Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics Education

Using Möbius strip to describe non-integral spin of electrons

Arindam Raj

Published Jun 18, 2020• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract This article presents a simple demonstration that can be used in high school/introductory college level courses to explain the meaning of ½-spin of fermions like electrons. One can use a simple-to-construct Möbius strip to distinguish 2π and 4π rotations of a point moving on the strip. This idea can then be extended to a pointer/arrow (in classroom settings, say a pen representing a classical analogue to the intrinsic spin vector), to show how a 4π rotation is needed to return the pointer, to its initial configuration with respect to the strip.

DOI
10.1088/1361-6552/ab9321

Related papers

Seeing Spin: Geometry from a Schoolbag

Okupski Arkadiusz

We've been describing spin with equations. What if we could *see* it instead? For a century, electron spin has been a mathematical abstraction: a two-valued quantum property with no classical picture, described by SU(2) algebra and $4\pi$ rotations. This work turns the problem inside out. It asks: *What minimal geometry could generate such behavior?* The answer is deceptively simple: a Möbius strip coupling the electron's internal cycle to its observable boundary. But not just one strip—two. A loop ($G_0$) and a figure-eight ($G_8$), energetically degenerate yet topologically distinct. Their choice corresponds to spin $+\tfrac{1}{2}$ or $-\tfrac{1}{2}$. From this single geometric postulate, the model *mechanically* explains: - **Why there are exactly two spin states** (no continuum)- **Why spin "remembers" its state** after a magnetic field is turned off (topological memory)- **How the $g \simeq 2$ relation** finds a striking qualitative parallel in a fundamental $2{:}1$ geometric ratio between the electron's internal cycle and its boundary- **How spinorial $4\pi$ rotation** emerges from Möbius topology This is **"pencil-case physics"**: no Lagrangians, no operators, just visualizable construction. It's a *sonar*—a conceptual probe mapping possible shapes beneath quantum formalism. The model doesn't replace quantum mechanics; it asks what geometry might be whispering beneath its equations. For physicists tired of "because the math says so," this paper offers a "here's how it *could* work." It's an invitation to imagine spin not as a vector in Hilbert space, but as a twist in the fabric of the electron itself.

•Dec 23, 2025•0 citations

Quantum particle on a Möbius strip, coherent states and projection operators

Diego Julio Cirilo-Lombardo

The coherent states for a quantum particle on a Möbius strip are constructed and their relation to the natural phase space for fermionic fields is shown. The explicit comparison of the obtained states with previous works where the cylinder quantization was used and the spin-1/2 was introduced by hand is given, and the relation between the geometrical phase space, constraints and projection operators is analyzed and discussed. This article is part of a special issue of Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical devoted to 'Coherent states: mathematical and physical aspects'.

arXiv:1204.5784•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•May 30, 2012•9 citations

Modelling spin

Stefan Heusler, Malte S. Ubben

Abstract Based on a geometric view on the famous Dirac belt trick in terms of a Möbius strip, we propose a simple haptic model for spin states as standing waves in non-trivial geometry. We compare two representations of the model: the spinor representation in SU (2), which geometrically is described by ‘Dirac belt’ states on S 3 , and the well-known Bloch-sphere representation on S 2 . We show that after Hopf-mapping S 3 → S 2 , the position and number of nodal points are sufficient to describe the spin state and make the relation between the representations on S 2 and on S 3 explicit in simple haptic models. Our approach is well-suited for graduate physics courses, and provides a thorough understanding of the complex geometry of spin states beyond the usual Bloch-sphere visualisation. It turns out that an even number 2 l of nodal points can be related to nodal lines of spherical harmonics Y lm , an odd number can be traced back to spin states. In this sense, our model provides a unified view for orbital and spin states based on a simple picture of standing waves.

