Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Avoiding apparent signalling in Bell tests for quantum information applications

Massimiliano Smania, Matthias Kleinmann, Adán Cabello, Mohamed Bourennane

Published Jan 1, 2020• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Bell tests have become a powerful tool for checking security, quantifying randomness, detecting entanglement, and many other applications, as well as for investigating fundamental physical limits. ...

Related papers

Bell tests and the no-signalling assumption

Massimiliano Smania

Bell's theorem was originally meant for testing fundamental properties of Nature, namely local realism. However, through the years it has become a powerful device for certifying encryption security ...

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

How to avoid (apparent) signaling in Bell tests

Massimiliano Smania, Matthias Kleinmann, Adán Cabello +1 more

Bell tests have become a powerful tool for quantifying security, randomness, entanglement, and many other properties, as well as for investigating fundamental physical limits. In all these cases, the specific experimental value of the Bell parameter is important as it leads to a quantitative conclusion. However, experimental implementations can also produce experimental data with (apparent) signaling. This signaling can be attributed to systematic errors occurring due to weaknesses in the experimental designs. Here we point out the importance, for quantitative applications, to identify and address this problem. We present a set of experiments with polarization-entangled photons in which we identify common sources of systematic errors and demonstrate approaches to avoid them. In addition, we establish the highest experimental value for the Bell-CHSH parameter obtained after applying strategies to minimize signaling that we are aware of: S = 2.812 ± 0.003 and negligible systematic errors. The experiments did not randomize the settings and did not close the locality loophole.

arXiv:1801.05739•Quantum•Jun 4, 2025•11 citations

Bell tests explained classically without quantum entanglement

Dean L. Mamas

Bell test experimental results can be classically explained as simply a trivial geometric effect, without any need to evoke any quantum phenomena such as entanglement. There is no instantaneous action-at-a-distance.

Physics Essays•Sep 21, 2021•1 citation

Revealing Bell Nonlocality Does Not Require the Same Physical Measurement to be Performed Twice

Paweł Cieśliński, Carlotta Versmold, Jan Wójcik +6 more

Bell inequality violations, or Bell nonlocality for short, is not only central to testing the foundations of quantum physics but have also become an essential ingredient of numerous quantum information protocols, from quantum key distribution to the device-independent certification of randomness and secure communication. Existing analyses of Bell nonlocality assume that a small set of predefined measurement directions can be reproduced exactly. But what if these directions cannot be reproduced at all? This may happen for fundamental or technical reasons, such as variations in the measurement apparatus. Here we show that the violation of a Bell inequality remains possible and that it also retains its operational significance, even when the measurement directions never repeat. We experimentally confirm these results using polarization-entangled photons, detecting only one particle pair per randomly chosen analyzer direction. Our results establish the robustness of Bell inequality violations against imperfect measurement repeatability and further connect Bell tests with the broader framework of randomized measurements. Moreover, they extend quantum information protocols to settings with limited measurement control, including quantum device certification, communication complexity, and quantum cryptography.

arXiv:2611.15871•Nov 11, 2026•0 citations

Photonic multipartite entanglement : Generation, measurement and applications

Massimiliano Smania

We are currently witnessing a fundamental change in the field of quantum information, whereby protocols and experiments previously performed in university labs are now being implemented in real-world scenarios, and a strong commercial push for new and reliable applications is contributing significantly in advancing fundamental research. In this thesis and related included papers, I first look at a keystone of quantum science, Bell's theorem. In particular, I will expose an issue that we call apparent signalling, which affects many current and past experiments relying on Bell tests. A statistical test of the impact of apparent signalling is described, together with experimental approaches to successfully mitigate it. Next, I consider one of the most refined ideas that recently emerged in quantum information, device-independent certification. Device-independent quantum information aims at answering the question: "Assuming we trust quantum mechanics, what can we conclude about the quantum systems or the measurement operators in a given experiment, based solely on its results, while making minimal assumptions on the physical devices used?". In my work, the problem was successfully approached in two different scenarios, one based on entangled photons and the other on prepare-and-measure experiments with single photons, with the aim of certifying informationally-complete quantum measurements. Finally, I conclude by presenting an elegant and promising approach to the experimental generation of multi-photon entanglement, which is a fundamental prerequisite in most modern quantum information protocols.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

TUTORIAL: Entanglement and Quantum Information Theory

S. J. van Enk

In this tutorial I'll review the old and modern definitions of entanglement, discuss why we think entanglement is useful, and present various methods that can be used to detect entanglement in an experiment. Article not available.

Frontiers in Optics•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation
Bell tests have become a powerful tool for quantifying security, randomness, entanglement, and many other properties, as well as for investigating fundamental physical limits. In all these cases, the specific experimental value of the Bell parameter is important as it leads to a quantitative conclusion. However, experimental implementations can also produce experimental data with (apparent) signaling. This signaling can be attributed to systematic errors occurring due to weaknesses in the experimental designs. Here we point out the importance, for quantitative applications, to identify and address this problem. We present a set of experiments with polarization-entangled photons in which we identify common sources of systematic errors and demonstrate approaches to avoid them. In addition, we establish the highest experimental value for the Bell-CHSH parameter obtained after applying strategies to minimize signaling that we are aware of: S = 2.812 ± 0.003 and negligible systematic errors. The experiments did not randomize the settings and did not close the locality loophole.
Bell inequality violations, or Bell nonlocality for short, is not only central to testing the foundations of quantum physics but have also become an essential ingredient of numerous quantum information protocols, from quantum key distribution to the device-independent certification of randomness and secure communication. Existing analyses of Bell nonlocality assume that a small set of predefined measurement directions can be reproduced exactly. But what if these directions cannot be reproduced at all? This may happen for fundamental or technical reasons, such as variations in the measurement apparatus. Here we show that the violation of a Bell inequality remains possible and that it also retains its operational significance, even when the measurement directions never repeat. We experimentally confirm these results using polarization-entangled photons, detecting only one particle pair per randomly chosen analyzer direction. Our results establish the robustness of Bell inequality violations against imperfect measurement repeatability and further connect Bell tests with the broader framework of randomized measurements. Moreover, they extend quantum information protocols to settings with limited measurement control, including quantum device certification, communication complexity, and quantum cryptography.
We are currently witnessing a fundamental change in the field of quantum information, whereby protocols and experiments previously performed in university labs are now being implemented in real-world scenarios, and a strong commercial push for new and reliable applications is contributing significantly in advancing fundamental research. In this thesis and related included papers, I first look at a keystone of quantum science, Bell's theorem. In particular, I will expose an issue that we call apparent signalling, which affects many current and past experiments relying on Bell tests. A statistical test of the impact of apparent signalling is described, together with experimental approaches to successfully mitigate it. Next, I consider one of the most refined ideas that recently emerged in quantum information, device-independent certification. Device-independent quantum information aims at answering the question: "Assuming we trust quantum mechanics, what can we conclude about the quantum systems or the measurement operators in a given experiment, based solely on its results, while making minimal assumptions on the physical devices used?". In my work, the problem was successfully approached in two different scenarios, one based on entangled photons and the other on prepare-and-measure experiments with single photons, with the aim of certifying informationally-complete quantum measurements. Finally, I conclude by presenting an elegant and promising approach to the experimental generation of multi-photon entanglement, which is a fundamental prerequisite in most modern quantum information protocols.