Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Reply to “Comment on ‘How to observe and quantify quantum-discord states via correlations’ ”

Matthew A. Hunt, Igor V. Lerner, I. V. Yurkevich, Yuval Gefen

Published Jul 23, 2020• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

The authors of the preceding Comment [Kumar and Snizhko, Phys. Rev. A 102, 016401 (2020)] made two critical remarks regarding the protocol for detecting and quantifying quantumness of separable states presented in our paper [Hunt et al., Phys. Rev. A 100, 022321 (2019)]. One is that our protocol is not ``experiment friendly'' in comparison to full quantum state tomography. The other is that the suggested quantifier fails to distinguish different degrees of quantumness within the family of Werner states. We will show that, while being technically correct, both remarks referred to generalizations of our protocol which had been neither suggested nor intended. We will reiterate why the proposed protocol would be advantageous, compared to full or partial quantum state tomography, for detecting and quantifying discord in many-body bipartite states.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.102.016402

Related papers

Comment on “How to observe and quantify quantum-discord states via correlations”

Parveen Kumar, Kyrylo Snizhko

The protocol proposed in the commented-upon article can certify zero discord; however, it fails to quantify nonzero discord for some states. Further, the protocol is less efficient than calculating discord via performing full quantum state tomography.

arXiv:2007.12345•Physical Review A•Jul 23, 2020•4 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Multiparty quantum mutual information: An alternative definition' ”

Asutosh Kumar

We reaffirm the claim of Lee et al. [preceding Comment, Phys. Rev. A 108, 066401 (2023)] that the expression of quantum dual total correlation of a multipartite system in terms of quantum relative entropy as proposed in previous work [A. Kumar, Phys. Rev. A 96, 012332 (2017)] is not correct.

arXiv:2401.00026•Physical Review A•Dec 27, 2023•2 citations

How to observe and quantify quantum-discord states via correlations

Matthew A. Hunt, Igor V. Lerner, I. V. Yurkevich +1 more

Quantum correlations between parts of a composite system most clearly reveal themselves through entanglement. Designing, maintaining, and controlling entangled systems is very demanding, which raises the stakes for understanding the efficacy of entanglement-free, yet quantum correlations, exemplified by quantum discord. Discord is defined via conditional mutual entropies of parts of a composite system and its direct measurement is hardly possible even via full tomographic characterization of the system state. Here we design a simple protocol to detect and quantify quantum discord in an unentangled bipartite system. Our protocol relies on a characteristic of discord that can be extracted from repeated direct measurements of certain correlations between subsystems of the bipartite system. The proposed protocol opens a way of extending experimental studies of discord to electronic systems, but can also be implemented in quantum-optical systems.

arXiv:1901.11514•Physical Review A•Aug 16, 2019•14 citations

Quantum discord for two-qubit systems

Shunlong Luo

Quantum discord, as introduced by Olliver and Zurek [Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 017901 (2001)], is a measure of the discrepancy between two natural yet different quantum analogs of the classical mutual information. This notion characterizes and quantifies quantumness of correlations in bipartite states from a measurement perspective, and is fundamentally different from the various entanglement measures in the entanglement vs separability paradigm. The phenomenon of nonzero quantum discord is a manifestation of quantum correlations due to noncommutativity rather than due to entanglement, and has interesting and significant applications in revealing the advantage of certain quantum tasks. We will evaluate analytically the quantum discord for a large family of two-qubit states, and make a comparative study of the relationships between classical and quantum correlations in terms of the quantum discord. We furthermore compare the quantum discord with the entanglement of formation, and illustrate that the latter may be larger than the former, although for separable states, the entanglement of formation always vanishes and thus is less than the quantum discord.

Physical Review A•Apr 3, 2008•1,062 citations

Quantumness and the role of locality on quantum correlations

Guido Bellomo, Angel Ricardo Plastino, Angel Ricardo Plastino

Quantum correlations in a physical system are usually studied with respect to a unique and fixed decomposition of the system into subsystems, without fully exploiting the rich structure of the state space. Here, we show several examples in which the consideration of different ways to decompose a physical system enhances the quantum resources and accounts for a more flexible definition of quantumness measures. Furthermore, we give a different perspective regarding how to reassess the fact that local operations play a key role in general quantumness measures that go beyond entanglement---as discordlike ones. We propose a family of measures to quantify the maximum quantumness of a given state. For the discord-based case, we present some analytical results for $2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}d$-dimensional states. Applying our definition to low-dimensional bipartite states, we show that different behaviors can be reported for separable and entangled states vis-\`a-vis those corresponding to the usual measures of quantum correlations. We show that there is a close link between our proposal and the criterion to witness quantum correlations based on the rank of the correlation matrix, proposed by Daki\ifmmode \acute{c}\else \'{c}\fi{}, Vedral, and Brukner [Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 190502 (2010)].

