Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Indeterminist Objectivity of Quantum Mechanics Versus the Determinist Subjectivity of Classical Physics

Vasil Dinev Penchev

Published Jan 1, 2020• 2 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.2139/ssrn.3653015

Related papers

Deterministic Quantum Mechanics versus Classical Mechanical Indeterminism

Mohamed Saladin El Naschie

International Journal of Nonlinear Sciences and Numerical Simulation•Jan 1, 2007•41 citations

Does Quantum Mechanics Save Free Will?

László E. Szabó

According to the widely accepted opinion, classical (statistical) physics does not support objective indeterminism, since the statistical laws of classical physics allow a deterministic hidden background, while --- as Arthur Fine writes polemizing with Grünbaum --- "{\sl the antilibertarian position finds little room to breathe in a statistical world if we take laws of the quantum theory as exemplars of the statistical laws in such a world. So, it appears that, contrary to what Grünbaum claims, the libertarians' 'could have done otherwise' does indeed find support from indeterminism if we take the indeterministic laws to be of the sort found in the quantum theory.}" In this paper I will show that, quite the contrary, quantum mechanics does not save free will. For instance, the EPR experiments are compatible with a deterministic world. They admit a deterministic local hidden parameter description if the deterministic model is 'allowed' to describe not only the measurement outcomes, but also the outcomes of the 'decisions' whether this or that measurement will be performed. So, the derivation of the freedom of the will from quantum mechanics is a tautology: from the assumption that the world is indeterministic it is derived that the world cannot be deterministic.

arXiv:quant-ph/9506040•Jun 28, 1995•0 citations

Indeterminism and Determinism in Quantum Mechanics

Brigitte Falkenburg, Friedel Weinert

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 2009•10 citations

Can the World Beshown to be Indeterministic after all?

Christian Wüthrich

Abstract Is the world deterministic and can we ever know whether it is or is not so? This chapter critically evaluates recent results that bear on these issues, and points out the relation to probabilities. While results from classical physics are neither fully relevant nor conclusive, quantum mechanics is often assumed to establish indeterminism beyond doubt. However, whether the quantum world is indeterministic crucially depends on how the measurement problem is solved. There are both deterministic and indeterministic contenders in this field, some of them empirically equivalent to another one. This is shown using the deterministic Bohm theory and Nelsonsion mechanics, which is indeterministic. Two arguments that purport to establish indeterminism and that rely on Gleason's theorem and on Conway and Kochen's recent Free Will Theorem are shown to be wanting.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 1, 2011•29 citations

Subquantum Models: Basic Principles, Effects and Tests

Jiří Souček

We present models in which the indeterministic feature of Quantum Mechanics is represented in the form of definite physical mechanisms. Our way is completely different from so-called hidden parameter models, namely, we start from a certain variant of QM - deterministic QM - which has most features similar to QM, but the evolution in this theory is deterministic. Then we introduce the subquantum medium composed of so-called space-like objects. The interaction of a deterministic QM-particle with this medium is represented by the random force, but it is the random force governed by the probability amplitude distribution. This is the quantum random force and it is very different from classical random force. This implies that in our models there are no Bell`s inequalities and that our models (depending on a certain parameter tau) can be arbitrarily close to QM. The parameter tau defines a relaxation time and on time intervals shorter than tau, the evolution violates Heisenberg`s uncertainty principle and it is almost deterministic - spreading of the wave packet is much slower than in QM. Such type of short-time effects form the bases of proposed tests, which can, in principle, define limits of validity of QM. The proposed experiments are related to the behavior of quantum objects on short time intervals, where we expect the behavior different from QM. The main proposed feature is violation of uncertainty relations on short time intervals.

arXiv:quant-ph/0107040•Jul 6, 2001•2 citations

INDETERMINISM IN QUANTUM PHYSICS AND IN CLASSICAL PHYSICS: PART II

Karl Raimund Popper

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•Nov 1, 1950•71 citations
According to the widely accepted opinion, classical (statistical) physics does not support objective indeterminism, since the statistical laws of classical physics allow a deterministic hidden background, while --- as Arthur Fine writes polemizing with Grünbaum --- "{\sl the antilibertarian position finds little room to breathe in a statistical world if we take laws of the quantum theory as exemplars of the statistical laws in such a world. So, it appears that, contrary to what Grünbaum claims, the libertarians' 'could have done otherwise' does indeed find support from indeterminism if we take the indeterministic laws to be of the sort found in the quantum theory.}" In this paper I will show that, quite the contrary, quantum mechanics does not save free will. For instance, the EPR experiments are compatible with a deterministic world. They admit a deterministic local hidden parameter description if the deterministic model is 'allowed' to describe not only the measurement outcomes, but also the outcomes of the 'decisions' whether this or that measurement will be performed. So, the derivation of the freedom of the will from quantum mechanics is a tautology: from the assumption that the world is indeterministic it is derived that the world cannot be deterministic.
Abstract Is the world deterministic and can we ever know whether it is or is not so? This chapter critically evaluates recent results that bear on these issues, and points out the relation to probabilities. While results from classical physics are neither fully relevant nor conclusive, quantum mechanics is often assumed to establish indeterminism beyond doubt. However, whether the quantum world is indeterministic crucially depends on how the measurement problem is solved. There are both deterministic and indeterministic contenders in this field, some of them empirically equivalent to another one. This is shown using the deterministic Bohm theory and Nelsonsion mechanics, which is indeterministic. Two arguments that purport to establish indeterminism and that rely on Gleason's theorem and on Conway and Kochen's recent Free Will Theorem are shown to be wanting.
We present models in which the indeterministic feature of Quantum Mechanics is represented in the form of definite physical mechanisms. Our way is completely different from so-called hidden parameter models, namely, we start from a certain variant of QM - deterministic QM - which has most features similar to QM, but the evolution in this theory is deterministic. Then we introduce the subquantum medium composed of so-called space-like objects. The interaction of a deterministic QM-particle with this medium is represented by the random force, but it is the random force governed by the probability amplitude distribution. This is the quantum random force and it is very different from classical random force. This implies that in our models there are no Bell`s inequalities and that our models (depending on a certain parameter tau) can be arbitrarily close to QM. The parameter tau defines a relaxation time and on time intervals shorter than tau, the evolution violates Heisenberg`s uncertainty principle and it is almost deterministic - spreading of the wave packet is much slower than in QM. Such type of short-time effects form the bases of proposed tests, which can, in principle, define limits of validity of QM. The proposed experiments are related to the behavior of quantum objects on short time intervals, where we expect the behavior different from QM. The main proposed feature is violation of uncertainty relations on short time intervals.