Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics

Statistical Properties of Many-Particle Systems with Hierarchical Structure

Mikhail Yu. Romanovsky

Published Feb 1, 2021• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Many-particle systems contained inside other particles (problem 1), as well as systems of particles delimited inside other particles, which, in turn, are delimited inside the third particles (problem 2), are considered. Under natural assumptions about conserved quantities such as the total number of all particles, the total energy, and a number of others, the most probable energy distributions of particles, true (internal) and external observables, are studied. The results of problems 1 and 2 can be interpreted as the separation of bottom level particles into kinds with different distributions observed in different experiments. In single-particle observations in the full probability problem 1, an effective Pauli principle arises in a consistent manner.

DOI
10.1134/s1063776121020059

Related papers

Most Probable Energy Distributions of Particles with Hierarchial Structures

Michael Y. Romanovsky

Similarly to the derivation of the Gibbs-Boltzmann distribution for structureless indistinguishable particles, we consider multi-particle systems some of which are contained (or delimited) inside others (Problem 1), as well as systems of particles delimited within other particles, which, in turn, are delimited yet inside another kind of particles (Problem 2). Under the natural assumptions concerning the conservation laws, such as the conservation of the total number of particles, total energy, etc, the problem of the most probable energy distributions is studied in a combinatorial formulation, with the obtained distributions treated as externally observable. For Problem 1, the particle distributions over maximal and minimal energies are also established and shown to coincide with the ones found in the framework of the original combinatorial treatment. The results for Problems 1 and 2 can be interpreted as a sorting of lower-level particles based on their statistical mechanics behavior observed in various experiments. An effective Pauli principle arises in a non-contradictory manner in one-particle observations for the complete probabilistic Problem 1 in the combinatorial formulation as well as in the problem of distributions over maximal and minimal energies. Several of the calculated distributions describe particles having no negative energy states.

arXiv:2107.07793•Jul 16, 2021•0 citations

Quantum Statistics and Coherent Access Hypothesis

N. G. de Almeida

The properties of quantum systems at equilibrium are mainly displayed by the very nature ofthe particles involved. As for example, distinguishable particles behave in a quite differentmanner of indistinguishable bosons, which in turns behave very different from the alsoindistinguishable fermions. Among the standard methods of statistical mechanics to handlewithquantumsystemsatequilibriumisincludedthewayofcountingtheaccessiblestatestoagivenparticle(1). Thus,thethermodynamicalprobability Ω comprisingthesetofpossibilitiesfor a system of N particles to populate the available states will depend on the type of particlebeing considered, as shown in Table 1. The method for calculating Ω consists in supposingthe existence of a number of energy levels, labeled by and index

InTech eBooks•Feb 22, 2012•0 citations

- Many-particle Systems

Alastair I. M. Rae, Jim Napolitano

Although many of the principles of quantum mechanics can be adequately illustrated by considering systems that consist of only one particle subject to external forces, there are a number of important phenomena that are manifest only in systems containing two or more particles, and these will be the subject of the present chapter. We shall begin with some general statements and go on to consider the case of two interacting particles subject to no external forces, when we shall find that, in this case, the problem can be separated into one describing the behaviour of the centre of mass of the system and another describing the relative motion. We shall then consider the case of two noninteracting particles and show that these can often be treated independently as would be expected. In the case of indistinguishable particles, however, we shall find that a symmetry is imposed on the wave function that ensures that the behaviour of such particles is coupled even when they do not interact. We shall introduce the problem of interacting systems containing more than two identical particles, explaining what is meant by “fermions” and “bosons” and how their properties compare. These results will be illustrated by discussing the energy levels and optical spectra of the helium atom, starting with the approximation that the two electrons do not interact and extending the discussion to the realistic case using perturbation theory. The chapter closes with a consideration of the effects of particle indistinguishability on scattering theory.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 16, 2015•0 citations