arXiv:1601.01236•Physical Review A•Jun 20, 2016•4 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Witnessed entanglement and the geometric measure of quantum discord’ ”

Tiago Debarba, Thiago O. Maciel, Reinaldo O. Vianna

We show that the mistakes pointed out by Rana and Parashar [Phys. Rev. A 87, 016301 (2013)] do not invalidate the main conclusion of our work [Phys. Rev. A 86, 024302 (2012)]. We show that the errors affected only a particular application of our general results, and present the correction.

arXiv:1304.3864•Physical Review A•Apr 9, 2013•7 citations
The authors of the preceding Comment [Kumar and Snizhko, Phys. Rev. A 102, 016401 (2020)] made two critical remarks regarding the protocol for detecting and quantifying quantumness of separable states presented in our paper [Hunt et al., Phys. Rev. A 100, 022321 (2019)]. One is that our protocol is not ``experiment friendly'' in comparison to full quantum state tomography. The other is that the suggested quantifier fails to distinguish different degrees of quantumness within the family of Werner states. We will show that, while being technically correct, both remarks referred to generalizations of our protocol which had been neither suggested nor intended. We will reiterate why the proposed protocol would be advantageous, compared to full or partial quantum state tomography, for detecting and quantifying discord in many-body bipartite states.
Quantum correlations between parts of a composite system most clearly reveal themselves through entanglement. Designing, maintaining, and controlling entangled systems is very demanding, which raises the stakes for understanding the efficacy of entanglement-free, yet quantum correlations, exemplified by quantum discord. Discord is defined via conditional mutual entropies of parts of a composite system and its direct measurement is hardly possible even via full tomographic characterization of the system state. Here we design a simple protocol to detect and quantify quantum discord in an unentangled bipartite system. Our protocol relies on a characteristic of discord that can be extracted from repeated direct measurements of certain correlations between subsystems of the bipartite system. The proposed protocol opens a way of extending experimental studies of discord to electronic systems, but can also be implemented in quantum-optical systems.
Quantum discord, as introduced by Olliver and Zurek [Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 017901 (2001)], is a measure of the discrepancy between two natural yet different quantum analogs of the classical mutual information. This notion characterizes and quantifies quantumness of correlations in bipartite states from a measurement perspective, and is fundamentally different from the various entanglement measures in the entanglement vs separability paradigm. The phenomenon of nonzero quantum discord is a manifestation of quantum correlations due to noncommutativity rather than due to entanglement, and has interesting and significant applications in revealing the advantage of certain quantum tasks. We will evaluate analytically the quantum discord for a large family of two-qubit states, and make a comparative study of the relationships between classical and quantum correlations in terms of the quantum discord. We furthermore compare the quantum discord with the entanglement of formation, and illustrate that the latter may be larger than the former, although for separable states, the entanglement of formation always vanishes and thus is less than the quantum discord.
Quantum correlations in a physical system are usually studied with respect to a unique and fixed decomposition of the system into subsystems, without fully exploiting the rich structure of the state space. Here, we show several examples in which the consideration of different ways to decompose a physical system enhances the quantum resources and accounts for a more flexible definition of quantumness measures. Furthermore, we give a different perspective regarding how to reassess the fact that local operations play a key role in general quantumness measures that go beyond entanglement---as discordlike ones. We propose a family of measures to quantify the maximum quantumness of a given state. For the discord-based case, we present some analytical results for $2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}d$-dimensional states. Applying our definition to low-dimensional bipartite states, we show that different behaviors can be reported for separable and entangled states vis-\`a-vis those corresponding to the usual measures of quantum correlations. We show that there is a close link between our proposal and the criterion to witness quantum correlations based on the rank of the correlation matrix, proposed by Daki\ifmmode \acute{c}\else \'{c}\fi{}, Vedral, and Brukner [Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 190502 (2010)].