Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.15871

Revealing Bell Nonlocality Does Not Require the Same Physical Measurement to be Performed Twice

Paweł Cieśliński, Carlotta Versmold, Jan Wójcik, Eun Mi Kim, Jan Dziewior, Paweł Kurzyński, Tomasz Paterek, Harald Weinfurter, Wiesław Laskowski

Published Nov 11, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Bell inequality violations, or Bell nonlocality for short, is not only central to testing the foundations of quantum physics but have also become an essential ingredient of numerous quantum information protocols, from quantum key distribution to the device-independent certification of randomness and secure communication. Existing analyses of Bell nonlocality assume that a small set of predefined measurement directions can be reproduced exactly. But what if these directions cannot be reproduced at all? This may happen for fundamental or technical reasons, such as variations in the measurement apparatus. Here we show that the violation of a Bell inequality remains possible and that it also retains its operational significance, even when the measurement directions never repeat. We experimentally confirm these results using polarization-entangled photons, detecting only one particle pair per randomly chosen analyzer direction. Our results establish the robustness of Bell inequality violations against imperfect measurement repeatability and further connect Bell tests with the broader framework of randomized measurements. Moreover, they extend quantum information protocols to settings with limited measurement control, including quantum device certification, communication complexity, and quantum cryptography.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.15871

Related papers

Guaranteed violation of a Bell inequality without aligned reference frames or calibrated devices

Peter Shadbolt, Tamás Vértesi, Yeong-Cherng Liang +3 more

Bell tests - the experimental demonstration of a Bell inequality violation - are central to understanding the foundations of quantum mechanics, and are a powerful diagnostic tool for the development of quantum technologies. To date, Bell tests have relied on careful calibration of measurement devices and alignment of a shared reference frame between two parties - both technically demanding tasks. We show that neither of these operations are necessary, violating Bell inequalities (i) with certainty using unaligned, but calibrated, measurement devices, and (ii) with near-certainty using uncalibrated and unaligned devices. We demonstrate generic quantum nonlocality with randomly chosen measurements on a singlet state of two photons, implemented using a reconfigurable integrated optical waveguide circuit. The observed results demonstrate the robustness of our schemes to imperfections and statistical noise. This approach is likely to have important applications both in fundamental science and quantum technologies, including device-independent quantum key distribution.

arXiv:1111.1853•Scientific Reports•Jun 25, 2012•79 citations

Bell nonlocality and device-independent quantum information

Sachin .

Bell nonlocality is the experimentally testable incompatibility between quantum correlations and explanations based on local hidden variables. Its significance now extends beyond the foundations of quantum mechanics: a Bell-inequality violation can certify entanglement, randomness, measurement incompatibility, and cryptographic security without requiring a detailed model of the devices producing the observed data. This article develops the mathematical structure of Bell experiments and explains its role in device-independent quantum information. Conditional probability distributions are classified into local, quantum, and no-signalling sets; the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality is derived, and its classical, quantum, and algebraic limits are distinguished. Tsirelson’s bound is obtained from the CHSH operator, while Popescu-Rohrlich correlations demonstrate that no-signalling alone does not identify the quantum set. The relation between entanglement and nonlocality is examined through local entangled states, hidden nonlocality, and activation. Nonlocal games, semidefinite relaxations, self-testing, certified randomness, and device-independent quantum key distribution are treated as operational consequences of Bell violation. Particular attention is given to entropy accumulation, finite-data security, loophole-free experiments, and the limitations of device independence. Bell nonlocality emerges as both a foundational separation between classical and quantum causal models and a quantitative resource for cryptographic and informational tasks.

International Journal of Physics and Mathematics•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Demonstration of Quantum Nonlocality in the Presence of Measurement Dependence

Djeylan Aktas, Sébastien Tanzilli, Anthony Martin +3 more

Quantum nonlocality stands as a resource for device independent quantum information processing (DIQIP), such as, for instance, device independent quantum key distribution. We investigate, experimentally, the assumption of limited measurement dependence, i.e., that the measurement settings used in Bell inequality tests or DIQIP are partially influenced by the source of entangled particle and/or by an adversary. Using a recently derived Bell-like inequality [G. Pütz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 190402 (2014)] and a 99% fidelity source of partially entangled polarization photonic qubits, we obtain a clear violation of the inequality, excluding a much larger range of measurement dependent local models than would be possible with an adapted Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality. It is therefore shown that the measurement independence assumption can be widely relaxed while still demonstrating quantum nonlocality.

arXiv:1504.08332•Physical Review Letters•Jun 4, 2015•26 citations

Engineering robust quantum resources from maximal violations of subcorrelation Bell inequalities

