Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2107.07793

Most Probable Energy Distributions of Particles with Hierarchial Structures

Michael Y. Romanovsky

Published Jul 16, 2021• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Similarly to the derivation of the Gibbs-Boltzmann distribution for structureless indistinguishable particles, we consider multi-particle systems some of which are contained (or delimited) inside others (Problem 1), as well as systems of particles delimited within other particles, which, in turn, are delimited yet inside another kind of particles (Problem 2). Under the natural assumptions concerning the conservation laws, such as the conservation of the total number of particles, total energy, etc, the problem of the most probable energy distributions is studied in a combinatorial formulation, with the obtained distributions treated as externally observable. For Problem 1, the particle distributions over maximal and minimal energies are also established and shown to coincide with the ones found in the framework of the original combinatorial treatment. The results for Problems 1 and 2 can be interpreted as a sorting of lower-level particles based on their statistical mechanics behavior observed in various experiments. An effective Pauli principle arises in a non-contradictory manner in one-particle observations for the complete probabilistic Problem 1 in the combinatorial formulation as well as in the problem of distributions over maximal and minimal energies. Several of the calculated distributions describe particles having no negative energy states.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2107.07793

Related papers

Statistical Properties of Many-Particle Systems with Hierarchical Structure

Mikhail Yu. Romanovsky

Many-particle systems contained inside other particles (problem 1), as well as systems of particles delimited inside other particles, which, in turn, are delimited inside the third particles (problem 2), are considered. Under natural assumptions about conserved quantities such as the total number of all particles, the total energy, and a number of others, the most probable energy distributions of particles, true (internal) and external observables, are studied. The results of problems 1 and 2 can be interpreted as the separation of bottom level particles into kinds with different distributions observed in different experiments. In single-particle observations in the full probability problem 1, an effective Pauli principle arises in a consistent manner.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics•Feb 1, 2021•0 citations

The Principle of equal Probabilities of Quantum States

M. Psimopoulos, Emilie Dafflon

The statistical problem of the distribution of $s$ quanta of equal energy $ε_0$ and total energy $E$ among $N$ distinguishable particles is resolved using the conventional theory based on Boltzmann's principle of equal probabilities of configurations of particles distributed among energy levels and the concept of average state. In particular, the probability that a particle is in the \k{appa}-th energy level i.e. contains \k{appa} quanta, is given by $p(κ)=\displaystyle \frac{\displaystyle \binom{N+s-κ-2}{N-2}}{\displaystyle \binom{N+s-1}{N-1}} \;\;\; ; \;\;\; κ= 0, 1, 2, \cdots, s$ In this context, the special case ($N=4$, $s=4$) presented indicates that the alternative concept of most probable state is not valid for finite values of $s$ and $N$. In the present article we derive alternatively $p(κ)$ by distributing $s$ quanta over $N$ particles and by introducing a new principle of equal probability of quantum states, where the quanta are indistinguishable in agreement with the Bose statistics. Therefore, the analysis of the two approaches presented in this paper highlights the equivalence of quantum theory with classical statistical mechanics for the present system. At the limit $ε_{o} \rightarrow 0 $; $s \rightarrow \infty $; $s ε_{o} = E \sim$ fixed, where the energy of the particles becomes continuous, $p(κ)$ transforms to the Boltzmann law $P(ε) = \displaystyle \frac{1}{\langle ε\rangle}e^{-\fracε{\langle ε\rangle}} \;\;\; ; \;\;\; 0\leq ε< +\infty$ where $\langle ε\rangle = E/N$. Hence, the classical principle of equal a priori probabilities for the energy of the particles leading to the above law, is justified here by quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2111.09246•Nov 17, 2021•0 citations

A REMARK ON BOLTZMANN H THEOREM

CHANG TSUNG-SDEI, 中国科学院数学研究所,北京师范大学物理系

It is pointed out that the quantum-mechanical Boltzmann H theorem in the restricted sense (i.e. with explicit consideration of the statistics of the particles constituting the system and their interactions) does not lead directly to the distribution laws for the particles among their various states as is commonly believed, but to the equality of the probability for all states belonging to the system as a whole if the system is isolated, (or to the Boltzmann factor for the probabilities of states belonging to a system at constant temperature), in agreement with the result of the generalized quantum-mechanical H theorem as given by Pauli. The distribution laws for the particles among their various states may of course be deduced from the latter.In the course of proof, we have also introduced the following minor improvements:(i) To avoid conservation of energy in microscopic processes which lead to changes in the states of the particles and thus to equilibrium, we let our system be in interaction with a heat reservoir, so that energy may be supplied by or given to it. This is tauto-mount to changing the study of the entropy for an isolated system to that of the free energy for a system at constant temperature.(ii) Interaction energies between the particles which affect the total energy of the system and thus the distribution laws for the particles among their various states are included.

