Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Structure, subject, and experiment: first forays of interdisciplinary philosophical investigations

Lucas W.E. Tessaro

Published Feb 21, 2020• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

The present dissertation aims to incorporate inter-disciplinarily features of philosophical inquiry, scientific exploration, and subjective reflection on the epistemology of knowledge. The work begins with an extensive literature review on the topics of MODERN PHYSICS AND PHILOSOPHY, in particular exploring in depth the PHILOSOPHY OF PHYSICAL SCIENCE of Sir Arthur Eddington and synthesizes it with works of CLASSICAL PHILOSOPHERS, namely Aristotle, Plato, and to a smaller extent Heraclitus. It borrows heavily from the early movers of QUANTUM MECHANICS – Werner Heisenberg and Erwin Schrodinger – and demonstrates their own familiarity with the aforementioned Classical Thinkers, finally emphasizing their still necessary and continued relevance in MODERN PHILOSOPHY OF PHYSICS. The work focusses on the nature of knowledge – EPISTEMOLOGY – under two particular facets; that of subjectivity and the role of experimenter/observer in creating knowledge, and that of structuralism as defined by Eddington as the metaphysical “structure” created by the objects of inquiry, the methods used to observe them, and the observer themselves. The introductory chapters conclude with a Treatise on the Nature of Interdisciplinary research, emphasizing INTERDISCIPLINARITY as a naturally-occurring process of the human mind, and thereby illustrating its omnipresence throughout the entirety of Homo sapiens – from pre-history to CLASSICAL ANTIQUITY to the modern official conceptualization of the term in ACADEMIA. The work proceeds with three experimental chapters designed to explore and illustrate these above features. The first demonstrates the communication of bacteria using photons of particular periodicities, emphasizing the notion of structure. The second explores the most destructive of human activities, war, through the resolution of potentially sub-conscious patterns and periodicities within this aggressive behaviour, demonstrating its governance by Lunar cycles. The third and final experiment investigates a fundamental behaviour of our species, language, by comparing the quantitative shifts in frequencies and formants resultant from holding facial expressions that encapsulate neutral, happy, and sad affective states; the phenomenon arises from the subjective expression and reception of vocalizations altered in periodic ways. The dissertation closes with a brief exploration of dogmatic approaches to knowledge production. There are a number of objectives for the present dissertation. First, it has an overarching aim of continuing the traditional field of what was NATURAL PHILOSOPHY – the highly integratory science in which the barriers between disciplines had not yet been firmly entrenched. In doing so, it is a work of interdisciplinary science, cobbling together diverse fields as biology, biophysics, experimental psychology, linguistics, with a particular emphasis on philosophy. It is arguably a work of EXPERIMENTAL PHILOSOPHY, only instead of focusing on moralist issues it explores the PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE through experimentation. Second, it enquires to what extent a particular tool is applicable in multiple scenarios from epistemological and ontological perspectives; it questions to what extent emergent phenomena are capable of describing the states of the biological systems. Whether recording biophotons from bacteria, observing patterns of human warfare, or measuring the vocalizations of psychology students, the dissertation hopes to demonstrate signals of those systems are equivalent epistemologically; in that breaking the signal down into its components is sufficient and justifiable for discerning knowledge of the system that produced it. In so doing, it is possible to argue they are ontologically related as signal phenomenon – although their precise natures of being differ, as signals they represent a particular class of being; a messenger. Finally, the document hopes to illustrate in a general sense the continued importance of including to some extent philosophical considerations and perspectives within science. It desires to be a demonstration of the “BIG PICTURE” approach to devising methodologies and comparing results for seemingly varied fields of study, promoting the act of interdisciplinarity without ascribing to any the nuances of particular interdisciplinary theory. In short, it emphasizes that “science can be destroyed by having the disciplines too thin, because there is no integration.” 1

