many copies of the protocols are run concurrently. Many UC commitment schemes in the CRS model have been proposed, but they are either interactive commitment or bit-commitment (not string-commitment) schemes. We note, however, that although our scheme is the first non-interactive UC string-commitment scheme, a CRS is not reusable. We use an extension of all-but-one trapdoor functions (ABO-TDFs) proposed by Peikert and Waters at STOC 2008 as an essential building block. Our main idea is to extend (original deterministic) ABO-TDFs to probabilistic ones by using the homomorphic properties of their function indices. The function indices of ABO-TDFs consist of ciphertexts of homomorphic encryption schemes (such as ElGamal, and Damgård-Jurik encryption). Therefore we can re-randomize the output of ABO-TDFs by re-randomization of ciphertexts. This is a new application of ABO-TDFs.

IEICE Transactions on Fundamentals of Electronics Communications and Computer Sciences•Jan 1, 2012•5 citations
The common reference string (CRS) model equips all protocol participants with a common string that is sampled from a pre-specified distribution, say the uniform distribution. This model enables otherwise-impossible cryptographic goals such as removing interaction from protocols and guaranteeing composable security. However, knowing the precise distribution of the reference string seems crucial for all known protocols in this model, in the sense that current security analyses fail when the actual distribution of the reference string is allowed to differ from the specified one even by a small amount. This fact rules out many potential implementations of the CRS model, such as measurements of physical phenomena (like sunspots), or alternatively using random sources that might be adversarially influenced. We study the possibility of obtaining universally composable (UC) security in a relaxed variant of the CRS model, where the reference string it taken from an adversarially specified distribution that's unknown to the protocol. On the positive side, we demonstrate that UC general secure computation is obtainable even when the reference string is taken from an arbitrary, adversarially chosen distribution, as long as (a) this distribution has some minimal min-entropy, (b) it has not too long a description, (c) it is efficiently samplable, and (d) the sampling algorithm is known to the adversary (and simulator). On the negative side, we show that if any one of these four conditions is removed then genera! UC secure computation becomes essentially impossible.
A desirable goal for cryptographic protocols is to guarantee security when the protocol is composed with other protocol instances. Universally Composable (UC) security provides this guarantee in a strong sense: A UC-secure protocol maintains its security properties even when composed concurrently with an unbounded number of instances of arbitrary protocols. However, many interesting cryptographic tasks are provably impossible to realize with UC security in the standard, “plain” model of computation. Impossibility holds even if ideally authenticated communication channels are provided. In contrast, it has been demonstrated that general secure computation can be obtained in a number of idealized models. Each one of these models represents a form of trust that is put in some of the system’s components. This survey examines and compares some of these trust models, both from the point of view of their sufficiency for building UC secure protocols, and from the point of view of their practical realizability. We start with the common reference string (CRS) model, and then describe several relaxations and alternatives including the Defective CRS model, the key registration models, the hardware token model, the global and augmented CRS models, and a timing assumption. Finally, we briefly touch upon trust models for obtaining authenticated communication.
A desirable goal for cryptographic protocols is to guarantee security when the protocol is composed with other protocol instances. Universally composable (UC) protocols provide this guarantee in a strong sense: A protocol remains secure even when composed concurrently with an unbounded number of instances of arbitrary protocols. However, UC protocols for carrying out general tasks are known to exist only if a majority of the participants are honest, or in the common reference string (CRS) model where all parties are assumed to have access to a common string that is drawn from some pre-defined distribution. Furthermore, carrying out many interesting tasks in a UC manner and without honest majority or set-up assumptions is impossible, even if ideally authenticated communication is provided. A natural question is thus whether there exist more relaxed set-up assumptions than the CRS model that still allow for UC protocols. We answer this question in the affirmative: we propose alternative and relaxed set-up assumptions and show that they suffice for reproducing the general feasibility results for UC protocols in the CRS model. These alternative assumptions have the flavor of a "public-key infrastructure": parties have registered public keys, no single registration authority needs to be fully trusted, and no single piece of information has to be globally trusted and available. In addition, unlike known protocols in the CRS model, the proposed protocols guarantee some basic level of security even if the set-up assumption is violated.