Acta Physica Sinica•Jan 1, 1954•2 citations

Observable Statistical Mechanics

Lodovico Scarpa, Abdulla Alhajri, Vlatko Vedral +1 more

Predicting the stationary behavior of observables in isolated many-body quantum systems is a central challenge in quantum statistical mechanics. While one can often use the Gibbs ensemble, which is simple to compute, there are many scenarios where this is not possible and one must instead use another ensemble, such as the diagonal, microcanonical or generalized Gibbs ensembles. However, these all require detailed information about the energy or other conserved quantities to be constructed. Here we propose a general and computationally easy approach to determine the stationary probability distribution of observables with few outcomes. Interpreting coarse measurements at equilibrium as noisy communication channels, we provide general analytical arguments in favor of the applicability of a maximum entropy principle for this class of observables. We show that the resulting theory accurately predicts stationary probability distributions without detailed microscopic information like the energy eigenstates. Extensive numerical experiments on 7 non-weakly interacting spin-1/2 Hamiltonians demonstrate the broad applicability and robustness of this framework in both quantum integrable and chaotic models.

arXiv:2309.15173•Sep 26, 2023•6 citations

Degeneracy, Average Occupancy and Microstates in Statistical Mechanics

Francesco R. Ruggeri

An interesting result arises in information theory, namely that if one considers a microstate with large N trials, each representing a state i with probability p(i), then even though this is only one of many possible microstates (each being a permutation of each other) it carries information about all of the permutations based on the average occupancy number. In particular, the probability of a microstate may be written as: Product over i p(ei) [power Np(ei) ] for large N. This holds for any microstate and so all have the same probability. Given that all of the microstates are permutations in the large N case, this probability is equivalent to 1/ {number of permutations} where Number of permutations = N! / { Product over i n(ei) }. We point out the above example, because it seems there are at least two main strategies in statistical mechanics. One is to begin with a set of average occupancy numbers n(ei/T) whose specific form is unknown. The idea then seems to be to seek degeneracy in the system, possibly among the arrangement of the n(ei)’s or degeneracy within single levels ei and to maximize the number of degenerate arrangements in order to account for as little information as possible. This approach may be used to calculate the Maxwell-Boltzmann, Fermi-Dirac and Bose-Einstein distributions. In the case of the latter two, degeneracy in the single energy levels ei is key. One then maximizes the ln of the degenerate arrangements subject to constraints such as Sum over i ei n(ei) and Sum over i n(ei) = N. The degeneracies themselves are associated with momentum degeneracies yielding the same energy. A completely different approach, it seems, is to consider exp(-(E-uN)/T) as representing the probability of a state with energy E and N particles and to use either the grand canonical ensemble i.e. sum the various exp(-(E-uN)/T)’s. These may then be broken into single particle sums using E(N) = sum over i ei n(ei) for n(ei) variable or sum over i ei for N fixed. Even though momentum degeneracy still exists, it is not part of the n sum of exp(-(E-uN)/T) factors which gives a single energy level probability distribution with no maximization necessary. Thus we point out that exp(-(E-uN)/T) for microstates seems to incorporate information about degeneracies without them needing to be explicitly added. On the other hand, if one starts with average n(ei) (without knowing their form), one must explicitly consider degeneracies in order to maximize so that there is no unnecessary information in the system. Both approaches should yield the same result. We consider the Bose-Einstein example of a photon gas as an example.

•May 15, 2023•0 citations

Position Uncertainty in a Statistical View of Quantum Bound States

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Derivations of statistical mechanical distributions often involve the maximization of some type of uncertainty (i.e. the number of spatial arrangements or arrangements in degenerate cells of phase space) subject to a global constraint on energy (and also particle number). Interactions within statistical systems (particles colliding with each other or with a wall), introducing conservation of energy at a particle collision level is a way to achieve global energy conservation. Quantum mechanics is a statistical theory, so one may ask whether it too is based on the conservation of a particle property and whether it makes use of the maximization of some type of uncertainty. In this note, we argue that momentum is the conserved particle quantity (kinetic and potential energy are conserved on average) and that for a momentum state, one maximizes the uncertainty of x in a particular way.