European Journal of Physics•Sep 24, 2018•5 citations

A New Theory for the Essence and Origin of Electron Spin

Nader Butto

Spin is an intrinsic form of angular momentum carried by elementary particles, composite particles, and atomic nuclei. It is wildly believed that spin is a purely quantum mechanical concept and has no classical analogue. In fact, elementary particles are conceived as point objects which have no axis to “spin” around. Therefore, there is no explaining how spin arises at the fundamental level, why particles have the values they do, and what underpins the Pauli Exclusion principle and Bose-Einstein behavior. However, spin is like a vector quantity; it has a definite magnitude, and it has a “direction”, in order to spin should be composite. In this paper we propose a physical explanation for spin of the electron at the sub-particle level, relying on the vortex model of the electron. The electron is described as a superfluid frictionless vortex which has a mass, angular momentum and spin to provide a complete explanation of all properties of the electron: it composite, spinning around its own axis, produces a tiny magnetic fields independent of those from its orbital motions. The classical hydrodynamic laws are used to describe the quantum properties of the electron, such as spin, angular momentum, magnetic momentum and a magnetic dipole. The circulation in the vortex is constant, and the angular momentum of the vortex is conserved and has the same value of Planck constant. The direction of the angular momentum of a spinning electron vortex is along the axis of rotation and determined by the direction of spin. The spin quantum number 1/2 has a fixed value which represents the gap between the circulation rate of the core of the vortex and the boundaries of the vortex. The changeable values +1/2 “spin-up” or -1/2 “spin-down” indicate the direction of the magnetic dipole of the vortex. The relation between spin and Planck constant is discussed and the origin h/4pi angular momentum units are revealed.

Journal of High Energy Physics Gravitation and Cosmology•Jan 1, 2021•12 citations

The non-relativistic nature of spin in quantum mechanics: a historical and pedagogical perspective

Marco Giliberti, Luisa Lovisetti

Abstract Conventional methods for teaching spin at a university level generally follow four main approaches. The first introduces spin into the Schrödinger equation artificially, leaving its physical meaning unclear. The second connects spin to the representation of the rotation group, which clarifies its nature but requires knowledge of group theory. The third approach derives from field theory, separating angular momentum into orbital and intrinsic parts, the latter corresponding to spin; however, this cannot be done within quantum mechanics alone. The fourth derives electron spin from Dirac’s 1928 relativistic equation, which, though correct, has led to the misconception that spin is a purely relativistic effect. A detailed analysis of Dirac’s 1928 papers shows that the concept of spin arises from the need to construct an equation linear in both energy and momentum to preserve Born’s probabilistic interpretation. This linearization of the Klein–Gordon equation reveals that spin is conceptually independent of relativity. Historical and pedagogical perspectives can together clarify conceptual difficulties and promote a deeper understanding of fundamental ideas in physics. Drawing on selected passages from Dirac’s original work, the present discussion offers broader conceptual and cultural considerations that introduce the notion of spin with limited mathematical requirements and can be applied independently of the didactic approach adopted.

•Aug 27, 2026•0 citations

Why the 4π-symmetry rotation property of the electron is possibly a special relativity effect?

Emmanouil N. Markoulakis, Emmanuel Antonidakis

We demonstrate how and why an electron's 4π full rotation returning to its initial state quantum characteristic measured in the lab frame could be explained as a special relativity effect.