Abstract. Universally composable (UC) multi-party computation has been studied in two settings. When a majority of parties are honest, UC multi-party computation is possible without any assumptions. Without a majority of honest parties, UC multi-party computation is impossible in the plain model, but feasibility results have been obtained in various augmented models. The most popular such model posits a common reference string (CRS) available to parties executing the protocol. In either of the above settings, some assumption regarding the protocol execution is made: i.e., that many parties are honest in the first case, or that a legitimately-chosen string is available in the second. If this assumption is incorrect then all security is lost. A natural question is whether it is possible to design protocols secure if either one of these assumptions holds, i.e., a protocol which is secure if either at most s players are dishonest or if up to t> s players are dishonest but the CRS is chosen in the prescribed manner. We show that such protocols exist if and only if s + t < n. 1
We show that there exist commitment, zero-knowledge and general function evaluation pro-tocols with universally composable security, in a model where all parties and all protocols have access to a single, global, random oracle and no other trusted setup. This model provides sig-nificantly stronger composable security guarantees than the traditional random oracle model of Bellare and Rogaway [CCS’93] or even the common reference string model. Indeed, these latter models provide no security guarantees in the presence of arbitrary protocols that use the same random oracle (or reference string or hash function). Furthermore, our protocols are highly efficient. Specifically, in the interactive setting, our commitment and general computation protocols are much more efficient than the best known ones due to Lindell [Crypto’11,’13] which are secure in the common reference string model. In the non-interactive setting, our protocols are slightly less efficient than the best known ones presented by Afshar et al. [Eurocrypt ’14] but do away with the need to rely on a non-global (programmable) reference string. 1
We consider non-malleable (NM) and universally composable (UC) commitment schemes in the common reference string (CRS) model. We show how to construct non-interactive NM commitments that remain non-malleable even if the adversary has access to an arbitrary number of commitments from honest players - rather than one, as in several previous schemes. We show this is a strictly stronger security notion. Our construction is the first non-interactive scheme achieving this that can be based on the minimal assumption of existence of one-way functions. But it can also be instantiated in a very efficient version based on the strong RSA assumption. For UC commitments, we show that existence of a UC commitment scheme in the CRS model (interactive or not) implies key exchange and - for a uniform reference string - even implies oblivious transfer. This indicates that UC commitment is a strictly stronger primitive than NM. Finally, we show that our strong RSA based construction can be used to improve the most efficient known UC commitment scheme so it can work with a CRS of size independent of the number of players, without loss of efficiency.
This paper presents a new non-interactive string-commitment scheme that achieves universally composable security. Security is proven under the decisional composite residuosity (DCR) assumption (or the decisional Diffie-Hellman (DDH) assumption) in the common reference string (CRS) model. The universal composability (UC) is a very strong security notion. If cryptographic protocols are proven secure in the UC framework, then they remain secure even if they are composed with arbitrary protocols and polynomially many copies of the protocols are run concurrently. Many UC commitment schemes in the CRS model have been proposed, but they are either interactive commitment or bit-commitment (not string-commitment) schemes. We note, however, that although our scheme is the first non-interactive UC string-commitment scheme, a CRS is not reusable. We use an extension of all-but-one trapdoor functions (ABO-TDFs) proposed by Peikert and Waters at STOC 2008 as an essential building block. Our main idea is to extend (original deterministic) ABO-TDFs to probabilistic ones by using the homomorphic properties of their function indices. The function indices of ABO-TDFs consist of ciphertexts of homomorphic encryption schemes (such as ElGamal, and Damgård-Jurik encryption). Therefore we can re-randomize the output of ABO-TDFs by re-randomization of ciphertexts. This is a new application of ABO-TDFs.