Ahmed Abdelsalam, Ahmed M. Ghander, Mamdouh Shams El-Din +1 more

Abstract Bell inequalities have long been essential for the device-independent detection of entanglement. This study introduces subcorrelation Bell inequalities as a robust framework for detecting entanglement and probing quantum non-locality. We derived a family of such inequalities, categorized according to their dependence on measurement settings, and numerically identified 19 distinct quantum states that achieve the maximal violation of these inequalities. Importantly, our focus on maximal violation is not for its own sake but because, in this framework, maximal violation directly corresponds to maximal robustness of nonlocal correlations against particle loss. This connection reveals a broad class of multipartite entangled states that remain resilient under loss, making them highly relevant for practical implementations of quantum information protocols. We further characterized their entanglement properties using concurrence and the geometric measure, confirming their utility for critical areas such as quantum communication, cryptography, and device-independent protocols. The framework established herein sets the stage for future investigations, including the generalization of these inequalities to higher-dimensional systems and a more comprehensive characterization of their robustness against various forms of noise, thereby expanding the potential for non-local states to drive progress in quantum technologies.

Physica Scripta•Apr 24, 2026•0 citations

Measurement compatibility in Bell nonlocality tests

Tassius Temistocles, Rafael Rabelo, Marcelo Terra Cunha

Incompatibility of observables, or measurements, is one of the key features of quantum mechanics, related, among other concepts, to Heisenberg's uncertainty relations and Bell nonlocality. In this manuscript we show, however, that even though incompatible measurements are necessary for the violation of any Bell inequality, some relevant Bell-like inequalities may be obtained if compatibility relations are assumed between the local measurements of one (or more) of the parties. Hence, compatibility of measurements is not necessarily a drawback and may, however, be useful for the detection of Bell nonlocality and device-independent certification of entanglement.

arXiv:1806.09232•Physical Review A•Apr 22, 2019•21 citations

Measurement dependence and limited detection nonlocality

Djeylan Aktas, Pütz, G., Anthony Martin +4 more

Quantum nonlocality stands as a resource for device independent quantum information processing (DIQIP). It finds repercussions in applications such as, among others, quantum key distribution and generation of randomness. In this work, we investigate two different approaches to attest nonlocality. First we follow the assumption of limited measurement dependence, i.e., that the measurement settings used in Bell inequality tests or DIQIP are partially influenced by the source of entangled particles and/or by an adversary. Then, we introduce the intermediate assumption of limi- ted detection efficiency, that is, in each run of the experiment, the overall detection efficiency is lower bounded by eta_min > 0. Hence, in an adversarial scenario, the adversaries have arbitrary large but not full control over the inefficiencies. We analyse the set of possible correlations that fulfil Measurement Dependence/Limited Detection Locality (MDL/LDL) and show that they necessarily satisfy some linear Bell-like inequalities. In both scenarios, quantum theory predicts the violation of such inequalities for l > 0 in the first case, and eta_min > 0 in the other. We validate these assumptions experimentally via a twin-photon implementation in which two users are provided each with one photon out of a partially entangled pair. On one hand, we show with the first inequality that the measurement independence assumption can be widely relaxed while still demonstrating quantum nonlocality. On the other hand with the second inequality, assuming the switches between the measurement bases are not fully controlled by an adversary, nor by hypothetical local variables, we reveal the nonlocality of the established correlations despite a low overall detection efficiency.

