Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1304.3864 · Physical Review A

Reply to “Comment on ‘Witnessed entanglement and the geometric measure of quantum discord’ ”

Tiago Debarba, Thiago O. Maciel, Reinaldo O. Vianna

Published Apr 9, 2013• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We show that the mistakes pointed out by Rana and Parashar [Phys. Rev. A 87, 016301 (2013)] do not invalidate the main conclusion of our work [Phys. Rev. A 86, 024302 (2012)]. We show that the errors affected only a particular application of our general results, and present the correction.
DOI
10.1103/physreva.87.046301

Related papers

Comment on “Witnessed entanglement and the geometric measure of quantum discord”

Swapan Rana, Preeti Parashar

In a recent article [Phys. Rev. A 86, 024302 (2012)], the authors have derived some hierarchy relations between geometric discord and entanglement (measured by negativity and its square). We point out that these results are incorrect and give analytic counterexamples. We also briefly discuss the reason for such violations.

arXiv:1301.1961•Physical Review A•Jan 22, 2013•22 citations

Comment on “Sudden change in quantum discord accompanying the transition from bound to free entanglement”

Swapan Rana, Preeti Parashar

In a recent article [Phys. Rev. A 87, 022340 (2013)], Yan et al. have studied geometric discord for a well-known class of bound entangled states. Based on their calculation, they claim ``It is found that there exists a nondynamic sudden change in quantum discord'' for these states. In this Comment, we criticize their work by pointing out that what has been calculated is actually a bound and is not the exact value of discord. Since, generally, it is not possible to infer the exact value (or property) of a quantity just from its bound, we cannot conclude about (exact) discord and its change. Thus, the above-mentioned conclusion cannot be drawn from the calculations of the paper.

arXiv:1309.6890•Physical Review A•Sep 16, 2013•1 citation

Reply to “Comment on ‘Entangled entanglement’ ”

Günther Krenn, Anton Zeilinger

Expounding an argument that we have stated in Sec. IV of our paper [Phys. Rev. A 54, 1793 (1996)], we demonstrate that according to our understanding Schafir's conclusion [preceding Comment, Phys. Rev. A 56, 4335 (1997)] is based upon a premise that is not tenable.

Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1997•3 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘How to observe and quantify quantum-discord states via correlations’ ”

Matthew A. Hunt, Igor V. Lerner, I. V. Yurkevich +1 more

The authors of the preceding Comment [Kumar and Snizhko, Phys. Rev. A 102, 016401 (2020)] made two critical remarks regarding the protocol for detecting and quantifying quantumness of separable states presented in our paper [Hunt et al., Phys. Rev. A 100, 022321 (2019)]. One is that our protocol is not ``experiment friendly'' in comparison to full quantum state tomography. The other is that the suggested quantifier fails to distinguish different degrees of quantumness within the family of Werner states. We will show that, while being technically correct, both remarks referred to generalizations of our protocol which had been neither suggested nor intended. We will reiterate why the proposed protocol would be advantageous, compared to full or partial quantum state tomography, for detecting and quantifying discord in many-body bipartite states.

Physical Review A•Jul 23, 2020•1 citation

Reply to “Comment on ‘Quantum convolutional error-correcting codes’ ”

H. F. Chau

In their Comment, de Almeida and Palazzo ͓Phys.Rev. A 72, 026301 ͑2005͔͒ discovered an error in my earlier paper concerning the construction of quantum convolutional codes ͓Phys.Rev. A 58, 905 ͑1998͔͒.This error can be repaired by modifying the method of code construction.

arXiv:quant-ph/0506015•Physical Review A•Aug 5, 2005•6 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Fermionic entanglement ambiguity in noninertial frames’ ”

Miguel Montero, Eduardo Martín-Martínez

We show that, contrary to the claims of the preceding Comment [Br\'adler and J\'auregui, Phys. Rev. A 85, 016301 (2012)], our original work [Phys. Rev. A 83, 062323 (2011)] is devoid of flaws or mistakes. We show that the criticism comes from a misunderstanding of part of our work.

arXiv:1108.6074•Physical Review A•Jan 17, 2012•24 citations
In a recent article [Phys. Rev. A 87, 022340 (2013)], Yan et al. have studied geometric discord for a well-known class of bound entangled states. Based on their calculation, they claim ``It is found that there exists a nondynamic sudden change in quantum discord'' for these states. In this Comment, we criticize their work by pointing out that what has been calculated is actually a bound and is not the exact value of discord. Since, generally, it is not possible to infer the exact value (or property) of a quantity just from its bound, we cannot conclude about (exact) discord and its change. Thus, the above-mentioned conclusion cannot be drawn from the calculations of the paper.
The authors of the preceding Comment [Kumar and Snizhko, Phys. Rev. A 102, 016401 (2020)] made two critical remarks regarding the protocol for detecting and quantifying quantumness of separable states presented in our paper [Hunt et al., Phys. Rev. A 100, 022321 (2019)]. One is that our protocol is not ``experiment friendly'' in comparison to full quantum state tomography. The other is that the suggested quantifier fails to distinguish different degrees of quantumness within the family of Werner states. We will show that, while being technically correct, both remarks referred to generalizations of our protocol which had been neither suggested nor intended. We will reiterate why the proposed protocol would be advantageous, compared to full or partial quantum state tomography, for detecting and quantifying discord in many-body bipartite states.