•Jun 20, 2020•0 citations
Similarly to the derivation of the Gibbs-Boltzmann distribution for structureless indistinguishable particles, we consider multi-particle systems some of which are contained (or delimited) inside others (Problem 1), as well as systems of particles delimited within other particles, which, in turn, are delimited yet inside another kind of particles (Problem 2). Under the natural assumptions concerning the conservation laws, such as the conservation of the total number of particles, total energy, etc, the problem of the most probable energy distributions is studied in a combinatorial formulation, with the obtained distributions treated as externally observable. For Problem 1, the particle distributions over maximal and minimal energies are also established and shown to coincide with the ones found in the framework of the original combinatorial treatment. The results for Problems 1 and 2 can be interpreted as a sorting of lower-level particles based on their statistical mechanics behavior observed in various experiments. An effective Pauli principle arises in a non-contradictory manner in one-particle observations for the complete probabilistic Problem 1 in the combinatorial formulation as well as in the problem of distributions over maximal and minimal energies. Several of the calculated distributions describe particles having no negative energy states.
Many-particle systems contained inside other particles (problem 1), as well as systems of particles delimited inside other particles, which, in turn, are delimited inside the third particles (problem 2), are considered. Under natural assumptions about conserved quantities such as the total number of all particles, the total energy, and a number of others, the most probable energy distributions of particles, true (internal) and external observables, are studied. The results of problems 1 and 2 can be interpreted as the separation of bottom level particles into kinds with different distributions observed in different experiments. In single-particle observations in the full probability problem 1, an effective Pauli principle arises in a consistent manner.
The statistical problem of the distribution of sss quanta of equal energy ε0ε_0ε0​ and total energy EEE among NNN distinguishable particles is resolved using the conventional theory based on Boltzmann's principle of equal probabilities of configurations of particles distributed among energy levels and the concept of average state. In particular, the probability that a particle is in the \k{appa}-th energy level i.e. contains \k{appa} quanta, is given by p(κ)=(N+s−κ−2N−2)(N+s−1N−1)      ;      κ=0,1,2,⋯ ,sp(κ)=\displaystyle \frac{\displaystyle \binom{N+s-κ-2}{N-2}}{\displaystyle \binom{N+s-1}{N-1}} \;\;\; ; \;\;\; κ= 0, 1, 2, \cdots, sp(κ)=(N−1N+s−1​)(N−2N+s−κ−2​)​;κ=0,1,2,⋯,s In this context, the special case (N=4N=4N=4, s=4s=4s=4) presented indicates that the alternative concept of most probable state is not valid for finite values of sss and NNN. In the present article we derive alternatively p(κ)p(κ)p(κ) by distributing sss quanta over NNN particles and by introducing a new principle of equal probability of quantum states, where the quanta are indistinguishable in agreement with the Bose statistics. Therefore, the analysis of the two approaches presented in this paper highlights the equivalence of quantum theory with classical statistical mechanics for the present system. At the limit $ε_{o} \rightarrow 0 $; $s \rightarrow \infty $; sεo=E∼s ε_{o} = E \simsεo​=E∼ fixed, where the energy of the particles becomes continuous, p(κ)p(κ)p(κ) transforms to the Boltzmann law P(ε)=1⟨ε⟩e−ε⟨ε⟩      ;      0≤ε<+∞P(ε) = \displaystyle \frac{1}{\langle ε\rangle}e^{-\fracε{\langle ε\rangle}} \;\;\; ; \;\;\; 0\leq ε< +\inftyP(ε)=⟨ε⟩1​e−⟨ε⟩ε​;0≤ε<+∞ where ⟨ε⟩=E/N\langle ε\rangle = E/N⟨ε⟩=E/N. Hence, the classical principle of equal a priori probabilities for the energy of the particles leading to the above law, is justified here by quantum mechanics.
It is pointed out that the quantum-mechanical Boltzmann H theorem in the restricted sense (i.e. with explicit consideration of the statistics of the particles constituting the system and their interactions) does not lead directly to the distribution laws for the particles among their various states as is commonly believed, but to the equality of the probability for all states belonging to the system as a whole if the system is isolated, (or to the Boltzmann factor for the probabilities of states belonging to a system at constant temperature), in agreement with the result of the generalized quantum-mechanical H theorem as given by Pauli. The distribution laws for the particles among their various states may of course be deduced from the latter.In the course of proof, we have also introduced the following minor improvements:(i) To avoid conservation of energy in microscopic processes which lead to changes in the states of the particles and thus to equilibrium, we let our system be in interaction with a heat reservoir, so that energy may be supplied by or given to it. This is tauto-mount to changing the study of the entropy for an isolated system to that of the free energy for a system at constant temperature.(ii) Interaction energies between the particles which affect the total energy of the system and thus the distribution laws for the particles among their various states are included.