Related papers

Language and Mind

T. Bergstein

Among philosophers in particular the principle of complementarity has been considered an unreasonable limitation of natural science, and Niels Bohr’s exposition of the inevitability of a statistical description when accounting for atomic phenomena has been regarded as a renouncement directly opposed to the very spirit of scientific investigation. Indeed, fundamental limitations in the range of applicability of the causal spacetime description of physical phenomena do exist, but quantum physics is precisely the generalization of the conceptual frame of classical physics which has converted these limitations into a springboard for investigations which are among the most fruitful in the history of science. Far from raising a barrier for scientific investigation, quantum physics has extended the scope of natural science to a degree that was unimaginable before its advent. Natural science now encompasses such different objects as the constituents of atoms, processes in remote galaxies, and psycho-chemical phenomena in man. Biochemistry and psychopharmacology, for instance, both rely on one of the most important results of quantum physics: the periodical system of the elements, which is fundamental to all modern chemistry. Furthermore atomic physics and chemistry are basic sciences for technology and thus contribute to the continuous development of instruments of observation for all branches of natural science.

•Jan 1, 1972•0 citations

Science as Narrative: As Paradigm Change in Explaining Quantum Physics

Georg Friedrich Simet

The language of modern science is understood as focused on papers, texts within disciplinary related discourses. Such texts address specific topics of scientific interest by providing arguments for or against research theorems. Nevertheless, events, particularly in quantum reality cannot be described as just statements of ‘truth’: unambiguousness and independence; the writing about science needs new formats and styles. Zeilinger, for instances, uses the dialogue format in order to show the interested, non-expert audience how to reflect on and interpret quantum events. Instead of indicating single research outputs and outcomes as absolute statements he considers the dependence of the observed from what is, or what is to be observed. He concentrates on the development of quantum theorems and shows such development processes in progress, in more or less fictive dialogues. This approach brings us back to the times of Attic Philosophy. Plato was the first who made use of the dialogic form: to let the reader/listener participate in philosophy as on-going process of reflection. The result was not as interesting as comprehending the way: the method to achieve it. Most of Plato’s dialogues ended in aporia indecidability. Aristotle instead was the first who established science as a system of classified true statements. In the following centuries science became more and important and modern. But in the beginning of the 20th century, the discovery of quantum effects suddenly led to the questioning of its mechanistic assumptions. Looking deeper into the history of science, this story, initiated by Aristotle, turned out to be a narrative of errors that necessarily caused and still causes paradigm changes. Once, Aristotle’s results oriented approach rightly succeeded over Plato’s pure methodology. By today, however, it seems that Aristotle’s founding of science becomes an obsolescent model. Plato’s process oriented way of reflection could be more adequate for the post-modern discourse of science.

BRILL eBooks•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

The Nature of Reality

Fritjof Capra

In this chapter, I offer some personal reflections about the nature of reality, shaped by my work as a quantum physicist, my experimentation with psychedelic drugs during the 1960s, and my more recent studies of modern cognitive science. Traditionally, questions about the essential nature of reality are asked by philosophers. In the twentieth century, these questions were asked for the first time by scientists as well. During the first three decades of the century, the exploration of the atomic and subatomic world brought physicists in contact with a strange and unexpected reality that shattered the foundations of their worldview and forced them to think in entirely new ways. Quantum physics showed scientists “a new reality,” and from that time on, the nature of reality became a popular subject of discussion not only in philosophy but also in science. In recent decades, cognitive scientists took another radical step in the scientific conception of the nature of reality. They asserted that the features of our ordinary, everyday reality are not features of an independently existing world, but are created in the very process of perception. In a way this generalizes the influence of the act of perception on the perceived object, which was famously analyzed in quantum physics by Werner Heisenberg, to everyday perception. In other words, even our everyday reality is just one of many alternate realities.

