Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

A study of one-turn quantum refereed games

Soumik Ghosh

Published Jul 13, 2020• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This thesis studies one-turn quantum refereed games, which are abstract zero-sum games with two competing computationally unbounded quantum provers and a computationally bounded quantum referee. The provers send quantum states to the referee, who plugs the two states into his quantum circuit, measures the output of the circuit in the standard basis, and declares one of the two players as the winner depending on the outcome of the measurement. The complexity class QRG(1) comprises of those promise problems for which there exists a one-turn quantum refereed game such that one of the players wins with high probability for the yes-instances, and the other player wins with high probability for the no-instances, irrespective of the opponent’s strategy. QRG(1) is a generalization of QMA (or co-QMA), and can informally be viewed as QMA with a no-prover (or co-QMA with a yes-prover). \n \nWe have given a full characterization of QRG(1), starting with appropriate definitions and known results, and building on to two new results about this class. Previously, the best known upper bound on QRG(1) was PSPACE. We have proved that if one of the provers is completely classical, sending a classical probability distribution instead of a quantum state, the new class, which we name CQRG(1), is contained in Ǝ · PP (non- deterministic polynomial-time operator applied to the class PP). We have also defined another restricted version of QRG(1) where both provers send quantum states, but the referee measures one of the quantum states first, and plugs the classical outcome into the measurement, along with the other prover’s quantum state, into a quantum circuit, before measuring the output of the quantum circuit in the standard basis. The new class, which we name MQRG(1), is contained in P · PP (the probabilistic polynomial time operator applied to PP). Ǝ · PP is contained in P · PP, which is, in turn, contained in PSPACE. Hence, our results give better containments than PSPACE for restricted versions of QRG(1).

Related papers

Space-efficient Simulations of Quantum Interactive Proofs.

Xiaodi Wu

Interactive proof systems form an important complexity model that has been central to many prominent results in computational complexity theory, such as those on probabilistically checkable proofs, hardness of approximation, and fundamental cryptographic primitives. In this thesis, we study the quantum-enhanced version of interactive proof systems, in which each party has access to quantum computing resources. We focus on its power and limitations, which lead us to the following results. (*) We provide an alternative and conceptually simpler proof of Jain et al.’s recent breakthrough result, which demonstrates that the expressive power of quantum interactive proof systems coincides with that of its classical counterpart, and therefore PSPACE. (*) We determine the complexity of several variants of quantum competing-prover interactive proof systems, which introduce zero-sum games into interactive proof systems. In particular, we prove that the complexity class of two-turn quantum refereed games coincides with PSPACE, answering an important open problem of Jain et al.’s. Our result suggests that a more general model called double quantum interactive proof systems coincides with PSPACE, which subsumes and unifies all previous results on short refereed games. (*) We contribute to the study of two-prover quantum Merlin-Arthur games (QMA(2)), which exhibit an intriguing tradeoff between an intrinsic quantum ingredient, entanglement, and computational power. We prove a PSPACE upper bound for a variant of QMA(2) that is to date the most general one known in PSPACE. We also provide a quasi-polynomial time algorithm for optimizing linear functions over separable states, giving an alternative to the one proposed by Brandao et al. Our main technical contribution behind the above results is the equilibrium value method for obtaining space-efficient algorithms for a class of optimization problems that arise naturally in quantum computation. We also contribute to QMA-complete problems, where we demonstrate that the “Non-Identity Check” problem remains QMA-complete on circuits of poly-logarithmic depths, improving upon polynomial depths from previous results.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Parallel Approximation of Non-interactive Zero-sum Quantum Games

Rahul Jain, John Watrous

This paper studies a simple class of zero-sum games played by two competing quantum players: each player sends a mixed quantum state to a referee, who performs a joint measurement on the two states to determine the players' payoffs. We prove that an equilibrium point of any such game can be approximated by means of an efficient parallel algorithm, which implies that one-turn quantum refereed games, wherein the referee is specified by a quantum circuit, can be simulated in polynomial space.

arXiv:0808.2775•IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Jul 1, 2009•50 citations

Zero-Knowledge Proof Systems for QMA

Anne Broadbent, Zhengfeng Ji, Fang Song +1 more

Prior work has established that all problems in NP admit classical zero-knowledge proof systems, and under reasonable hardness assumptions for quantum computations, these proof systems can be made secure against quantum attacks. We prove a result representing a further quantum generalization of this fact, which is that every problem in the complexity class QMA has a quantum zero-knowledge proof system. More specifically, assuming the existence of an unconditionally binding and quantum computationally concealing commitment scheme, we prove that every problem in the complexity class QMA has a quantum interactive proof system that is zero-knowledge with respect to efficient quantum computations. Our QMA proof system is sound against arbitrary quantum provers, but only requires an honest prover to perform polynomial-time quantum computations, provided that it holds a quantum witness for a given instance of the QMA problem under consideration. The proof system relies on a new variant of the QMA-complete local Hamiltonian problem in which the local terms are described by Clifford operations and standard basis measurements. We believe that the QMA-completeness of this problem may have other uses in quantum complexity.