•Nov 18, 2015•0 citations
Bell inequality violations, or Bell nonlocality for short, is not only central to testing the foundations of quantum physics but have also become an essential ingredient of numerous quantum information protocols, from quantum key distribution to the device-independent certification of randomness and secure communication. Existing analyses of Bell nonlocality assume that a small set of predefined measurement directions can be reproduced exactly. But what if these directions cannot be reproduced at all? This may happen for fundamental or technical reasons, such as variations in the measurement apparatus. Here we show that the violation of a Bell inequality remains possible and that it also retains its operational significance, even when the measurement directions never repeat. We experimentally confirm these results using polarization-entangled photons, detecting only one particle pair per randomly chosen analyzer direction. Our results establish the robustness of Bell inequality violations against imperfect measurement repeatability and further connect Bell tests with the broader framework of randomized measurements. Moreover, they extend quantum information protocols to settings with limited measurement control, including quantum device certification, communication complexity, and quantum cryptography.
Bell tests - the experimental demonstration of a Bell inequality violation - are central to understanding the foundations of quantum mechanics, and are a powerful diagnostic tool for the development of quantum technologies. To date, Bell tests have relied on careful calibration of measurement devices and alignment of a shared reference frame between two parties - both technically demanding tasks. We show that neither of these operations are necessary, violating Bell inequalities (i) with certainty using unaligned, but calibrated, measurement devices, and (ii) with near-certainty using uncalibrated and unaligned devices. We demonstrate generic quantum nonlocality with randomly chosen measurements on a singlet state of two photons, implemented using a reconfigurable integrated optical waveguide circuit. The observed results demonstrate the robustness of our schemes to imperfections and statistical noise. This approach is likely to have important applications both in fundamental science and quantum technologies, including device-independent quantum key distribution.
Bell nonlocality is the experimentally testable incompatibility between quantum correlations and explanations based on local hidden variables. Its significance now extends beyond the foundations of quantum mechanics: a Bell-inequality violation can certify entanglement, randomness, measurement incompatibility, and cryptographic security without requiring a detailed model of the devices producing the observed data. This article develops the mathematical structure of Bell experiments and explains its role in device-independent quantum information. Conditional probability distributions are classified into local, quantum, and no-signalling sets; the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality is derived, and its classical, quantum, and algebraic limits are distinguished. Tsirelson’s bound is obtained from the CHSH operator, while Popescu-Rohrlich correlations demonstrate that no-signalling alone does not identify the quantum set. The relation between entanglement and nonlocality is examined through local entangled states, hidden nonlocality, and activation. Nonlocal games, semidefinite relaxations, self-testing, certified randomness, and device-independent quantum key distribution are treated as operational consequences of Bell violation. Particular attention is given to entropy accumulation, finite-data security, loophole-free experiments, and the limitations of device independence. Bell nonlocality emerges as both a foundational separation between classical and quantum causal models and a quantitative resource for cryptographic and informational tasks.
Quantum nonlocality stands as a resource for device independent quantum information processing (DIQIP), such as, for instance, device independent quantum key distribution. We investigate, experimentally, the assumption of limited measurement dependence, i.e., that the measurement settings used in Bell inequality tests or DIQIP are partially influenced by the source of entangled particle and/or by an adversary. Using a recently derived Bell-like inequality [G. Pütz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 190402 (2014)] and a 99% fidelity source of partially entangled polarization photonic qubits, we obtain a clear violation of the inequality, excluding a much larger range of measurement dependent local models than would be possible with an adapted Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality. It is therefore shown that the measurement independence assumption can be widely relaxed while still demonstrating quantum nonlocality.
Abstract Bell inequalities have long been essential for the device-independent detection of entanglement. This study introduces subcorrelation Bell inequalities as a robust framework for detecting entanglement and probing quantum non-locality. We derived a family of such inequalities, categorized according to their dependence on measurement settings, and numerically identified 19 distinct quantum states that achieve the maximal violation of these inequalities. Importantly, our focus on maximal violation is not for its own sake but because, in this framework, maximal violation directly corresponds to maximal robustness of nonlocal correlations against particle loss. This connection reveals a broad class of multipartite entangled states that remain resilient under loss, making them highly relevant for practical implementations of quantum information protocols. We further characterized their entanglement properties using concurrence and the geometric measure, confirming their utility for critical areas such as quantum communication, cryptography, and device-independent protocols. The framework established herein sets the stage for future investigations, including the generalization of these inequalities to higher-dimensional systems and a more comprehensive characterization of their robustness against various forms of noise, thereby expanding the potential for non-local states to drive progress in quantum technologies.
Incompatibility of observables, or measurements, is one of the key features of quantum mechanics, related, among other concepts, to Heisenberg's uncertainty relations and Bell nonlocality. In this manuscript we show, however, that even though incompatible measurements are necessary for the violation of any Bell inequality, some relevant Bell-like inequalities may be obtained if compatibility relations are assumed between the local measurements of one (or more) of the parties. Hence, compatibility of measurements is not necessarily a drawback and may, however, be useful for the detection of Bell nonlocality and device-independent certification of entanglement.
Quantum nonlocality stands as a resource for device independent quantum information processing (DIQIP). It finds repercussions in applications such as, among others, quantum key distribution and generation of randomness. In this work, we investigate two different approaches to attest nonlocality. First we follow the assumption of limited measurement dependence, i.e., that the measurement settings used in Bell inequality tests or DIQIP are partially influenced by the source of entangled particles and/or by an adversary. Then, we introduce the intermediate assumption of limi- ted detection efficiency, that is, in each run of the experiment, the overall detection efficiency is lower bounded by eta_min > 0. Hence, in an adversarial scenario, the adversaries have arbitrary large but not full control over the inefficiencies. We analyse the set of possible correlations that fulfil Measurement Dependence/Limited Detection Locality (MDL/LDL) and show that they necessarily satisfy some linear Bell-like inequalities. In both scenarios, quantum theory predicts the violation of such inequalities for l > 0 in the first case, and eta_min > 0 in the other. We validate these assumptions experimentally via a twin-photon implementation in which two users are provided each with one photon out of a partially entangled pair. On one hand, we show with the first inequality that the measurement independence assumption can be widely relaxed while still demonstrating quantum nonlocality. On the other hand with the second inequality, assuming the switches between the measurement bases are not fully controlled by an adversary, nor by hypothetical local variables, we reveal the nonlocality of the established correlations despite a low overall detection efficiency.