The Principle of equal Probabilities of Quantum States

M. Psimopoulos, Emilie Dafflon

The statistical problem of the distribution of $s$ quanta of equal energy $ε_0$ and total energy $E$ among $N$ distinguishable particles is resolved using the conventional theory based on Boltzmann's principle of equal probabilities of configurations of particles distributed among energy levels and the concept of average state. In particular, the probability that a particle is in the \k{appa}-th energy level i.e. contains \k{appa} quanta, is given by $p(κ)=\displaystyle \frac{\displaystyle \binom{N+s-κ-2}{N-2}}{\displaystyle \binom{N+s-1}{N-1}} \;\;\; ; \;\;\; κ= 0, 1, 2, \cdots, s$ In this context, the special case ($N=4$, $s=4$) presented indicates that the alternative concept of most probable state is not valid for finite values of $s$ and $N$. In the present article we derive alternatively $p(κ)$ by distributing $s$ quanta over $N$ particles and by introducing a new principle of equal probability of quantum states, where the quanta are indistinguishable in agreement with the Bose statistics. Therefore, the analysis of the two approaches presented in this paper highlights the equivalence of quantum theory with classical statistical mechanics for the present system. At the limit $ε_{o} \rightarrow 0 $; $s \rightarrow \infty $; $s ε_{o} = E \sim$ fixed, where the energy of the particles becomes continuous, $p(κ)$ transforms to the Boltzmann law $P(ε) = \displaystyle \frac{1}{\langle ε\rangle}e^{-\fracε{\langle ε\rangle}} \;\;\; ; \;\;\; 0\leq ε< +\infty$ where $\langle ε\rangle = E/N$. Hence, the classical principle of equal a priori probabilities for the energy of the particles leading to the above law, is justified here by quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2111.09246•Nov 17, 2021•0 citations

Problems and Solutions in Many-Particle Systems

Pradeep Kumar Sharma

Many-particle systems play a fundamental role in physics where we encounter systems of molecules or systems of elementary particles in quantum field theory. Many-particle theories provide the basis for understanding the macroscopic behaviour of vast assemblies of interacting particles starting from their microscopic properties and leads to descriptions of entropy, statistical mechanics and fluid mechanics. Covering a wide range of topics and including more than 400 problems and solutions, this book is an ideal resource for students specialising in many-particle systems. Key features • Several hundred problems with solutions in each volume. • Problems range from basic introductory to advanced level. • Features worked examples as well as solutions to many problems. • Includes key concepts. • Covers essential complete physics course.

Institute of Physics eBooks•Feb 1, 2025•0 citations

Conservation and the Distribution of a Defining Property(energy/momentum) Versus The Distribution of Probability

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In classical statistical mechanics, e.g. a Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB) gas, one tries to find the probability distribution of a particular quantity such as particle energy pp/2m. Thus there is a distribution in a quantity, making it the stochastic variable. This quantity, however, is subject to a conservation law i.e. elastic two particle scattering. In a previous note (1), we considered the case of reflection/refraction and called momentum the stochastic variable and noted that it too was linked with conservation. In fact, we argued that both the MB gas and reflection/refraction followed the same stochastic law: P(variable1) P(variable 2) = P(variable 1 + variable 2) whether variable 1 is a scalar or vector. In (2), however, we noted that exp(ipx), a free particle wavefunction, treats p as a parameter with x being the “probability” variable. This seems a little unusual because p, which is normally a variable in an MB gas and even in a quantum bound state i.e. a*(p)a(p) where W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p) exp(ipx) takes on the role of a parameter i.e. p=hbar/wavelength. Why this duality? Why is p a parameter for “x” of the probability distribution and yet at the same time a variable associated with conservation of momentum? In this note, we argue that unlike the distribution of a defining property of a particle such as momentum or energy, one may have a distribution associated with probability itself. This we argue is the case for a reflection/refraction problem which applies to both light and a particle. In the case of light, there is an interface of two media with different indices of refraction and in the case of a particle an interface with two constant potentials. In both cases, total energy of the photon/particle is constant, but there are two choices or probabilities, reflection or refraction, but they are linked with different times. A single photon or particle can only undergo one at a time. One knows exactly the two values of momentum, but the probability of each is unknown. Thus unlike an MB gas where energy/momentum is being redistributed because the two particles of the outcome exist at the same time, here a probability of 1 must somehow be distributed to the two events.. Given that the incident momentum is p, the reflected -p and the refracted p2, only considering a specific time event i.e. reflection or refraction, does not conserve momentum. In the MB case, a single time event i.e. scattering conserves both momentum and energy. Thus it seems that one does not deal with events in time. There is a distribution of probability in such a way as to ensure conservation of momentum, but does this probability already exist or get created at the interface point? We argued in (3) that if the scenario were deterministic one would have to follow it in time and treat each event separately. Rather we suggest that a distribution of probabilities allows for conservation of momentum, but this means that all three momenta exist at the interface x point as one is not considering an event at a precise point in time. This then allows for each momentum to have its own x distribution based on momentum p so that one may impose conservation of momentum and not have a deterministic time associated with the interface point.. This last idea of conservation of momentum appearing is not discussed in (3) and allows for p to behave like a parameter for x while at the same time being a variable which is conserved. In short, in an MB gas one distributes energy between two colliding particles in order to conserve total energy while for a quantum particle or photon which reflects/refracts one distributes probability to the two scenarios (reflection or refraction) such that momentum is conserved. Thus the nature of what is “distributed” is very different.