SIAM Journal on Computing•Jan 1, 2020•21 citations

Short Quantum Games

Gus Gutoski

In this thesis we introduce quantum refereed games, which are quantum interactive proof systems with two competing provers. We focus on a restriction of this model that we call "short quantum games" and we prove an upper bound and a lower bound on the expressive power of these games. For the lower bound, we prove that every language having an ordinary quantum interactive proof system also has a short quantum game. An important part of this proof is the establishment of a quantum measurement that reliably distinguishes between quantum states chosen from disjoint convex sets. For the upper bound, we show that certain types of quantum refereed games, including short quantum games, are decidable in deterministic exponential time by supplying a separation oracle for use with the ellipsoid method for convex feasibility.

arXiv:cs/0511017•Jan 1, 2005•3 citations

Generalized Quantum Arthur--Merlin Games

Hirotada Kobayashi, François Le Gall, Harumichi Nishimura

This paper investigates the role of interaction and coins in quantum Arthur--Merlin games (also called public-coin quantum interactive proof systems). While the existing model restricts the messages from the verifier to be classical even in the quantum setting, the present work introduces a generalized version of quantum Arthur--Merlin games where the messages from the verifier can be quantum as well: the verifier can send not only random bits, but also halves of EPR pairs (to share with the prover). This generalization turns out to provide several novel characterizations of quantum interactive proof systems with a constant number of turns. First, it is proved that the complexity class corresponding to two-turn quantum Arthur--Merlin games where both of the two messages are quantum (denoted qq-QAM in this paper) does not change by adding a constant number of turns of classical interaction prior to the communications of qq-QAM proof systems. This can be viewed as a quantum analogue of the celebrated collapse theorem for AM due to Babai. To prove this collapse theorem, this paper presents a natural complete problem for qq-QAM: deciding whether the output of a given quantum circuit is close to a totally mixed state. This complete problem is on the very line of the previous studies investigating the hardness of checking properties related to quantum circuits, and thus qq-QAM may provide a good measure in computational complexity theory. It is further proved that the class ${qq-QAM}_1$, the perfect-completeness variant of qq-QAM, gives new bounds for standard well-studied classes of two-turn quantum interactive proof systems. Finally, the collapse theorem above is extended to comprehensively classify the role of classical and quantum interactions in quantum Arthur--Merlin games: it is proved that, for any constant $m\geq2$, the class of problems having $m$-turn quantum Arthur--Merlin proof systems is either equal to PSPACE or equal to the class of problems having two-turn quantum Arthur--Merlin proof systems of a specific type, which provides a complete set of quantum analogues of Babai's collapse theorem.

arXiv:1312.4673•SIAM Journal on Computing•Jan 1, 2019•12 citations

Generalized Quantum Arthur-Merlin Games

Hirotada Kobayashi, François Le Gall, Harumichi Nishimura

This paper investigates the role of interaction and coins in quantum Arthur-Merlin games (also called public-coin quantum interactive proof systems). While the existing model restricts the messages from the verifier to be classical even in the quantum setting, the present work introduces a generalized version of quantum Arthur-Merlin games where the messages from the verifier can be quantum as well: the verifier can send not only random bits, but also halves of EPR pairs. This generalization turns out to provide several novel characterizations of quantum interactive proof systems with a constant number of turns. First, it is proved that the complexity class corresponding to two-turn quantum Arthur-Merlin games where both of the two messages are quantum, denoted qq-QAM in this paper, does not change by adding a constant number of turns of classical interaction prior to the communications of qq-QAM proof systems. This can be viewed as a quantum analogue of the celebrated collapse theorem for AM due to Babai. To prove this collapse theorem, this paper presents a natural complete problem for qq-QAM: deciding whether the output of a given quantum circuit is close to a totally mixed state. This complete problem is on the very line of the previous studies investigating the hardness of checking properties related to quantum circuits, and thus, qq-QAM may provide a good measure in computational complexity theory. It is further proved that the class qq-QAM_1, the perfect-completeness variant of qq-QAM, gives new bounds for standard well-studied classes of two-turn quantum interactive proof systems. Finally, the collapse theorem above is extended to comprehensively classify the role of classical and quantum interactions in quantum Arthur-Merlin games: it is proved that, for any constant m >= 2, the class of problems having $m$-turn quantum Arthur-Merlin proof systems is either equal to PSPACE or equal to the class of problems having two-turn quantum Arthur-Merlin proof systems of a specific type, which provides a complete set of quantum analogues of Babai's collapse theorem.

Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jan 1, 2015•4 citations
This thesis studies one-turn quantum refereed games, which are abstract zero-sum games with two competing computationally unbounded quantum provers and a computationally bounded quantum referee. The provers send quantum states to the referee, who plugs the two states into his quantum circuit, measures the output of the circuit in the standard basis, and declares one of the two players as the winner depending on the outcome of the measurement. The complexity class QRG(1) comprises of those promise problems for which there exists a one-turn quantum refereed game such that one of the players wins with high probability for the yes-instances, and the other player wins with high probability for the no-instances, irrespective of the opponent’s strategy. QRG(1) is a generalization of QMA (or co-QMA), and can informally be viewed as QMA with a no-prover (or co-QMA with a yes-prover). \n \nWe have given a full characterization of QRG(1), starting with appropriate definitions and known results, and building on to two new results about this class. Previously, the best known upper bound on QRG(1) was PSPACE. We have proved that if one of the provers is completely classical, sending a classical probability distribution instead of a quantum state, the new class, which we name CQRG(1), is contained in Ǝ · PP (non- deterministic polynomial-time operator applied to the class PP). We have also defined another restricted version of QRG(1) where both provers send quantum states, but the referee measures one of the quantum states first, and plugs the classical outcome into the measurement, along with the other prover’s quantum state, into a quantum circuit, before measuring the output of the quantum circuit in the standard basis. The new class, which we name MQRG(1), is contained in P · PP (the probabilistic polynomial time operator applied to PP). Ǝ · PP is contained in P · PP, which is, in turn, contained in PSPACE. Hence, our results give better containments than PSPACE for restricted versions of QRG(1).
Interactive proof systems form an important complexity model that has been central to many prominent results in computational complexity theory, such as those on probabilistically checkable proofs, hardness of approximation, and fundamental cryptographic primitives. In this thesis, we study the quantum-enhanced version of interactive proof systems, in which each party has access to quantum computing resources. We focus on its power and limitations, which lead us to the following results. (*) We provide an alternative and conceptually simpler proof of Jain et al.’s recent breakthrough result, which demonstrates that the expressive power of quantum interactive proof systems coincides with that of its classical counterpart, and therefore PSPACE. (*) We determine the complexity of several variants of quantum competing-prover interactive proof systems, which introduce zero-sum games into interactive proof systems. In particular, we prove that the complexity class of two-turn quantum refereed games coincides with PSPACE, answering an important open problem of Jain et al.’s. Our result suggests that a more general model called double quantum interactive proof systems coincides with PSPACE, which subsumes and unifies all previous results on short refereed games. (*) We contribute to the study of two-prover quantum Merlin-Arthur games (QMA(2)), which exhibit an intriguing tradeoff between an intrinsic quantum ingredient, entanglement, and computational power. We prove a PSPACE upper bound for a variant of QMA(2) that is to date the most general one known in PSPACE. We also provide a quasi-polynomial time algorithm for optimizing linear functions over separable states, giving an alternative to the one proposed by Brandao et al. Our main technical contribution behind the above results is the equilibrium value method for obtaining space-efficient algorithms for a class of optimization problems that arise naturally in quantum computation. We also contribute to QMA-complete problems, where we demonstrate that the “Non-Identity Check” problem remains QMA-complete on circuits of poly-logarithmic depths, improving upon polynomial depths from previous results.
Prior work has established that all problems in NP admit classical zero-knowledge proof systems, and under reasonable hardness assumptions for quantum computations, these proof systems can be made secure against quantum attacks. We prove a result representing a further quantum generalization of this fact, which is that every problem in the complexity class QMA has a quantum zero-knowledge proof system. More specifically, assuming the existence of an unconditionally binding and quantum computationally concealing commitment scheme, we prove that every problem in the complexity class QMA has a quantum interactive proof system that is zero-knowledge with respect to efficient quantum computations. Our QMA proof system is sound against arbitrary quantum provers, but only requires an honest prover to perform polynomial-time quantum computations, provided that it holds a quantum witness for a given instance of the QMA problem under consideration. The proof system relies on a new variant of the QMA-complete local Hamiltonian problem in which the local terms are described by Clifford operations and standard basis measurements. We believe that the QMA-completeness of this problem may have other uses in quantum complexity.