Routledge eBooks•May 8, 2025•0 citations

CLASSICAL MECHANICS AND CONTEMPORARY FUNDAMENTAL PHYSICAL RESEARCH

Мarian Аmbrozy, M. V. Lokajíček, Michal Valčo

The contemporary scientific and technological progress builds on the accomplishments of classical mechanics from the 19th century when the so-called 'European scientific method and values' were accepted practically by the whole educated world.Most scientific results and conclusions were reached based on the causal ontological approach proposed in principle already by Plato's Socrates and developed further by Aristotle.Despite the late-modern paradigm shift in science (Galilei, Newton, etc.), the topicality of the ontological approach proposed by Aristotle (II.Analytics) remains.On the other hand, 19th and 20th century philosophers, mainly positivists such as Mach and Avenarius but also Schlick and Carnap, attempted to change this approach to unify scientific knowledge in accordance with an ideological, i.e. positivist outlook on reality.The authors place a special emphasis on the contribution of Rudolf Carnap and his interaction with Martin Heidegger.Three very different theories are applied to physical reality in the present: classical mechanics in the standard macroscopic realm, Copenhagen quantum mechanics in the microscopic realm, and special theory of reality in both realms in the case of systems consisting of objects having higher velocity values.Any explanation or description of transitions between different realms and theories had not been provided until now.Our paper describes the corresponding evolution in the modern period and identifies the underlying false philosophical assumptions and statements existing in today's scientific systems.We will then demonstrate that one common theory for all realms of reality may exist; one that will be based fully on Hamilton equations (only the law

Philosophia International Journal of Philosophy•Jun 1, 2019•2 citations

"SUBJECTIVE" AND "OBJECTIVE" AS A METHODOLOGICAL PROBLEM

Тетяна Малкова

Today, many concepts from the dictionaries of academic psychology have entered the language of everyday communication. Perhaps the most common are the concepts of «subjective» and «objective». In many textbooks of psychology, «objective» is understood as something that belongs to the object itself, something that does not depend on the subject. The objective is opposed to the subjective-personal. Experimental research in the field of quantum physics questioned the division of the world into an impartial «objective reality» and its «subjective» (not impartial, biased) reflection, which provoked a crisis in this field of knowledge and the methodology of science as a whole. The main methodological problems of psychology are the question of the place of the mental in nature; on the relationship of mental and material phenomena, on the possibilities of human cognition - questions that also arose in the depths of quantum physics and were predetermined by the internal logic of their development. An excursion into quantum physics was necessary, firstly, for a deep understanding that reality is given to us in our sensations, perceptions, ideas and mental constructs (this was evidenced by the so-called «double slit experiment» and its interpretations) and we cannot say anything about reality as it is «in itself»; secondly, the realization that the foundations on which our knowledge is built differ from those in quantum physics. Currently, there is a dichotomy between material (physical) and conceptual reality. Thus, the principle of locality, which professes ordinary consciousness and according to which specific objects occupy a specific place in time and space, contradicts the principle of non-locality, according to which isolated systems do not exist at all and every particle of the universe is in «instantaneous» communication with all other particles. The world is created from the same quantum substance and it is impossible to say that one is the cause of the other. (This statement implies, in particular, a rethinking of the «principle of determinism» which requires the establishment of unambiguous causal relationships). The reality in which we live is not quantum, our language and stereotypes of thinking do not correspond to the nature of the phenomena described by quantum physics. It is about the deep properties of matter. Personally, I got the impression that the deeper you plunge into the world of atomic and subatomic, the more the outlines of the specific, material world familiar to us become blurred and the thinner the line between the physical and conceptual world, between the material and the spiritual becomes. The purpose of this article is to define the concepts of "objective" and "subjective" based on the analysis of achievements in quantum physics in the context of psychology.

Scientific notes of the UniversityKROK•Sep 30, 2023•0 citations

Interrelationship between physics and philosophy: A dialogue of science and thought

M. Šćepanović, Vladimir Drekalović

This paper examines the deep and enduring relationship between physics and philosophy, a connection that has shaped the trajectory of human inquiry from antiquity to the present. By tracing their shared historical roots, the paper emphasizes how early philosophical speculations laid the groundwork for scientific reasoning. Despite the modern institutional separation of these two disciplines, physics continues to grapple with questions that are fundamentally philosophical in nature, questions concerning the essence of time, space, causality, determinism, and the very nature of reality. The paper explores the epistemological structures that underpin scientific knowledge, such as the criteria for theory confirmation and falsifiability, and investigates the ontological assumptions embedded in classical and modern physics. Special attention is devoted to paradigm shifts in the history of science, including the contributions of figures such as Aristotle, Newton, Popper, and Kuhn, as well as the radical implications of quantum mechanics and general relativity. Through an analysis of contemporary debates, such as those surrounding interpretations of quantum mechanics, the multiverse, and the conceptual validity of string theory, the paper argues that philosophy remains indispensable for critically examining and contextualizing scientific thought. Far from being obsolete, philosophical reflection serves as a compass for navigating the conceptual challenges of physics. Ultimately, the dialogue between philosophy and physics is presented as a dynamic and reciprocal exchange, one that not only enriches both fields but is also necessary for advancing our understanding of the universe.