•Feb 7, 2023•0 citations
Many-particle systems contained inside other particles (problem 1), as well as systems of particles delimited inside other particles, which, in turn, are delimited inside the third particles (problem 2), are considered. Under natural assumptions about conserved quantities such as the total number of all particles, the total energy, and a number of others, the most probable energy distributions of particles, true (internal) and external observables, are studied. The results of problems 1 and 2 can be interpreted as the separation of bottom level particles into kinds with different distributions observed in different experiments. In single-particle observations in the full probability problem 1, an effective Pauli principle arises in a consistent manner.
Similarly to the derivation of the Gibbs-Boltzmann distribution for structureless indistinguishable particles, we consider multi-particle systems some of which are contained (or delimited) inside others (Problem 1), as well as systems of particles delimited within other particles, which, in turn, are delimited yet inside another kind of particles (Problem 2). Under the natural assumptions concerning the conservation laws, such as the conservation of the total number of particles, total energy, etc, the problem of the most probable energy distributions is studied in a combinatorial formulation, with the obtained distributions treated as externally observable. For Problem 1, the particle distributions over maximal and minimal energies are also established and shown to coincide with the ones found in the framework of the original combinatorial treatment. The results for Problems 1 and 2 can be interpreted as a sorting of lower-level particles based on their statistical mechanics behavior observed in various experiments. An effective Pauli principle arises in a non-contradictory manner in one-particle observations for the complete probabilistic Problem 1 in the combinatorial formulation as well as in the problem of distributions over maximal and minimal energies. Several of the calculated distributions describe particles having no negative energy states.
The properties of quantum systems at equilibrium are mainly displayed by the very nature ofthe particles involved. As for example, distinguishable particles behave in a quite differentmanner of indistinguishable bosons, which in turns behave very different from the alsoindistinguishable fermions. Among the standard methods of statistical mechanics to handlewithquantumsystemsatequilibriumisincludedthewayofcountingtheaccessiblestatestoagivenparticle(1). Thus,thethermodynamicalprobability Ω comprisingthesetofpossibilitiesfor a system of N particles to populate the available states will depend on the type of particlebeing considered, as shown in Table 1. The method for calculating Ω consists in supposingthe existence of a number of energy levels, labeled by and index
Although many of the principles of quantum mechanics can be adequately illustrated by considering systems that consist of only one particle subject to external forces, there are a number of important phenomena that are manifest only in systems containing two or more particles, and these will be the subject of the present chapter. We shall begin with some general statements and go on to consider the case of two interacting particles subject to no external forces, when we shall find that, in this case, the problem can be separated into one describing the behaviour of the centre of mass of the system and another describing the relative motion. We shall then consider the case of two noninteracting particles and show that these can often be treated independently as would be expected. In the case of indistinguishable particles, however, we shall find that a symmetry is imposed on the wave function that ensures that the behaviour of such particles is coupled even when they do not interact. We shall introduce the problem of interacting systems containing more than two identical particles, explaining what is meant by “fermions” and “bosons” and how their properties compare. These results will be illustrated by discussing the energy levels and optical spectra of the helium atom, starting with the approximation that the two electrons do not interact and extending the discussion to the realistic case using perturbation theory. The chapter closes with a consideration of the effects of particle indistinguishability on scattering theory.
The statistical problem of the distribution of sss quanta of equal energy ε0ε_0ε0​ and total energy EEE among NNN distinguishable particles is resolved using the conventional theory based on Boltzmann's principle of equal probabilities of configurations of particles distributed among energy levels and the concept of average state. In particular, the probability that a particle is in the \k{appa}-th energy level i.e. contains \k{appa} quanta, is given by p(κ)=(N+s−κ−2N−2)(N+s−1N−1)      ;      κ=0,1,2,⋯ ,sp(κ)=\displaystyle \frac{\displaystyle \binom{N+s-κ-2}{N-2}}{\displaystyle \binom{N+s-1}{N-1}} \;\;\; ; \;\;\; κ= 0, 1, 2, \cdots, sp(κ)=(N−1N+s−1​)(N−2N+s−κ−2​)​;κ=0,1,2,⋯,s In this context, the special case (N=4N=4N=4, s=4s=4s=4) presented indicates that the alternative concept of most probable state is not valid for finite values of sss and NNN. In the present article we derive alternatively p(κ)p(κ)p(κ) by distributing sss quanta over NNN particles and by introducing a new principle of equal probability of quantum states, where the quanta are indistinguishable in agreement with the Bose statistics. Therefore, the analysis of the two approaches presented in this paper highlights the equivalence of quantum theory with classical statistical mechanics for the present system. At the limit $ε_{o} \rightarrow 0 $; $s \rightarrow \infty $; sεo=E∼s ε_{o} = E \simsεo​=E∼ fixed, where the energy of the particles becomes continuous, p(κ)p(κ)p(κ) transforms to the Boltzmann law P(ε)=1⟨ε⟩e−ε⟨ε⟩      ;      0≤ε<+∞P(ε) = \displaystyle \frac{1}{\langle ε\rangle}e^{-\fracε{\langle ε\rangle}} \;\;\; ; \;\;\; 0\leq ε< +\inftyP(ε)=⟨ε⟩1​e−⟨ε⟩ε​;0≤ε<+∞ where ⟨ε⟩=E/N\langle ε\rangle = E/N⟨ε⟩=E/N. Hence, the classical principle of equal a priori probabilities for the energy of the particles leading to the above law, is justified here by quantum mechanics.