•Jul 8, 2026•0 citations
Abstract This article presents a simple demonstration that can be used in high school/introductory college level courses to explain the meaning of ½-spin of fermions like electrons. One can use a simple-to-construct Möbius strip to distinguish 2π and 4π rotations of a point moving on the strip. This idea can then be extended to a pointer/arrow (in classroom settings, say a pen representing a classical analogue to the intrinsic spin vector), to show how a 4π rotation is needed to return the pointer, to its initial configuration with respect to the strip.
We've been describing spin with equations. What if we could *see* it instead? For a century, electron spin has been a mathematical abstraction: a two-valued quantum property with no classical picture, described by SU(2) algebra and 4π4\pi4π rotations. This work turns the problem inside out. It asks: *What minimal geometry could generate such behavior?* The answer is deceptively simple: a Möbius strip coupling the electron's internal cycle to its observable boundary. But not just one strip—two. A loop (G0G_0G0​) and a figure-eight (G8G_8G8​), energetically degenerate yet topologically distinct. Their choice corresponds to spin +12+\tfrac{1}{2}+21​ or −12-\tfrac{1}{2}−21​. From this single geometric postulate, the model *mechanically* explains: - **Why there are exactly two spin states** (no continuum)- **Why spin "remembers" its state** after a magnetic field is turned off (topological memory)- **How the g≃2g \simeq 2g≃2 relation** finds a striking qualitative parallel in a fundamental 2:12{:}12:1 geometric ratio between the electron's internal cycle and its boundary- **How spinorial 4π4\pi4π rotation** emerges from Möbius topology This is **"pencil-case physics"**: no Lagrangians, no operators, just visualizable construction. It's a *sonar*—a conceptual probe mapping possible shapes beneath quantum formalism. The model doesn't replace quantum mechanics; it asks what geometry might be whispering beneath its equations. For physicists tired of "because the math says so," this paper offers a "here's how it *could* work." It's an invitation to imagine spin not as a vector in Hilbert space, but as a twist in the fabric of the electron itself.
The coherent states for a quantum particle on a Möbius strip are constructed and their relation to the natural phase space for fermionic fields is shown. The explicit comparison of the obtained states with previous works where the cylinder quantization was used and the spin-1/2 was introduced by hand is given, and the relation between the geometrical phase space, constraints and projection operators is analyzed and discussed. This article is part of a special issue of Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical devoted to 'Coherent states: mathematical and physical aspects'.
Abstract Based on a geometric view on the famous Dirac belt trick in terms of a Möbius strip, we propose a simple haptic model for spin states as standing waves in non-trivial geometry. We compare two representations of the model: the spinor representation in SU (2), which geometrically is described by ‘Dirac belt’ states on S 3 , and the well-known Bloch-sphere representation on S 2 . We show that after Hopf-mapping S 3 → S 2 , the position and number of nodal points are sufficient to describe the spin state and make the relation between the representations on S 2 and on S 3 explicit in simple haptic models. Our approach is well-suited for graduate physics courses, and provides a thorough understanding of the complex geometry of spin states beyond the usual Bloch-sphere visualisation. It turns out that an even number 2 l of nodal points can be related to nodal lines of spherical harmonics Y lm , an odd number can be traced back to spin states. In this sense, our model provides a unified view for orbital and spin states based on a simple picture of standing waves.
Spin is an intrinsic form of angular momentum carried by elementary particles, composite particles, and atomic nuclei. It is wildly believed that spin is a purely quantum mechanical concept and has no classical analogue. In fact, elementary particles are conceived as point objects which have no axis to “spin” around. Therefore, there is no explaining how spin arises at the fundamental level, why particles have the values they do, and what underpins the Pauli Exclusion principle and Bose-Einstein behavior. However, spin is like a vector quantity; it has a definite magnitude, and it has a “direction”, in order to spin should be composite. In this paper we propose a physical explanation for spin of the electron at the sub-particle level, relying on the vortex model of the electron. The electron is described as a superfluid frictionless vortex which has a mass, angular momentum and spin to provide a complete explanation of all properties of the electron: it composite, spinning around its own axis, produces a tiny magnetic fields independent of those from its orbital motions. The classical hydrodynamic laws are used to describe the quantum properties of the electron, such as spin, angular momentum, magnetic momentum and a magnetic dipole. The circulation in the vortex is constant, and the angular momentum of the vortex is conserved and has the same value of Planck constant. The direction of the angular momentum of a spinning electron vortex is along the axis of rotation and determined by the direction of spin. The spin quantum number 1/2 has a fixed value which represents the gap between the circulation rate of the core of the vortex and the boundaries of the vortex. The changeable values +1/2 “spin-up” or -1/2 “spin-down” indicate the direction of the magnetic dipole of the vortex. The relation between spin and Planck constant is discussed and the origin h/4pi angular momentum units are revealed.
Abstract Conventional methods for teaching spin at a university level generally follow four main approaches. The first introduces spin into the Schrödinger equation artificially, leaving its physical meaning unclear. The second connects spin to the representation of the rotation group, which clarifies its nature but requires knowledge of group theory. The third approach derives from field theory, separating angular momentum into orbital and intrinsic parts, the latter corresponding to spin; however, this cannot be done within quantum mechanics alone. The fourth derives electron spin from Dirac’s 1928 relativistic equation, which, though correct, has led to the misconception that spin is a purely relativistic effect. A detailed analysis of Dirac’s 1928 papers shows that the concept of spin arises from the need to construct an equation linear in both energy and momentum to preserve Born’s probabilistic interpretation. This linearization of the Klein–Gordon equation reveals that spin is conceptually independent of relativity. Historical and pedagogical perspectives can together clarify conceptual difficulties and promote a deeper understanding of fundamental ideas in physics. Drawing on selected passages from Dirac’s original work, the present discussion offers broader conceptual and cultural considerations that introduce the notion of spin with limited mathematical requirements and can be applied independently of the didactic approach adopted.