EPJ Web of Conferences•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
The present dissertation aims to incorporate inter-disciplinarily features of philosophical inquiry, scientific exploration, and subjective reflection on the epistemology of knowledge. The work begins with an extensive literature review on the topics of MODERN PHYSICS AND PHILOSOPHY, in particular exploring in depth the PHILOSOPHY OF PHYSICAL SCIENCE of Sir Arthur Eddington and synthesizes it with works of CLASSICAL PHILOSOPHERS, namely Aristotle, Plato, and to a smaller extent Heraclitus. It borrows heavily from the early movers of QUANTUM MECHANICS – Werner Heisenberg and Erwin Schrodinger – and demonstrates their own familiarity with the aforementioned Classical Thinkers, finally emphasizing their still necessary and continued relevance in MODERN PHILOSOPHY OF PHYSICS. The work focusses on the nature of knowledge – EPISTEMOLOGY – under two particular facets; that of subjectivity and the role of experimenter/observer in creating knowledge, and that of structuralism as defined by Eddington as the metaphysical “structure” created by the objects of inquiry, the methods used to observe them, and the observer themselves. The introductory chapters conclude with a Treatise on the Nature of Interdisciplinary research, emphasizing INTERDISCIPLINARITY as a naturally-occurring process of the human mind, and thereby illustrating its omnipresence throughout the entirety of Homo sapiens – from pre-history to CLASSICAL ANTIQUITY to the modern official conceptualization of the term in ACADEMIA. The work proceeds with three experimental chapters designed to explore and illustrate these above features. The first demonstrates the communication of bacteria using photons of particular periodicities, emphasizing the notion of structure. The second explores the most destructive of human activities, war, through the resolution of potentially sub-conscious patterns and periodicities within this aggressive behaviour, demonstrating its governance by Lunar cycles. The third and final experiment investigates a fundamental behaviour of our species, language, by comparing the quantitative shifts in frequencies and formants resultant from holding facial expressions that encapsulate neutral, happy, and sad affective states; the phenomenon arises from the subjective expression and reception of vocalizations altered in periodic ways. The dissertation closes with a brief exploration of dogmatic approaches to knowledge production. There are a number of objectives for the present dissertation. First, it has an overarching aim of continuing the traditional field of what was NATURAL PHILOSOPHY – the highly integratory science in which the barriers between disciplines had not yet been firmly entrenched. In doing so, it is a work of interdisciplinary science, cobbling together diverse fields as biology, biophysics, experimental psychology, linguistics, with a particular emphasis on philosophy. It is arguably a work of EXPERIMENTAL PHILOSOPHY, only instead of focusing on moralist issues it explores the PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE through experimentation. Second, it enquires to what extent a particular tool is applicable in multiple scenarios from epistemological and ontological perspectives; it questions to what extent emergent phenomena are capable of describing the states of the biological systems. Whether recording biophotons from bacteria, observing patterns of human warfare, or measuring the vocalizations of psychology students, the dissertation hopes to demonstrate signals of those systems are equivalent epistemologically; in that breaking the signal down into its components is sufficient and justifiable for discerning knowledge of the system that produced it. In so doing, it is possible to argue they are ontologically related as signal phenomenon – although their precise natures of being differ, as signals they represent a particular class of being; a messenger. Finally, the document hopes to illustrate in a general sense the continued importance of including to some extent philosophical considerations and perspectives within science. It desires to be a demonstration of the “BIG PICTURE” approach to devising methodologies and comparing results for seemingly varied fields of study, promoting the act of interdisciplinarity without ascribing to any the nuances of particular interdisciplinary theory. In short, it emphasizes that “science can be destroyed by having the disciplines too thin, because there is no integration.” 1