Many-particle systems play a fundamental role in physics where we encounter systems of molecules or systems of elementary particles in quantum field theory. Many-particle theories provide the basis for understanding the macroscopic behaviour of vast assemblies of interacting particles starting from their microscopic properties and leads to descriptions of entropy, statistical mechanics and fluid mechanics. Covering a wide range of topics and including more than 400 problems and solutions, this book is an ideal resource for students specialising in many-particle systems. Key features • Several hundred problems with solutions in each volume. • Problems range from basic introductory to advanced level. • Features worked examples as well as solutions to many problems. • Includes key concepts. • Covers essential complete physics course.
In classical statistical mechanics, e.g. a Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB) gas, one tries to find the probability distribution of a particular quantity such as particle energy pp/2m. Thus there is a distribution in a quantity, making it the stochastic variable. This quantity, however, is subject to a conservation law i.e. elastic two particle scattering. In a previous note (1), we considered the case of reflection/refraction and called momentum the stochastic variable and noted that it too was linked with conservation. In fact, we argued that both the MB gas and reflection/refraction followed the same stochastic law: P(variable1) P(variable 2) = P(variable 1 + variable 2) whether variable 1 is a scalar or vector. In (2), however, we noted that exp(ipx), a free particle wavefunction, treats p as a parameter with x being the “probability” variable. This seems a little unusual because p, which is normally a variable in an MB gas and even in a quantum bound state i.e. a*(p)a(p) where W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p) exp(ipx) takes on the role of a parameter i.e. p=hbar/wavelength. Why this duality? Why is p a parameter for “x” of the probability distribution and yet at the same time a variable associated with conservation of momentum? In this note, we argue that unlike the distribution of a defining property of a particle such as momentum or energy, one may have a distribution associated with probability itself. This we argue is the case for a reflection/refraction problem which applies to both light and a particle. In the case of light, there is an interface of two media with different indices of refraction and in the case of a particle an interface with two constant potentials. In both cases, total energy of the photon/particle is constant, but there are two choices or probabilities, reflection or refraction, but they are linked with different times. A single photon or particle can only undergo one at a time. One knows exactly the two values of momentum, but the probability of each is unknown. Thus unlike an MB gas where energy/momentum is being redistributed because the two particles of the outcome exist at the same time, here a probability of 1 must somehow be distributed to the two events.. Given that the incident momentum is p, the reflected -p and the refracted p2, only considering a specific time event i.e. reflection or refraction, does not conserve momentum. In the MB case, a single time event i.e. scattering conserves both momentum and energy. Thus it seems that one does not deal with events in time. There is a distribution of probability in such a way as to ensure conservation of momentum, but does this probability already exist or get created at the interface point? We argued in (3) that if the scenario were deterministic one would have to follow it in time and treat each event separately. Rather we suggest that a distribution of probabilities allows for conservation of momentum, but this means that all three momenta exist at the interface x point as one is not considering an event at a precise point in time. This then allows for each momentum to have its own x distribution based on momentum p so that one may impose conservation of momentum and not have a deterministic time associated with the interface point.. This last idea of conservation of momentum appearing is not discussed in (3) and allows for p to behave like a parameter for x while at the same time being a variable which is conserved. In short, in an MB gas one distributes energy between two colliding particles in order to conserve total energy while for a quantum particle or photon which reflects/refracts one distributes probability to the two scenarios (reflection or refraction) such that momentum is conserved. Thus the nature of what is “distributed” is very different.