Predicting the stationary behavior of observables in isolated many-body quantum systems is a central challenge in quantum statistical mechanics. While one can often use the Gibbs ensemble, which is simple to compute, there are many scenarios where this is not possible and one must instead use another ensemble, such as the diagonal, microcanonical or generalized Gibbs ensembles. However, these all require detailed information about the energy or other conserved quantities to be constructed. Here we propose a general and computationally easy approach to determine the stationary probability distribution of observables with few outcomes. Interpreting coarse measurements at equilibrium as noisy communication channels, we provide general analytical arguments in favor of the applicability of a maximum entropy principle for this class of observables. We show that the resulting theory accurately predicts stationary probability distributions without detailed microscopic information like the energy eigenstates. Extensive numerical experiments on 7 non-weakly interacting spin-1/2 Hamiltonians demonstrate the broad applicability and robustness of this framework in both quantum integrable and chaotic models.
An interesting result arises in information theory, namely that if one considers a microstate with large N trials, each representing a state i with probability p(i), then even though this is only one of many possible microstates (each being a permutation of each other) it carries information about all of the permutations based on the average occupancy number. In particular, the probability of a microstate may be written as: Product over i p(ei) [power Np(ei) ] for large N. This holds for any microstate and so all have the same probability. Given that all of the microstates are permutations in the large N case, this probability is equivalent to 1/ {number of permutations} where Number of permutations = N! / { Product over i n(ei) }. We point out the above example, because it seems there are at least two main strategies in statistical mechanics. One is to begin with a set of average occupancy numbers n(ei/T) whose specific form is unknown. The idea then seems to be to seek degeneracy in the system, possibly among the arrangement of the n(ei)’s or degeneracy within single levels ei and to maximize the number of degenerate arrangements in order to account for as little information as possible. This approach may be used to calculate the Maxwell-Boltzmann, Fermi-Dirac and Bose-Einstein distributions. In the case of the latter two, degeneracy in the single energy levels ei is key. One then maximizes the ln of the degenerate arrangements subject to constraints such as Sum over i ei n(ei) and Sum over i n(ei) = N. The degeneracies themselves are associated with momentum degeneracies yielding the same energy. A completely different approach, it seems, is to consider exp(-(E-uN)/T) as representing the probability of a state with energy E and N particles and to use either the grand canonical ensemble i.e. sum the various exp(-(E-uN)/T)’s. These may then be broken into single particle sums using E(N) = sum over i ei n(ei) for n(ei) variable or sum over i ei for N fixed. Even though momentum degeneracy still exists, it is not part of the n sum of exp(-(E-uN)/T) factors which gives a single energy level probability distribution with no maximization necessary. Thus we point out that exp(-(E-uN)/T) for microstates seems to incorporate information about degeneracies without them needing to be explicitly added. On the other hand, if one starts with average n(ei) (without knowing their form), one must explicitly consider degeneracies in order to maximize so that there is no unnecessary information in the system. Both approaches should yield the same result. We consider the Bose-Einstein example of a photon gas as an example.
Derivations of statistical mechanical distributions often involve the maximization of some type of uncertainty (i.e. the number of spatial arrangements or arrangements in degenerate cells of phase space) subject to a global constraint on energy (and also particle number). Interactions within statistical systems (particles colliding with each other or with a wall), introducing conservation of energy at a particle collision level is a way to achieve global energy conservation. Quantum mechanics is a statistical theory, so one may ask whether it too is based on the conservation of a particle property and whether it makes use of the maximization of some type of uncertainty. In this note, we argue that momentum is the conserved particle quantity (kinetic and potential energy are conserved on average) and that for a momentum state, one maximizes the uncertainty of x in a particular way.