Among philosophers in particular the principle of complementarity has been considered an unreasonable limitation of natural science, and Niels Bohr’s exposition of the inevitability of a statistical description when accounting for atomic phenomena has been regarded as a renouncement directly opposed to the very spirit of scientific investigation. Indeed, fundamental limitations in the range of applicability of the causal spacetime description of physical phenomena do exist, but quantum physics is precisely the generalization of the conceptual frame of classical physics which has converted these limitations into a springboard for investigations which are among the most fruitful in the history of science. Far from raising a barrier for scientific investigation, quantum physics has extended the scope of natural science to a degree that was unimaginable before its advent. Natural science now encompasses such different objects as the constituents of atoms, processes in remote galaxies, and psycho-chemical phenomena in man. Biochemistry and psychopharmacology, for instance, both rely on one of the most important results of quantum physics: the periodical system of the elements, which is fundamental to all modern chemistry. Furthermore atomic physics and chemistry are basic sciences for technology and thus contribute to the continuous development of instruments of observation for all branches of natural science.
The language of modern science is understood as focused on papers, texts within disciplinary related discourses. Such texts address specific topics of scientific interest by providing arguments for or against research theorems. Nevertheless, events, particularly in quantum reality cannot be described as just statements of ‘truth’: unambiguousness and independence; the writing about science needs new formats and styles. Zeilinger, for instances, uses the dialogue format in order to show the interested, non-expert audience how to reflect on and interpret quantum events. Instead of indicating single research outputs and outcomes as absolute statements he considers the dependence of the observed from what is, or what is to be observed. He concentrates on the development of quantum theorems and shows such development processes in progress, in more or less fictive dialogues. This approach brings us back to the times of Attic Philosophy. Plato was the first who made use of the dialogic form: to let the reader/listener participate in philosophy as on-going process of reflection. The result was not as interesting as comprehending the way: the method to achieve it. Most of Plato’s dialogues ended in aporia indecidability. Aristotle instead was the first who established science as a system of classified true statements. In the following centuries science became more and important and modern. But in the beginning of the 20th century, the discovery of quantum effects suddenly led to the questioning of its mechanistic assumptions. Looking deeper into the history of science, this story, initiated by Aristotle, turned out to be a narrative of errors that necessarily caused and still causes paradigm changes. Once, Aristotle’s results oriented approach rightly succeeded over Plato’s pure methodology. By today, however, it seems that Aristotle’s founding of science becomes an obsolescent model. Plato’s process oriented way of reflection could be more adequate for the post-modern discourse of science.
In this chapter, I offer some personal reflections about the nature of reality, shaped by my work as a quantum physicist, my experimentation with psychedelic drugs during the 1960s, and my more recent studies of modern cognitive science. Traditionally, questions about the essential nature of reality are asked by philosophers. In the twentieth century, these questions were asked for the first time by scientists as well. During the first three decades of the century, the exploration of the atomic and subatomic world brought physicists in contact with a strange and unexpected reality that shattered the foundations of their worldview and forced them to think in entirely new ways. Quantum physics showed scientists “a new reality,” and from that time on, the nature of reality became a popular subject of discussion not only in philosophy but also in science. In recent decades, cognitive scientists took another radical step in the scientific conception of the nature of reality. They asserted that the features of our ordinary, everyday reality are not features of an independently existing world, but are created in the very process of perception. In a way this generalizes the influence of the act of perception on the perceived object, which was famously analyzed in quantum physics by Werner Heisenberg, to everyday perception. In other words, even our everyday reality is just one of many alternate realities.
The contemporary scientific and technological progress builds on the accomplishments of classical mechanics from the 19th century when the so-called 'European scientific method and values' were accepted practically by the whole educated world.Most scientific results and conclusions were reached based on the causal ontological approach proposed in principle already by Plato's Socrates and developed further by Aristotle.Despite the late-modern paradigm shift in science (Galilei, Newton, etc.), the topicality of the ontological approach proposed by Aristotle (II.Analytics) remains.On the other hand, 19th and 20th century philosophers, mainly positivists such as Mach and Avenarius but also Schlick and Carnap, attempted to change this approach to unify scientific knowledge in accordance with an ideological, i.e. positivist outlook on reality.The authors place a special emphasis on the contribution of Rudolf Carnap and his interaction with Martin Heidegger.Three very different theories are applied to physical reality in the present: classical mechanics in the standard macroscopic realm, Copenhagen quantum mechanics in the microscopic realm, and special theory of reality in both realms in the case of systems consisting of objects having higher velocity values.Any explanation or description of transitions between different realms and theories had not been provided until now.Our paper describes the corresponding evolution in the modern period and identifies the underlying false philosophical assumptions and statements existing in today's scientific systems.We will then demonstrate that one common theory for all realms of reality may exist; one that will be based fully on Hamilton equations (only the law