In this thesis we introduce quantum refereed games, which are quantum interactive proof systems with two competing provers. We focus on a restriction of this model that we call "short quantum games" and we prove an upper bound and a lower bound on the expressive power of these games. For the lower bound, we prove that every language having an ordinary quantum interactive proof system also has a short quantum game. An important part of this proof is the establishment of a quantum measurement that reliably distinguishes between quantum states chosen from disjoint convex sets. For the upper bound, we show that certain types of quantum refereed games, including short quantum games, are decidable in deterministic exponential time by supplying a separation oracle for use with the ellipsoid method for convex feasibility.
This paper investigates the role of interaction and coins in quantum Arthur--Merlin games (also called public-coin quantum interactive proof systems). While the existing model restricts the messages from the verifier to be classical even in the quantum setting, the present work introduces a generalized version of quantum Arthur--Merlin games where the messages from the verifier can be quantum as well: the verifier can send not only random bits, but also halves of EPR pairs (to share with the prover). This generalization turns out to provide several novel characterizations of quantum interactive proof systems with a constant number of turns. First, it is proved that the complexity class corresponding to two-turn quantum Arthur--Merlin games where both of the two messages are quantum (denoted qq-QAM in this paper) does not change by adding a constant number of turns of classical interaction prior to the communications of qq-QAM proof systems. This can be viewed as a quantum analogue of the celebrated collapse theorem for AM due to Babai. To prove this collapse theorem, this paper presents a natural complete problem for qq-QAM: deciding whether the output of a given quantum circuit is close to a totally mixed state. This complete problem is on the very line of the previous studies investigating the hardness of checking properties related to quantum circuits, and thus qq-QAM may provide a good measure in computational complexity theory. It is further proved that the class qq−QAM1{qq-QAM}_1qq−QAM1​, the perfect-completeness variant of qq-QAM, gives new bounds for standard well-studied classes of two-turn quantum interactive proof systems. Finally, the collapse theorem above is extended to comprehensively classify the role of classical and quantum interactions in quantum Arthur--Merlin games: it is proved that, for any constant m≥2m\geq2m≥2, the class of problems having mmm-turn quantum Arthur--Merlin proof systems is either equal to PSPACE or equal to the class of problems having two-turn quantum Arthur--Merlin proof systems of a specific type, which provides a complete set of quantum analogues of Babai's collapse theorem.
This paper investigates the role of interaction and coins in quantum Arthur-Merlin games (also called public-coin quantum interactive proof systems). While the existing model restricts the messages from the verifier to be classical even in the quantum setting, the present work introduces a generalized version of quantum Arthur-Merlin games where the messages from the verifier can be quantum as well: the verifier can send not only random bits, but also halves of EPR pairs. This generalization turns out to provide several novel characterizations of quantum interactive proof systems with a constant number of turns. First, it is proved that the complexity class corresponding to two-turn quantum Arthur-Merlin games where both of the two messages are quantum, denoted qq-QAM in this paper, does not change by adding a constant number of turns of classical interaction prior to the communications of qq-QAM proof systems. This can be viewed as a quantum analogue of the celebrated collapse theorem for AM due to Babai. To prove this collapse theorem, this paper presents a natural complete problem for qq-QAM: deciding whether the output of a given quantum circuit is close to a totally mixed state. This complete problem is on the very line of the previous studies investigating the hardness of checking properties related to quantum circuits, and thus, qq-QAM may provide a good measure in computational complexity theory. It is further proved that the class qq-QAM_1, the perfect-completeness variant of qq-QAM, gives new bounds for standard well-studied classes of two-turn quantum interactive proof systems. Finally, the collapse theorem above is extended to comprehensively classify the role of classical and quantum interactions in quantum Arthur-Merlin games: it is proved that, for any constant m >= 2, the class of problems having mmm-turn quantum Arthur-Merlin proof systems is either equal to PSPACE or equal to the class of problems having two-turn quantum Arthur-Merlin proof systems of a specific type, which provides a complete set of quantum analogues of Babai's collapse theorem.