Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

The Classical Limit of an Atom

Carlos R. Stroud

Published Sep 2, 1993• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

. A series of recent experiments and calculations are described that study the classical limit of an atom. The classical limit of an atom is defined to be the quantum mechanical state that most nearly approximates the ideal of a classical particle traveling in a Kepler orbit. It is found that correspondence between the quantum and classical descriptions is always in the form of ensembles of many realizations so long as the electron is taken to be a point particle. Even in the limit of a wave packet made up of states with all quantum numbers large there are distinctly quantum interference features in the evolution of the quantum ensemble. However, when the classical theory is modified by allowing within the ensemble only the Kepler orbits corresponding to energies and angular momenta allowed by Bohr's old quantum theory, most of the interference features are produced by the ensemble of classical particles. Ed Jaynes has been characterized variously as a physicist, a statistician, an inventor, a free thinker, a teacher, a mentor, and a rabble rouser. It is hard to dispute his right to any of these mantles he might wish to claim, but it is equally hard to find a finite set of descriptors that do him justice. From my own selfish point of view his most important contribution has been to act as a source of ideas and new ways of looking at some long-standing and fundamental problems.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511524448.013

Related papers

Classical and quantum-mechanical dynamics of a quasiclassical state of the hydrogen atom

Z. D. Gaeta, Carlos R. Stroud

We explore the classical limit of the hydrogen atom by constructing a minimum-uncertainty wave packet that travels along a Kepler orbit. The dynamics of the wave packet display both classical and quantum-mechanical properties. Over a limited period of time, during which the dynamics of the wave packet may be considered linear, the motion of the wave packet can be described by classical equations of motion. After this time, the quantum dynamics, whose most prominent features are decays and revivals of the wave packet, becomes dominant. We discuss decays and revivals of the wave packet in detail.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1990•125 citations

Rydberg Wave Packets and the Classical Limit

Jonathan S. Parker, Carlos R. Stroud

A method is proposed and analyzed for producing single atom Rydberg states which are nearly as possible classical. It is shown that a picosecond laser pulse can excite a localized wave packet of Rydberg states which propagates like a particle in a classical Kepler orbit. These states are studied numerically and approximate analytic techniques are developed for analyzing their properties.

Physica Scripta•Jan 1, 1986•51 citations

Are Electrons Real?

W. V. Houston

Recent years have shown a revival of interest in the conceptual problem raised by the incorporation of quantum mechanics into physics. The problem is an old one, but the use of both waves and particles as visualizations of electrons has presented it in a new and acute form. Several observations based on the methods of quantum mechanics can be made. (1) The time development of an isolated system is completely determinate, as in classical mechanics. (2) A precisely defined quantum mechanical state is an eigenstate of some operator described in classical terms. The production of such a state requires a suitable large scale apparatus. (3) If the state is not precisely defined as an eigenstate, quantum statistical mechanics must be used. (4) The idea of measurement is of doubtful applicability in the analysis of idealized experiments, since the process of measurement destroys the identity of the object (an electron) whose properties are measured. Quantum mechanics may be viewed strictly as a method of describing, in classical terms, the behavior of large scale apparatus, although the use of visualizations with a properly conditioned intuition is probably essential to progress in the analysis of new phenomena.

American Journal of Physics•Apr 1, 1966•2 citations

Rydberg atom wave packets localized in the angular coordinates

John A. Yeazell, Carlos R. Stroud

The quantum theory of atoms is based on a Hamiltonian which is just that of the classical Kepler theory of planetary orbits. In spite of this common foundation, the predictions of quantum theory ordinarily do not much resemble those of classical theory. Even in the limit of large quantum numbers the energy eigenstates of quantum theory do not look at all like the classical elliptical orbits. Recently, Parker and Stroud1 have shown that it is possible to excite a Rydberg atom wave packet whose radial dependence resembles the classical ideal of a particle traveling in an elliptical orbit. In this paper we discuss the formation of a wave packet in the polar and azimuthal angles by the coherent excitation of Rydberg states with the same principal quantum, but with a distribution of the angular momentum quantum numbers. When this wave packet is formed of the Rydberg states of an alkali atom the connection with classical theory is again striking. The wave packet precesses due to the core polarization, just as the classical elliptical orbit precesses due to an added r–4 perturbing potential.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1986•0 citations

Classical Limit of Quantum Mechanics

Xiang-You Huang

Because of the use of different limiting procedures, there are two conflict conclusions on wave function. One is that a wave function can describe a single particle and the other is that it can only describe an ensemble in the classical limit. In this paper the limiting procedures have been compared. We put the synthesized limit n→∞, →0 but keep E(n, ) to be the actual measured value of energy. Under this limit condition, we can not only prove that a wave function can only describe an ensemble, but also can make clear the dynamical behavior of the particles of the ensemble. Calculations show that the reason why quantum mechanics cannot describe a particle is not because of the motion equation but because of the definition of state for the particle.