Today, many concepts from the dictionaries of academic psychology have entered the language of everyday communication. Perhaps the most common are the concepts of «subjective» and «objective». In many textbooks of psychology, «objective» is understood as something that belongs to the object itself, something that does not depend on the subject. The objective is opposed to the subjective-personal. Experimental research in the field of quantum physics questioned the division of the world into an impartial «objective reality» and its «subjective» (not impartial, biased) reflection, which provoked a crisis in this field of knowledge and the methodology of science as a whole. The main methodological problems of psychology are the question of the place of the mental in nature; on the relationship of mental and material phenomena, on the possibilities of human cognition - questions that also arose in the depths of quantum physics and were predetermined by the internal logic of their development. An excursion into quantum physics was necessary, firstly, for a deep understanding that reality is given to us in our sensations, perceptions, ideas and mental constructs (this was evidenced by the so-called «double slit experiment» and its interpretations) and we cannot say anything about reality as it is «in itself»; secondly, the realization that the foundations on which our knowledge is built differ from those in quantum physics. Currently, there is a dichotomy between material (physical) and conceptual reality. Thus, the principle of locality, which professes ordinary consciousness and according to which specific objects occupy a specific place in time and space, contradicts the principle of non-locality, according to which isolated systems do not exist at all and every particle of the universe is in «instantaneous» communication with all other particles. The world is created from the same quantum substance and it is impossible to say that one is the cause of the other. (This statement implies, in particular, a rethinking of the «principle of determinism» which requires the establishment of unambiguous causal relationships). The reality in which we live is not quantum, our language and stereotypes of thinking do not correspond to the nature of the phenomena described by quantum physics. It is about the deep properties of matter. Personally, I got the impression that the deeper you plunge into the world of atomic and subatomic, the more the outlines of the specific, material world familiar to us become blurred and the thinner the line between the physical and conceptual world, between the material and the spiritual becomes. The purpose of this article is to define the concepts of "objective" and "subjective" based on the analysis of achievements in quantum physics in the context of psychology.
This paper examines the deep and enduring relationship between physics and philosophy, a connection that has shaped the trajectory of human inquiry from antiquity to the present. By tracing their shared historical roots, the paper emphasizes how early philosophical speculations laid the groundwork for scientific reasoning. Despite the modern institutional separation of these two disciplines, physics continues to grapple with questions that are fundamentally philosophical in nature, questions concerning the essence of time, space, causality, determinism, and the very nature of reality. The paper explores the epistemological structures that underpin scientific knowledge, such as the criteria for theory confirmation and falsifiability, and investigates the ontological assumptions embedded in classical and modern physics. Special attention is devoted to paradigm shifts in the history of science, including the contributions of figures such as Aristotle, Newton, Popper, and Kuhn, as well as the radical implications of quantum mechanics and general relativity. Through an analysis of contemporary debates, such as those surrounding interpretations of quantum mechanics, the multiverse, and the conceptual validity of string theory, the paper argues that philosophy remains indispensable for critically examining and contextualizing scientific thought. Far from being obsolete, philosophical reflection serves as a compass for navigating the conceptual challenges of physics. Ultimately, the dialogue between philosophy and physics is presented as a dynamic and reciprocal exchange, one that not only enriches both fields but is also necessary for advancing our understanding of the universe.