Science in China Series A-Mathematics Physics Astronomy & Technological Science•Feb 20, 1993•1 citation

Spatially localized Rydberg atom wave packets

John A. Yeazell, Carlos R. Stroud

The quantum theory of atoms is based on a Hamiltonian which is just that of the classical Kepler theory of planetary orbits. In spite of this common foundation, the predictions of the quantum theory ordinarily do not much resemble those of the classical theory. Even in the limit of large quantum numbers the energy eigenstates of quantum theory do not look at all like the classical elliptical orbits. Recently, Parker and Stroud1 showed that it is possible to excite a Rydberg atomic wave packet localized in the radial coordinate. Also, Yeazell and Stroud2 showed that a wave packet localized in the angular coordinates can be formed. Both wave packets exhibit an evolution describable, at least in part, by classical theory. However, neither wave packet truly corresponds to a wave packet traveling in a classical elliptical orbit. We discuss the manner in which such a wave packet might be formed using a short-pulsed laser and arf dressing field. The evolution of the resulting wave packet is compared with that of its classical counterpart.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1987•0 citations
. A series of recent experiments and calculations are described that study the classical limit of an atom. The classical limit of an atom is defined to be the quantum mechanical state that most nearly approximates the ideal of a classical particle traveling in a Kepler orbit. It is found that correspondence between the quantum and classical descriptions is always in the form of ensembles of many realizations so long as the electron is taken to be a point particle. Even in the limit of a wave packet made up of states with all quantum numbers large there are distinctly quantum interference features in the evolution of the quantum ensemble. However, when the classical theory is modified by allowing within the ensemble only the Kepler orbits corresponding to energies and angular momenta allowed by Bohr's old quantum theory, most of the interference features are produced by the ensemble of classical particles. Ed Jaynes has been characterized variously as a physicist, a statistician, an inventor, a free thinker, a teacher, a mentor, and a rabble rouser. It is hard to dispute his right to any of these mantles he might wish to claim, but it is equally hard to find a finite set of descriptors that do him justice. From my own selfish point of view his most important contribution has been to act as a source of ideas and new ways of looking at some long-standing and fundamental problems.
We explore the classical limit of the hydrogen atom by constructing a minimum-uncertainty wave packet that travels along a Kepler orbit. The dynamics of the wave packet display both classical and quantum-mechanical properties. Over a limited period of time, during which the dynamics of the wave packet may be considered linear, the motion of the wave packet can be described by classical equations of motion. After this time, the quantum dynamics, whose most prominent features are decays and revivals of the wave packet, becomes dominant. We discuss decays and revivals of the wave packet in detail.
Recent years have shown a revival of interest in the conceptual problem raised by the incorporation of quantum mechanics into physics. The problem is an old one, but the use of both waves and particles as visualizations of electrons has presented it in a new and acute form. Several observations based on the methods of quantum mechanics can be made. (1) The time development of an isolated system is completely determinate, as in classical mechanics. (2) A precisely defined quantum mechanical state is an eigenstate of some operator described in classical terms. The production of such a state requires a suitable large scale apparatus. (3) If the state is not precisely defined as an eigenstate, quantum statistical mechanics must be used. (4) The idea of measurement is of doubtful applicability in the analysis of idealized experiments, since the process of measurement destroys the identity of the object (an electron) whose properties are measured. Quantum mechanics may be viewed strictly as a method of describing, in classical terms, the behavior of large scale apparatus, although the use of visualizations with a properly conditioned intuition is probably essential to progress in the analysis of new phenomena.
The quantum theory of atoms is based on a Hamiltonian which is just that of the classical Kepler theory of planetary orbits. In spite of this common foundation, the predictions of quantum theory ordinarily do not much resemble those of classical theory. Even in the limit of large quantum numbers the energy eigenstates of quantum theory do not look at all like the classical elliptical orbits. Recently, Parker and Stroud1 have shown that it is possible to excite a Rydberg atom wave packet whose radial dependence resembles the classical ideal of a particle traveling in an elliptical orbit. In this paper we discuss the formation of a wave packet in the polar and azimuthal angles by the coherent excitation of Rydberg states with the same principal quantum, but with a distribution of the angular momentum quantum numbers. When this wave packet is formed of the Rydberg states of an alkali atom the connection with classical theory is again striking. The wave packet precesses due to the core polarization, just as the classical elliptical orbit precesses due to an added r–4 perturbing potential.
Because of the use of different limiting procedures, there are two conflict conclusions on wave function. One is that a wave function can describe a single particle and the other is that it can only describe an ensemble in the classical limit. In this paper the limiting procedures have been compared. We put the synthesized limit n→∞, →0 but keep E(n, ) to be the actual measured value of energy. Under this limit condition, we can not only prove that a wave function can only describe an ensemble, but also can make clear the dynamical behavior of the particles of the ensemble. Calculations show that the reason why quantum mechanics cannot describe a particle is not because of the motion equation but because of the definition of state for the particle.
The quantum theory of atoms is based on a Hamiltonian which is just that of the classical Kepler theory of planetary orbits. In spite of this common foundation, the predictions of the quantum theory ordinarily do not much resemble those of the classical theory. Even in the limit of large quantum numbers the energy eigenstates of quantum theory do not look at all like the classical elliptical orbits. Recently, Parker and Stroud1 showed that it is possible to excite a Rydberg atomic wave packet localized in the radial coordinate. Also, Yeazell and Stroud2 showed that a wave packet localized in the angular coordinates can be formed. Both wave packets exhibit an evolution describable, at least in part, by classical theory. However, neither wave packet truly corresponds to a wave packet traveling in a classical elliptical orbit. We discuss the manner in which such a wave packet might be formed using a short-pulsed laser and arf dressing field. The evolution of the resulting wave packet is compared with that of its classical counterpart.